ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABACADAEAFAGAHAIAJAKALAMANAOAPAQARASAT
1
New Incentives – current states of operationNew Incentives – prospective statesNew Incentives – prospective states
2
NigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeria
3
unittypeOverallBauchiGombeJigawaKadunaKanoKatsinaKebbiSokotoZamfaraAbiaAdamawaAkwa IbomAnambraBayelsaBenueBornoCross RiverDeltaEbonyiEdoEkitiEnuguFCTImoKogiKwaraLagosNasarawaNigerOgunOndoOsunOyoPlateauRiversTarabaYobe
4
Simple CEA
5
6
Grant
7
Grant size$input$1,000,000-------------------------------------
8
9
Under-five mortality benefits
10
Cost per child reached$input$21.27-------------------------------------
11
Number of children reached#calc-47,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,00547,005
12
Proportion of reached children who would be vaccinated in the absence of the program%input-74%84%80%88%79%71%60%50%68%95%94%94%92%91%91%76%97%92%100%96%98%99%96%97%92%85%97%87%80%83%88%96%88%91%96%88%89%
13
Number of additional children vaccinated as a result of the program%calc-12,0887,4109,5025,69110,08813,48518,90823,38814,9482,2432,8462,9353,6644,2774,26711,3381,4463,9521521,8809955421,6641,2303,6597,0581,4986,0729,3937,8345,6702,0485,7714,1112,0225,7145,148
14
Probability that an unvaccinated child will die of vaccine-preventable causes before age 5%input-6.05%4.51%6.13%2.92%4.18%4.44%4.92%6.65%7.75%1.85%4.15%1.18%1.30%1.80%2.26%1.89%1.50%1.51%2.23%1.71%1.33%0.93%1.44%0.95%1.35%0.83%0.73%1.79%2.59%1.08%1.29%0.62%0.80%1.47%1.51%4.15%3.35%
15
Effect of vaccination on under-five deaths attributable to vaccine-preventable disease%input-53%52%55%53%52%54%54%53%54%50%52%53%54%52%51%53%54%53%53%54%53%54%53%53%56%54%53%53%52%53%53%54%54%53%53%51%54%
16
Number of deaths averted before age five#calc-3871753188821832250182662421611826404911412322177313628326581274539725321612193
17
18
Initial cost-effectiveness estimate
19
Cost per under-five death averted$calc-$2,584$5,700$3,146$11,350$4,580$3,104$1,996$1,211$1,603$48,275$16,318$54,126$38,617$24,884$20,224$8,787$85,196$31,469$556,600$57,907$141,009$363,248$78,117$159,506$35,883$31,343$172,308$17,205$7,856$22,138$25,822$146,322$39,678$31,391$61,649$8,237$10,701
20
Moral value of averting the death of a person under age fiveUoVinput116-------------------------------------
21
Initial cost-effectiveness in terms of multiples of GiveDirectly's unconditional cash transfer programxcashcalc-13.46.111.03.17.611.217.428.621.60.72.10.60.91.41.73.90.41.10.10.60.20.10.40.21.01.10.22.04.41.61.30.20.91.10.64.23.2
22
28
Percentage of program impact coming from different benefits
29
Mortalities averted before age five%input-60%59%59%56%60%58%58%59%61%41%54%37%42%47%48%52%31%45%9%39%25%12%34%22%42%39%21%49%54%44%45%23%40%42%37%58%51%
30
Mortalities averted after age five%input-18%15%18%15%15%20%21%20%17%12%13%16%16%17%20%23%14%17%3%11%9%7%11%11%18%27%10%20%21%25%20%14%20%22%12%15%23%
31
Developmental benefits (long-term income increases)%input-20%20%20%18%20%19%19%20%20%13%18%12%14%16%16%18%10%15%3%13%8%4%11%7%14%13%7%17%18%15%15%8%13%14%12%19%17%
32
Consumption benefits%input-3%6%3%11%5%3%2%1%2%33%15%34%27%20%16%8%44%24%85%38%58%76%44%60%26%21%61%14%7%16%20%56%27%22%38%8%9%
33
34
Additional adjustments
35
Adjustment for additional program benefits and downsides%input33%-------------------------------------
36
Adjustment for grantee-level factors%input-7%-------------------------------------
37
Adjustment for leverage%input--4%-6%-4%-8%-7%-6%-5%-4%-3%-10%-6%-14%-14%-12%-10%-12%-9%-13%-2%-10%-8%-6%-10%-10%-13%-20%-13%-12%-9%-18%-15%-16%-21%-13%-11%-6%-7%
38
Adjustment for funging%input--9%-9%-9%-8%-9%-9%-10%-10%-10%-3%-7%-3%-4%-6%-7%-8%-1%-5%8%-2%2%6%-1%2%-5%-6%3%-7%-9%-7%-6%2%-4%-5%-2%-8%-8%
39
40
Final cost-effectiveness estimate
41
Final cost-effectiveness in terms of multiples of GiveDirectly's unconditional cash transfer programxcashcalc-23.810.819.95.713.120.331.551.338.11.94.21.82.23.03.77.41.52.50.91.71.20.91.51.12.32.61.14.18.33.32.91.12.02.71.67.76.7
42
Final cost per life saved$calc-$2,098$4,833$2,526$9,843$3,999$2,419$1,524$957$1,302$38,824$13,860$38,740$29,867$19,539$15,047$6,627$54,796$25,007$375,843$46,169$98,475$207,913$60,194$102,954$26,429$20,715$115,978$13,369$6,052$15,749$19,524$86,593$30,641$22,084$47,115$7,077$7,481
43