1 of 23

NetLogo Workshop Series� ��Model 07. Axelrod’s Culture Model

2 of 23

Axelrod’s Culture Model

  • One of seminal agent-based models
  • Culture formation
  • Originally published in JCR (1997)

​

​

​

​

​

​

* He also studied “game theory and cooperation” to understand international relations.

​

​

3 of 23

If people tend to become more alike in their beliefs, attitudes, and behavior when they interact, why do not all such differences eventually disappear?

4 of 23

5 of 23

Axelrod (1997, p. 207)

6 of 23

Agent properties

  • Agents have multiple cultural features
    • {computer, hair style, top, bottom, phone}

​

  • Each feature has multiple traits
    • Computer: 1 Mac, 2 PC, 3 Chromebook
    • Hair style: 1 short, 2 medium, 3 long
    • Top: 1 t-shirt, 2 shirts, 3 sweater, 4 sweatshirt
    • Bottom: 1 skirt, 2 trouser, 3 jeans, 4 sweatpants, 5 leggings
    • Phone: 1 Iphone, 2 android

​

e.g. My culture set: {PC, medium hair, shirt, jeans, android} = {2, 2, 2, 3, 1}

​

* Consider the academic culture: e.g. R vs. Python; SPSS vs. STATA

7 of 23

  1. Agent X (82330) select one of their neighbors. Let’s say it picked the south (67730)
  2. Calculate similarity between self and the neighbor = 40%
  3. They have 40% chance of interacting.
  4. Let’s say they do interact. Then the agent X take on the trait of one of the three features

that are different in the south’s culture. (e.g. 62330).

* Now the cultural similarity between two agents increases from 40% to 60%.

This increases the chance for two agents interact and converge.

​

8 of 23

This interaction rule can be called…

Conformity

​

Latitude of Acceptance

​

Homophily & Influence

​

Coordination

9 of 23

10 of 23

11 of 23

12 of 23

WHAT IS IT?

This is a replication of Robert Axelrod's model of cultural dissemination, as presented in "The Dissemination of Culture: A Model with Local Convergence and Global Polarization".

13 of 23

HOW IT WORKS

Patches are assigned a list of num-features integers which can each take on one of num-traits values. Each tag is called a feature, while it's value is called the trait.

The links in the view represent walls between patches where solid black walls mean there is no cultural similarity, and white walls mean the neighbors have the same culture.

14 of 23

HOW IT WORKS

The order of actions is as follows:�1) At random, pick a site to be active, and pick one of it's neighbors�2) With probability equal to their cultural similarity, these sites interact. The active site replaces one of the features on which they differ (if any) with the corresponding trait of the neighbor.�

The model ends when no further interactions can take place.

15 of 23

HOW TO USE IT

Setup assigns the patches random culture based on the num-features and num-traits sliders, and updates the walls between them.�

The plot "Connected Regions" has 2 pens. The black pen tracks the number of clusters of culturally identical patches, while the red pen tracks the size of the largest cluster. This is a time consuming algorithm for larger scale models, so the interval between updates is controlled by the sample-interval slider.

16 of 23

THINGS TO NOTICE

Q1) Try setting num-features to 5 and num-traits to 10. Under these settings, a typical culture list might be [9 6 0 3 4]. Run the model. How do the plots vary over time? Are changes gradual, or sudden?�

Try running the model a few times. What different features can you see under these settings?�

Q2) Try increasing num-traits to 15 and then to 20. How does this affect the final picture? Can you explain this?�

Q3) With num-traits set at 20, try increasing num-features to 10. What happens now? More features means there is even more variety in culture, so the results may be surprising. What aspect of the model causes this behavior?

​

​

17 of 23

Discussion points

18 of 23

Agents: Schelling vs. Axelrod

  • Schelling’s agents do not change their attributes but change their location
    • e.g., race, ethnicity, gender

​

  • Axelrod’s agents do not change their location but change their attributes
    • e.g., fads, trends, beliefs, attitudes

19 of 23

Variations in a particular cultural feature

  • QWERTY 🡪 1
  • PC vs. Mac 🡪 2ish
  • Iphone, Android, etc 🡪 2ish
  • …
  • …
  • Languages and dialects 🡪 many

20 of 23

QWERTY Keyboard

21 of 23

PC vs. Mac

vs. Linux

22 of 23

Languages and dialects

23 of 23

In 2014 ABM class, Eric and Patrick extended Axelrod’s cultural model by adding

self-selected media influence and townhall meetings influence for their final project.

This paper was published in JASSS 2016: http://jasss.soc.surrey.ac.uk/19/2/1.html