Schottky Signals�& Diagnostics
Manfred Wendt, CERN
with major contributions for Piotr Kowina, GSI
U.S. Particle Accelerator School 2024
Design and Engineering of Modern beam Diagnostics
Hampton (VA), U.S.A., January 29 – February 2, 2024
Longitudinal�Schottky band
Background image:
Schoktty signal spectras taken during a �LHC lead ion run on 3th Dec. 2015, fill #4690.
frequency
time
Lower transverse�Schottky sideband
Upper transverse�Schottky sideband
Page 1
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Learning Objectives
Page 2
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Outline
Page 3
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
To set the Scene: Single Particles
Page 4
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
To set the Scene: Single Particles
Page 5
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Walter Schottky
Page 6
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Page 7
28th Oct. – 7th Nov. 2019, JAS 2019, Dubna, Russia – Beam Instrumentation & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Schottky Signals�of charged particles �in a storage ring
Page 7
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Schottky Signals
Inoise
V
-
+
d,τ
vacuum
tube
= linac
e-
rev. time
T0 = 1/f0
injection
extraction
Schottky pickup
Ring�accelerator
Page 8
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Noise Signals from Electronic Components
noise�free
Vnoise
voltage [Vrms ]
signal only
S/N=4
sample
Typical challenge for “regular”
beam instrumentation:
This is NOT a Schottky beam signal!
Noise contents originates from the electronics, not from the beam signal
Page 9
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Schottky Noise in the Frequency Domain
courtesy P. Kowina
Page 10
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Simulation of a Schottky Beam Signal
Time domain
Sample number
7.17 µS
Frequency domain
(FFT)
Page 11
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Longitudinal Schottky Signals, unbunched (2)
1
2
3
4
0
Fourier trans. or
spectrum analyzer
0
1
2
3
4
The entire information �is available around�every revolution harmonic
Schottky pickup
Σ
Page 12
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Longitudinal Schottky Signals, unbunched (3)
θi
Σ
Page 13
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Longitudinal Schottky Signals, unbunched (4)
For ions the �power scales with:�(larger signal levels!)
What happens at �very high frequencies?
Page 14
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Longitudinal Schottky Signals, unbunched (5)
h=120
h=121
h=122
500 kHz
fcenter = 25.4MHz
100dB
CF∅ 250mm
horizontal
pickup
250mm
70mm
Example: �Schottky pickup at �GSI synchrotron (left)
Operation from unbunched �to bunched beam (right)
injection
frev injection
coasting
beam
adiabatic
bunch formation
start
acceleration
frev = h ⋅ f rf
bunched
beam
Page 15
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Momentum spread analysis
time or phase
δ = Δp/ p
long. phase space
LINAC bunches at injection:
from LINAC
35 kHz
8 dB
Δp/p ≈ 2.5 ⋅10-3
Δp/p ≈ 1.3 ⋅10-3
Δp/p ≈ 0.6 ⋅10-3
bunched
only drift
de-bunched
6 dB
6 dB
fcenter = 24.9 MHz
Δfh ∝ h⋅Δp
time or phase
δ = Δp/ p
long. phase space
de-bunching
De-bunching after some ms:
Schottky
courtesy
P. Forck
P. Kowina
synchrotron
LINAC
buncher
injection
extraction
Schottky
pickup
Σ
Page 16
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Schottky Application: Electron Cooling
e.g.: 220 keV electrons�cool 400 MeV/u ions
electron
temperature
kBT⊥ ≈ 0.1 eV
kBT║ ≈ 0.1 - 1 meV
Example:
Electron cooler at GSI, Umax = 300 kV
hot beam,
(p-bars, ions, protons)
cold �electron beam
Page 17
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Monitoring the Cooling Process
t = 650 s
fcenter = 245 MHz
⇔ h = 124
fspan = 200 kHz
Δp/p0 = 3⋅10 -5
Δp/p0 = 4⋅10 -4
Schottky pickup
Σ
electron cooler
Page 18
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Resonant Cavity as Schottky Pickup
fres = 244.965 MHz
frequency f – fres [kHz]
0
5
mom. spread: Δp/p = 6.6 ⋅ 10-6
time
each trace meas. for 32 ms
beam
100mm
CF250
∅600
ceramic
gap
Elong
beam
TM010 cavity
Page 19
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Transverse Schottky Signal, unbunched (1)
transverse part�“signal” contribution
observed frequency at a�fixed location, e.g BPM
betatron sidebands
amplitude modulation:
left & right sideband
with
at each
Schottky pick-up
Δ
Page 20
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Transverse Schottky Signal, unbunched (2)
long. h=10
lower SB
f10-
upper SB
f10+
lower SB
f11-
upper SB
f11+
long. h=11
q
q
Schottky pick-up
Δ
Page 21
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Transverse Schottky Signal, unbunched (3)
long. part
trans.
chromatic coupling
Page 22
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Transverse Schottky Signal, unbunched (4)
t=1.2s
longitudinal
lower SB
upper SB
frequency [GHz]
1.2997
1.3007
1.2987
Page 23
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
RMS Emittance Measurement
TM120& TM210 mode cavity
154mm
power in long band
depend on beam position x
upper SB
lower SB
Schottky cavity
drive
drive
Page 24
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Longitudinal Schottky Signal, bunched (1)
significant bandwidth
Schottky pick-up
Δ
Page 25
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Longitudinal Schottky Signal, bunched (2)
overlap!
Σ
rf cavity
bunch
Page 26
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Transverse Schottky Signals, bunched (1)
Schottky pickup
Δ
bunch
Page 27
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Transverse Schottky Signals, bunched (2)
Page 28
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Page 29
28th Oct. – 7th Nov. 2019, JAS 2019, Dubna, Russia – Beam Instrumentation & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
The LHC Schottky Monitor
Page 29
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Motivation
Amplitude modulation terms
Time modulation terms
synchrotron�frequency
betatron�frequencies
“chromatic”�frequency
Page 30
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
LHC Beam Parameter Extraction
typical LHC Schottky spectrum at h = 427746 (frev = 11.245 kHz)�in low-resolution FFT mode
Page 31
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
LHC Schottky Design Choices
frequency
ampl.
(h-1)∆f
(h-1)frev
h ∆f
(h+1)∆f
h frev
Overlap
Page 32
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Principle of Operation
∆
RF-Signal Processing
DAQ
Fast�Gate-Switch
∆-Hybrid
bunched �beam
v ≈ c0
vacuum pipe,
60x60mm cross-section
WR-187 wave-guides,
~1000mm long
2x270 coupling slots,
~20x2mm
WG-to-coaxial
transitions
4.8 GHz�oscillation
~6 ns
Page 33
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
The LHC Schottky monitor
2-of-4 LHC Schottky “tanks” installed�in the straight section near point 4
Page 34
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Schottky Signals since 2018
Ion Schottky signals
before and after the energy ramp
Proton Schottky signals at injection energy
Page 35
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Schottky Signals in 2012
B1H
B1V
B2H
B2V
50 dB
Page 36
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
LHC Schottky Pickup
Beam pipe 60x60mm
TE10 mode waveguides �type WR187 (WG12)
270 coupling slots in 0.2mm thick CuBe-foil (~20x2mm, 4mm pitch)
Page 37
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
EM Analysis
transfer impedance�∆-mode Σ-mode
Σ-mode
∆-mode
Page 38
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Pickup Issue: WG-Coax Coupler
modified pin �extension
blended �through hole
for feedthrough
Metal burr
WG-to coaxial mode launchers: Problems �with tolerances and impedance matching
-20 dB
-30 dB
4.6 GHz
5.2 GHz
WG-to-coaxial �mode launcher
WG-to-coaxial �mode launcher
EM simulation
Page 39
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Pickup Issue: Warped Coupling Foil
elongated coupling foil�after disassembly
warped foil
Page 40
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Schottky Pickup Remanufacturing
Page 41
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Remaining Issue: Beam pipe Coupling
Page 42
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
RF Signal Processing
Page 43
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
RF Front-end after Overhaul
LNA
fast gate
Δ-hybrid
cavity �BPF
Bessel �BPF
isolator
compensation path
RF amplifier
Page 44
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Compensation Path
compensation path
Δ-hybrid
cable delay line
Sensitivity:
≈ 0.25 dB / ≈ 1 ps
Tuning for best �common mode rejection
ADS simulation
based on meas.
S-Parameters
Page 45
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Fast Gate-Switch
LHC proton bunch Schottky signals in the time-domain (acquired with a 20 GHz / 60 GSPS oscilloscope)
Gate-switch performance after resolving numerous problems
Page 46
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Interdigital Bessel Band-pass Filter
AgAu-plated:�BW ≈ 72 MHz (15 %)�5τ ≈ 25 ns
Insertion loss ≈ 2 dB
TD response of a commercial�Butterworth pre-selector filter
4.8 GHz pre-selector BPF to limit the instantaneous signal level at the 1st LNA
Page 47
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Cavity Band-pass Filter
TE110
TM111
TE311
Prototype out of brass:�Q0 ≈ 9300�5τ ≈ 1μs�QL ≈ 3700
��
�Insertion loss ≈ 2 dB
Features to suppress unwanted modes
Inductive coupling loop
Plunger to fine-adjust fc
Mode-chart for a �cylindrical resonator
with fTE110 = 4.8 GHz
sweet spot
Page 48
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
RF Back-end
Triple stage downconverter
4.8 GHz → 400 MHz → 21.4 MHz → 11 kHz
4 x downconverters
LO distribution
Local-Oscillators (LOs)
VME crate
(control and acq.)
LO signal �distribution system
Page 49
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Beam Measurements & Studies
Ion Schottky signals before and after the energy ramp
Time domain Schottky pickup signal (12 GHz BW oscilloscope)�indicating beam pipe related reflection effects
Supporting MD1447: Collimator impedance study
with high resolution tune measurements
Background image:
Schoktty signal spectras taken during a �LHC lead ion run on 3th Dec. 2015, fill #4690.
frequency
time
Longitudinal�Schottky band
Lower transverse�Schottky sideband
Upper transverse�Schottky sideband
Page 50
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
MD1767: Fun with Fitting
Page 51
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
LHC MD1767: Beam 1 Results for Chromaticity
Single nominal bunch
Bunch trains
Switching the Schottky measurement�to different bunches
Page 52
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
LHC MD2408: Chromaticity and Emittance
Page 53
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Analysis of the longitudinal Spectra
No intra-bunch coherent motion
Single particle spectrum
Synch amp pdf
This is the measured spectrum
This we know how to calculate
These we need to find!
courtesy
K. Lasocha
D. Alves
Page 54
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
LHC long. SB Spectrum Analysis
Minimize cost function:
Page 55
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
THANK YOU!
Page 56
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
https://cas.web.cern.ch/schools/kaunas-2020
Page 57
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Page 58
28th Oct. – 7th Nov. 2019, JAS 2019, Dubna, Russia – Beam Instrumentation & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Backup Slides
Page 58
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
MD1767: Chromaticity Study
Shift start
Shift end
Single nominal
Octupoles off
Chroma +5…+20
Trains: 1x12b, 6x96b
Octupoles on
Chroma 0…+20�
Switching �between
bunches
Change of chromaticity
Page 59
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
More on Schottky Signal Studies
Effect of the ”RF-blow-up”�during the proton energy ramp
Offline studies on signal
interpolation and fitting
Offline studies to separate coherent �and incoherent signal contents
Page 60
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Automatic C-Path Tuning w Beam
Page 61
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
RF Front-end Cascade Analysis
Page 62
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt
Changing LO-Frequencies
step-recovery�diode as�frequency�multiplier
low phase noise�fractional PLL�RF source
Page 63
January 29th – February 2nd , 2024, USPAS Hampton (VA), U.S.A. – Schottky Signals & Diagnostics – M. Wendt