3 of 16

Tangible / Physical Property

Definition: Physical assets that exist in material form (Movable or Immovable).

Intellectual Property (IP)

Definition: Intangible creations of the human intellect and mind.

Ownership Boundaries: Clearly defined by physical dimensions (land, machinery, devices).

Rivalrous Nature: Consumption by one party prevents simultaneous use by another.

Depreciation: Suffers wear and tear over time through usage.

Protection Mechanism: Governed by Property Law, Trespass, and Real Estate regulations.

Non-Rivalrous Nature: Software code, algorithms, or formulas can be used by millions concurrently.

Monopoly Rights: Grants statutory exclusive rights to exploit the creation for a specified duration.

Territorial Nature: Rights granted under national legislation (e.g., Indian Patents Act, 1970).

Protection Mechanism: Statutory registration of Patents, Copyrights, Trademarks, and Trade Secrets.

•

Concept of Property vs. Intellectual Property

4 of 16

Patents: Exclusive rights granted for technical inventions (product or process) offering novel solutions to technical problems.

Copyrights: Protects original literary, dramatic, musical, artistic works, and computer software source code.

Trademarks: Distinctive signs, logos, or brand names used to identify goods/services of an enterprise.

Trade Secrets: Confidential business information, formulas, or ML datasets providing a competitive edge.

Industrial Designs & GI: Protects visual aesthetic appearance and geographic origin indications.

•

Core Types of Intellectual Property Rights

5 of 16

IP Type	Governing Act in India	Subject Matter Protected	Term of Protection
Patents	The Patents Act, 1970 (Amended 2005)	Inventions (Product/Process) fulfilling Novelty, Inventive step	20 Years (from filing date)
Copyrights	The Copyright Act, 1957 (Amended 2012)	Software code, literary works, artistic creations, databases	Author's Lifetime + 60 Years
Trademarks	The Trade Marks Act, 1999	Brand names, logos, slogans, trade dress, sound marks	10 Years (Renewable indefinitely)
Industrial Designs	The Designs Act, 2000	Visual 2D/3D shapes, patterns, ornamentation of products	10 Years (Extendable to 15 yrs)
Trade Secrets	Common Law / Contract Act, 1872 (NDAs)	Proprietary algorithms, ML dataset weights, secret formulas	Indefinite (Until disclosed)

Comparative Matrix of IP Legislation in India

6 of 16

STATUTORY DEEP-DIVE

Indian Patent Laws & Statutory Framework

Analysis of The Patents Act 1970, Patentability Criteria, and Section 3 Statutory Exclusions

7 of 16

The Indian Patents Act, 1970

Historical Context & Amendments

Enacted based on the Ayyangar Committee Report, replacing the colonial 1911 Act. It originally allowed only process patents for pharmaceuticals and agrochemicals to encourage domestic industrial growth.

The 2005 TRIPS Amendment: Re-introduced product patents across all technology sectors, establishing a uniform 20-year term and compliance with WTO obligations.

Key Principles: Balances private monopoly rights with public welfare, access to healthcare, and technological dissemination.

8 of 16

Economic Rationale

Social Contract & Public Interest

Incentivizing R&D: Recovers high capital expenditure incurred in technology, software, and AI model development.

Market Exclusion: Grants statutory monopoly allowing innovators to commercialize without immediate piracy.

Technology Transfer: Encourages Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and licensing of patented technology into emerging economies.

Quid Pro Quo Bargain: Full public disclosure of the invention in exchange for limited-time monopoly rights.

Building Public Domain: After 20 years, inventions enter the public domain, enabling free usage and further innovation.

Preventing Abuse: Includes provisions like Compulsory Licensing (Sec 84) to prevent market hoarding or exorbitant pricing.

•

Objectives & Economic Rationale of IPR

9 of 16

WIPO

World Intellectual Property Organization: Specialized UN agency headquartered in Geneva administering 26 international IP treaties.

TRIPS Agreement

WTO TRIPS (1994): Enforces minimum standards of IP protection, enforcement mechanisms, and dispute resolution across member nations.

Paris & Berne

Paris Convention (1883): Right of Priority for Industrial Property. Berne Convention (1886): Automatic protection for copyrights globally.

International Regimes & IP Treaties

10 of 16

3.5M+

Annual Patent Filings Worldwide

Strategic Asset in the AI Era

Intellectual Property has shifted from a legal formality to a primary driver of corporate valuation. Over 80% of enterprise value in modern tech companies (e.g., Apple, Microsoft, Google) resides in intangible IP assets, proprietary source codes, and data pipelines rather than physical infrastructure.

Global Impact of IP in Technology

11 of 16

Patents: Technical Claims

Protects hardware architecture, novel software methods, and technical AI execution pipelines.

Copyrights: Source Code

Protects literal expression of code, user interfaces, documentation, and database structures.

Trade Secrets: ML Models

Protects un-patented neural network weights, proprietary training data, and hyper-parameters.

Pillars of IP Protection in Software Engineering

12 of 16

Domestic filings by Indian residents have surpassed foreign filings for the first time in recent years, driven significantly by modern tech startups, engineering universities, and AI research breakthroughs.

Growth of Patent Filings in India (IPO Trends)

13 of 16

Section 3(k) - Software Exclusions: Mathematical methods, business methods, computer programs per se, or algorithms are NOT patentable unless tied to a novel technical hardware effect.

Section 3(d) - Incremental Inventions: Mere discovery of a new form of a known substance without enhancement of efficacy (crucial for pharmaceutical and chemical cases).

Section 3(j) - Biological Matters: Plants, animals, seeds, and biological processes for production of plants or animals are non-patentable.

Section 3(b) - Morality & Public Order: Inventions contrary to public order, morality, or causing serious harm to human, animal, or plant life.

Non-Patentable Subject Matter: Section 3 (India)

14 of 16

Emerging IPR Challenges in AI & Data Science

Can an AI algorithm (e.g., DABUS) be legally recognized as a sole inventor on a patent? Who owns the copyright of code generated by Large Language Models? How do we balance fair-use data training with content creator rights? Unit 1 establishes the foundational legal principles required to solve these contemporary challenges.

15 of 16

Questions & Discussion

End of Unit 1: Introduction to Intellectual Property Rights

16 of 16

https://hoover-s3-website.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/news/intellectualproperty_istock_000019902429.jpg

Source: www.hoover.org

https://lookaside.fbsbx.com/lookaside/crawler/media/?media_id=1381312014190541

Source: www.facebook.com

https://i.etsystatic.com/6412311/r/il/4929a7/5663203083/il_570xN.5663203083_b714.jpg

Source: www.etsy.com

https://media.istockphoto.com/id/2282725652/vector/futuristic-ai-chip-inside-data-center-server-corridor.jpg?s=612x612&w=0&k=20&c=CUf__EvpmaY4leDZVMqyNDL8kV-EYPltrAnMNBPYVDw=

Source: www.istockphoto.com

Image Sources