1 of 31

Community Heat Group

An ECCAN Sub-network

Launch event Mon 3 February 2025

2 of 31

Agenda

  • Update from ECCAN
  • Introduction to the Community Heat Gp
  • EdinBRIC
  • CHEF
  • Breakout / Group discussions
  • Questions and discussion

3 of 31

Kaz Lyon, ECCAN Operations Lead �explored the new ECCAN website:�

https://www.eccan.scot/

4 of 31

Introduction

ECCAN invited Clean Heat Edinburgh Forum (CHEF) and Edinburgh Building Retrofit & Improvement Collective (EdinBRIC) to support the setup of ECCAN’s “Community Heat Group” (CHG).

The aim is to be a sub-network of groups that can learn from each other and collaborate, to help communities to create Community Heat Plans.

For this exercise EALA are to work as secretariat.

5 of 31

Introduction

Heat is fundamental to human health and comfort. The cost of heat is often a driver of financial inequality.

Our current systems are a product of 100 years of development, largely shaped by cheap oil and gas from the North Sea since the 1970s. Our heat is predominantly provided by petrochemicals, mostly natural gas.

Heating our homes accounts for 15% of Scotland’s carbon emissions. Scotland has a target of being ‘net zero carbon’ by 2045. However, the electricity generation capacity is much smaller than what is needed to replace gas.

6 of 31

Government work so far

The Scottish Government (SG) published a draft Heat in Buildings Bill in 2024 which suggests many ways this will be done. One proposal is to ban new gas boilers from 2038, meaning most will have expired by 2045. A new solution will have to be in place before then.

A significant element of SG’s answer is heat networks. They published the Heat Networks (Scotland) Act in 2021.

SG had all local authorities develop Local Heat and Energy Efficiency Strategies (LHEES) in 2024. They zone where heat networks will be licensed, amongst other things.

7 of 31

The Opportunity

The move away from gas will be the biggest change in how we heat our buildings in a century.

Our current energy supply systems create unintended financial consequences, increase financial inequality, have little local control and builds no community wealth or cohesion.

The clean energy transition is a chance to build a better system, for communities to take control, and for the proceeds of energy generation and distribution to stay in communities.

8 of 31

Why now?

Legislation takes time. The shape of the new energy landscape in the 2040s will come from Scottish Government work happening now.

Large physical changes like pipes in the ground will take time to install.

If we don’t shape the work being done now, yet another era of corporate-controlled for-profit energy supply will be established.

Because of the gap between now and then, interim solutions will be put in – individual ASHPs for instance.

9 of 31

Energy now

10 of 31

Energy future

11 of 31

Planned Activity�Spring 2025

  • Two city-wide events:
    • February (today)
    • Late March
  • Work with a Pathfinder Community (Granton Rd)
    • Giving information
    • Gathering opinions and reactions
    • Starting to draft a plan – link to Local Place Plans Autumn deadline
    • Linking to Local Place Plan process
  • Report on findings – late March/April
  • Decide what to do next – April

Community Heat Group

12 of 31

13 of 31

14 of 31

15 of 31

16 of 31

17 of 31

18 of 31

Examples – Brighton & Rosefield

19 of 31

Examples – Westhall Gardens

20 of 31

Examples – the Dudleys

21 of 31

Examples – Kirk Street, Leith

22 of 31

Collaborate with your community �for better homes

www.edinbric.scot

23 of 31

What is CHEF (Clean Heat Edinburgh Forum)

  • Started by Johanna Carrie in 2020
  • Members are mostly from Communities / Academic / Industry,
  • Meeting every Monday (3pm)
  • Focus: Decarbonise heat in Edinburgh, specific focus on heat networks
  • Knowledge sharing
  • Raising awareness

Individual homes

Community choice

24 of 31

Heat network

  • Sewer (Seafield)
  • Incineration (Shawfair – Millerhill)
  • Data centres (University of Edinburgh)
  • Industrial heat pumps
  • Waste heat from Lothian region (East Lothian, Grangemouth)
  • Geothermal

Millerhill

Cockenzie Power station

25 of 31

CHEF in 2023 - 2024

EVENTS

  • Weekly meetings (Mondays 3pm)
  • Edinburgh Association of CC (x2)
  • Fairmilehead Community Council
  • Public meetings (x2), consultation, and response for the LHEES
  • Dave Pearson’s lecture (Napier Uni)
  • Meetings with CEC (Officers and Councillors)
  • ECCAN launch event
  • SERA Members Briefing
  • Research opportunities (Napier Uni)
  • Green Homes Festival (with BE-ST)
  • Site visits (Queen’s Quay, Clydebank)

GRANT BIDS / SUPPORT

  • CEC Community Grant Fund
  • ECCAN Heat subgroup

NEW STRUCTURE FOR CHEF

  • Transformation into a SCIO
  • Website + Logo

26 of 31

ECCAN

Community Heat group

27 of 31

ECCAN

Community Heat group

28 of 31

Break-out groups

29 of 31

Questions and discussion

30 of 31

Wrap up & Conclusion

31 of 31

Contact details