Copy of v3 AMF BOTEC (and sensitivity to different views)

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K	L	M	N	O	P	Q	R	S	T	W	X	Y	Z	AA	AB	AC	AD	AE
1	Version of analysis	StrongMinds WELLBYs per $1000	GiveDirectly WELLBYs per $1000	Account of death's badness	Neutral Point of LS 0-10	AMF vs Strong Minds	AMF vs Give Directly	Share from improving v. saving	total WELLBYs per $1000	WELLBYs from saving per $1k	WELLBYs from improving per $1k	Lives saved per $1k	WELLBYs from grief averted per $1K	total life-saving WELLBYs	WELLBYs saved from increase in wellbeing over time	WELLBYs saved per person	Phil adj. factor (weighted)	TRIA discount (below 5)	TRIA discount (above 5)	TRIA age of connect- ivity	Avg. net wellbeing	Expected LS for life saved (Avg. LS in country w/ adj. on 0-10)	Years of life saved	Life expectancy	Avg. Age when saved	Avg. Age when saved (below 5)	Avg. Age when saved (above 5)	below AC weight	above AC weight

2	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	0	0.53	3.96	0.31%	32.36	3.95	0.10	0.23	28.31	17.37	39.76	-22.39	100%	100%	100%	0	-0.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
3	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	1	0.36	2.72	0.46%	22.18	-6.24	0.10	0.23	28.31	-27.42	39.76	-67.18	100%	100%	100%	0	-1.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
4	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	2	0.20	1.47	0.85%	11.99	-16.42	0.10	0.23	28.31	-72.21	39.76	-111.97	100%	100%	100%	0	-2.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
5	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	3	0.03	0.22	5.62%	1.80	-26.61	0.10	0.23	28.31	-116.99	39.76	-156.75	100%	100%	100%	0	-3.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
6	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	4	-0.14	-1.03	-1.21%	-8.38	-36.79	0.10	0.23	28.31	-161.78	39.76	-201.54	100%	100%	100%	0	-4.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
7	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	5	-0.30	-2.27	-0.55%	-18.57	-46.98	0.10	0.23	28.31	-206.57	39.76	-246.33	100%	100%	100%	0	-5.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
8	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	TRIA	0	0.50	3.77	0.33%	30.76	2.35	0.10	0.23	28.31	10.32	23.62	-13.31	59%	30%	100%	5	-0.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
9	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	TRIA	5	0.15	1.10	1.13%	9.00	-19.41	0.10	0.23	28.31	-85.33	16.43	-101.76	41%	13%	100%	25	-5.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	3.22	55.42	0.67	0.33
10	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	TRIA	2	0.30	2.28	0.54%	18.65	-9.76	0.10	0.23	28.31	-42.90	23.62	-66.53	59%	30%	100%	5	-2.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
11	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	TRIA	2	0.35	2.65	0.47%	21.63	-6.78	0.10	0.23	28.31	-29.83	16.43	-46.25	41%	13%	100%	25	-2.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	3.22	55.42	0.67	0.33
16	Saving + GW income	61.35	8.17	Epicureanism		0.46	3.48	0.00%	28.41	0.00	0.10	0.23	28.31	0.00	0.00	0.00	0%	100%	100%	0	-0.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
17	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	0	0.53	3.95	0.08%	32.29	3.95	0.03	0.23	28.31	17.37	39.76	-22.39	100%	100%	100%	0	-0.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
18	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	1	0.36	2.71	0.12%	22.10	-6.24	0.03	0.23	28.31	-27.42	39.76	-67.18	100%	100%	100%	0	-1.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
19	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	2	0.19	1.46	0.21%	11.91	-16.42	0.03	0.23	28.31	-72.21	39.76	-111.97	100%	100%	100%	0	-2.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
20	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	3	0.03	0.21	1.48%	1.73	-26.61	0.03	0.23	28.31	-116.99	39.76	-156.75	100%	100%	100%	0	-3.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
21	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	4	-0.14	-1.04	-0.30%	-8.46	-36.79	0.03	0.23	28.31	-161.78	39.76	-201.54	100%	100%	100%	0	-4.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
22	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	deprivationist	5	-0.30	-2.28	-0.14%	-18.64	-46.98	0.03	0.23	28.31	-206.57	39.76	-246.33	100%	100%	100%	0	-5.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
23	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	TRIA	0	0.50	3.76	0.08%	30.68	2.35	0.03	0.23	28.31	10.32	23.62	-13.31	59%	30%	100%	5	-0.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
24	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	TRIA	0	0.49	3.67	0.09%	29.97	1.63	0.03	0.23	28.31	7.17	16.43	-9.25	41%	13%	100%	25	-0.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	3.22	55.42	0.67	0.33
25	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	TRIA	2.5	0.30	2.26	0.14%	18.49	-9.85	0.03	0.23	28.31	-43.31	18.20	-61.51	46%	14%	100%	15	-3.00	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	2.09	51.19	0.63	0.37
26	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	TRIA	5	0.01	0.05	6.03%	0.42	-27.91	0.03	0.23	28.31	-122.73	23.62	-146.36	59%	30%	100%	5	-5.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
27	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	TRIA	5	0.15	1.09	0.29%	8.93	-19.41	0.03	0.23	28.31	-85.33	16.43	-101.76	41%	13%	100%	25	-5.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	3.22	55.42	0.67	0.33
34	Saving + adj. income	61.35	8.17	Epicureanism		0.46	3.47	0.09%	28.34	0.00	0.03	0.23	28.31	0.00	0.00	0.00	0%	100%	100%	0	-0.50	-0.50	44.79	65.03	20.2	1.50	46.10	57.98%	42.02%
35			0.72																	adj factor	discount	weighted by pop
68					Deprivationism															0.30	0.70	0.41
69						Philosophical factors	AMF cost-effectiveness (WELLBYs per $1k)				Comparison (cost-effectiveness multiples)			Charity	StrongMinds	GiveDirectly	AMF			0.06	0.94	0.63
70						Neutral Point of LS 0-10	Saved	Improved	Grief averted	Total	AMF vs. GD	AMF vs. SM		Life improving WELLBY effect	61	8.17	0
71						0.00	3.95	0.03	28.31	32.29	3.95	0.53
72						1.00	-6.24	0.03	28.31	22.10	2.71	0.36
73						2.00	-16.42	0.03	28.31	11.91	1.46	0.19
74						3.00	-26.61	0.03	28.31	1.73	0.21	0.03
75						4.00	-36.79	0.03	28.31	-8.46	-1.04	-0.14
76						5.00	-46.98	0.03	28.31	-18.64	-2.28	-0.30
77						0.00	3.95	0.10	28.31	32.36	3.96	0.53
78						5.00	-46.98	0.10	28.31	-18.57	-2.27	-0.30
79
80					Epicureanism
81						Philosophical factors	AMF cost-effectiveness (WELLBYs per $1k)				Comparison (cost-effectiveness multiples)
82						Neutral Point of LS 0-10	Saved	Improved	Grief averted	Total	AMF vs. GD	AMF vs. SM
83						NA	0	0.03	28.31	28.34	3.47	0.46
84						NA	0	0.10	28.31	28.41	3.48	0.46
85
86					Tria
87						Philosophical factors			AMF cost-effectiveness (WELLBYs per $1k)				Comparison (cost-effectiveness multiples)
88						Neutral Point of LS 0-10	Tria Discount	TRIA age of connectivity	Saved	Improved	Grief averted	Total	AMF vs. GD	AMF vs. SM
89						0	40.58%	5	2.35	0.03	28.31	30.68	3.76	0.50
90						0	58.69%	25	1.63	0.03	28.31	29.97	3.67	0.49
91						2.5	54.22%	15	-9.85	0.03	28.31	18.49	2.26	0.30
92						5	40.58%	5	-27.91	0.03	28.31	0.42	0.05	0.01
93						5	58.69%	25	-19.41	0.03	28.31	8.93	1.09	0.15
94						0	0.41	5.00	2.35	0.10	28.31	30.76	3.77	0.50
95						5	0.59	25.00	-19.41	0.10	28.31	9.00	1.10	0.15
96
97
98			with life improving effects									with HLI discounted life improving effectts
99			Neutral point	StrongMinds	GiveDirectly	Deprivationism	TRIA (AC = 5)	TRIA (AC = 25)	Epicureanism		Neutral point	StrongMinds	GiveDirectly	Deprivationism	TRIA (AC = 5)	TRIA (AC = 25)	Epicureanism	AMF (TRIA)	AMF (Epicureanism)
100			0	61.35	8.17	32.36	30.76	30.19	7.22		0	61.35	8.17	32.29	30.68	29.97	28.34
101			1	61.35	8.17	22.18	24.71	25.60	7.22		1	61.35	8.17	22.10	24.63	25.76	28.34
102			2	61.35	8.17	11.99	18.65	21.00	7.22		2	61.35	8.17	11.91	18.58	21.55	28.34
103			3	61.35	8.17	1.80	12.60	16.41	7.22		3	61.35	8.17	1.73	12.53	17.34	28.34
104			4	61.35	8.17	-8.38	6.55	11.81	7.22		4	61.35	8.17	-8.46	6.48	13.14	28.34
105			5	61.35	8.17	-18.57	0.50	7.22	7.22		5	61.35	8.17	-18.64	0.42	8.93	28.34				GiveDirectly	AMF (Deprivationism)	TRIA (AC = 5)	TRIA (AC = 25)	AMF (Epicureanism)
106																					8.17	102.26	68.60	53.36	19.01
107																					8.17	85.52	58.65	46.49	19.01
108																					8.17	68.78	48.71	39.62	19.01
109																					8.17	52.05	38.76	32.75	19.01
110																					8.17	35.31	28.82	25.88	19.01
111																					8.17	18.57	18.87	19.01	19.01
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142