All the Johns and Anns

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K	L
1	Name	Birth	Place	Death	Place	Parent 1	Parent 2	Spouse	Marriage	Place	ScotlandsPeople	FamilySearch

2	John Cromar	1733-09-30	Aboyne			Alexander Cromar		(poss Agnes Meston)			10 113	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBNG-LBS
3	John Cromar	1737-01-01	Aboyne			Peter Cromar 1690	Janet Bonar	Jean Smith	1762-08-05	Aboyne		https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/L441-MP7
4	John Cromar	1754-09-30	Aboyne			Alexander Cromar 1730		(poss Ann Cromar 1751)			10 5	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/G9MJ-GJ3
5	John Cromar	1754-10-24	Leochel-Cushnie			George Cromar 1720		(poss Ann Cromar 1751)			10 116	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBJS-4BF
6	John Cromar	1755-04-16	Aboyne (1755-09-16 chrstg)	1756-01-01	Scotland	Robert Cromar 1717	Jannet Dun	(poss Ann Cromar 1751)			10 9	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBNG-L1L
7	John Cromar	1757-05-04	Leochel-Cushnie			John Cromar (1733/7??)		(poss Ann Cromar 1751)			10 120	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBJS-412
8	John Cromar	1758-01-01	Scotland (Stirlingshire?)					Margaret Salmond				https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/KZJM-SP6
9	John Cromar	1760-01-01	Scotland (Lanarkshire?)			Peter Cromar 1720	Mary Thomson					https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/G3PZ-PYK
10	John Cromar	1760-07-05	Aboyne			Robert Cromar		(poss Ann Cromar 1766)			10 22	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBNG-GM7
11	John Cromar	1766-01-13	Leochel-Cushnie (1766-03-28 chrstg)			William Cromar		(poss Ann Cromar 1766)			10 142 \| 10 143	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBJS-H94
12	John Cromar	1769-01-26	South Leith, Midlothian	1793-11-15		George Cromar	Janet Laurie				60 276	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MJLX-LS6
13	John Cromar	1773-12-19	Leochel-Cushnie			ALEXR. CROMAR					10 161
14	John Cromar	1774-01-01	Scotland					Mary Hay				https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/KHZX-VCM
15	John Cromar	1776-07-07	Alford			Peter Cromar					10 87	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBNF-WD6
16											SP list	https://www.scotlandspeople.gov.uk/record-results?search_type=People&surname=Cromar&forename=John&forename_so=starts&from_year=1700&to_year=1800&surname_so=exact&church_type=Old%20Parish%20Registers&event=%28B%20OR%20C%20OR%20S%29&record_type%5B0%5D=opr_births&sort=asc&order=Date&field=year
17											FS list	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/find/name?self=John%7CCromar%7C0%7C0&gender=male&birth=Aberdeenshire%2C%20Scotland%2C%20United%20Kingdom%7C1732-1772%7C0%7C1
18
19	Jean Smith	1741-09-08	Kinellar (closest to Lumphanan)					John Cromar	1762-08-05	Aboyne	10 128	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/KZSV-9VL
20	Agnes Meston	1731-03-27	Kincardine O'Neil			Alexander Meston	Isobel Birss	John Cromar	1782-12-09	Lumphanan	10 136	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBN4-GPN
21	Mary Gordon	1753-04-29	Brechin					John Cromar	1785-01-18	Stracathro	10 152	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/K8WV-9WC
22	Ann Cromar	1743-11-18	Alford			ALEXANDER CROMAR		John Cromar	1789-09-17	Lumphanan	10 148	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBNN-CVW
23	Ann Cromar	1745-01-01				Peter Cromar		Robert Herdman	1770-10-07	Aboyne		https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/K8K6-3MM
24	Ann Cromar	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone			PETER CROMAR	Margaret Anderson				10 148	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBVF-6YD
25	Ann Cromar	1754-01-01	Scotland (Lanarkshire?)			Peter Cromar 1720	Mary Thomson	Robert Davidson	1776-01-01			https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/G3G4-718
26	Ann Cromar	1766-11-05	Peterculter			ALEXR. CROMAR					10 148	https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MBCK-FBK
27												https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/MB5M-D16
28
29		HYPOTHESIS: WHICH SPOUSE IS GEORGE 1792'S MOTHER?
30		Above there are a half-dozen possible candidates with records at Family Search, all of whom have documentation at ScotlandsPeople.gov.uk
31		Assumptions 1 and 2 same as above.
32		Assumption 3: Spouses are born within 5 years of each other with a bias toward male being older.
33		A1 rules out: Agnes Meston, beyond early range, and Jean Smith, at edge of early range.
34		A2 rules out: Mary Gordon: Stracathro, near Brechin, too far south.
35		A2 rules out: Ann Cromar 1754: Lanarkshire too far south (and spouse Robert Davidson lives long).
36		A3 rules out: Ann Cromar 1743, too early for John 1754 or later.
37		Ann Cromar 1745 remotely possible for John 1754 (son of Alexander), 1754 (son of George), 1755 (son of Robert), or 1757 (son of John). Reason: second marriage (Robert dies 1779).
38		Ann Cromar 1751 possible for John 1754 (son of Alexander), 1754 (son of George), 1755 (son of Robert), or 1757 (son of John).
39		Ann Cromar 1766 possible for John 1760 (son of Robert) and 1766 (son of William).
40
41		18 POSSIBLE COMBINATIONS OF JOHN (6) AND ANN (3): SOME MORE PLAUSIBLE, SOME LESS
42		Criteria 1: Age adjacency among parents and ideal childbearing age for George.
43		Criteria 2: Proximity to Lumphanan for the birth of George (marriage or birth data in or near Lumphanan).
44
45
46	John Cromar	1754-09-30	Aboyne	3	2	1		2		3
47	Ann Cromar	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)
48						1755-04-16	Aboyne	1754-09-30	Aboyne	1754-10-24	Leochel-Cushnie
49	John Cromar	1754-09-30	Aboyne	2	1	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)
50	Ann Cromar	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone
51						1754-09-30	Aboyne	1754-10-24	Leochel-Cushnie	1757-05-04	Leochel-Cushnie
52	John Cromar	1754-09-30	Aboyne	6		1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)
53	Ann Cromar	1766-11-05	Peterculter
54								1755-04-16	Aboyne	1760-07-05	Aboyne
55								1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)
56	John Cromar	1754-10-24	Leochel-Cushnie	4	3
57	Ann Cromar	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)					1757-05-04	Leochel-Cushnie	1766-01-13	Leochel-Cushnie
58								1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone
59	John Cromar	1754-10-24	Leochel-Cushnie	3	2
60	Ann Cromar	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone					1760-07-05	Aboyne	1766-01-13	Leochel-Cushnie
61								1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone	1766-11-05	Peterculter
62	John Cromar	1754-10-24	Leochel-Cushnie	6
63	Ann Cromar	1766-11-05	Peterculter
64						CONCLUSIONS: MOST LIKELY SCENARIOS BELOW
65
66	John Cromar	1755-04-16	Aboyne	3	2
67	Ann Cromar	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)
68
69	John Cromar	1755-04-16	Aboyne	2	1
70	Ann Cromar	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone
71
72	John Cromar	1755-04-16	Aboyne	6
73	Ann Cromar	1766-11-05	Peterculter
74
75
76	John Cromar	1757-05-04	Leochel-Cushnie	4	3
77	Ann Cromar	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)
78
79	John Cromar	1757-05-04	Leochel-Cushnie	3	2
80	Ann Cromar	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone
81
82	John Cromar	1757-05-04	Leochel-Cushnie	5
83	Ann Cromar	1766-11-05	Peterculter
84
85
86	John Cromar	1760-07-05	Aboyne	4	3
87	Ann Cromar	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)
88
89	John Cromar	1760-07-05	Aboyne	3	2
90	Ann Cromar	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone
91
92	John Cromar	1760-07-05	Aboyne	5
93	Ann Cromar	1766-11-05	Peterculter
94
95
96	John Cromar	1766-01-13	Leochel-Cushnie	5
97	Ann Cromar	1745-01-01	(Aboyne, first marriage)
98
99	John Cromar	1766-01-13	Leochel-Cushnie	4	3
100	Ann Cromar	1751-05-16	Logie Coldstone