ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
1
Competitive audit
Goal : Compare the user experience of each competitor's website
2
General informationUX
(rated: needs work, okay, good, or outstanding)
3
First ImpressionInteractionVisual designContent
4
Competitor type
(direct or indirect)
Product offering
Website
(URL)
Target audience Unique value proposition FeaturesAccessibilityUser flow NavigationBrand identityToneDescriptiveness
5
Nourish by WebMDdirectProvide health information, tools for managing health, and support to those who seek informationwww.webmd.compeople who want to control their weightDiet and Weight ManagementGOOD
+ Visually appealing
- Too much information displayed in homepage
GOOD
+ Food Calculator
- So much feature make website feel complicated
NEED WORKS
- Only available in English
- No features for audio or visual impairments
- Same feature still can be united in one category
GOOD
+ Easy to find food calculator
+ Simple calculation process
GOOD
+ Easy to navigate
- Some elements seem not clickable but are
OUTSTANDING
+ Strong brand indentity including color, font and imagery
Fun and IndirectGOOD
+ All key Info is presented
- Too descriptive
6
MyfitnesspaldirectCalorie counter and diet plan by tracking caloric intakewww.myfitnesspal.compeople who currently on a dietSuggested Fitness And Nutrition GoalsGOOD
+ Simple to navigate
- Minimal Visual
OUTSTANDING
+ Calorie Chart, Nutrition Facts for Food
+ Food Diary
GOOD
+ Availables in 15 language
- No features for audio impairments
GOOD
+ Straightforward user flow
+ Simple calculation process
OUTSTANDING
+ Easy to navigate
+ Easy to switch languange
NEEDS WORK
- Minimal brand identity
- Only uses 2 colors
Serious and directGOOD
+ Short and to the point
+ Focused on info relevant to target audience
7
Fat Secretdirect lets users track their nutrition, exercise and weightwww.fatsecret.compeople who want to track their food nutritiontrack nutrition per day and connect with communityGOOD
+ Simple to navigate
+ Visually appealing
OUTSTANDING
+ Food Diary
+ Browse common foods and products from brands and restaurants
GOOD
+ Availables in 31 countries
- No features for audio or visual impairments
GOOD
+ Straightforward user flow
- Search bar in food calculator is less visible
OUTSTANDING
+ Easy to navigate
+ Easy to switch countries
OUTSTANDING
+ Strong brand indentity including color, font and imagery
Friendly and directOUTSTANDING
+ Short and to the point
+ All key info is presented
8
Great EasternIndirectinsurancewww.greateasternlife.comfamilies in need of health protectionCalculate daily calorie needs, body mass index and exercise caloriesGOOD
+ Landing page is straightforward
- Minimal color
OKAY
+ Calculate daily calorie needs, body mass index and exercise calories
- Nutrition fact for food
GOOD
+ Availables in 4 language
- No features for audio impairments
GOOD
+ Straightforward user flow
+ Simple calculation process
OUTSTANDING
+ Easy to navigate
+ Easy to switch languange
NEEDS WORK
- Minimal brand identity
- Only uses 1 colors
Serous and directGOOD
- Minimal visual and color
+ Focused on info relevant to target audience
9
10
11
12
13
Needs work: The app is not usable, and users aren’t getting what they need from this aspect of the app.
14
Okay: This aspect has some issues, but with some work, it could meet user needs.
15
Good: This aspect works well, but doesn’t always provide users with the necessary information easily.
16
Outstanding: This aspect feels consistent, and it meets or exceeds the user’s needs. 
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100