ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
1
ROSES Current Version Update Record
2
3
Current Version:Version 1.0Nov-17
4
5
ROSES formUpdate itemUpdate descriptionUpdate performed byUpdate reasonDate of updateImplemented on website (yes/no)
6
Systematic review report
Declarations/Competing interests
Line removed due to duplication with Ensuring procedural independence
NRH and BMDuplication29/1/2018yes
7
Systematic map report
Declarations/Competing interests
Line removed due to duplication with Ensuring procedural independence
NRH and BMDuplication29/1/2018yes
8
Systematic review reportConclusions
Identified knowledge gaps and Identified knowledge clusters removed from conclusions due to duplication with Discussion section
NRH and BMDuplication29/1/2018yes
9
Systematic map reportConclusions
Identified knowledge gaps and Identified knowledge clusters removed from conclusions due to duplication with Discussion section
NRH and BMDuplication29/1/2018yes
10
Systematic map protocolForm citations
CEE Guidelines citation updated
NRH and BMUpdate29/1/2018yes
11
Systematic review protocolForm citations
CEE Guidelines citation updated
NRH and BMUpdate29/1/2018yes
12
Systematic review reportForm citations
CEE Guidelines citation updated
NRH and BMUpdate29/1/2018yes
13
Systematic map reportForm citations
CEE Guidelines citation updated
NRH and BMUpdate29/1/2018yes
14
Systematic review protocol
Critical appraisal
Compulsory' removed from Further explanation column
NRH and BMCorrection29/1/2018yes
15
Systematic review report
Critical appraisal exclusions
Typographical error corrected: 'f' replaced with 'for'
NRH and BMCorrection29/1/2018yes
16
Systematic map reportAbstract
References to statistical analysis and data extraction removed and reworded to apply specifically for systematic maps
NRH and BMCorrection29/1/2018yes
17
Systematic review reportDiscussion
Removed line dedicated to knowledge gaps and clusters erroneously present
NRH and BMCorrection29/1/2018yes
18
Systematic review reportDiscussion
Line added for general discussion text
NRH and BMAmendment29/1/2018yes
19
Systematic map report
Data extraction
Title changes to meta-data extraction and coding strategy
NRH and BMCorrection1/2/2018yes
20
Systematic map report
Critical appraisal used in synthesis
Changed from optional to 'Compulsory if critical appraisal performed'
NRH and BMAmendment1/2/2018yes
21
Systematic map report
Knowledge gaps and clusters
Section moved from Discussion to Conclusions
NRH and BMCorrection1/2/2018yes
22
Systematic map reportDeclarations
Line added to cover conflicts of interest
NRH and BMCorrection27/2/2018yes
23
Systematic map protocolDeclarations
Line added to cover conflicts of interest
NRH and BMCorrection27/2/2018yes
24
Systematic review protocolDeclarations
Line added to cover conflicts of interest
NRH and BMCorrection27/2/2018yes
25
Systematic review reportDeclarations
Line added to cover conflicts of interest
NRH and BMCorrection27/2/2018yes
26
Systematic map reportAll
n/a' option added to optional checklist items
NRH and BMCorrection28/2/2018yes
27
Systematic map protocolAll
n/a' option added to optional checklist items
NRH and BMCorrection28/2/2018yes
28
Systematic review protocolAll
n/a' option added to optional checklist items
NRH and BMCorrection28/2/2018yes
29
Systematic review reportAll
n/a' option added to optional checklist items
NRH and BMCorrection28/2/2018yes
30
Systematic review reportResults
"Number of search results (-duplicates)" changed to "Number of search results after duplicate removal"
NRH and BMClarification28/2/2018yes
31
Systematic map reportResults
"Number of search results (-duplicates)" changed to "Number of search results after duplicate removal"
NRH and BMClarification28/2/2018yes
32
Systematic review reportAll
Removed "Compulsory" from additional information column for clarity, all items not marked as "Optional" are compulsory
NRH and BMClarification28/2/2018yes
33
Systematic map reportAll
Removed "Compulsory" from additional information column for clarity, all items not marked as "Optional" are compulsory
NRH and BMClarification28/2/2018yes
34
Flow diagramAll
Separated the flow diagram into one for systematic reviews (as is) and one for systematic maps, with critical appraisal section removed and synthesis section simplified
NRH and BMUpdate04/04/18yes
35
Systematic review protocol
Knowledge gaps and clusters
Removed "and knowledge clusters (well-represented subtopics that are amenable to full synthesis via systematic review)."; topic renamed to "Knowledge gap identification strategy"
NRH and BMCorrection27/04/18yes
36
SR flow diagram
Exclusions at critical appraisal
'Excluded studies' replaced with 'Excluded from further synthesis' to indicate that studies were not fully exlcuded from the review
NRHCorrection25/5/20yes
37
SR flow diagram
Articles / Studies included after full text screening
'articles/studies included after full text screening' replaced with 'articles/studies included in the review' at the point of the line (articles --> studies)
NRHClarification25/5/20yes
38
Systematic map protocolMethods
Removed redundant drop down menu related to "Methods" item
BMCorrection15/5/22yes
39
Systematic map protocolItem numbersAdded item numbersBMAmendment15/5/22yes
40
Systematic review reportResults
Added "(review findings)" to section heading "Results"
BMClarification15/5/22yes
41
Systematic review reportDiscussion
Removed text related to discussion, including following: "Discuss the review results and suggest further enquiry or analysis (e.g. potential reasons for heterogeneity in outcome). Authors may draw attention to specific knowledge gaps" to avoid possible overinterpretation of review findings
BM
Clarification/Correction
15/5/22yes
42
Systematic review reportItem numbersAdded item numbersBMAmendment15/5/22yes
43
Systematic map reportDiscussion
Removed text related to discussion, including following: "Discuss the review results and suggest further enquiry or analysis (e.g. potential reasons for heterogeneity in outcome)" to avoid possible overinterpretation of review findings
BM
Clarification/Correction
15/5/22yes
44
Systematic map reportItem numbersAdded item numbersBMAmendment15/5/22yes
45
Systematic map reportResults
Added "(review findings)" to section heading "Results"
BMClarification15/5/22yes
46
Systematic review protocolItem numbersAdded item numbersBMAmendment15/5/22yes
47
Systematic review protocolMethods
Removed redundant drop down menu related to "Methods" item
BMCorrection15/5/22yes
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100