ABCDE
1
2
RPcon 2014 - Ambizione
3
4
5
6
AuthorVideo[key]Scarlet CommentVovanKoperativ Comment
7
[H]opeWayYōtōThe song is terrible... in general it's a nice video, scene selection is ok and cuts too, the effect meh... Some masks were too much forced and the contrast with the color behind them was really annoying. Anyway, you keep improving and considering that you don't edit much, it's not bad ;)Good effort on masking, some effects, but couldn't see clear story + Soul Eater heavily overused
8
ReggieSmallsY'all Gone Make Me Do 20 YearsThe editing is fine, scene selection not always the best though. Also, I don't think that the song fit that much with all the aniem you used.Very weird random, nice dynamic, but lack of synchronisation and length too big a bit.
9
xDieguitoAMVCloser to HellCool, you tried to make a good story and seems that you succeeded in your goal.Good editing, good story, but could be much depper, especialy if author want leave sourse aside and creat his own world\story. A bit boring, but overall very good.
10
TheGreenDudeLet's Go!Unfortunately, it wasn't good. It has to be improved in a lot of aspects (timing, scene selectiom, pacing, and so on). Too random, even if I like M\V. Couple strange CC effects, general ignore of dynamic\synchronisation + logos on top right and couple titles.
11
TritioAFBTenbi AcademyI'm scared D: Il lip sync is often out of sync and in general the video has several defects: black flashes, bad scene selection, bad zooms. Unfortunately wasn't even that funny, so I couldn't enjoy it :(xDD What? Weird, but definitly fun M\V and anime selection. I hope it could be less random. Anyway, make my day^^
12
YusukeNEMESIGreat video, but something is missing. The song is too much the same thing, there's never a moment of pause, a moment when things slow down... and this was annoying and after a while it gets boring. Beyond that, there's also the fact that the first seconds were excelent and slowly they lose quality (not immediately, of course), maybe because the scenes weren't the top. Dragonball is a punch in the eyes. You couldn't choose a worst anime to insert in. Yes, cool scenes but... hum. However, nice work, but not the best ;)I hope whole amv would be as first 15 seconds. Well, not bad editing, but boring. Need deeper, more sensitive video above this intresting music. In title: "Anime: various" - lazy author :D
13
Mathieu AMVFairy Tail AMV - Grand Magic GamesIt has a lot of lacks, it seems come out from Movie Maker 99.. sorry but here everything has to be improved.What an intresting amv name! Song is too overused, endless boring action.
14
AMV StratMy ZombieNot bad. But the story isn't clear (if there's one). There are some errors in the changes of scenes and in the zooms. The scene selection isn't the best. However, overall it was nice.I have seen not so many Sankarea amv, this one is probably one of the best. Nice, attractive M\V, but editing is too sharp and synch to obvious. Nice try.
15
Gene Starwind 21122Don't Mess with Fairy TailThe color corrector for keep a single color on black&white amd the glows were a punch in the eyes. The cuts for the changes of scenes were really bad (especially the first ones with the black flashes) and the timing is completely wrong. At 1:15 I really wanted to close the video, but I had to finish it..Weird CC in the beginning, average in all aspects.
16
Iren S.S.MonarchI really liked it! Even if it's random, I could understand something. One of my favourite in the contest.Great instrumental amv, one of the best in category I have ever seen.
17
Hinata1495FEELSI liked your idea! maybe it haven't come out as you wished, but I liked the intention ;) If you keep going on, I'm sure your future work will be really niceNice, but it would be better if you use this effect technic in entire amv.
18
UniquevilMy preciousNot bad. Selection of scenes was good, but they were often too dynamic for what the song offers. Moreover, I think that the video, after the first seconds (30, approximately) starts being boring and it's difficult keep the attention high (I have re-watched it 3 times because I realized that at a certain point I was just looking at the screen and not the video). You can do better. Nice, cute, but thanks to video source.
19
ZakAttack on Titan Don't StopAs for the Fairy Tail video of Mathieu, this had a lot of problems and things to be improved.. clearly a work from a beginner. This came out from WMM '75.Shingeki no Kyojin and modern emocore+dubstep? Pls, no more.
20
Ryuu-DonoMetal Gear TitansReally good work, considering that this is only your second amv. I''ll tell the truth, I don't believe you xD Ok, the anime is really dynamic, and this helps a lot, but scene selection, cuts, zooms and so on are often nailed it (I believe thay you did some practice before starting editing amvs, and this is the result). Good work --b Now we have too see if this video was just an exception or not ;)Again too modern music for a such oldstyle pictured anime. You should have focused more on a synch.
21
Artistic AnarchyColorblindBoring. The color corrector in the video isn't good at all, and the colors are often desaturated. The timing is not well folowwed, too long scenes, lack of camera movements... Well, that's no good.Nice try to creat crossover, but video and audio sourses already overused.
22
Galia & KittySmile of an AngelExcelent video, with a particular and solid story. At the first vision it was a bit boring and I didn't follow it well, so I didn't understand it, but rewatching it... really cool. Masks have little flaws sometimes. Overall a really good work, but maybe a bit too long.Time for revange after BC. Great romantic\sentemental amv, nothing more I can say.
23
AhkariPermanent DreamFor me it's the best video of the competition, I fell in love with it the first time I saw it. It's like "official videoclip-style" and it's very particular. The music was perfect for the anime used and it was really catchy, it gave a great atmosphere to the video. The editing itself is above average, it's not flawless but overall it was a solid work. Well, I left my pretty detailed commned on Amvnews page.
24
KyoroichiThe Day We Fought BackIn general the video is good. There were some changes of scenes which weren't nailed it and some scenes were too long. The final moment is terrible. Some point are really good though and the internal sync is fine. the cookie cutter moments weren't always that good.Ending cutted to sharp. Strange fun(?) amv, but not bad at all.
25
RikudoLimitlessGood video, solid, with correct effects. The timing wasn't always perfect but in general you followed pretty well the song rhythm (really nailed it by the way). This let you a good scene selection. Good job --bNicely done, appropriate effects, but a bit too long.
26
[madaraxD]Demonic DreamsVery good video, solid and well edited. I liked the atmosphere and how you altered the source (sometimes, some scenes - like the floors - seemed to be already altered in the anime: in that case, you still used them well). Great job --bGreat visual, great effort, but since JE author could replace some of bad masks, extreme annoying red CC and other stuff. Too random for me + sychronisation could be based on more intresting song's sounds. But great job!
27
BreakerSeventh FononI didn't like it. Technically speaking is ok, with just some useless effects, but overall was pretty forgettable.Respect, very rare good anime in amv. Still m\v too boring, but overall ok
28
LightLost DeepPretty much the same as the video above, but I liked more this one. The action parts were quite good, overall an average job with the anime.Just another alternative amv
29
Rolfyboy8Farewell of SlaviankaI cheer USA! Ok, jokes aside, good video but I didn't like the subtitles (not because they weren't well made, but because they weren't necessary in my opinion). Good scene selection, it helps understanding the meaning of the video in a smoothly; good job ;)Lol, very obvious m\v, well, it works, but I got bored fast.
30
Pima MladshiyFrozen DreamsIt surely deserved more in Big Contest. Masks are really good and well inserted (sometimes they were a bit sharp though). You did an impressive job and I really liked it. The story is easy to follow and it goes well until the final moment when the explosion comes and the only thing in my mind was "it ends like this?". The ending is quite doubt and it lacks of something that could have make it complete. Pity for this little flaw! Overall it was a good video, well edited and technically above average. Keep going on --bOne of my favorite amv from BC, great job.
31
CrossButterfl[ies]Nice work, quite solid and with good editing. Maybe a little bit monotonous and without really epic moments. Nice mood, but some part are too fast and messy + a lot of unnecessary action.
32
BakaOppaiAnimu StewOf course the funniest scene is the one with the giant running. In general is quite funny, but not that much. I think that it can be more enjoyable for an audiance than a group of judges. Good work though --bSome parts work for me, other are too simple and could be better done (for example: color correction for specific atmosphere)
33
AdventLostKaichouHey, Miss SpringNot bad, but too long. The editing was average.Relaxing, but there are so many good amvs on Hyouka, get bored after 1 min.
34
Akira-chan AMVAnother DimensionBad cuts, fade, camera movements, flahes and.. karaoke-stye writtens? ..that's no good. The video is full of flaws and it has nothing that could let me say "well it's bad but...". No good at all. Try watching Futuristic Love by Okami in order to see how this song could have been edited, and keep practicing!Too dark, to fast, to messy.
35
DarkeldionBig JumpThe video is not that bad, but for a good half I had onlt tunnels and codes and in the other half a flock of "pigeons" and two (or three) flying guys. I guess that this is really a big jump, yeah, but in the precipice.Enoy a lot, especially frist part.Shame, too short and synch could be much intresting.
36
SebacarpFly AwayYou had good cues here, but the video was too slow and in general it didn't follow the timing well. The changes aren't often correct, and the airplanes never do anything if not flying here and there. Then suddenly there's a random explosion and he gets shot. But why the explosion? His ariplane was in perfect conditions and there wasn't even a shot before..Too long, slow = boring.
37
CeccoFatalityI can see the improvement (I wonder how many people helped you this time). The scene selection is wrong sometimes (for example, the one with the bucket). Since there isn't a "real" story, except for a ticket with the written "fight", I can't understand the meaning of the making of). I'll explain it: I can't understand why you masked the girl with black hair who gives a ticket to the protagonist if we will never see her again. You made me understand of a possible fight between them, and in the end nothing happens, there are just random things (yeah, I guess it's cool for you).Intesting song, but editing and synch of dubstep could be much better.
38
Maboroshi StudioAkira - The SignalGood trailer! The scene selection is correct, great changes, good transitions, and you chose the proper anime! Too bad for some forced lip syncs. Good work in genera --bGreat atmosphere and editing. Enjoyed it alot!
39
SkydeanA.T.E.Good video and scene selection, excellent changes and transition but moreover, the song was really nailed it. The video itself is nothing special but it's probably the best with this anime. Maybe a bit too long, and with the same type of scenes for all its length. Fun, relatively new, undiscovered anime, at some parts good synch, but overall it's monotonous, especially camara. Title is my favorite part!
40
KireblueKill La BillFunny ;D A well made trailer. I just didn't like some scenes which I think they didn't fit well in some moments. For the rest, a fine job.Simple, but it works. Saw some good lypsynch
41
BecauseImBored1Otaku ParadiseFirst of all, great music! About the video, you did an amazing job! Smooth, with great changes from anime to reality (some of them were a little bit forced, but nothing of really annoying). Scenes like Rock Lee and the guy who imitates him were very good. I also liked the shingeki no kyojin moment when they bring the fist to the heart. In general is an excellent video, keep it up! (some cosplays were really bad though D:)Not bad, even I'm not fan of reall video in amvs, it's looks inappropriate anyway.
42
Obsidian ZeroResonance of RainQuite boring, and moreover too much long! It's not a bad video but when I saw the first half I did a big "meh". technically isn't the top and even the story you tried to tell is not well done (not really clear). You can improve then, keep practicing ;)Way too simple and too long.
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60