1 of 28

Understanding Risks to NEET��Tackling NEET Toolkit

Dr Ceri Brown

University of Bath,

Department of Education

Dr Alison Douthwaite

University of Bath,

Department of

Education

2 of 28

Objectives

Share research findings about the risks to NEET/ ESL

Introduce you to using resources from the Tackling NEET Toolkit

Guide reflection on how these findings and resources could support your professional practice

3 of 28

Activity

  • Think of a ‘case’ young person who is NEET or at risk of NEET
  • This could be a real young person or an invented one.
  • Write a brief description of them on your sheet

 

5 minutes

4 of 28

Common Assumptions & Misconceptions:� How Young People become NEET

  • Not motivated – don't care, lack of effort
  • Young person’s unrealistic expectations
  • Poor parenting – lack of positive role models and boundaries
  • Chaotic, disrupted lives
  • Fallen in with a bad crowd
  • Lack of effort and guidance from schools/ colleges

5 of 28

The Complexity of Risks to NEET

Their needs can often be:

  • Complex
  • Multiple –Interrelated
  • Unique for each individual

Support can be difficult because:

  • Its challenging to get a holistic view
  • There is a difference between ‘having support’ and ‘feeling supported’

6 of 28

Increased NEET Risk for Specific Groups

  • Care-experienced
  • Designated Child in Need
  • Caring responsibilities
  • Young parents
  • SEND at age 15
  • Has attended Alternative Provision
  • Previously permanently excluded
  • Involvement with Youth Offending Team
  • Substance abuse
  • Eligible for Free School Meals in Secondary School
  • Persistently absent (10% absence in KS3 or 4)

7 of 28

Where Do These Findings Come From?

  • 3.5 year EU-funded research project (Orienta4YEL)
  • 2019-2022
  • Understanding and Intervening in NEET
  • UK study led by University of Bath 
  • UK Data from South West England

8 of 28

Research Project Overview and Outputs

Phase 1

Understanding NEET

    • 11 Settings
    • 78 participants
    • Literature Review

Comprehensive model of risks to NEET

Phase 2

Developing Interventions

    • Variety of education settings
    • Across 5 nations

Handbook of 13 intervention strategies

Phase 3

Trialling & evaluating Interventions

    • 11 Settings
    • 110 participants
    • Tailor interventions for each setting

Identified a ‘Pathway to Change’ – 5 mechanisms

9 of 28

Research Project Overview and Outputs

Phase 1

Understanding NEET

    • 11 Settings
    • 78 participants
    • Literature Review

Comprehensive model of risks to NEET

Phase 2

Developing Interventions

    • Variety of education settings
    • Across 5 nations

Handbook of 13 intervention strategies

Phase 3

Trialling & evaluating Interventions

    • 11 Settings
    • 110 participants
    • Tailor interventions for each setting

Identified a ‘Pathway to Change’ – 5 mechanisms

10 of 28

Research Project Overview and Outputs

Phase 1

Understanding NEET

    • 11 Settings
    • 78 participants
    • Literature Review

Comprehensive model of risks to NEET

Phase 2

Developing Interventions

    • Variety of education settings
    • Across 5 nations

Handbook of 13 intervention strategies

Phase 3

Trialling & evaluating Interventions

    • 11 Settings
    • 110 participants
    • Tailor interventions for each setting

Identified a ‘Pathway to Change’ – 5 mechanisms

11 of 28

Research Project Overview and Outputs

Phase 1

Understanding NEET

    • 11 Settings
    • 78 participants
    • Literature Review

Comprehensive model of risks to NEET

Phase 2

Developing Interventions

    • Variety of education settings
    • Across 5 nations

Handbook of 13 intervention strategies

Phase 3

Trialling & evaluating Interventions

    • 11 Settings
    • 110 participants
    • Tailor interventions for each setting

Identified a ‘Pathway to Change’ – 5 mechanisms

12 of 28

NEET: A Comprehensive Framework of Risk Factors

  • Over 150 risk factors
  • Interconnection between risk factors
  • Rarely single factor reason for NEET
  • Complex interplay

For further exploration of this contrast see our paper in the Journal of Youth Studies​

13 of 28

Bronfenbrenner

  • How child development is impacted by contextual factors

  • Universal Model (ie for development of all children)

  • Misses specific barriers for disadvantaged young people

  • Commonly used in Social Work, Health and Criminal Justice as well as Education

Theories Underpinning The Model

14 of 28

See Educational Binds of Poverty by Ceri Brown

  • Child-centred lens, disadvantaged pupils

  • 'Binds' – as child negotiates/wrestles barriers they constrict further, developing tensions and trade-offs

  • Acknowledges important role of child's agency  - not passive

  • Highlights how children's actions mediate and shape external challenges

Theories Underpinning The Model

15 of 28

NEET: A Comprehensive Framework of Risk Factors

  • Over 150 risk factors
  • Interconnection between risk factors
  • Rarely single factor reason for NEET
  • Complex interplay

For further exploration of this contrast see our paper in the Journal of Youth Studies​

16 of 28

Activity

As you watch the video, think about your case young person

What are the specific risks they face in each of the 5 domains?

Watch The Video which will play automatically on the next slide. If it doesn’t you can access it here https://vimeo.com/431748528 or on your toolkit link

17 of 28

Which factors might be most/least important for your 'case' young person?

  • In their daily lives?
  • In your work with them?

18 of 28

Risk Review Tool

19 of 28

Use the Risk Review Tool

  • List up to 3 risk factors for each of the 5 domains in column 1
  • Discuss and add notes in column 2 about ways risks in one domain impact on, or are impact by risk in another domain
  • Share examples with the wider group

Activity

20 minutes

20 of 28

See the toolkit resource: Understanding NEEThood Case Studies Risks to NEET for further examples of how other practitioners have completed the first two columns of this for their Case Young Person

Save your complete Risk Review Tool for Workshop 2 which looks at Intervening o NEET.

Case Studies

21 of 28

Activity – Discussion/Reflection

  • How might the model of 5 domains of risk support your practice?
  • How might you use this risk review tool with existing processes in your professional role?

10 minutes

22 of 28

Young People and Adults Highlight�Different Factors as being most significant

Institutional Factors

Social Relationship Factors

Structural Factors

Personal Challenges

23 of 28

Factors Stressed by

 Young People

Factors Stressed by

 Educators

Institutional Factors

Social Relationship Factors

Structural Factors

Personal Challenges

Rigidity and inflexibility of rules, timings and environment

Behaviour management approaches

Large class sizes 

Pressure around academic performance

Bullying

Feeling different, judged and singled out

Bad experiences and negative relationships with teachers

Not feeling cared about

Peer pressure

Difficulty navigating friendships.

Requirement for post-16 maths and literacy

Lack of funding and time to meet young people’s needs

Non-flexible curriculum

Poorly managed transitions 

Unclear pathways

Low self-esteem or self-confidence

Mental health problems

SEND

Isolation

Low achievement 

Low motivation, aspiration or expectation

What do you notice about the risks highlighted by the two groups?

Why do you think adults and young people focus on these different risk categories?

Activity

5 minutes

24 of 28

Factors Stressed by

 Young People

Factors Stressed by

 Educators

Institutional Factors

Social Relationship Factors

Structural Factors

Personal Challenges

Rigidity and inflexibility of rules, timings and environment

Behaviour management approaches

Large class sizes 

Pressure around academic performance

Bullying

Feeling different, judged and singled out

Bad experiences and negative relationships with teachers

Not feeling cared about

Peer pressure

Difficulty navigating friendships.

Requirement for post-16 maths and literacy

Lack of funding and time to meet young people’s needs

Non-flexible curriculum

Poorly managed transitions 

Unclear pathways

Low self-esteem or self-confidence

Mental health problems

SEND

Isolation

Low achievement 

Low motivation, aspiration or expectation

What do you notice about the risks highlighted by the two groups?

Why do you think adults and young people focus on these different risk categories?

Further information available in our paper in the Journal of Youth Studies (see final slide)

Activity

5 minutes

25 of 28

Discussion – Seeking YP’s Perspectives

  • Knowing this, why might it be important to discuss young people’s own perspectives on the risks they face?

  • How do you seek young people's viewpoints on the barriers they face?

  • Are there further opportunities for seeking young people's perspectives on their challenges and how to overcome them?

10 minutes

26 of 28

How a broader understanding of risk to NEET can shape your work

  • Having the awareness to avoid one-size fits all 'explanations' for risk
  • Making time to get to know YPs' wider lives- shows genuine interest
  • Creating the space to ask young person about their barriers/challenges - as a start to a collaborative unpicking
  • Identifying which risk categories (and factors) are within your 'gift' and the YP's capacity to address
  • Ensuring adequate opportunity (in contact point and over time) to build a trusting relationship between adult and YP
  • Identify scope to co-opt support in other domains
  • Planning adequate time to develop a shared strategy for addressing risk barriers
  • Flexibility- in approach and mindset, to plan B, C and D...
  • Identifying second chance options if YP can't engage/attend – reduce pressure

27 of 28

Thank you�

Please contact us with any comments or questions about this session. We would be pleased to hear about how this session has been useful, or impacted your work, and for all constructive feedback on the toolkit. Do contact us regarding potential opportunities for collaboration or development around these resources.

Dr Ceri Brown, C.L.Brown@bath.ac.uk

Department of Education, University of Bath

Dr Alison Douthwaite, ad879@bath.ac.uk

Department of Education, University of Bath

28 of 28

References and Links�

Educational Binds of Poverty: The Lives of School Children (2014) C Brown, Routledge, Abingdon

A multi-stakeholder analysis of the risks to early school leaving; comparing young peoples’ and educators’ perspectives on five categories of risk (2022), C Brown, A Douthwaite, I Costas Batlle and N Savvides, Journal of Youth Studies. Access at https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13676261.2022.2132139

Understanding and Intervening on the Risks to Early School Leaving in Europe (2021) C Brown, P Olmos Rueda, I Costas Batlle and J Gairin Sallan, Journal of Education and Work, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13639080.2021.2003007

Conceptual Framework for Understanding the Risks to Early Leaving/ NEEThood Video (2020) https://vimeo.com/431748528