1 of 9

School Committee - Special Meeting�November 12, 2020

1

Discussion of Proposed Revision �of Public Health Metrics

2 of 9

2

Updates since last discussion

Metrics Update

CPS COVID-19 Data Dashboard

3 of 9

3

Updates since last discussion

Expanded CPS COVID-19 Dashboard

​

The Cambridge Public Health Department and the Cambridge Public Schools �are collaborating to expand the COVID-19 Dashboard to keep the Cambridge community up to date on the level of risk in the community.

​

​

​

​

Confirmed COVID-19 cases among:

  • Among in-person staff and in-person students
  • At the district and school level
  • For the previous week and cumulatively since schools opened for in-person learning on 10/13

Rates of staff participation in COVID-19 testing

  • Among in-person staff
  • For the previous week and a monthly average
  • At the district and school level

About the data:

​

  • Data will be provided by the Cambridge Public Health Department

​

  • Will be reported in alignment with the policy of the Cambridge Public Health Department, to protect individual privacy:
    • 0 cases = report “0 cases”
    • 1- 4 cases = report “1 - 4 cases”
    • 5+ cases = report the exact number of cases

In addition to the current public �health metrics, the Dashboard will �be expanded to include:

4 of 9

School Committee - Special Meeting�November 12, 2020

4

Previously presented:

Recommended metrics

5 of 9

5

Summary of Reopening Contingencies

  1. Routine testing and surveillance testing plan for anyone returning �to classrooms

​

  • Frequent evaluation and adaptation of key metrics, including those centered on equity & vulnerable populations disproportionately affected by COVID-19

Review planned for October 2020

​

  • Adoption of the safety and facilities manual and ensure there are no spaces used that do not meet guidelines/requirements

​

  • Vote is subject is change as the COVID-19 pandemic is fluid and changes to this reopening plan may be necessary, and must continue to improve centering the voices of educators, families, and scholars

​

  1. Plan for scholars in substantially separate programs co-created by special educators, families of those in substantially separate classrooms, with the administration and COVID-19 Task Force experts as scholars and professionals in these rooms are at greater risk of COVID-19 and face the greatest challenges to remote and in person learning.

​

  • Discussion on childcare options for families and educators during remote learning (with the City Council, CDHS, �and City of Cambridge) �
  • Co-created social emotional learning, mental and behavioral health plan for all scholars developed by educators, staff, out �of school time professionals, scholars and families for in person �and remote learning.

​

​

6 of 9

Recommendations from CPS Scientific Advisors

October 29, 2020

​

6

Bradley Bernstein, MD, PhD

Massachusetts General Hospital, �Broad Institute & CPS Parent

​

Jill Crittenden, PhD�MIT; Co-chair, COVID-19 Cambridge Expert Advisory Panel; Member, N95Decon.org & CPS Parent

​

Keith Marzilli Ericson, PhD�BU Questrom School of Business & �CPS Parent

​

Helen Jenkins, PhD�BU School of Public Health & �CPS parent

​

Jamie Lichtenstein, PhD�Emerson College & CPS parent

​

  • Reviewed metrics, updated evidence, and CPS practices

​

  • Proposed updated metrics �and related recommendations (See full letter on website)

​

  • Discussed and passed unanimously by Buildings & Grounds Subcommittee �on 10/30/20

​

7 of 9

7

New Evidence

More Substantial Data about SARS-CoV-2 Risks

​

  • Spread within schools using mitigation strategies is uncommon
  • Young children are less susceptible
  • Cases of school-based spread have occurred in crowded middle and high school classrooms where students not wearing masks (Israel, Georgia, Utah)
  • New evidence supporting the effectiveness of universal face-masking in controlling spread

Specific Evidence from CPS’s �Limited Reopening: �

  • Recommended safety measures effectively implemented
    • Masking
    • Ventilation remediation & monitoring,
    • Surveillance testing
    • Hand hygiene�
  • Surveillance testing of staff assess prevalence, including among non-Cambridge residents
    • Was not in place when initial metrics set
    • 1300+ tests performed
    • very few positives
    • Positives not traced to in-school transmission
    • CPHD provided immediate guidance .
  • High testing availability in Cambridge
  • Waste water metrics that provide a separate assessment of virus prevalence, will soon be published for Cambridge.

8 of 9

8

​

Current Metrics & �Closure Guidelines

Proposed �Updates

​

Metric 1: Daily New Cases

Fewer than 25 new cases per day, per 100,000 people (weighted average for Suffolk County and Middlesex County) �(7-day average)

Fewer than 25 new cases per

day per 100,000 people (in Cambridge)(7-day average)

Metric 2: �Test �Positivity

Less than 5% of COVID-19 tests �are positive in Massachusetts (7-day average)

Less than 5% of COVID-19 tests �are positive in Cambridge �(7-day average)

Metric 3: Sewage Wastewater

COVID-19 in wastewater detected at < 100 copies viral genomes/mL.

No current change. �Will discuss change if local Cambridge data becomes available.

Recommendations: Updated Metrics

9 of 9

9

​

Current Metrics & Closure Guidelines

Proposed �Updates

Closure

If two of three metrics exceed “acceptable” level described, CPS shifts to remote only learning.

No change.

If two of three metrics exceed �“acceptable” level described, CPS �shifts to remote only learning.

Reopening

Not specified.

Schools remain closed for at least �1 week. In-person education resumes �when either one or no metrics exceed threshold for 7 consecutive days.

Surveillance Testing for Students

Not specified.

​

Offer surveillance testing to older �students when prevalence is high.

Timing �to Revisit Metrics

October 2020

January 2021

Recommendations: Additional Guidelines