Mattress Comparisons
 Share
The version of the browser you are using is no longer supported. Please upgrade to a supported browser.Dismiss

View only
 
 
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAAB
1
BrandModel
Price (Queen) before discounts
DeliveryReturnsMaterialGood ForWarranty
Made in USA?
ReviewsDiscountsBonusEbatesNotesProsConsLinkTUFT reviewVIDEO reviewOther links ?
2
Most of these brands carry more models than the ones I have listed, I just chose to focus on the models that I thought best fit our needs/budget.
Don't have ebates? Please use my link to sign up to get the cash back options listed here. (You'll get $10 free if you use my link!) https://www.ebates.com/r/LADYMA700?eeid=28187
3
PurpleNew Purple .3$2,199
Free White Glove
Free 100 days
(Purple polymer grid) Top Layer: 3” Hyper-Elastic Polymer™ material in Smart Comfort Grid. Non-toxic polyethylene copolymer powder coating. Foam Layer: 1” 2.0 lbs density polyurethane foam. Responsive Support Coils:7.5” Pocketed Springs
The New Purple, on the other hand, is exceptional for every body profile and sleep style. It has give in the areas where you dig further into the mattress, like your shoulders and hips, at the same time giving you mid-back support. We recommend the 4″ model for heavier sleepers and the 2″ for those of you who are lighter weight.
10 yearMade in USA-Free pillow or sheets2% cash back
"Purple’s anomalous materials are well-suited to those who sleep hot and hate foam (even hybrid mattresses will layer coils with foam; Purple uses just two very thin layers of foam) and who are game to try something very different." http://nymag.com/strategist/article/best-mattresses-buy-online.html
Can't be used with tradtitional boxspring. Cost of platform base $174
https://purple.com/
https://www.tuck.com/purple-mattress-review/
4
PurpleOriginal$999
Free White Glove
Free 100 days10 yearMade in USA-Free pillow or sheets2% cash backCan't be used with tradtitional boxspring. Cost of platform base $174
https://purple.com/
https://www.tuck.com/purple-mattress-review/
5
Saatva
Luxury Firm (all firmness options are the same price)
$1,099
Free White Glove delivery, Free removal of old mattress.
120 day home trial, $99 transportation fee
Individually wrapped coils, edge & lumbar support, steel coil support base, organic cotton cover, and euro pillow top with a memory foam enhancement in the lumbar area.
15 year non-prorated
Made in USA-$75 visa gift card (link through TUFT)4% cash back
We would generally recommend purchasing our entire system, both mattress and foundation. But if your box spring/foundation is in very good condition, meaning it's sturdy and has absolutely no sagging, it should work fine. Your mattress warranty remains in place even when using your foundation/ box spring.
Eco Materials. 0% APR if paid in full in 6 months.
limited motion isolation, heavy compared to foam, life of 6-7 years
https://www.saatvamattress.com/
https://www.tuck.com/saatva-mattress-review/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=juoIVlpGOwQ
6
SaatvaLoom & Leaf$1,299
Free White Glove delivery, Free removal of old mattress.
120 day home trial, $99 transportation fee
Featuring high-density 5lb memory foam, cooling support layers, and handcrafted details like a breathable organic cotton convering.
Side sleepers15 yearMade in USA-$75 visa gift card (link through TUFT)4% cash back offgassing, life 6-7 years, bad edge support, bad heat dispersion
https://www.loomandleaf.com/
https://www.tuck.com/loom-and-leaf-mattress-review/
7
Leesa SapiraSapira$1,595
Free standard shipping. $50 for delivery. another $50 for removal
100 days full refund
Premium foams and springs for enhanced pressure relief with edge-to-edge support
This is a foam mattress, but a substantial one that offers excellent pressure relief. It should suit all kinds of sleepers and is a good mattress for anyone who doesn’t want to overthink it. http://nymag.com/strategist/article/best-mattresses-buy-online.html "Side-, stomach-, and back-sleepers should all like the Sapira. It’s especially good for people who change positions (aka rotators), because the springs make it easy to move around on."
10 year limitedMade in USA4/5 Amazon
$235 off with code TUCK, 15% off with WELCOME15, 18% with code WIRECUTTER
15% off and 2 free pillows (Presidents Day?)
3% cash back
Our mattresses are designed to deliver their signature feel sitting on a firm, flat, and sturdy surface. Below are the best options to support your mattress: - The Leesa Foundation $295, A solid platform, A solid box spring/foundation, A Bunkie board on a traditional box spring, A slatted base
1 mattress donated for every 10 sold. Motion Isolation "Very Good"
Not good for side sleeper under 130 lbs (LOL that's not me)
https://www.leesa.com/products/sapira-mattress?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=Sapira-Brand-National&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIjc227Kvq4AIVlksNCh2UwgAsEAAYASABEgIyX_D_BwE
https://www.tuck.com/sapira-mattress-review/
8
LeesaUniversal Adaptive Feel$995
Free standard shipping. $50 for delivery. another $50 for removal
100 days full refund
Made with premium foams for cooling, contouring and pressure-relieving support
10 year limitedMade in USA4/5 Amazon
$160 off with code TUCK, 15% off with WELCOME15, 18% with code WIRECUTTER
15% off and 2 free pillows (Presidents Day?)
3% cash back
1 mattress donated for every 10 sold.
offgassing, life 7-8 years
https://www.leesa.com/collections/mattresses
https://www.tuck.com/leesa-mattress-review/
9
Aviya
Luxury Firm (all firmness options are the same price)
$1,099
Free shipping, 3rd-party delivery, not upstairs. $99 Delivery & Set up. $159 old mattress removal
hybrid 3 layers of high-density foam over coiled innerspring
10 yearsMade in USA$100 off with code MARCH2019-
The Aviya is supportive but soft, and is another can’t-go-wrong choice for those who don’t want to overthink it, but know that they’d prefer an innerspring system. http://nymag.com/strategist/article/best-mattresses-buy-online.html
"If your boxspring is older than five years and/or has an uneven surface, we recommend you replace it to give your new Aviya mattress the solid support it needs." poor motion isolation, only "fair" for most sleeping positions.
https://www.aviyamattress.com/products/the-aviya-mattress
https://www.tuck.com/aviya-mattress-review/
10
Wink
Luxury Firm (all firmness options are the same price)
$1,599
Free shipping, $99 delivery
120 days full refund
from top to bottom, these have a thin layer of foam (for comfiness), air springs (to keep things cool), a support pad (to keep your lumbar area well-supported), and tempered steel coils (for pushback, and to keep the mattress from losing shape). Wink beds come in soft, luxury firm, and firm.
Limited Lifetime
Made in USA
$200 off with code SLEEP200, $50 off with code TUCK
-
"We generally recommend purchasing both the mattress and foundation. However, if your box spring/foundation is in very good condition, meaning it’s sturdy, has no sagging, and remains a smooth and even surface, it should work fine."
Lifetime 50% off comfort replacement. Good all over reviews on TUCK, and good for all types of sleepers. The price point is the only downfall.
Traditional boxspring not recommended. Cost of foundation $250. mandatory. 30 night break in period before returns
https://www.winkbeds.com/pages/shop
https://www.tuck.com/winkbeds-mattress-review/
11
ParachuteThe Mattress$1,899
Free white glove delivery, includes removal
90 day trial free returns
Layers of pure New Zealand wool, 100% organic cotton and pocketed steel coils are hand-tufted together for a superior sleep experience.
10 yearsMade in USA--
The Mattress does not require a box spring, but we recommend having some sort of foundation or frame (slats, platform etc.). If you are using slats, be sure the gaps are no wider than five inches. The Mattress is compatible with adjustable bases.
The quality is great, the materials used are clean, eco friendly, all natural. Comfort sounds amazing. Wish we could afford it.
Honestly, if it weren't out of our budget this would be my top choice.
https://www.parachutehome.com/products/mattress
Released in Jan 2019. Too early for user reviews.
12
AvocadoGreen Mattress
$1399 + $400 for pillowtop
Free shipping. $199 setup and mattress removal
100 night free
Our natural mattress features 100% natural latex rubber, natural wool, GOTS organic certified cotton and up to 1,414 pocketed support coils.
Side sleepers couldn’t be happier on the Avocado mattress, though folks who weigh 130 lbs and under often find themselves more comfortable on the pillow-top model that’s a Medium feel. Similarly, our in-house testing team found side sleepers of any weight receive great support and body contouring effects. Tuck.com
25-Year Limited Warranty. Years 1 - 10: Full coverage, Non-Prorated | Years 11-25: Limited Coverage, Prorated
Made in USA
$150 off with code NATURE150, $100 off with code TUCK100
2 free pillows with code 2FREEPILLOWS
-
Excellent temperature neutrality. Firm. Top-rated by consumer reports, all-natural, eco friendly, Greenguard Gold Certified. "We've partnered with Affirm®, so you can pay for your Avocado Green Mattress and bedding over 6, 12 or 18 months with rates as low as 0% APR with qualifying credit."
Too firm for side sleepers. Too expensive. Uhm I might be a little allergic to latex. :(
https://www.avocadogreenmattress.com/shop/avocado-mattress/
https://www.tuck.com/avocado-mattress-review/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z7T29NHv3KQ
13
Tuft & NeedleMint$1,145
Free Shipping. Comes in a box.
100 days
Memory foam - enhanced T&N Adaptive® foam, 30% more graphite for maximum heat dispersion, STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX® certified ultra plush, cozy charcoal knitted cover (16.HUS.79211, Hohenstein HTTI), 12" thickness
10 year limitedMade in USA$150 off2 free pillows-
"Another crowd pleaser for anyone who’s happy with foam, Tuft & Needle is a very smart choice for anyone looking to spend a bit less."
Very Good Motion Isolation. Maybe we do need to try a foam mattress? Compatible with any bed frame/boxspring
offgassing, edge support
https://www.tuftandneedle.com/mattress/mint/
https://www.tuck.com/tuft-and-needle-mattress-review/
14
NestAlexander Signature Hybrid$1,199
Free Shipping. Comes in a box.
100 nights, must keep for 30 days
hybrid memory foam coil
Side & back sleepers who run hot
Lifetime warranty, lifetime comfort guarantee
Made in USA
4.5/5 Amazon (only 5 reviews)
$100 off with code NEST1003.5% cash back
Do I need a new foundation with my new Nest Bedding mattress? No, but it is highly recommended that you use this time to review your foundation and supports to make sure that they are still working well and providing rigid support for your mattress. It is highly recommended that boxed foundations or boxed springs are replaced each time a new mattress is purchased.
very good edge support, good motion isolation,
lower heat dispersion, memory foam not great if you like to move around in your sleep.
https://www.nestbedding.com/products/the-alexander-hybrid-signature-select-mattress
https://www.tuck.com/nest-bedding-mattress-reviews/
15
NestAlexander Signature (foam)$1,199
Free Shipping. Comes in a box.
100 nights, must keep for 30 days
memory foam
med weight side & back sleepers
Lifetime warranty, lifetime comfort guarantee
Made in USA
$100 off with code NEST100, 8% off with code TUCK8
3.5% cash back
Do I need a new foundation with my new Nest Bedding mattress? No, but it is highly recommended that you use this time to review your foundation and supports to make sure that they are still working well and providing rigid support for your mattress. It is highly recommended that boxed foundations or boxed springs are replaced each time a new mattress is purchased.
very good motion Isolation.
low edge support, not good for stomach sleeper, hot
https://www.nestbedding.com/products/the-alexander-signature-select-mattress
https://www.tuck.com/nest-bedding-mattress-reviews/
https://youtu.be/7AdMvbWiIEc
16
NestHybrid Latex$1,399
Free Shipping. Comes in a box.
100 nights, must keep for 30 days
hybrid coil & latex foam
Lifetime warranty, lifetime comfort guarantee
Made in USA
$100 off with code NEST100, 8% off with code TUCK8
3.5% cash back
Do I need a new foundation with my new Nest Bedding mattress? No, but it is highly recommended that you use this time to review your foundation and supports to make sure that they are still working well and providing rigid support for your mattress. It is highly recommended that boxed foundations or boxed springs are replaced each time a new mattress is purchased.
natural materials, latex has longer lifespan than memory foam, sleeps cool. very good edge support, good motion isolation.
a little squeeky (noisy)
https://www.nestbedding.com/products/the-nest-bedding-hybrid-latex
https://www.tuck.com/nest-bedding-mattress-reviews/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMJ4BWNoGPQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=556&v=Fn_r5daLH3s
17
NectarMemory Foam Mattress$824
Free Shipping. Comes in a box.
365 daysMemory foam
"Forever Warranty"
China and they lied about it. https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2018/03/nectar-brand-llc-agrees-settle-ftc-charges-companys-claims-about
$125 off with code TUCK2 free pillows-
Works with all frames. "Our flexible foam is CertiPUR-US® Certified which means it meets the CertiPUR-US® standards for being free from ozone depleters, PBDEs, TDCPP, mercury, or lead."
made in china. memory foam = sinking in, , low edge support, bad if you get too hot
https://www.nectarsleep.com/mattress
https://www.tuck.com/nectar-mattress-review/
18
Eco TerraEco Terra Mattress$899
Free Shipping. (Comes in a box) White Glove for $299
90 nights
Latex hybrid. The supreme luxury and pure comfort of natural latex combined with the buoyant support of premium encased coils, delivered right to your door.
Our testing process found Eco Terra mattresses should also be great for you if… You want a latex hybrid with a below-average price-point, You tend to sleep hot, You and/or your sleep partner awaken easily due to noise or movement, You want a bed with an average thickness profile
15 non-prorated
Made in USA3.5 / 5 amazon$150 off with code SALE150-
motion dispersal, eco friendly materials, charitable
30 day break in period.
https://ecoterrabeds.com/products/ecoterra-latex-mattresses?sscid=31k3_3k8jz&variant=38327851399
https://www.tuck.com/eco-terra-mattress-reviews/
19
KeetsaTea Leaf Classic$1,590
Free Shipping. Comes in a box.
90 day trial, 30 day break in period requirement, 10% fee
Hybrid Biofoam & iCoil
12 year nonprorated
?5% with code BETTERDAY-5% cash back
eco friendly materials, charitable
bad for lightweight side sleepers. fee for returns. price.
https://www.keetsa.com/collections/mattresses/products/tea-leaf-classic?variant=1294402
https://www.tuck.com/keetsa-hybrid-mattress-review/
20
Live and SleepLuxury$849
Free 2 day shipping
100 night sleep trial
CertiPUR-US Certified memory foam
side sleepers20 years?
$150 and 2 free pillows with code LUXURY2019
$150 and 2 free pillows with code LUXURY2019
-
eco friendly materials, charitable
ratings are just ok?
https://www.liveandsleep.com/
https://www.sleepcupid.com/mattress-reviews/live-sleep-mattress-review
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H65DPLjr_3M
21
Lucid12" Latex Hybrid$620
Free Shipping. Comes in a box.
30 days
Hybrid Latex and Coil
10 yearsChina :(
4.5/5 Amazon (422)
maybe cheaper rate from Amazon--
the price is right.
only 30 day return window. made in china.
https://lucidmattress.com/products/lucid-12-latex-hybrid-mattress
https://www.tuck.com/lucid-mattress-review/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1C28lKfZraQ
22
Lucid
Bamboo Charcoal Aloe Vera Hybrid
$400
Free Shipping. Comes in a box.
30 days
Hybrid Memory Foam and Coil
10 yearsChina :(4.5/5 Amazonmaybe cheaper rate from Amazon--
the price is right.
only 30 day return window. made in china.
https://lucidmattress.com/products/lucid-12-bamboo-charcoal-and-aloe-vera-hybrid-mattress
https://www.tuck.com/lucid-mattress-review/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dH70hsm-rh8
23
24
25
We ultimately decided on the Nest Bedding - Latex Foam Hybrid. The most important factors to us were edge support, motion isolation, heat dispersion, Made in USA, the generous lifetime warranty. Also appealing: The top layer of foam can be zipped out and replaced. So if we're not happy, we can request a new foam layer of either a less/more firm latex or switch for memory foam.
26
If price were not a factor: Top choices would have been Purple, Parachute, or Avocado green with topper.
27
Helpful articles:
28
http://nymag.com/strategist/article/best-mattresses-buy-online.html
29
https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-foam-mattresses-you-can-buy-online/
30
https://elemental.green/19-eco-friendly-mattresses-for-every-budget/
31
https://thewirecutter.com/guides/buying-a-mattress/
32
https://myslumberyard.com/
33
https://www.usalovelist.com/buying-a-mattress-made-in-usa/
34
35
36
note to self: if using a headboard, measure the height and choose a mattress height that doesn't cover the base of it.
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
Loading...