Witch reads

	A	B	C	D
1	Name	Read	Notes	Rating prior to flip

2	LightningStrike	0%	cons: asks a lot of questions but doesn't tend to post much of his own thought process, Spends a lot of time saying things are null, acts relatively meek, e.g. "Just seemed like that I guess". Also spends a lot of time talking about what he's going to do or going to do later (e.g. will come back after dinner!). Meta; He's NOT new, so none of this behaviour is good. Almost certainly mafia. Looked into his past games and he takes this tone only when playing scum. He doesn't give out null reads or useless posts when he is town, and he tends to form complete sentences as town, whereas as scum he tends to ramble randomly and talk about how he's gonna post. Would lynch 100%, no pros to speak of now that I know he's not a new player. His "meta case" to say I'm town was incredibly forced, inaccurate, and had no citations. Why are people accepting that shit? It's not alignment-indicative for a scum to go ahead and say they've read a person's past games and come back with no citations and a strong town read an hour later.	5%
3	Bill Murray	0%	hard to tell what this dude is most of the time, but I can't say I've liked any of his posts so far. Aside from the fact that he seems to be okay with putting forth a vote, his posting style is very questionable. In particular the response to FrozenFoot's request to explain his vote on me was more or less "ad hominem = scum", which if anything has the opposite correlation. Scum are very rarely confrontational. He's not inexperienced but more than capable of being this bad. I would lynch but maybe not the best idea until we get some more time. Also can be strong, confrontational scum, but generally completely unhelpful as either alignment. I feel like he's scum again this game, though, seems similar in style to the last time I saw him play scum (I think Mafia L or JubJub)
4	ShoCkeyy	20%	his tone seems townish. Started off slowly but after he entered the thread (and in particular his responses to certain players) he is town. His language is too bold he has too much of a care-free attitude (care-free in the sense of not giving a fuck what others think of him) to be scum, IMO. Reads are garbage and make very little sense. has enough experience playing mafia to provide proper reads, but...
5	Tubesock	40%	pros: seems to have a genuine reaction to thread happenings. Originally had as townish but good point from bats lead me to reread. Response to FF was good, but entrance was meh-asked if anyone was around, but only followed up with FF. On second read and subsequent posts this dude's opinions seem rather twisted. Admits that meta is useful but chooses only to accept the side that is convenient to voting me. Most of his posts and opinions make not so much sense after closer inspection and his votes seem to come out of pure convenience. Stutters vote is completely useless and he even accepts it as pure policy, which ironically could be the only indicator in his recent posts that he is town. Would scum be so willing to acknowledge their own shitty vote? I feel a bit more confident he's scum given there are some others who agree (for different reasons which I did not actually notice). Has said he hates policy in past games. 0 contribution in 24 hours
6	Onegu	60%	Lurked so far and said nothing of value in 3 posts. He responded to yamato's entry and has so far completely avoided discussion despite bothering to post 3 times. Would not mind lynching if no better candidate
7	The Shining	80%	His entrance seemed genuine. His push on shockey is a little weird but the attitude re: shockey's posts makes sense. I would have probably felt the same if I thought that lurkers should be punished and then the lurker I was pushing proceeded to make the post that he ended up making. Not enough information to make a solid read but townish enough for now and not worth another look with so little time left
8	FreezingFoot	99%	later responses are okay but all of the early responses suck. Need to see what he does once I back off a bit. Probably simply misguided town. Problem is he has completely disappeared after I relieved pressure. Where are his reads on other players? Responses to other players thus far (and attitude re: the game) have increased my confidence that he is town but not by much
9	batsnacks	99%
10	Breshke	99%	actually reads the thread, +1. Seems to also think with his head. He was reading FrozenFoot's responses to me and saw many of the same things I did. One of the few players to elucidate his own thought process for his vote and do so in a consistent and straightforward manner. His post on his own thought process for why he agreed with me (and the scenario from his perspective) is very hard to fake as mafia. Probably town.
11	Yamato77	99%	Not useful until just recently. Entrance into the thread was very strong. His needlessly strong response to my simple question along with ignoring half the things I ask is very fishy, however. He helped push LS but what if he's bussing? Fairly unlikely still, but question remains. w/e fuck it let's not get paranoid
12	Kickstart	100%	reaction to my push seemed relatively genuine. Probably unlikely to have said the things in the manner he had said them if he was scum, e.g. his post clarifying his misunderstanding to bats. I have him lower than the others because he seems like he could be doing a long con, but it's very unlikely and I'd be fairly impressed if a scum is behaving the way he is now. really stupid opinions though. Demoting my read of him to slightly above null because of the complete and utter lack of sense his posts make. Attitude still indicative of town but the rest of the play doesn't match. But again, could just be bad	99%
13	Stutters695	100%	god damn it	50%
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100