OT20 orders and recusals

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G
1	f	Case no.	Case caption	Recused justice	Reason for recusal	Shorter version	Notes

2	MERITS-STAGE RECUSALS: 1
3	1	19-1189	B.P. ET AL V. CITY OF BALTIMORE, ET AL. (to be argued 1/19/21)	Alito	Alito owns up to $50,000 in shares in two parties, ConocoPhillips and Phillip66	stock ownership
4
5	PER CURIAM RECUSALS: 2
6	From Nov. 2 orders: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/110220zor_08m1.pdf
7	1	19-1108	DERAY MCKESSON V. JOHN DOE	Barrett	per curiam decision at end of order list	not on court when case was discussed
8	2	19-1261	TRENT MICHAEL TAYLOR V. ROBERT RIOJAS, ET AL.	Barrett	per curiam decision at end of order list	not on court when case was discussed
9
10	CERT.-STAGE RECUSALS: 245						(count excludes Barrett's recusals from the 11/2 orders list, except where opinions were issued)
11	Oct. 5 orders: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/100520zor_3204.pdf
12	1	20-8	DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO., ET AL. V. ROBERT McCORMICK FOUNDATION	Alito	several named defendants appear to be subsidiaries of companies in which Alito owns shares	stock ownership	hundreds of named parties; several of the defendants appear to be subsidiaries of companies Alito owns share in
13	2	20-5155	COUGHLIN, CHARLES E. V. UNITED STATES	Kavanaugh	Kavanaugh heard an earlier version of this case when he was a DC Circuit judge (610 F.3d 89 (D.C. Cir. 2010))	previous work	denial of IFP
14	3	19-7688	NOBLE, RICARDO V. PENNSYLVANIA	Alito	earlier iteration of the case was in Third Circuit when Alito was a judge there	previous work	juvenile lifer sentenced in 1992 applying for Miller resentencing; Q is whether any direct appeals reached CA3 or a dist court where he sat by designation
15	4	19-8531	HALL, MARC P. V. INCH, M., ET AL.	Kagan	earlier version of the case overlapped with Kagan at OSG and she likely worked on the case	previous work
16	5	19-8560	NOBLE, RICARDO V. PENNSYLVANIA	Alito	earlier iteration of the case was in Third Circuit when Alito was a judge there	previous work	juvenile lifer sentenced in 1992 applying for Miller resentencing; Q is whether any direct appeals reached CA3 or a dist court where he sat by designation
17	6	19-8614	FIELDS, EDWARD L. V. UNITED STATES	Gorsuch	earlier iteration of the case was in Tenth Circuit when Gorsuch was a judge there	previous work	direct appeal was heard by CA10 while on court; wasn't on panel
18	7	19-8621	PETERSON, STEVEN D. V. UNITED STATES	Kagan	earlier version of the case overlapped with Kagan at OSG and she likely worked on the case	previous work	various appeals and prior cert petitions since 2000; at least one appeal in CA4 overlaps her tenure at OSG
19	8	19-8656	JACOBY, MICHAEL V. UNITED STATES	Gorsuch	earlier iteration of the case was in Tenth Circuit when Gorsuch was a judge there	previous work	earlier appeal heard by CA10 while on court; wasn't on panel
20	9	19-8671	ARUNACHALAM, LAKSHMI V. WELLS FARGO BANK, N.A.	Roberts	named as party	named in case
21	10	19-8707	ARUNACHALAM, LAKSHMI V. APPLE, INC., ET AL.	Roberts	named as party	named in case
22	11	19-8708	ARUNACHALAM, LAKSHMI V. PRESIDIO BANK	Roberts	named as party	named in case
23	12	19-8735	JACKSON, MICHAEL A. V. UNITED STATES	Alito	earlier iteration of the case was in Third Circuit when Alito was a judge there	previous work	direct appeal heard at CA3 while on court; unclear if he was on panel
24	13	19-8735	JACKSON, MICHAEL A. V. UNITED STATES	Kagan	earlier version of the case overlapped with Kagan at OSG and she likely worked on the case	previous work	case is originally from the 90s, has been on direct and collateral appeals in the fed'l system since then -- presumably overlapped Kagan at OSG
25	14	19-8750	ARUNACHALAM, LAKSHMI V. SAP AMERICA, INC.	Roberts	named as party	named in case
26	15	19-8814	DAVIS, NICHOLAS A. V. SHARP, INTERIM WARDEN	Gorsuch	earlier iteration of the case was in Tenth Circuit when Gorsuch was a judge there	previous work	best guess i have is it was bouncing around CA10 when he was on that court; it didn't reach the appeals court until after his SCOTUS elevation, but it was in W.D. Okla. in early 2017
27	16	19-8857	JONES, JOSEPH L. V. DOUGLAS COUNTY JAIL	Gorsuch	earlier iteration of the case was in Tenth Circuit when Gorsuch was a judge there	previous work	seems like the only connection is it came out of CA10; postdates his SCOTUS elevation, maybe heard a prior case w/ same defendant?
28	17	19-8924	JENKINS, WILLIAM R. V. UNITED STATES	Alito	Alito heard an earlier version of this case when he was a Third Circuit judge (333 F.3d 151 (3d Cir. 2003))	previous work
29	18	20-57	McGINNIS, MAURICE V. PERDUE, SEC. OF AGRIC., ET AL.	Kavanaugh	earlier iteration of the case was in DC Circuit when Kavanaugh was a judge there	previous work	litigation related to a consent order entered in 1999, ongoing dispute with Ag Dep't related to misclassification of arbitration claim -- nearly impossible Kavanaugh didn't encounter a piece of this while on CADC
30	19	20-98	WOOD, THOMAS V. BOEING CO.	Alito	Alito owns Boeing stock	stock ownership
31	20	20-106	VILAR, ALBERTO, ET AL. V. UNITED STATES	Sotomayor	earlier iteration of the case was in Second Circuit when Sotomayor was a judge there	previous work	case has been bouncing around SDNY and CA2 since 2006, it's almost certain she encountered a piece of it at some point
32	21	20-265	RAMIREZ, LEON O., ET AL. V. CONOCOPHILIPS CO., ET AL.	Alito	Alito owns ConocoPhillips stock	stock ownership
33	22	20-5028	LUSSY, RICHARD C. V. DAHOOD, WADE J.	Roberts	named in brief	named in case	from 1/11 orders list: CJ also recused from motion to rehear petition
34	23	20-5029	LUSSY, RICHARD C. V. LUSSY, HENRY P.	Roberts	named in brief	named in case	from 1/11 orders list: CJ also recused from motion to rehear petition
35	24	20-5094	LAUX, ANITA V. MENTOR WORLDWIDE, LLC	Alito	Mentor Worldwide LLC is a subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson, in which Alito owns shares	stock ownership
36	25	20-5235	BIKUNDI, MICHAEL D. V. UNITED STATES	Kavanaugh	earlier iteration of the case was in DC Circuit when Kavanaugh was a judge there	previous work
37	26	20-5311	HOLLIHAN, RICHARD V. PENNSYLVANIA	Alito	earlier iteration of te case was in Third Circuit when Alito was a judge there	previous work
38	27	20-5431	ACKERMAN, WALTER V. UNITED STATES	Gorsuch	Gorsuch heard an earlier version of this case when he was a Tenth Circuit judge (831 F.3d 1292 (10th Cir. 2016))	previous work
39	28	20-5469	LEE, ALFONZO T. V. UNITED STATES	Kagan	earlier version of the case overlapped with Kagan at OSG and she likely worked on the case	previous work
40	29	19-8860	IN RE LAKSHMI ARUNACHALAM	Roberts	named as party	named in case	from 11/9 orders list: CJ also recused from motion to reconsider IFP (denied)
41	30	19-1343	IN RE EDWARD STARLING	Kavanaugh	Kavanaugh heard appeal in a related proceeding when he was a DC Circuit judge (688 Fed'l App'x 15 (D.C. Cir. 2017))	previous work	this is another protracted case with lots of related proceedings that has stretched on for decades and across fed'l districts, at least one related proceeding was heard by Kav on CADC
42
43	Oct. 13 orders: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/101320zor_8m58.pdf
44	31	20-100	BARTH, MICHAEL S. V. BERNARDS TWP. PLANNING, ET AL.	Alito	not 100% clear -- see notes	previous work	Barth started as an intervenor in this case, trying to keep a mosque from getting built -- initial case was in fed'l court (fed q) in CA3 but years after Alito's SCOTUS elevation
45	32	20-154	BYZON, WAYNE P., ET UX. V. PNC BANK, NAT. ASSN.	Alito	Alito owns PNC stock	stock ownership
46	33	20-259	NGUYEN, MINHNGA V. BOEING CO.	Alito	Alito owns Boeing stock	stock ownership
47	34	20-5564	AKEL, ANTONIO U. V. UNITED STATES	Kagan	earlier version of the case overlapped with Kagan at OSG and she likely worked on the case	previous work	case in fed'l system, initial collateral attacks overlap w/ Kagan's service in SG's office
48	35	20-5583	CROSBY, GREGORY D. V. UNITED STATES	Gorsuch	Gorsuch heard an earlier version of this case when he was a Tenth Circuit judge (468 Fed'l App'x 913 (10th Cir. 2012))	previous work
49	36	20-5661	SHELTON, MONTY M. V. UNITED STATES	Kagan	earlier version of the case overlapped with Kagan at OSG and she likely worked on the case	previous work	likely had some involvement when case in fed'l system was on earlier appeals; unclear how direct involvement may have been/to what extent overlaps
50
51	Oct. 19 orders: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/101920zor_8758.pdf
52	37	20-241	JORDAN, JACK V. DEPT. OF LABOR	Kavanaugh	earlier iteration of the case was in DC Circuit when Kavanaugh was a judge there	previous work	case out of CADC, originally filed while he was on court, but unclear if he was ever involved in it substantively -- appeals to CADC appear to postdate SCOTUS elevation
53	38	20-5755	JONES, JOSEPH L. V. GOOGLE LLC, INC.	Gorsuch	earlier iteration of the case was in Tenth Circuit when Gorsuch was a judge there	previous work	same party as in line 16, another pro se filing; I'm suspecting that he heard this case when it was on direct appeal maybe, and so is recusing from collateral attacks
54
55	Oct. 28 miscellaneous order: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/102820zr_g314.pdf
56	39	20A71	WISE, PATSY J., ET AL. V. CIRCOSTA, DAMON, ET AL.	Barrett	per Court's PIO, she recused because she hadn't had time to fully review the filings (joined Court one day prior)	has not had time to review filings
57
58	Oct. 28 miscellaneous order: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/20-542_i3dj.pdf
59	40	20-542	REPUBLICAN PARTY OF PENNSYLVANIA V. KATHY BOOCKVAR, SECRETARY OF PENNSYLVANIA, ET AL.	Barrett	per Court's PIO, she recused because she hadn't had time to fully review the filings (joined Court one day prior)	has not had time to review filings
60
61	Oct. 29 miscellaneous order: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/102920zr_bqm1.pdf
62	41	20A74	BERGER, PHILIP E., ET AL. V. NC BOARD OF ELECTIONS, ET AL.	Barrett	per Court's PIO, she recused because she hadn't had time to fully review the filings (joined Court two days prior)	has not had time to review filings	got confirmation on prior two via SCOTUSblog, no noted confirmation from PIO in Amy Howe's update on case, but likely same as Wise (20A71) bc it's a related NC case
63
64	Nov. 2 orders: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/110220zor_08m1.pdf						Justice Barrett blanket "took no part" for the entire orders list
65	42	19-1412	JOHNSON, MARK V. UNITED STATES	Sotomayor	potentially encountered an earlier piece of related litigation, or could know some involved party - unclear	previous work	CA2 case, seems to post-date SCOTUS elevation
66	43	20-5557	CROWNHART, EARL V. STRIVE	Gorsuch	frequent Tenth Circuit litigant; Gorsuch heard an earlier related case when he was a Tenth Circuit judge (575 Fed'l App'x 834 (10th Cir. 2014))	previous work
67	44	19-1098	NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE, ET AL. V. NINTH INNING, INC., ET AL.	Barrett	per curiam decision at end of order list	not on court when case was discussed
68
69	Nov. 9 orders: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/110920zor_1a72.pdf
70	45	19-825	FTC V. CREDIT BUREAU CENTER, ET AL.	Barrett	presumably recused bc original cert grant predated her appointment to SCOTUS	previous work	case was from CA7
71	46	20-285	CLARK, HERMAN T. V. BRAGGS, WARDEN	Gorsuch	frequent Tenth Circuit litigant; Gorsuch heard an earlier related case when he was a Tenth Circuit judge (560 Fed'l App'x 804 (10th Cir. 2014))	previous work
72	47	20-309	REARDON, JOHN E. V. NEW JERSEY, ET AL.	Alito	frequent Third Circuit litigant; multiple related cases involving the same party were in CA3 while Alito was a judge there	previous work
73	48	20-5971	CROSBY, GREGORY D. V. TRUE, WARDEN	Gorsuch	Gorsuch heard an earlier version of this case when he was a Tenth Circuit judge (468 Fed'l App'x 913 (10th Cir. 2012))	previous work
74	49	19-8766	IN RE LINDA A. WRIGHT	Breyer	case tried in N.D. Cal. by Judge Charles Breyer	family/personal	habeas denial
75	50	19-8767	IN RE LINDA A. WRIGHT	Breyer	case tried in N.D. Cal. by Judge Charles Breyer	family/personal	mandamus denial
76	51	19-8860	IN RE LAKSHMI ARUNACHALAM	Roberts	named in case	named in case	denial of IFP rehearing; original denial line 29
77
78	Nov. 16 orders: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/111620zor_4hdj.pdf
79	52	19-1362	LAUT, JASON V. UNITED STATES	Barrett	earlier iteration of the case was in Seventh Circuit when Barrett was a judge there	previous work	she wasn't on panel, but CA7 denied rehearing en banc, a decision she almost assuredly took part in
80	53	20-316	PAPPAS, MARIA, ET AL. V. A.F. MOORE & ASSOCIATES, ET AL.	Barrett	Barrett heard an earlier version of this case when she was a Seventh Circuit judge (948 F.3d 889 (7th Cir. 2020)); opinion author	previous work	two cert petitions arising out of the same case
81	54	20-357	KAEGI, FRITZ V. A.F. MOORE & ASSOCIATES, ET AL.	Barrett	Barrett heard an earlier version of this case when she was a Seventh Circuit judge (948 F.3d 889 (7th Cir. 2020)); opinion author	previous work	two cert petitions arising out of the same case
82	55	20-6062	AKERS, MONTGOMERY C. V. UNITED STATES	Kagan	earlier version of the case overlapped with Kagan at OSG and she likely worked on the case	previous work
83	56	20-6062	AKERS, MONTGOMERY C. V. UNITED STATES	Gorsuch	Gorsuch heard an earlier version of this case when he was a Tenth Circuit judge (384 Fed'l App'x 758 (10th Cir. 2010))	previous work
84
85	Nov. 23 orders: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/112320zor_7l48.pdf
86	57	20M40	JOHNSON, DUANE J. V. WILSON, WARDEN	Kagan	earlier version of the case overlapped with Kagan at OSG and she likely worked on the case	previous work	federal inmate arguing ineffective assistance of counsel; has been pressing this and related claims for the intervening 20-odd years, Kagan almost certainly was involved w/ it at some point
87	58	19-8741	ANKENY, KELLY D. V. UNITED STATES	Kagan	Kagan represented respondent United States as USSG when an earlier iteration of this case was denied certiorari (No. 08-9393)	previous work	literally has Kagan's name on the filings
88	59	20-254	OU-YOUNG, KUANG-BAO V. ROBERTS, CHIEF JUSTICE, ET AL.	Roberts	named as party	named in case	appears to be a vexatious litigant
89	60	20-254	OU-YOUNG, KUANG-BAO V. ROBERTS, CHIEF JUSTICE, ET AL.	Breyer	named as party	named in case
90	61	20-254	OU-YOUNG, KUANG-BAO V. ROBERTS, CHIEF JUSTICE, ET AL.	Alito	named as party	named in case
91	62	20-5155	COUGHLIN, CHARLES E. V. UNITED STATES	Kavanaugh	Kavanaugh heard an earlier version of this case when he was a DC Circuit judge (610 F.3d 89 (D.C. Cir. 2010))	previous work	cert denial; IFP denial line 8
92	63	20-6173	IN RE TOMMIE H. TELFAIR	Kagan	frequent litigant, including while Kagan was in OSG	previous work
93	64	20-5094	LAUX, ANITA V. MENTOR WORLDWIDE, LLC	Alito	Mentor Worldwide LLC is a subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson, in which Alito owns shares	stock ownership	petition for rehearing denied; original denial line 24
94	65	20-5295	ATKINS, ISAAC S. V. SAUL, ANDREW M.	Barrett	Barrett heard an earlier version of this case when she was a Seventh Circuit judge (814 Fed'l App'x 150 (7th Cir. 2020))	previous work
95
96	Dec. 7 orders: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/120720zor_6jg7.pdf
97	66	19-8585	JACKSON, VAN V. UNITED STATES	Barrett	earlier iteration of the case was in Seventh Circuit when Barrett was a judge there	previous work
98	67	20-319	COMCAST CORPORATION, ET AL. V. VIAMEDIA,INC.	Barrett	earlier iteration of the case was in Seventh Circuit when Barrett was a judge there	previous work
99	68	20-388	SUN, LINGFEI V. NEW YORK, NY ET AL.	Sotomayor	earlier iteration of the case was in Second Circuit when Sotomayor was a judge there	previous work	unclear that it was heard at CA2 while Sotomayor was there, but it was in EDNY from 2007-2009
100	69	20-5922	HOOK, JULIA V. UNITED STATES, ET AL.	Gorsuch	earlier iteration of the case was in Tenth Circuit when Gorsuch was a judge there	previous work	three-judge panel heard earlier appeal in 2015; Gorsuch not on panel but was on court at the time