1 of 30

Beyond Compliance: Creating Innovative Win-Win Reasonable Accommodations and Modifications

Talley Wells, Executive Director,

North Carolina Council on Developmental Disabilities

2026 Virtual ADA Conference for State and Local Governments

State ADA Coordinator's Office

Georgia State Financing and Investment Commission

Photo from Unsplash

2 of 30

Session Objectives

  • Review the basic law of reasonable accommodations and modifications in the Americans with Disabilities Act.

  • Explore the possibility of innovative "win-win" accommodations—solutions that empower individuals with disabilities while simultaneously enhancing efficiency and productivity.

  • Examine potential applications of Artificial Intelligence and Smartphone-based assistive technologies and the continuing value of non-technology accommodations.

  • Consider potential pitfalls of win-win accommodations.

  • Examine the ethical and legal downsides of prioritizing "win-win" scenarios, including the risk of shifting the focus from civil rights to return on investment.

3 of 30

Definition of Disability

  • A physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities;

  • A record of such an impairment;

  • Is regarded as having such an impairment.

4 of 30

42 U.S. Code § 12112 – Discrimination

(a)General rule

No covered entity shall discriminate against a qualified individual on the basis of disability in regard to job application procedures, the hiring, advancement, or discharge of employees, employee compensation, job training, and other terms, conditions, and privileges of employment.

(b)Construction

As used in subsection (a), the term “discriminate against a qualified individual on the basis of disability” includes—

. . . .

(5) (A)not making reasonable accommodations to the known physical or mental limitations of an otherwise qualified individual with a disability who is an applicant or employee, unless such covered entity can demonstrate that the accommodation would impose an undue hardship on the operation of the business of such covered entity; or

. . . . (emphasis added)

Title I (Employment) of the ADA: Reasonable Accommodations

5 of 30

42 U.S. Code § 12132 – Discrimination

[N]o qualified individual with a disability shall, by reason of such disability, be excluded from participation in or be denied the benefits of the services, programs, or activities of a public entity, or be subjected to discrimination by any such entity.

28 CFR § 35.130 General prohibitions against discrimination.

(a) No qualified individual with a disability shall, on the basis of disability, be excluded from participation in or be denied the benefits of the services, programs, or activities of a public entity, or be subjected to discrimination by any public entity.

....

(b)(7)

  1. A public entity shall make reasonable modifications in policies, practices, or procedures when the modifications are necessary to avoid discrimination on the basis of disability, unless the public entity can demonstrate that making the modifications would fundamentally alter the nature of the service, program, or activity. (emphasis added)

Title II (Public Entities) of the ADA: Reasonable Modifications

6 of 30

42 U.S. Code § 12182 - Prohibition of discrimination by public accommodations

(a)General rule

No individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases (or leases to), or operates a place of public accommodation.

. . . .

(2)Specific prohibitions

(A)Discrimination

For purposes of subsection (a), discrimination includes—

. . . .

(ii)a failure to make reasonable modifications in policies, practices, or procedures, when such modifications are necessary to afford such goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations to individuals with disabilities, unless the entity can demonstrate that making such modifications would fundamentally alter the nature of such goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations; (emphasis added)

Title III (Public Accommodations) of the ADA: Reasonable Modifications

7 of 30

What is win win?

Photo from Unsplash

  • Innovative
  • Curb Cut Effect
  • Return on Investment
  • Makes everyone safer at times

8 of 30

9 of 30

Poll Question

Which statement do you agree with the most about how important it is for accommodations to be beneficial for everyone, or the entity providing the accommodation?

  • Very important. Right now, we have to depend on more than the law to ensure employers, government entities, and organizations provide accommodations.
  • Somewhat important. It is helpful if accommodations also benefit the general public or the entity providing the accommodation, but it is more important that entities understand they have a legal requirement to follow the ADA. It is the right of the person with a disability to have an accommodation.
  • Not important. Accommodations are required by the ADA. It is the civil right of people with disabilities to have accommodations whether or not it benefits the larger public or the entity providing the accommodation.
  • Not sure. I am not sure. I need to think about it more.

10 of 30

Universal Design

Universal design (UD) is a strategy for making products, environments, operational systems, and services welcoming and usable to the widest range of people possible. The key principles of UD are simplicity, flexibility, and efficiency. Whether we realize it or not, most of us benefit from UD on a daily basis.

Originally developed in response to the needs of the aging population and people with disabilities, UD now increases access to products, places, and services for all populations. Companies that embrace UD in their facilities, programs, and services recognize that their workforce and customers have a broad range of abilities, ages, reading levels, learning styles, languages, etc.—and an even wider variety of needs and expectations.

Good customer service means providing every customer with a welcoming environment, respectful treatment, and needed information. This goes for the workforce as well. UD provides an important tool set for companies seeking to provide such advantages for both their customers and their employees.

UD is a lens through which every aspect of a business can be viewed, and a set of tools by which products, services, customer satisfaction, and employee attraction and retention can be improved. The principles of UD apply throughout the workplace, to products, services, the physical environment, communications, and technology.

-- United States Department of Labor Office of Disability Employment Policy

https://www.dol.gov/agencies/odep/program-areas/employment-supports/universal-design

11 of 30

12 of 30

Concerns about Focusing on Win Win and Universal Benefits

  • Shifts from Civil Rights Purpose to Business or Universal Benefit.
  • Diminishes the Legal Responsibility argument.
  • Not all Reasonable Accommodations and Modifications required by law will result in win-win situations or benefit everyone.

Photo by Saif71.com on Unsplash

13 of 30

Be Careful!

Accommodations and modifications must effectively meet the individual's specific needs and are decided on a case-by-case basis through an interactive process, provided they do not cause undue hardship or fundamental alteration (look at each Title law for specific requirements).

14 of 30

Poll Question

What do you think of Artificial Intelligence (AI) for accommodations?

  • I am very excited about it.
  • I have mixed feelings. I think there are some good things, but I am also uncomfortable with some of it.
  • I am not comfortable with AI.
  • I am not sure.

15 of 30

Artificial Intelligence (AI)

Potential Accommodations

Pros and Big Cons

AI Deaf/Hard of Hearing Accommodations

Pros

Big Cons

Live AI Captioning

Essential for people hard of hearing and everyone in loud environments

Inaccuracy! Challenges with accents, technical jargon,

ASL to Text Translation

Reduces costs, Bridges communication gaps in real-time

Lacks nuance and facial expression of human interpreters, accuracy

Visual Sound Alerts

Converts fire alarms and doorbells to haptics/visual signals

Must work because critical to safety.

Audio Cleaning/Enhancement

Isolates voice from background noise for hearing aid users

Can clip important ambient sounds

16 of 30

Let’s Talk Captioning

AI Captioning is almost never sufficient on its own to meet the "effective communication" standards required by the ADA.

Not accurate Enough Yet!

The Department of Justice (DOJ) and the EEOC have clarified that for an accommodation to be "reasonable" and "effective," it must be accurate.

  • The Problem: Standard AI (Automatic Speech Recognition or ASR) typically averages 80–95% accuracy. While that sounds high, a 5% error rate means one out of every 20 words is wrong, which can completely change the meaning of a sentence (e.g., "cannot" vs. "can").
  • The Standard: Under Title II (State/Local Gov) and Title III (Public Places), the standard is effective communication. If the AI is inaccurate, misses technical jargon, names, or non-speech cues (like "[Laughter]" or "[Alarm ringing]"), it may fail the legal test.

17 of 30

Artificial Intelligence (AI)

Potential Accommodations

Pros and Big Cons

AI Vision

Accommodations

Pros

Cons

Real Time Scene Description

Independence for navigation

AI can struggle with complex layouts or low-light; safety risk

Alt-Text Generation

Makes digital content accessible

Can be generic or factually incorrect

Handwriting to Speech

Read handwritten notes

Success depends on legibility of handwriting

Smart Glasses

Hands free navigation and reading

High cost

18 of 30

Artificial Intelligence (AI)

Potential Accommodations

Pros and Big Cons

AI Mobility and Physical Disability

Accommodations

Pros

Cons

Voice Control

Allows users to control lights, switches, and devices with voice

Sensitive to environmental noise and can trigger accidentally

MaaS-Bridge platforms

Optimizes pickup/dropoff and traveling

Requires quality mapping of curbs and ramps

Eye-Tracking Navigation

Allows computer/virtual reality use via gaze

Significant strain, challenging to use, requires sufficient eye gaze ability

Exoskeleton Balance AI

Assists in walking/standing; reduces physical strain

High cost; extensive training needed.

19 of 30

  1. Multi-Dimensional Analysis: The AI analyzes real-time road traffic, pedestrian infrastructure (sidewalk quality, curb heights, ramp locations), and the specific profile of the user (e.g., a power wheelchair user vs. a person with low vision).
  2. Mobility Points (MP): Instead of just giving a street address, the platform identifies precise "Mobility Points." These are optimized pick-up and drop-off zones where the infrastructure is guaranteed to be accessible for that specific user.

3. Infrastructure Mapping: Using AI-enabled cameras and data crowdsourcing, the platform maps obstacles that Google Maps often misses, such as steep slopes, broken pavement, or temporary construction barriers.

An AI-driven system designed to solve the "last-mile" connectivity gap for people with disabilities. It recently gained significant attention as a CES 2026 Best of Innovation award winner.

 MaaS-Bridge Platform (Mobility-as-a-Service Bridge)

20 of 30

“Smartphones have become the Swiss Army knives of technology . . .”

--Edward C. Baig, AARP

Photo by Patrick on Unsplash

21 of 30

Poll Question

How often do you use an accommodation on your smart phone?

  • Every day
  • Occasionally
  • Not often
  • Never
  • Not sure

22 of 30

Mobile Phone Win-Win Accommodations

Screen Readers -- reads the screen or articles on the screen. Everyone can use while exercising, driving, or doing other tasks.

Magnification – allows small print to be increased in size. Everyone can read very small print, including menus and product codes.

Live Captioning – provides real-time captioning for apps, videos, podcasts, calls, and live activities. Everyone can follow along in loud spaces or when they cannot use sound.

Sound amplifier – filters background noise. Everyone can hear in loud places, such as airplanes and restaurants.

Live transcribe – allows full transcripts to be created. Everyone can have notes or searchable content from meetings.

Voice control – hands free use of different apps and aspects of smart phone. Everyone can use their phone more safely when their hands cannot be touching the phone such as in the car.

Eye Tracking – navigates with gaze. Everyone has a simpler way to use their phone.

Smart reminders – allows for tasks to be reminded at a certain time or location. Everyone needs a reminder!

23 of 30

Personalized Speech Recognition (PSR).

Technology for understanding atypical speech due to conditions like Cerebral Palsy, ALS, Stroke, or Down Syndrome use these tools to train specifically on one’s own voice.

Atypical Speech Recognition

24 of 30

Win/Win – Universal Design – Accommodations

Physical Environment & Mobility

Curb Cuts (Sidewalk Ramps): Essential for wheelchairs; vital for strollers, bicycles, and heavy rolling suitcases.

Automatic Doors: Helpful for mobility impairments; a lifesaver for anyone carrying groceries, holding a baby, or moving furniture.

Levers Instead of Doorknobs: Easier for people with arthritis; accessible for anyone whose hands are full or greasy (e.g., while cooking).

No-Step Entrances: Provides access for wheelchair users; prevents tripping hazards for seniors and children.

Wide Hallways and Doorways: Accommodates wheelchairs; makes moving large furniture and high-traffic flow much easier.

Lowered Counters: Accessible for wheelchair users and people of short stature; comfortable for children and safer for the elderly.

Handrails on Both Sides of Stairs: Provides stability for those with balance issues; increases safety for everyone in icy or wet conditions.

Photo by Cari Kolipoki on Unsplash

25 of 30

Win/Win – Universal Design – Accommodations

Communication & Navigation

Clear, High-Contrast Signage: Assists people with low vision; helps tourists, children, and anyone in a hurry navigate unfamiliar spaces quickly.

Tactile Paving (Bumpy Sidewalk Strips): Warns blind pedestrians of traffic; serves as a non-slip surface and a visual "edge" indicator for everyone.

Pictograms and Icons: Breaks down barriers for those with cognitive disabilities; overcomes language barriers for non-native speakers.

Redundant Cueing (Visual and Auditory): A "ding" and a light for an elevator assists those with sensory impairments; ensures no one misses their floor while distracted.

Easy-to-Read Fonts and Simplified Language: Supports people with dyslexia or learning disabilities; improves clarity and reduces "cognitive load" for all readers.

Photo by Nick Fewings on Unsplash

26 of 30

Workspace & Social Design

Flexible Work Schedules: Accommodates medical appointments or energy management; supports parents, students, and caregivers.

Quiet Zones/Sensory Rooms: Essential for neurodivergent individuals; provides a much-needed mental break for anyone feeling stressed or overstimulated.

Adjustable Lighting: Helps those with light sensitivity (migraines/autism); allows everyone to customize their environment for eye comfort.

Ergonomic Seating/Furniture: Necessary for those with chronic pain; prevents injury and increases productivity for the general workforce.

Inclusive Playgrounds: Designed for children with disabilities; encourages social interaction and empathy among all children.

Photo by Nick Fewings on Unsplash

27 of 30

So . . . To Win/Win or Not to Win/Win?

What about Universal Design?

28 of 30

Going Forward

29 of 30

30 of 30

CONTACT INFORMATION

Talley Wells, Esq.

Executive Director

North Carolina Council on Developmental Disabilities

talley.wells@dhhs.nc.gov