School / Partnership Initials: Example: Capital City XY, Boston Latin AB

Affirmative Plan Text (As used in round)

Off-Case Positions (please separate with a comma)

Link Your Evidence Set, If Applicable

jacksonk0408@student.k12.tulsaschools.org

Edison Preperatory School, Tulsa, OK

The United States federal government should reform current mining laws that affect federal public land.

Mining, Framing, Solvency

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ltZZh70jBGK80tp1bsBo8cs56KGfvm9jhzaHJCxdAUE/edit?usp=sharing

Requested additional link added by Wayne / Centner from MIA:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PcbTRvkbrxqI2lOrfMw7o9xrG6PmFGxq/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=117211827543380833481&rtpof=true&sd=true

wayneselogy@gmail.com

The US federal government will protect the water by implementing 5 best management practices. (streamside buffers, streamside fencing, nutrient management plans, continuous no-till, and cover crops)

- without changes to our federal policies, our pollution problem will continue to grow
- over-reliance on antibiotics in livestock feeds produces ABR
- CAFO spillovers are direct threats to local water supplies
- AG RUNOFF creates aquatic dead zones
- Our plan solves, we need to mandate uniform standards

Out plan sufficiently curbs CAFO pollution, Regulation requirements are inadequate they only apply once they have been caught, Regulations don’t work and fail to protect water resources, Biodiversity loss can cause a cascade affect and cause mass extinction,
The AFF does not violate federalism there is precedent for federal intervention when the states fail to address water quality standards.

wayneselogy@gmail.com

PLAN FOR FRACKING: The United States federal government should ban the use of hydraulic fracturing techniques by energy companies in the United States.
PLAN FOR AGG RUN OFF : The Us should substantially protect US water resources by establishing mandatory best practices for farmland sources contributing to water quality impairment

ADV FOR FRACKING:1. Pennsylvania links framing to health problems.
2. States have already banned fracking.
3. Methane contributes 30%
ADV FOR AGG RUN OFF: Regulations do not protect water resources
CAFOs create antibiotic resistant diseases
Mutating diseases leas to extinction
Agriculture is the biggest contributor to water pollution
Nutrient runoff comes from intensive farming practices

AGG RUN OFF :https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PcbTRvkbrxqI2lOrfMw7o9xrG6PmFGxq/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=117007373486849810396&rtpof=true&sd=true

wayneselogy@gmail.com

The United States Federal Government should ban the use of hydraulic fracturing techniques by energy companies in the united states by revoking permits for current oil and gas wells within 2500 ft of inhabited structures and end federal subsides for fracking companies.

Water and air pollution hurts our planet
Health harms such as mental health problems, impaired infant development, asthma, heart problems, skin rashes, and Cancer.
Water is not possible to to decontaminate.
Protection of low income communities
Not profitable industry

Energy security is a myth, fracking is a non profitable industry, fracking can't be regulated.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xTb0RUI5V1lySPnfe-rw0DYtvO7yu_rE/edit

wayneselogy@gmail.com

The United States federal government should substantially increase its protection of water resources in the United States by establishing the five mandatory best management practices: stream side buffers, stream side fencing, nutrient management plans, continuous no till and cover crops for farmland sources contributing to water quality impairment.

Antibiotic Resistant Bacteria
Marine Life
Improving food production without being wasteful
Reduces costs and allows the Agriculture industry to focus on profit

AFF plan curbs CAFO pollution
regulation requirements are inadequate
regulations fail to protect water resources
biodiversity loss can cause a mass extinction
the AFF does not violate federalism, there is a precedent for federal intervention the states fail to address water quality standards.

https://ecology.wa.gov/Water-Shorelines/Water-quality/Runoff-pollution/Agricultural-runoff
https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/agricultural-runoff
https://www.ibm.com/blogs/internet-of-things/the-benefits-of-sustainable-agriculture-and-how-we-get-there/
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PcbTRvkbrxqI2lOrfMw7o9xrG6PmFGxq/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=117007373486849810396&rtpof=true&sd=true

molly.miller@tulsadebate.org

The United States federal government should designate 30 percent of ocean territory in each major geographic ocean region of the United States, including it’s EEZ as no-take Marine Protected Areas.

Oceans, Climate Change, Food Security

Topicality, ASPEC, Fisheries DA, Biz Con DA, State CP, Cap K, Set Col K, Econ DA, EPA Tradeoff DA, Federalism DA, Food Prices DA, Politics DA, Inflation DA, Russia DA,

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1McfEefzAs-omwxPJRBTpDSNCQdIM7vFR/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=112377845798241553458&rtpof=true&sd=true

larry.dang2018@gmail.com

Water Privatization: The United States federal government should expand access to privatized water, so that everyone has the option to choose it as a source.
Fracking: The United States Federal Government should phase out “fracking” in the United States over the next five years.
Ag Runoff: The United States federal government should substantially increase its protection of water resources in the United States by establishing mandatory best management practices for farmland sources contributing to water quality impairment.

Water Privatization: Cost, Health
Fracking: Health, Climate Change
Ag Runoff: Antibiotic Resistance, Marine Life

Cyber Security DA, Energy Security DA, Economy DA, Regulation CP, Federalism DA, Business Confidence DA, States CP

Water Privatization: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Ur7NahN2K2dCxpfTTPN-goqlR0tCLlQN/edit?rtpof=true
Fracking: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1j1jiDq2PcvVtkrnEOJHypW1mxP-IGeKh/edit
Ag Runoff: https://docs.google.com/document/d/155RK0-gjwJji-EnvhiUJIijdI9rfnyC3OQ1pX1zvoS4/edit

Thus the Plan: The United States Federal Government should phase out unconventional oil and natural gas extraction, or “fracking” in the United States over the next five years.

&

The United States should adopt a sliding scale rule without an imminence requirement to regulate aquatic invasive species in United States waters.

Fracking Aff - Climate Change and Green Leadership

Aquatic Invasive Species Aff - Biodiversity

Neoliberalism K, Regulation CP, Energy Shock DA, Economy DA, Manufacturing DA, T: Water Resources, Shipping DA, Interstate CP, Fishing CP

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1yrTIGx-mEpQd-BO7p9BIPxZGZCxuBBcg?usp=sharing

David.trigaux@urbandebate.org

Thus the Plan: The United States Federal Government should phase out unconventional oil and natural gas extraction, or “fracking” in the United States over the next five years.

david.trigaux@urbandebate.org

Instead of debating about the water resources of the US, we propose we should engage in a deeper understanding of the environment in general, reject indigenous genocide and anthropocentrism and embrace wholistic ecological activism, that connects to a whole system of impacts. The judge has a responsibility to reject shallow ecology shown in the resolution.

Deep Ecology, Other WUDL off-case positions

david.trigaux@urbandebate.org

Thus the Plan: The United States Federal Government should phase out unconventional oil and natural gas extraction, or “fracking” in the United States over the next five years.

Health, Warming, Soft Power, LNG, Russia,

david.trigaux@urbandebate.org

The United States federal government should enforce tribal Water Quality Standards where the conflict with other standards and establish Water Quality Standards throughout those parts of Indian Country where tribes have not yet created them based on narrative, site specific requirements.

david.trigaux@urbandebate.org

Plan: The United States federal government should substantially increase the protection of water resources in disadvantaged communities by:
1.] Develop a metric to identify disadvantaged communities
2.] Provide funding for water infrastructure to those disadvantaged communities

Environmental Justice, Democracy

(All WUDL Teams)
T: Protection, Substantial, USFG/Framework, Resources
DAs: Elections, Agenda Politics, Agriculture, Energy Prices, Russia, Pollution Export, Fiscal Discipline, Federalism, and Mineral Mining
CPs: States, Courts, Privatization
Cap K, Deep Eco K, Anthro K (Hobson and MoVi mostly)

https://urbandebatewashingtondc.org/resources/evidence-curriculum/

Therefore Paola and I oppose fossil fuel expansion in North Brooklyn and urge everyone in this debate round to sign the "Don't Vaporize Brooklyn!" petition.

T: Protection, Resources
CPs: States
Cap K, Environmental Racism K