| A | B | C | D | E | F | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Challenge | Name | Weight multiplier | Description | Reasoning | Link to explantory medium post |
2 | 1 | (In person) Event POAPs | 4 | POAP from major in-person event (devcon, ethcc, etc) | Difficulty to spoof: high Incentive to spoof: low In total: strong assurance, but users could use different addresses at different events | https://medium.com/gyroscope-protocol/gyroscope-level-4-enter-the-frog-games-b5b80f5d3ad2 |
3 | 2 | Sybil List | 3 | Gov participants that registered at https://sybil.org/#/delegates/uniswap prior to cut-off | Difficulty: medium Incentive: low; mostly real-usage; possibly some airdrop hunting In total: medium assurance; typically coupled to gov participation (forum threads, votes etc) | https://medium.com/gyroscope-protocol/gyroscope-level-4-let-the-frog-games-continue-fee463ca0f19?source=collection_detail----1d44736f4db6-----10----------------------- |
4 | 3 | Governance Participants | 2 | Criteria: (1) Vote on at least 3 Snapshot proposals of included crypto projects (see list below) (2) Be active for a minimum period of 30 days (i.e. difference between earliest and latest vote >30d) (3) Pass the above two criteria before the 1st December of 2021 | Difficulty: low Incentive: low; possibly some airdrop hunting In total: medium-low assurance | https://medium.com/gyroscope-protocol/gyroscope-level-4-frog-games-iii-36d7cf33558c?source=collection_detail----1d44736f4db6-----9----------------------- |
5 | 4 | Additional POAPs | https://medium.com/gyroscope-protocol/gyroscope-level-4-frog-games-iv-5660a6ff6a4f?source=collection_detail----1d44736f4db6-----8----------------------- | |||
6 | bankless | 1 | POAP for the community of the bankless podcast | Difficulty: minimal Incentive: low In total: low assurance | ||
7 | additionalPOAPs | 1 | e.g. 'reward POAPs' | Difficulty: minimal Incentive: low In total: low assurance | ||
8 | communityCalls | 2 | e.g. DAO working groups, 'community game nights' etc | Difficulty: low Incentive: low In total: medium-low assurance, requires some community activity | ||
9 | highInvolvement | 3 | e.g. virtual event that requires & tests user-attention | Difficulty: medium Incentive: low In total: medium assurance, requires significant community activity | ||
10 | 5 | Discord | unweighted score + 1 if unweighted score = 3 --> + 2 | discord live event: - pass captcha/ chaos & have telephone number linked to discord account - post address: 1 (unweighted) point - post address + description: 2 (unweighted) points - post address + description + twitter ama: 3 (unweighted) points | Difficulty: medium-high Incentive: medium In total: medium-high assurance; also participating in twitter ama is a more robust assurance than describing sybil resistance in addition to posting an address | https://medium.com/gyroscope-protocol/post-mortem-challenge-v-11c25f046a69?source=collection_detail----1d44736f4db6-----6----------------------- |
11 | 6 | User account checks | .json file from lvl 2.5 | Difficulty: low-high Incentive: medium In total: between low and high assurance | https://medium.com/gyroscope-protocol/challenge-vi-user-account-checks-b51eb7693307?source=collection_detail----1d44736f4db6-----7----------------------- | |
12 | 1 + 1 + 3 -- (for ch 6 & 7 in total) if ch 6 & 7 is passed with the same twitter account (3 bonus points) 1+ 1 -- (for ch 6 & 7 in total) if ch 6 & 7 is passed with different twitter accounts 1 -- if only ch6 is passed | Difficulty: low (/ high) Incentive: medium In total: medium-high assurance if matched oauth check (requires pre-committing old, active social account a significant time ago; most likely early community member that used main twitter account; otherwise: early community member, but suspectible to manipulation from people who did the early levels with multiple accounts/ socials) | ||||
13 | github | 1 + 1 + 3 -- (for ch6 & 7 in total) if ch 6 & 7 is passed with the same github account (3 bonus points) 1 + 1 -- (for ch6 & 7 in total) if ch 6 & 7 is passed with different github accounts 1 -- if only ch6 is passed | Difficulty: low (/ high) Incentive: medium In total: as above; high assurance if matched oauth check (since there is less incentive to have multiple github accounts; otherwise: early community member) | |||
14 | phone | 2 | Difficulty: medium-low Incentive: medium In total: medium-low assurance (since some countries still provide easy access to multiple phone numbers) | |||
15 | 7 | OAuths | O-Auths enable users to log-in into an account and thus confirm & signal their respective ownership | https://medium.com/gyroscope-protocol/challenge-vii-social-accounts-ff635973e194?source=collection_detail----1d44736f4db6-----4----------------------- | ||
16 | stackexchange | 3 | Difficulty: medium-hard Incentive: low In total: medium assurance (real activity required; very atypical to have multiple stackexchange accounts; theoretically spoofable) | |||
17 | 2 | Difficulty: medium-low Incentive: medium In total: medium-low assurance (activity required; some incentive for multiple accounts) | ||||
18 | minecraft | 1 | Difficulty: low Incentive: low In total: low assurance (useful, since there is very little incentive for multiple minecraft accounts; but account age could not be controlled for) | |||
19 | github | 2 (also see cell C13) | Difficulty: medium Incentive: medium In total: medium assurance (real activity required; aytpical to have multiple accounts; theoretically spoofable) | |||
20 | 1 (also see cell C12) | Difficulty: medium-low Incentive: medium In total: medium-low assurance (activity required; some incentive for multiple accounts; spoofable) | ||||
21 | 8 | Last challenge | https://medium.com/gyroscope-protocol/defi-whitelist-community-contributors-and-optional-kyc-8eb3f184ff1d?source=collection_detail----1d44736f4db6-----2----------------------- | |||
22 | community contributions | original score | discord activity | Difficulty: high Incentive: medium In total: strong assurance (+ part of 'proof of work' sybil challenge by participating in workstreams & the community more generally) | ||
23 | coinbase | 5 | indirect kyc | Difficulty: very high Incentive: medium In total: very strong assurance (all coinbase accounts require KYC; checking for coinbase accounts piggybacks on their internal KYC) | ||
24 | goldfinch | 5 | kyc | Difficulty: very high Incentive: medium In total: very strong assurance (KYC required) | ||
25 | defi whitelist | 2 | Eligible users: - LOBS airdrop recipients - WRITE token users - ETH 2.0 stakers - early compound LPs | Difficulty: medium-low Incentive: medium In total: medium-low assurance (LOBS/ WRITE/ ETH 2.0 stakers are medium-strong; early compound LP low) |