Peer Critique of Research Paper Draft (English 382)

JavaScript isn't enabled in your browser, so this file can't be opened. Enable and reload.

Please use this form to respond to the draft of your peer's paper. It is not required that you respond in this manner. Please see the instructor if you prefer a traditional paper format.

Privacy (of paper author) *

Please confirm this prior to proceeding.

The person whose paper I am critiquing knows I am filling out this form about their work and that my comments about his/her work will be online and publicly viewable.

The person whose paper I am critiquing has agreed to allow this open critique provided that I identify her/him using a pseudonym

The person whose paper I am to critique has not granted permission for me to discuss his/her work online (IF SO, PLEASE DO NOT PROCEED)

Privacy (of paper critic) *

Please confirm this prior to proceeding.

I understand that my comments here about my peer's work will be online and publicly viewable.

I would prefer not to be publicly identified as a critic and will use a pseudonym when filling out this form

I would prefer not to participate in an open peer critique (PLEASE DO NOT PROCEED)

Paper Author *

Lastname, Firstname (Use pseudonym if that has been requested by the paper author)

Peer Critic's Name *

Lastname, Firstname (Use pseudonym if you wish, but share that pseudonym with the paper author)

Paper Title

Please just copy the title here. If none is provided, state "none"

Argument / Thesis

What is the paper’s main point or thesis? Please write it here. Is this clearly evident from the start? Does the paper have cohesion (its parts continually refer back to the main thesis and are connected to one another)?

Text

Does the author quote the primary text and use it to directly support his/her argument? Is there evidence of more than just thematic and character analysis?

Sources

Does the author draw upon a good variety of secondary sources, including both informal social proof and formal scholarship? Does he or she appropriately quote or paraphrase these sources to support his or her point?

Format

Is MLA format used for the heading, pagination/header, in-text citations, and Works Cited page?

Chief strength

Where is this paper most interesting or show the most promise in your opinion?

Needs most work

What aspect of the writing or research needs attention foremost in your opinion?

Submit

Clear form

Never submit passwords through Google Forms.

This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Does this form look suspicious? Report

Forms