|content||Can we create coherent constitutions?|
|content||How do we create a few coherent constitutions, built out of a bunch of conversations?||RED: How is the merging process organized and structured?|
Can we vote on single articles or only whole proposals? Can we work out the major differences of the various proposals? Can we facilitate a decision making process by delegating representatives of each camp ?
|content||How long or short should the constitution be?|
|content||In order to keep the constitution short and simple, do we need other governance documents to go along with the constitution that go into deeper detail?||BLUE: What is the most desired format of the constitution?|
If we go for short and accessible, what would be the sub documents? (definitions glossary, execution protocol...) How would these documents be amended? Which format and distribution promises the highest voter participation?
|content||Should the name “constitution” be changed to something else?|
|BIG QUESTION||What makes an excellent constitution?|
excellent constitution: coherent, representative, power regulating, protecting users and developers
|content||Who should do the creating? How are they selected?|
|ecaf||Should we make it written in the constitution, that BP shouldn’t act without the ECAF’s order, except the basic Block produce function.||GREEN: How can the concentration of powers be balanced in the ecosystem?|
What are the biggest threats? (whales/exchanges/collusion/self appointed arbitrators/uncontrolled BPs/general fraud or theft) How can we enforce and what would be penalties? Can bond systems work along the constitution? Whistleblower?
|process||How do we merge multiple constitution proposals?|
|process||What will the newcomer to EOS appreciate in a constitution?||CYAN: How can we maximize voter participation?|
|process||Will be possible to choose different articles from different constitution to vote, or should be choosed one of the constitutions entirely?|
|validity||What is validity really (of editors or drafts), for our context?|
|validity||Who selects the editors? How does the editor-selection achieve validity?|
|voting||Voting process will be similar to choosing BPs or another concept?|
|voting||What’s the minimum vote participate ratio for the constitution pass ?|
|公约执行||公约一定要强制执行嘛？约定俗成的规矩也有一定作用。||Is the Constitution compulsory? Agreed conventions are also useful.|
|公约执行||在其他公约版本被选定之前，这期间社区应当遵循的版本是v1还是v2？||Before other versions of Constitution are selected, during this period, should the community follow v1 or v2?|
|公约草拟||公约一定要足够简约吗？很多国家公投的宪法都非常细致，EOS现有的公约让人感觉它并未处理实际问题。我们需要一份更细致，对更多问题有实际解决作用的公约。||Must the Constitution be sufficiently simple? The constitutions of many national referendums are very detailed, but the existing Constitution of EOS makes people feel that it has not dealt with practical problems. Therefore, we need a more detailed Constitution that has a practical solution to more problems.|
|公约草拟||各种版本之间是否存在必须共有的标准条款？||Is there a standard clause that must be shared between the various versions?|
|公约草拟||有无可能存在一个公立的第三方或者组织来撰写一个版本的公约？||Is it possible for a public third party or organization to draft a version of the convention?|
|公约草拟||针对区块链体系“强势”群体，交易所是否应当单独设立约束条款？使其投票和行为有所约束，并建立披露制度。||For the “privileged” group of the blockchain system, should the exchange establish separate restrictive clauses in order to make their voting and behavior constrained and establish a disclosure system?|
|投票原则||如果说要想出三个连贯的问题，需要社区大众建立共识的基础上设立这三个问题的核心准则，也就是说在通过回答这三个问题的基础上，我可以相对应的选择出我认为最好的公约版本||If we want to come up with three coherent problems, we need to set up the core principles of these three questions on the basis of community consensus. That is to say, by answering these three questions, I can choose correspondingly the one that I regard the best.|
|投票方法||公投链上还是链下进行？||Is the referendum on chain or off chain?|
Who should develop and design the voting tools of the Constitution?
How to ensure that the community is widely involved in the Constitution referendum?
What if the community can’t communicate, for example, the Korean community does not agree with the Chinese community Constitution ?
How to vote on the future Constitution ?
|投票时间||到底要等到何时？比如现在已经有了4份公约，马上会出另外一份。12期的公约讨论够吗？||So how long on earth do we have to wait? For example, there are already four constitutions and another one will be released soon. Is the 12-week discussion for Constitution enough?|
|投票步骤||一定要在这几版公约中选择一个？或者有的各有优缺点，可以综合定制一版么？||Must we choose one among these versions of the Constitution? Or if some constitutions bear their own advantages and disadvantages, can you customize a version?|
|投票步骤||什么时候开始进行公约公投？||When will the Constitution referendum begin?|
How can the Constitution be revised? The Constitution also needs to be revised. So how often is that?
So as long as a candidate reaches the standard of the proposal, he can be listed on the referendum system?
Is every referendum featured by only one version of the Constitution? As the Constitution gets more versions, when can we vote out the Constitution that everyone in the community agree on?
Who will be responsible for formulating the final ballot question?
If we don't make a Constitution by human’s efforts, will a set of order grow itself? And is this order the most decentralized?
How to achieve this process?
A mechanism for popularizing ballot issues to the community should be formed, as it may not be that everyone is familiar with the process
|content||Can we leave the free choose of proxy vote to token holders?|
|content||Should the constitution make the it clear that arbitration on EOS should be free market or not?|
|process||Should we make it clear that organize any arbitration forum on EOS shouldn't be involved by any BPs?|
Does the Constitution solve voting issues (owning too much potential rights ) for bps and exchange?
The reasonable level of the voting process itself (Does potential monopoly voting exist?)
我选的公约是否能够被最好的推广给non eos token holders，have them really buy in what we do and why we need this Constitution on EOS
Can the Constitution I choose be best promoted to non-EOS token holders，have them really buy in what we do and why we need this Constitution on EOS?
We said that the technology has to be used, and that the application to be on the ground . The version of Constitution that I vote for, can it really be implemented?
intent of code is law, judgement of "the intent"
The arbitration system process, the market (are there multiple choices?)Is it voluntarily chosen whether to arbitrated?
How is the voting method determined? Can the operability of the process be simple enough to attract more people to participate?