EPDP-IDNs Phase 1 Initial Report Public Comment Review Tool

	A	B	C	D	F	G	H
1	Rec # & Link	Comments Received?	Significant Concerns or Objections Raised?	Further Discussion Required	Public Comment Statistics

2	Section 4.1 RZ-LGR as the Sole Source				No. Submission	12
3	Rec 1.1	Yes	Yes	No	No. Commenters	10
4	Section 4.2 Same Entity Principle				Commenters	ALAC
5	Rec 2.1	Yes	No	No		BC
6	Section 4.3 Application Submission, Administrative Check, Initial Evaluation					CCWP-HR	Note: Cross-Community Working Party on ICANN and Human Rights
7	Rec 3.1	Yes	No	No		CORE Association
8	Rec 3.2	No	No	No		GAC
9	Rec 3.3	Yes	No	No		ICANN org
10	Rec 3.4	Yes	No	Yes		Julius Kirimi
11	Rec 3.5	Yes	Yes	Yes		PointQuebec	Note: 3 submissions total; 2 submissions are duplicative
12	IG 3.6	Yes	Yes	Yes		RrSG
13	Rec 3.7	Yes	No	No		RySG
14	IG 3.8	No	No	No	No. Recs that received comments	42 out of 68
15	IG 3.9	Yes	No	Yes	No. Recs that received significant concerns or objections	21 out of 68	Note: Some commenters did not explicitly indicate the level of support or non-support; staff placed such comments under relevant recommendations and categories for the EPDP Team to discuss
16	Rec 3.10	Yes	No	No
17	Rec 3.11	Yes	Yes	No	Other Relevant Development
18	Rec 3.12	Yes	Yes	No	Rec 3.22	ICANN Board	Possible non-adoption of SubPro Recommendation 32.2 and 32.10
19	Rec 3.13	Yes	Yes	No	Rec 3.17	CJK GPs	Pending decision on relevant guidelines
20	Rec 3.14	Yes	Yes	No
21	Rec 3.15	Yes	Yes	No
22	Rec 3.16	Yes	Yes	No
23	Rec 3.17	No	No	Pending Input
24	Rec 3.18	Yes	No	No
25	Rec 3.19	No	No	No
26	Rec 3.20	No	No	No
27	Rec 3.21	No	No	No
28	Rec 3.22	No	No	Pending Input
29	IG 3.23	No	No	No
30	Rec 3.24	Yes	No	No
31	Section 4.4 String Similarity Review
32	Rec 4.1	Yes	No	No
33	Rec 4.2	No	No	No
34	Rec 4.3	No	No	No
35	Rec 4.4	Yes	Yes	No
36	Section 4.5 Objection Processes
37	Rec 5.1	No	No	No
38	Rec 5.2	No	No	No
39	Rec 5.3	Yes	No	No
40	Rec 5.4	No	No	No
41	Rec 5.5	No	No	No
42	Section 4.6 String Contention
43	Rec 6.1	No	No	No
44	Rec 6.2	Yes	No	No
45	Section 4.7 Contractual Requirements
46	Rec 7.1	Yes	No	Yes
47	IG 7.2	No	No	No
48	Rec 7.3	Yes	Yes	Yes
49	IG 7.4	No	No	No
50	Rec 7.5	Yes	Yes	No
51	Rec 7.6	Yes	Yes	No
52	Rec 7.7	Yes	Yes	No
53	Rec 7.8	Yes	Yes	No
54	Rec 7.9	Yes	Yes	No
55	Rec 7.10	Yes	No	No
56	Rec 7.11	No	No	No
57	Rec 7.12	Yes	Yes	No
58	Rec 7.13	Yes	Yes	No
59	IG 7.14	Yes	No	Yes
60	Rec 7.15	No	No	Yes
61	Section 4.8 Delegation and Removal
62	Rec 8.1	Yes	Yes	No
63	Rec 8.2	Yes	Yes	Yes
64	IG 8.3	Yes	No	No
65	Rec 8.4	No	No	No
66	Rec 8.5	Yes	No	No
67	Rec 8.6	No	No	No
68	Rec 8.7	Yes	No	No
69	Rec 8.8	No	No	No
70	IG 8.9	Yes	No	No
71	Rec 8.10	No	No	No
72	Rec 8.11 (see new IG 8.12)	Yes	Yes	Yes
73	Rec 8.12	Yes	No	No
74	Section 4.9 Variant Label States
75	Rec 9.1	No	No	No
76	IG 9.2	No	No	No
77	Rec 9.3	No	No	No
78	IG 9.4	Yes	No	No
79	Other Comments
80	Other	Yes	No	No
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100