1 of 11

The Black Lutheran Experience

Lessons and Reflections

Sylvia A. Eley

2 of 11

Reflection

I created this presentation to educate myself and others with some history of how Blacks became part of the Lutheran religion.

Lutherans live a life of action and service. This along with the Church Doctrine of faith, proclaiming of the Word of God, Christ’s life, death on the cross and resurrection; makes me proud to be a Lutheran. As a lifelong Lutheran, I was educated in Lutheran School and attended Lutheran camp during the summer.

Although there is an impression that the ELCA is a predominantly “white” denomination, there is a history of Blacks being accepted, baptized into the faith and making milestone contributions. My commitment to God and the kingdom's work has led me to bring awareness of Blacks and Lutheranism.

​

​

3 of 11

African-American Lutherans have been in America for more than 350 years, longer than many European immigrants whom we generally think of as being Lutheran.

4 of 11

Beginnings���On Palm Sunday, 1669, a Lutheran pastor in Albany, New York, baptized into his congregation an African-American man, who was given the name, Emmanuel. In subsequent years other African Americans, enslaved or free, became members of the Lutheran congregations in New York and New Jersey.��African Americans become Lutherans in many places during the colonial period. In addition to New York, they were found in the Carolinas and Georgia, on the Danish Virgin Islands and in British and Dutch Guiana in South America.��

5 of 11

Beginnings

  • Some Lutherans were slaveholders. By 1700 slavery existed throughout British colonial America.
  • Though not always, they often were slaves of Lutheran masters; initially, Lutherans were against slavery, but some quickly adapted to it in this country. By the time of the Civil War, there were several thousand African American Lutheran members in the South, and many more (probably 8,000-10,000) who had been baptized Lutheran.
  • After the Civil War, most of the African-American Lutherans in the South left the white congregations, where they had generally been second-class citizens. In response, various Southern Lutheran synods began sporadic efforts to evangelize the newly-freed African Americans, and to establish separate Lutheran congregations.
  • Samuel Schmucker, founded the first Lutheran Seminary in North America at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania (1826),
  • Starting in 1868, the Lutheran synods in Tennessee, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia began to license African-American preachers to preach the gospel and gather in congregations.

​

​

​

6 of 11

The Morality of Slavery

  • It was the duty of the elders of congregations among which Negros are living slave of free, to provide a place for them in churches; or when that cannot be done to build them a house adjoining or near the church. (quoted in Johnson .108)
  • Not all Lutherans in the South saw slavery as worth defending. Most Lutherans, particularly in the Lower South, whether they were slaveholders or not, were committed to the Southern way of life, including slave-owning and white racial superiority.
  • Overall, Lutherans did not become strong anti-slavery advocates, nor did they champion the cause of free Black people in the North or the South.
  • Norwegian and Swedish newcomers who easily preferred the Midwest over the South, viewed slavery as unrighteous.
  • Gottlieb Schober of the General Synod advocated mission work among both slaves and free blacks.
  • Debates over slavery among Lutherans in the Upper South during the 1820’s caused dissension.
  • The Tennessee Synod held sessions in 1822 saying slavery was a great evil in our land.
  • Half of anti-slavery men in the North Carolina legislature in the 1820’s were German.
  • Lutherans in the Upper South, wishing to free their slaves, moved north of the Ohio Valley to do so.

7 of 11

The Synods

​

  • In 1818, only three Lutheran synods existed in America: the Pennsylvania Ministerium, the New York Ministerium, and the North Carolina Synod.
  • The General Synod- Formed in In 1820. The General Synod was at its core an advisory body that would help regulate who and what was entering Lutheran churches.
  • The Franckean Synod –was a Lutheran church body in North America in the 19th century. The Synod was formed by Lutheran pastors in New York who were dissatisfied with their church's position on slavery in 1837.
  • Pittsburg Synod- followed The Franckean Synod in the 1840’s.
  • Norwegian Eielsen Synod-In 1850 this Synod denounced the “fearful sin of giving our consent to the slave traffic,” and advocated “all possible diligence in bringing about… the freeing of the negroes”.
  • Southern Lutheran Synods- Starting in 1868 in TN, NC, SC, and GA began to license African- American preachers to preach the gospel and gather in congregations.

​

8 of 11

The Synods continued

  • Alpha Synod- It was the first African- American Lutheran organization. In 1889, four Black Lutheran pastors, the Reverends David Koontz, Samuel Holt, Nathan Clapp, and Philo Phifer, petitioned and received permission from the Synod of North Carolina to form their own synod, the Alpha Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Freedmen in America.
    • Synod of North Carolina failed to financially support the new Alpha Synod, which reached out to the Evangelical Lutheran Synodical Conference of North America for help. The Lutheran Church--Missouri Synod responded and in 1891 the Synodical Conference appointed the Reverend N. J. Bakke (a white pastor) .
    • The Reverend Koontz was the first Black president of a Lutheran synod.
    • The Missouri Synod- In 1877 the Synodical Conference which was dominated by the Lutheran Church- Missouri Synod, began mission work among African American- first in Little Rock Arkansas and then more successfully in New Orleans.
      • The Synodical Conference also incorporated the preachers and congregations of the Alpha Synod and began a very successful mission work among African Americans in Alabama. (They were joined here by the Joint Synod of Ohio.) In the South, these African-American Lutherans opened schools, academies, and teacher-training institutions, one of which grew into Concordia College, Selma, Alabama, the only historically-black Lutheran college in the country.

​

9 of 11

Black Lutheran Expansion

  • By 1860, 200 Black members worshipped at St. John Lutheran Church in Charleston, SC.
  • In 1877 the Synodical Conference began mission work among African Americans.
  • Between 1923 and 1950, 38 African American Lutheran congregations were formed in the North and West.
  • By 1950, there were 11,000 African American Lutherans, primarily in urban areas.
  • Beginning in the 1960’s, the three largest American Lutheran denominations began to push for integrated congregations and increased outreach to African Americans. In the Lutheran Church in America (LCA), the number of African American members jumped from 5,000 in 1962 to 49,000 (with 111 African American pastors) in 1989, when the LCA became a part of the ELCA. In all the American Lutheran bodies in 1991, there were 132,000 African American Lutherans (about two percent of all Lutherans).
  • Many congregations were formed by migrants from the American South, while others were comprised of immigrants from the Virgin Islands and South America.

10 of 11

Influential Historical Black Lutherans

  • Rosa Young (1890-1971)-Known as the “mother of Black Lutheranism in central Alabama” and a strong advocate of education for rural children, Rosa Young was instrumental in founding and promoting the development of Lutheran schools and congregations in Alabama’s Black Belt.
  • Jehu Jones(1769-1893) – The first Black Lutheran Pastor who was ordained in 1832 and founded the first African-American Lutheran congregation two years later.
  • Daniel Alexander Payne (1811-1893) Payne entered the Theological Seminary in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, studying there from 1835 to 1837. In 1837 he joined the Franklin Synod of the Lutheran Church and was ordained as the first African American minister in the Lutheran Church in Fordsboro, New York in 1839.
  • Rev. Dr. Nelson Trout(1921-1996)- The first African-American bishop of the American Lutheran Church and the Evangelical Church of America, presiding over the South Pacific District from 1983 to 1987.

​

​

​

11 of 11

Works cited