ABC
1
Critiques
2
This spreadsheet pulls together sources of critique about the Cass Review.
3
Note: Some critiques may be badly founded. Read critically and use your own judgement. https://gidmk.substack.com/p/the-cass-review-into-gender-identity-d6f is a good sanity check.
4
Kudos to Ruth Pearce for pulling together the initial list here: https://ruthpearce.net/2024/04/16/whats-wrong-with-the-cass-review-a-round-up-of-commentary-and-evidence/
5
6
Column definitions
7
Link
Link to the source
8
Title
Title of the source
9
Author
Author of the source
10
Author link
Link to the author of the source
11
Type
Type of the source, one of:
12
paperacademic paper
13
statementofficial statement from a body
14
letteropen letter
15
blogblog post on own website
16
articlearticle on website
17
podcastpodcast episode
18
postpost or thread on social media platform (link to first post in thread if there are several)
19
Novel
Does the source include a novel point or analysis (rather than summarising those from others)
20
Notes
Summary of what the source says overall, and any particular highlights
21
Critique: Process
Summary of any critique given about the process, eg the set up of the review, advisory board and so on
22
Critique: Evidence
Summary of any critique about either the quality of evidence used, or how evidence was interpreted in the report
23
Critique: Recommendations
Summary of any critique about the recommendations and how they have arisen from the evidence
24
Critique: Policy adoption
Summary of any critique about how the Review's recommendations have been translated into policy action
25
Critique: Media coverage
Summary of any critique about how the Review's recommendations have been characterised in the media
26