1 of 32

Case Study:

Intrinsic Motivation & the TAB Classroom

by Jihee Kang, Amari Bachan, & Jason Kemp

2 of 32

CONTENTS

  1. Site analysis
  2. Case observation
  3. Case analysis
  4. Theories & Strategies
    1. Intrinsic motivation
    2. TAB (Teaching for Artistic Behavior)
  5. Suggestions
  6. Resources

3 of 32

  1. Site analysis: Colham Ferry Elementary School

Individual characteristics

  • White dominated population (1-2 students who have different ethnicity but speak English well)
  • Students’ temperament is basically docile and compliant, but sometimes exhibit a lack of interest in art activities & lessons.

​

Environment

  • A public school located in Oconee county
  • The largest ethnic group in Oconee is Caucasian, which is 83.5% of the population.
  • According to the self-report, none of the households in Oconee County speak a non-English language at home (mono-lingual nature)
  • The homeownership rate in Oconee county was 83.6%.

4 of 32

Physical Environment (1) Walls full of artistic images

5 of 32

Physical Environment (2) Well-organized materials

6 of 32

7 of 32

8 of 32

Instruction is demonstrated through multiple forms of audible and visual communication as well as hands on assistance.

9 of 32

Class observations:

We saw 4th grade and 5th grade for 8 weeks and observed the same students every week.

We observed issues in the 5th grade class that we observed, so we will reflect on the 5th grade’s class for this case study (even though we taught a lesson to a 4th grade class).

10 of 32

Class observation (1): School yearbook design

11 of 32

Class observation (2):

Aztec Sun Face project

12 of 32

“How is this project relevant to the learners?”

13 of 32

Class observation (3): Veteran’s Day “thank you” card

14 of 32

Class observation (4): Onomatopoeia-Typographic comic book design (Lichtenstein)

15 of 32

Class observation (4): Onomatopoeia-Typographic comic book design (Lichtenstein)

16 of 32

Student A:

“I don’t like art.”

2. Case observations:

Student B:

“I know it, but I won’t do it.”

Students C & D:

Choose to/or not to…

  • Student A is a fifth grade student
  • Student A was constantly distracted and worked in a very cursory and roughshod manner, also, copying the work of other students.
  • Student A often was trying to get attention from other students by wearing and discussing a particular painting smock even though it was unnecessary to wear one for the lesson.
  • Student A often interrupted the lesson by leaving his seat.
  • Student B is fifth grader sitting right next to Student A.
  • Student B continuously talked during the lesson with student A and did not concentrate on the artwork assignment.
  • Student B used negative self-deprecating language and demonstrated a lack of self-confidence in their abilities.
  • Student B often compared and copied the work of student A
  • C and D are fifth graders sitting next to each other.
  • During class other students started drawing their school yearbook, these two students were still doing their former work of designing emblem very slowly by choice.
  • When the researcher asked why are you still working on your emblem, they answered that they did not want to do the yearbook project.
  • Thus, the slow making itself can be considered as a kind of refusal or dismissal of art activity.

17 of 32

→ Lack of motivation

3. Case analysis: three key insights

→ Lack of authenticity

→ Lack of choice

→ Necessity of promoting intrinsic motivation

→ Necessity of giving chance to be autonomous in art making

  • Case observersation has shown significant lack of interest in art
  • We assumed that there may be reasons that inhibit this intrinsic motivation

→ Strategy to enhance intrinsic motivation (e.g., more life-related topics) is needed.

​

  • Many students just followed the rules and instruction from the teacher and did not think deeply about their own artwork and process
  • ​

→ Promoting authenticity in art making seems to be essential to artistic motivation.

  • The activity is somewhat directive and well-constructed so there is less availability to for students to choose their own projects.
  • ​

→ Teachers need to provide opportunities for students to choose what they want to and how to express themselves

18 of 32

4. Theories & Strategies

19 of 32

a. (TAB) Art Class to improve Intrinsic Motivation

Is there a relationship between a student’s temperament and intrinsic motivation in 5th grade art students?

Can a TAB classroom encourage a student’s intrinsic Motivation?

​

We understand that intrinsic motivation is the desire to engage in an activity because it is inherently satisfying for its own sake. It is contrasted with extrinsic motivation, which is the desire to engage in an activity to achieve an external reward or avoid punishment.

It seems that students we observed who seem to have a higher level of self-regulation are more likely to be intrinsically motivated to engage in art activities than the students who are less able to self-regulate their behavior. Self-regulation refers to the ability to control one's emotions, thoughts, and behaviors. Students with high self-regulation are better able to focus on their goals, persist in the face of challenges, and delay gratification. This makes them more likely to be intrinsically motivated to engage in art activities.

In the TAB classroom, alll students, despite their individual self-regulation abilities, are given the freedom to choose their own art projects, materials, and techniques. This allows them to pursue their own artistic interests, which can lead to increased intrinsic motivation (Chad. et al pg.2).

20 of 32

Intrinsic motivation in homeschool

Intrinsic motivation, the personal drive to do something because it is interesting, challenging, and absorbing, is essential for high levels of creativity and achievement. Homeschooling often allows for a high degree of intrinsic motivation, as students have more freedom to explore and learn about topics that interest them. Traditional Student experiences can benefit from some aspects of intrinsic motivation focused on in homeschooled students.

Here are some strategies that might be beneficial for traditional school children drawing from homeschool environment

Autonomy: Homeschooling often provides children with a greater sense of autonomy. This could be incorporated into traditional schooling by allowing students more choice in their assignments or projects, fostering a sense of ownership and personal investment in their work.

Interest-Based Learning: Homeschooling allows children to delve deeply into subjects that fascinate them. Traditional schools could benefit from incorporating more project-based learning opportunities that allow students to explore topics they are passionate about.

Personalized Pace: Homeschooled children often have the advantage of learning at their own pace. In a traditional school setting, offering differentiated instruction and allowing students to progress at their own speed could boost intrinsic motivation.

Positive Environment: A supportive and positive learning environment can foster intrinsic motivation. Traditional schools can strive to create such environments by promoting positive relationships among students and teachers, and encouraging a love for learning.

Real-World Connections: Homeschooling often involves learning through real-world experiences. Traditional schools could incorporate more experiential learning opportunities, helping students see the relevance and application of what they are learning.

21 of 32

TAB: Teaching Artistic Behavior

  • What is the artistic behavior?�Artists make art about things that matter to them.

​

Basic principles:

  • What do artists do
  • The child is the artist
  • The classroom is the child’s studio

b. TAB approach to giving authenticity

22 of 32

  • Focus on support divergent thinking and creativity
  • Start with a short demonstration followed by self-directed projects
  • Students typically make all choices with materials, processes, and interpretation
  • The level of choices can be modified by setting limits: applicable well in the elementary level

Why TAB?

23 of 32

Artists practice constantly, observing and evaluating outcomes to determine their next steps:

8 studio habits

24 of 32

25 of 32

5. Suggestions for further examination

  • Intrinsic motivation seems to be an important factor that can influence a student's personal and academic success with regards to their education, especially when working to complete assignments in art class.

​

  • How do we use our knowledge of TAB to foster a positive environment in the classroom for all students to thrive and increase intrinsic motivation?

​

  • How much freedom are we as educators actually ready to relinquish in order to accomplish these goals?

​

26 of 32

27 of 32

Strategies for self-initiated and intrinsically motivated art classroom

  1. Set the lesson based on children’s interests and concerns
  2. Foster an environment of collaboration between students
  3. Encourage independent projects and give students choice
  4. Share and discuss insights in terms of process & material utilization

​

INQUIRY QUESTIONS (Reference)

​

What insights can I gain about students’ learning needs and those students’ corresponding experiences in schools?

​

What resources can I find that will help me differentiate instruction and develop a classroom environment to better meet the needs of these learners?

​

What new teaching strategies and approaches can I find through my research that will help me meet the needs of these learners?

Teaching Strategies: (Reference)

​

Relevant instructional strategies (for presenting information, class discussions, discussions of artworks, demonstrations, etc.)

Material/tool/resource adaptations as relevant

Classroom environment adaptations as relevant

Relevant assessment strategies or adaptations

28 of 32

6. Resources

29 of 32

Studio Thinking series:

  • Providing resources for “artistic habits” to follow

30 of 32

Choice-based art classroom

  • Learner-directed, engaging school culture

31 of 32

TAB website & Facebook pages

  • Choice Art Educators
  • TAB facebook group
  • CAST UDL Guidelines

32 of 32

Chad, F. E., Lee, Y., Liu, X., & Watson, M. W. (2019). The Effects of Visual Arts Pedagogies on Children’s Intrinsic Motivation, Creativity, Artistic Skill, and Realistic Drawing Ability. Journal of Creative Behavior, 53(4), 482–495. https://doi.org/10.1002/jocb.228

​

Data USA. Oconee County, GA. Retrieved [November 1, 2023] from https://datausa.io/profile/geo/oconee-county-ga#:~:text=97.6%25%20of%20the%20residents%20in,commute%20time%20was%2025.9%20minutes

​

Ellis, J. (2022). Learning to Engage and Persist in a TAB (Teaching for Artistic Behavior) Classroom. Art Education, 75(2), 14–18.

Gates, L. (2016). Rethinking Art Education Practice One Choice at a Time. Art Education, 69(2), 13–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/00043125.2016.1141646

Hess, C. (2018). Choosing to Change: Discipline Based Art Education to Choice Based Art Education. Online Submission.

​

Maslow, A. H., Abraham H., & Frager, R. (1987). Motivation and personality (3rd ed., revised by Robert Frager [and others].). Harper and Row.

​

Medlin, R., & Blackmer, R. (n.d.). Academic Intrinsic Motivation in Homeschooled Children. https://www.stetson.edu/artsci/psychology/media/medlin-academic-intrinsic-motivation.pdf

​

Purtee, M. (2015). The difference between TAB and Choice and why it matters. The art of Education University. (Retrieved from https://theartofeducation.edu/2015/11/the-difference-between-tab-and-choice-and-why-it-matters)

Raffini, J. P. (1996). 150 ways to increase intrinsic motivation in the classroom. Allyn and Bacon.

​

​

​