Polybuilt
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 1
A - Team Design Report 2021
_________________________ __________________________
Dante P. , Team Captain Dr. Mohammad Sadek, Advisor
Table of Contents
Design Objectives
Design Specifications
Operator’s Station Design
Polybuilt Organizational Design
Strategy
Structure
Processes
People
Drivetrain Design
Steering and Electrical systems design
Brake design evolution
Clutch Hydraulic Throwout Cylinder Evolution and Re-Design
Manufacturing
Serviceability and Safety
Tractor Cost Overview
Cost Analysis
Qualitative Risk Analysis
Acknowledgments and Citations
FMEA - Electric Kill Switch
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20-21
22
23
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 1
List of Figures
Figure 1. Polybuilt Tractor
Figure 2. Organizational Structure
Figure 3. Labeled Tool Wall
Figure 4. Drivetrain
Figure 5. Disk Brakes
Figure 6. Hydraulic Throwout Cylinder
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 1
6
9
10
12
14
15
Design Objectives
Design Objectives
Matching Features
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 1
Durability
Production Efficiency
Easy Maintenance
Potential for Various Uses
Maneuverability
Design Specifications
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 2
Engine
Transaxle
Steering
Capacities
Dimensions
Operator’s Station Design
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 3
Features | Benefits |
Steel framing steering column instead of the previous Aluminum column | More stiff steering column |
Shorter frame compared to prior design | Closer proximity to the steering wheel to make it more accessible |
Ergonomic seat | More comfort for the operator |
Figure 1. 2021 Polybuilt Tractor
Polybuilt Organizational Design
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 4
Strategy
Structure
Processes
People
Polybuilt applied several elements of the Star Model to design the organization
Galbraith, J. (n.d.). Designing your organization: The Star Model. John Wiley & Sons.
Strategy
What Polybuilt offers to our clientele
1. Design and cost control
Parts designed and built in-house to maintain greater design and cost flexibility
2. Excellent services to keep equipment functioning and reliable when it is needed most
Aftermarket repair and maintenance options and plans
Polybuilt’s competitive advantage
Custom built tractors that align with the specific needs of our client’s operation
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 5
Structure
Polybuilt was developed as a relatively decentralized organization because the company is small and takes advantage of the fluidity of the horizontally oriented transfer of communications and decision making. Horizontally designed firms also benefit from the speed at which they can respond to demand fluctuations, evolving customer needs, and other market changes.
As shown in the figure, Polybuilt has 3 departments: design, construction, and business. The company’s founders determined that this structure represented the optimal level of specialization to keep the firm functioning effectively. The horizontal arrows in the figure represent the subsystems of the tractor and the project teams tasks with developing each. The joints are there to visually convey the matrix structure and show how it aligns projects with professionals from all departments to maximize the benefits to be gained from cross-functional teams.
Figure 2. Organizational Structure
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 6
Processes
Polybuilt uses standard practices and procedures for budget allocation, but continuously changing workflow processes with the following objectives in mind:
1. Improving efficiency by selecting the optimal combination of material, design, and manufacturing process
2. Reducing the wastes identified in the lean model by identifying them and developing workflows for future operations that eliminate them
3. Conducting value-added analyses on our workflows to ensure that all steps in an operation are necessary and produce valuable features for the end user
4. Keeping organized and accessible workstations by having designated locations for all tools with clear labels, as shown in the figure to the side, to avoid misplacement of tools or time spent obtaining the tools required for an operation
Figure 3. Labeled Tool Wall
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 7
People
Polybuilt’s model for training and development is represented in the figure on the side. The concept is to not only promote specialization in one of the 3 departments at Polybuilt, but to also give teams an opportunity to think holistically.
For example, the design expert on a team may have a conceptual design for a major drivetrain component that they discuss with the construction expert and the business specialist. The representative from the construction department may then state that the design is unnecessarily complex and that simplifying it will cut fabrication time by 10% without having to eliminate any required features of the component. The business expert may then enter the discussion and propose some methods of reducing direct labor or material cost.
Recruitment
Develop department related skills
Gain familiarity with the operations of the other department
Work as a member of a cross functional team on a specific custom tractor
Solve problems and track job progress as each tractor is being designed and constructed
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 8
Drivetrain Design
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 9
The differential in the transaxle was flipped which allowed Polybuilt to eliminate the 1 to 1 gearbox that was previously being used to change the direction of rotation on the incoming shaft. Not only did this gearbox represent an extra cost especially because of the CNC machining required to produce it, but it also increased the weight of the vehicle. Eliminating the gearbox saved PolyBuilt both money and weight.
Figure 4. Drivetrain
Steering System Design
A hydraulic system was chosen over a rack and pinion design because it would be easier for the operator to repair and replace parts. An electrical steering system was another option, but was decided against because an electrical power loss would leave the operator with no means of controlling their steering. Such a scenario could be dangerous for the operator, so a system that could function without power was selected.
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 10
Electrical System Design
The electrical system of the tractor includes a ground speed sensor, a gear position sensor, and an engine speed sensor.
Brake Design Evolution
Brake Design Version I
The internal brake built into the transaxle was originally going to be used to halt the tractor. To test the brake, a six foot moment arm was attached to the axle shafts and it was concluded that the brake could only handle 503 Lb-ft on average. From the technical inspection requirements, it was determined that 805 Lb-ft of force is required to support the tractor on a 20 degree incline.
Disk brakes were incorporated into the design, one on each rear wheel, as a substitute for the internal brake. Each brake is controlled by a separate pedal for independent braking and better maneuverability.
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 11
Figure 5. Disk Brakes
Clutch Hydraulic Throwout Cylinder Evolution and Re-Design
Since the development of the PolyBuilt TorqMaster clutch-pack, PolyBuilt has experienced frequent issues with the hydraulic throwout cylinder on their clutch-pack. The first cylinder used was a pre-manufactured part (a new one shown in Figure 6 in the rear center) which kept failing from over pressurization, extruding the o-ring. The wall thicknesses across this cylinder were considerably thin, and it also suffered from some mechanical damage over a short time. Two years ago, engineers at PolyBuilt designed a replacement for this throwout cylinder. The new cylinder (shown on the left in the figure) was structurally stronger and utilized two back-up anti-extrusion rings for each o-ring groove. The internal grooves were fairly difficult to properly manufacture, but the new cylinder seemed to operate well. When testing the new cylinder for a couple of hours, it developed a large leak and failed to maintain pressure. The cause was determined to be a sharp burr cutting into the o-ring in the groove that went undetected.
The engineers at PolyBuilt decided that the internal grooves posed a severe threat to quality assurance and designed their latest throwout cylinder with external grooves (shown on the right of the figure). The new hydraulic throwout cylinder was much easier to manufacture and has performed well for multiple tests without issue.
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 12
Figure 6. Hydraulic Throwout Cylinders
Manufacturing
Aluminum was chosen instead of steel to manufacture the tractor’s steering column, front axle, and parallel shaft gearbox. This decision saved labor hours and decreased wear on the attachments for the CNC machine.
The CNC machine was used to decrease labor hours to machine parts and to ensure that they are manufactured precisely because the machine is programmed to cut the material to the exact dimensions inputted. Another benefit of using the CNC is that once it is programmed to perform an operation, the machine can repeat the process numerous times which would accelerate production if the tractor were to be manufactured on a large scale.
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 13
Serviceability
Safety
The spaciousness of the tractor’s overall design allows for easy access to drivetrain elements so they can be serviced without obstacles or the need to remove and disassemble large components to reach these components.
The heat shielding surrounding the exhaust pipe has been improved in comparison to the previous models of Polybuilt’s tractors. Another feature Polybuilt added to improve operator safety is pressure switches on the brakes that ensure the engine will not start until the brake is applied. One other item newly added to the tractor is a gear position sensor that will prevent the engine from starting unless the vehicle is in neutral. Finally, there is one breakaway switch and 1 kill switch that will shut down the engine when the operator is not present in the seat.
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 14
Tractor Cost Overview
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 15
* = shown as a percentage of total manufacturing cost
Profit margin | 20% |
Total Manufacturing Cost / Unit | $13,546.17 |
Manufacturing Variable Cost | $11,779.28 |
*Indirect Manufacturing Cost | 10% |
*Research and Development Cost | 5% |
Suggested sales price | $16,255.00 |
Cost Analysis
Cost Strategy: Applied the Theory of Constraints
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 16
Future cost reduction steps
When Polybuilt expands its operation to reach growing demand pools, costs will be reduced naturally through economies of scale. The fixed costs of operation will certainly rise as new manufacturing plants become active, but overall variable costs across all branches of the firm will decrease since more orders will be placed and more units will be sold.
Qualitative Risk Analysis
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 17
Impact Level Risk Type | Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 |
Quality | Minor problems with the paint and exterior finishes | The frame, armrests, or steering wheel location make the tractor less ergonomic | Drivetrain problems that cause the vehicle to be inoperable or unsafe |
Procurement | The cost of steel or aluminum material rises 1-2% | A single source vendor can no longer provide a part Polybuilt outsources | A sole source vendors that provides a key drivetrain component goes out of business |
Market | A time-phase financial analysis reveals that sales dropped less than 2% | Sales decrease more than 5% in less than 1 year | A recession pushes down demand for tractors because farmers can no longer justify the large investment with lower forecasted revenues |
Q1
Q2
Q3
P1
P2
P3
M3
M2
M1
Qualitative Risk Analysis
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 18
Risk ID (from previous slide) | Risk Prevention Plan |
M1 | Polybuilt will continuously improve its products to offer more value to our customers and more reason to purchase our vehicles |
M2 | Polybuilt will encourage its distributors to use sale pricing, enhanced marketing and visibility techniques, and other means of boosting sales |
M3 | Polybuilt will help farmers during economic downturns by offering payment plans and other flexible purchase options |
P1 | Polybuilt will be prepared in advance to secure material from one or two other alternative sources |
P2 | Polybuilt will compare other vendors based on pre-established criterion and select a different source for parts that must be outsourced |
P3 | Polybuilt will plan a means of manufacturing all parts of the tractor so, if need be, the firm can operate without being dependent on any sole source vendors |
Q1 | The risk will be accepted because its low impact severity and low probability combined result in it being a low priority risk |
Q2 | User experience will be tested with every major design change that impacts the ergonomic rating of Polybuilt’s tractors |
Q3 | Quality testing and inspection will be conducted on a regular basis at every Polybuilt manufacturing plant |
Acknowledgments and Citations
Polybuilt would like to acknowledge all of the following sponsors for the resources they provided to make this year’s participation in the competition possible:
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 19
FMEA – Electric Kill Switch
California Polytechnic University San Luis Obispo 20