G8 Education: Start caring for the carers
Investor brief
March 2025
What SIX is asking
SIX is asking G8 to implement an employer-funded paid parental leave (PPL) policy. The policy should be determined by the Board and informed by the WGEA Leading Practice Parental Leave Policy Guide
The proposal balances the need for the company to remain competitive in a market where paid parental leave is increasingly the norm with the flexibility to offer an amount and length of PPL that the Board determines is appropriate.
The resolution is found on the UNPRI website: https://collaborate.unpri.org/group/27561/stream
If you read one slide, read this one
G8 Education is the largest childcare provider in Australia that does not fund paid parental leave (PPL) for employees.* It runs 400+ centres and employs over 10,000 people
Behind competitors
Barrier to women in work
Australian women spend 43% less time in paid work than men - one of the lowest rates in the OECD due to low wages and inadequate PPL
PPL means higher GDP
Achieving womens full and equal economic participation would add equivalent of 500,000 FTE jobs and $128bn to Australia’s economy
*The Australian Government funds parental leave at the minimum wage for 22 weeks. It is widely accepted this is amount and duration is insufficient to harness full female workforce participation and close the gender pay gap, hence companies largely now pay PPL on top of this amount
Staff turnover = higher costs
Childcare workers are leaving the industry due to poor conditions, keeping them is crucial for future profitability. Staff leaving G8 after birth jumped 150% in past year - potentially millions spent on rehiring - but not disclosed in reporting
PPL improves profitability
We estimate the cost of any type of PPL is less than the cost of rehiring lost staff from not offering it, resulting in higher Net Profit After Tax (NPAT)
Higher returns for investors
Over the long-term, market returns that universal owners are invested in will move in relation to GDP and other measurements of the intrinsic value of the economy - therefore more women in workforce should improve GDP and financial returns
G8 lags behind largest childcare providers
| Weeks of employer funded PPL | Includes super | Employees |
Mission Australia Early Learning | 11 | No | 2,473 |
YMCA | 10 | Yes | 3,819 |
United Early Learning | 10 | Yes | 3,562 |
Mayfield Childcare | 10 | Yes | 730 |
Early Childhood Management | 6 | Yes | 1,042 |
Goodstart | 4 | Yes | 17,548 |
KU Children’s Services | 3 | Yes | 1,829 |
G8 Education | 0 | N/A | 10,193 |
Affinity Education Group | 0 | N/A | 5,528 |
Guardian | 0 | N/A | 5,008 |
Leaders
Laggards
7.7 weeks is the average length
of PPL when offered by the biggest providers
Employer-funded PPL is ASX norm
Source:WGEA
75% of companies in female dominated industries (such as retail and child care) provide employer-funded PPL
85% of employers with more than 5000 staff provide employer-funded PPL
93 of ASX100 companies offer PPL to primary carers. 89 offer it to primary and secondary carers
Median primary PPL for ASX100 is 16 weeks, and 5.9 weeks for secondary carers
84% of ASX300 companies offer PPL to primary carers
PPL can enhance G8 enterprise value
Sources
HESTA, ‘State of the Sector: Early Child Care and Education, 2021; Randstad, 2023: Focusing on the high cost of employee turnover; Australian Consumer and Competition Commission, 2023, Child care inquiry, Final Report.; Bankwest Curtin Economics Centre, Dimensions and Prevalence of Decent Work in Australia.; G8 Education, Annual Report 2024.
Ruppaner and Squires (2020), The Future of Women @ Work
“It was a rude awakening for me. Perhaps I was a bit naive not to realise we don't get paid maternity leave. When I worked in my previous industry, they offered 6 months of paid parental leave. Childcare is a sector that's all about women and children, but they don't offer any parental leave! I thought it was a given. The wage gap between my usual pay and the government scheme was huge. I haven't gone back since having my child.”
Former childcare centre director speaking to SIX
PPL can enhance G8 enterprise value
Sources
HESTA, ‘State of the Sector: Early Child Care and Education, 2021; Randstad, 2023: Focusing on the high cost of employee turnover; Australian Consumer and Competition Commission, 2023, Child care inquiry, Final Report.; Bankwest Curtin Economics Centre, Dimensions and Prevalence of Decent Work in Australia.; G8 Education, Annual Report 2024.
G8 is failing women and mothers
Sources:
Source:Impact Economics and Policy: Addressing Australia's Critical Skill Shortages: Unlocking Women's Economic Participation
G8 not counting cost of inequality imposed on other companies
Sources
TAI, The Economic Benefits of High Quality Universal Early Child Education; UNPRI, A Legal Framework for Impact: Australia, 2022.; Impact Economics and Policy: Addressing Australia's Critical Skill Shortages: Unlocking Women's Economic Participation
Inadequate PPL is a driver of the gender pay gap
G8’s PPL policy reduces GDP and diversified portfolio returns
Sources
Jon Lukomnik and James P. Hawley, Moving Beyond Modern Portfolio Theory: Investing that Matters, 2021.
The Shareholder Commons, Living Wage & the Engagement Gap
Impact Economics: Addressing Australia's Critical Skill Shortages, 2022
Women’s Economic Equality Taskforce: A 10-Year Plan to Unleash the Full Capacity and Contribution of Women to the Australian Economy, October 2023.
Diversified universal owners depend on overall market return
Inequality reduces economic growth and market returns
Responding to objections
#1 - “We already offer discount childcare instead of PPL which is of greater financial value than 6-8 weeks of PPL”
8 weeks of PPL at full pay would be over $9,000 (not including super) - meaning less wages and less super at the end of their career.
Responding to objections
#2 - “Our employees didn’t say they want PPL”
The Independent Education Union supports SIX’s ask. It represents over 33,000 people in Australia, including many G8 child care workers. PPL was a demand in recently completed Multi-Enterprise Agreement that the companies rejected.
#3 - “Inequality isn’t relevant to fiduciary duty”
Law firm Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer recently issued a report arguing prioritising systemic macroeconomic risks over individual enterprise value should be consistent with best “financial interest” test applied by Australian regulators - as well as respecting the duties of institutional investors to address sustainability concerns in 10 other critical jurisdictions
For more common objections to using stewardship to address systemic risk - see The Shareholder Commons: Labour and Inequality Case Study, pp. 36-37.
#4 - “This is a cost borne by shareholders”
we estimated the cost of 4-8 weeks of PPL ($1.2-2.2m) is less than the cost of rehiring lost staff ($2.7m) resulting in higher NPAT.
If G8 ‘topped up’ the difference between government PPL and staff wages, rather than paid it in addition to Gov PPL as we have assumed, the effect would be even greater.
If you would like to discuss this analysis please contact
James Alexander
Senior ESG Manager
james@six-invest.com.au