| A | B | C | |
|---|---|---|---|
1 | Critiques | ||
2 | This spreadsheet pulls together sources of critique about the Cass Review. | ||
3 | Note: Some critiques may be badly founded. Read critically and use your own judgement. https://gidmk.substack.com/p/the-cass-review-into-gender-identity-d6f is a good sanity check. | ||
4 | Kudos to Ruth Pearce for pulling together the initial list here: https://ruthpearce.net/2024/04/16/whats-wrong-with-the-cass-review-a-round-up-of-commentary-and-evidence/ | ||
5 | |||
6 | Column definitions | ||
7 | Link | Link to the source | |
8 | Title | Title of the source | |
9 | Author | Author of the source | |
10 | Author link | Link to the author of the source | |
11 | Type | Type of the source, one of: | |
12 | paper | academic paper | |
13 | statement | official statement from a body | |
14 | letter | open letter | |
15 | blog | blog post on own website | |
16 | article | article on website | |
17 | podcast | podcast episode | |
18 | post | post or thread on social media platform (link to first post in thread if there are several) | |
19 | Novel | Does the source include a novel point or analysis (rather than summarising those from others) | |
20 | Notes | Summary of what the source says overall, and any particular highlights | |
21 | Critique: Process | Summary of any critique given about the process, eg the set up of the review, advisory board and so on | |
22 | Critique: Evidence | Summary of any critique about either the quality of evidence used, or how evidence was interpreted in the report | |
23 | Critique: Recommendations | Summary of any critique about the recommendations and how they have arisen from the evidence | |
24 | Critique: Policy adoption | Summary of any critique about how the Review's recommendations have been translated into policy action | |
25 | Critique: Media coverage | Summary of any critique about how the Review's recommendations have been characterised in the media | |
26 | |||