1 of 65

The Future of SEO Content

Considerations and pitfalls of using AI for SEO content generation

2 of 65

Your webinar speaker

Bernard Huang

Co-Founder

bernard@clearscope.io

@clearscope

3 of 65

Table of Contents

  • Evolution of Google’s main content algo updates
  • How Google determines content “helpfulness”
  • Information gain and SERP similarity
  • Search intent / topics change over time
  • Search perspective frameworks
  • Future of SEO content

4 of 65

What has Google been up to?

Google algo updates, how Google determines content helpfulness

5 of 65

Google’s mission statement

“Our mission is to organize the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful.”

6 of 65

Evolution of Google’s content algo updates

  • 2011 - Panda
  • 2011 - Freshness
  • 2013 - Hummingbird
  • 2015 - RankBrain
  • 2017 - Fred
  • 2018 - Medic
  • 2019 - BERT
  • 2021 - Product Review
  • 2022 - Helpful Content
  • 2022 - E-E-A-T
  • 2023 - Bard
  • 2023 - SGE

7 of 65

How Google calculates “helpfulness”

?

Technical

SEO

Links, topical authority, quality content, brand

}

User engagement signals

}

}

8 of 65

How Google calculates “helpfulness”

Relevant backlinks (domain authority)

9 of 65

How Google calculates “helpfulness”

Related subtopic rankings (topical authority)

10 of 65

How Google calculates “helpfulness”

Quality content (knowledge graph)

11 of 65

How Google calculates “helpfulness”

  • domain authority
    • build more links
  • topical authority
    • search perspectives + hub & spoke
    • refresh existing content & wait
  • knowledge graph
    • content optimization w/ Clearscope

?

12 of 65

User engagement signals

?

?

?

13 of 65

How Google calculates user engagement

SERPs that conclude search journeys

14 of 65

How Google calculates user engagement

#1

#1

#1

#2

SERPs that conclude search journeys

15 of 65

How Google calculates user engagement

75% no further search

SERPs that conclude search journeys

what is

what is

what is

50% no further search

recipe

benefits

recipe

<

16 of 65

How Google calculates user engagement

Only one <title> & above the fold experience

Serve the most engaging above the fold experience

17 of 65

Information gain

What the heck is information gain, and why is it important?

18 of 65

What is information gain?

Concepts and entities on the fringe of Google’s knowledge graph

19 of 65

Information gain and SERP similarity

Certain topics have a high amount of SERP similarity

this is the answer

agreed

+1

same

20 of 65

Information gain and SERP similarity

Beat SERP similarity with relevant information gain

#1 answer

Entity-rich content matching fringes of knowledge graph�

#2 answer

what is X

what is X

21 of 65

Information gain and SERP similarity

High confidence SERP similarity produces Featured Snippets

99.99%

22 of 65

Information gain and SERP similarity

Certain topics have a high amount of SERP disparity

this is the answer

nope, I disagree

wrong!

how about this?

23 of 65

Information gain and SERP similarity

50% no further search

Disparity = more aggressive Google sampling

result #1

result #2

result #3

25% no further search

result A

result B

result #1

<

24 of 65

Information gain and SERP similarity

Shortcut rankings by presenting new search perspectives

#1 answer

Perspective that prevents further searches

#2 answer

should you X?

what is X

25 of 65

Information gain and SERP similarity

what�how to�top / best

Shortcut rankings by presenting new search perspectives

0%

25%

50%

75%

?

chaos

insights�experience�unique pov

why �why not�how it works

featured snippet

99.9%

26 of 65

Topic Lifecycles

Content decay and search intent shift

27 of 65

Search intent / topics evolve over time

?

?

?

28 of 65

Search intent / topics change over time

1 year ago

1 month ago

1 month from now

1 year from now

The farther future

Content decay results from search intent shift over time

29 of 65

Search intent / topics change over time

[bone broth], Google search in May 2023

#2

30 of 65

Search intent / topics change over time

Google Trends > [bone broth] > interest peaks 01/2019

31 of 65

Search intent / topics change over time

[bone broth], Google search in March 2019

#1

32 of 65

Search intent / topics change over time

what is bone broth

top bone broth benefits

does both broth have benefits?

I drank bone broth, here are my thoughts

33 of 65

Search intent / topics change over time

[bone broth]

why?

what?

how?

best

34 of 65

Search intent / topics change over time

informational

research

commercial

transactional

35 of 65

Search intent / topics change over time

[bone broth]

why?

are we sure?

who can we trust?

what was your experience like?

top benefits

36 of 65

Search perspective frameworks

What do searchers want to know at different stages of the topic lifecycle?

37 of 65

Search perspective: consideration

#4

best for: how to X, challenging topics (eg. diets, learning new things)

38 of 65

Search perspective: consideration

[topic]

how?

how to do X

common mistakes while doing X

reasons not to do X

things to consider before X

39 of 65

Search perspective: consideration

Best for: how to do X, challenging topics (eg. diets)

  • “things to consider before doing X”
    • [start a blog] 45 things I wish I knew before starting a blog�
  • “common mistakes/myths while doing X”
    • [train for triathlon] Common injury mistakes training for your first triathlon�
  • “reasons not to do X”
    • [start a gym] 7 reasons not to open a gym

40 of 65

Search perspective: experience

best for: X review, consumer-related topics (eg. travel, consumer packaged goods)

#2

41 of 65

Search perspective: experience

[topic]

review?

X alternatives reviewed

I tried X and here’s what happened

42 of 65

Search perspective: experience

Best for: consumer packaged goods, reviews, travel

  • “I tried X and here’s my thoughts”
    • [soylent] 30 days without food, my experience on Soylent
  • “Honest Review of X”
    • [dyson v8 cordless review] My honest of dyson review after 2 years
  • “I did X, here’s my review”
    • [disney world attractions] I Worked at Disney World — Best Rides and Shows to Do There

43 of 65

Search perspective: contrarian

best for: trendy / new topics & industries, questionable research, bold claims

#2

44 of 65

Search perspective: contrarian

Best for: trendy topics, questionable topics, bold claims

  • “X is dead”
    • [google amp] Google AMP is dead! AMP pages no longer get preferential treatment�
  • “Should you try X”
    • [keto diet] Is the Keto Diet actually safe for you?
  • “Please don’t X”
    • [learn to code] Please don’t learn to code

45 of 65

Search perspective: contrarian

[topic]

benefits

X benefits

Should you actually X?

Does X has benefits?

46 of 65

Search perspective: expert

best for: [how to X], [X is good / benefits], [X best practices / tips]

#1

47 of 65

Search perspective: discussion

best for: is it okay to do X, alternatives / reviews, should I X

#6

48 of 65

Search perspective: current events

Best for: depends on current events

#4

49 of 65

Search perspective: predict the future

Best for: depends on your subject matter expertise

50 of 65

Ranch-style SEO

top benefits

[bone broth]

  • guide
  • what is
  • benefits
  • side effects
  • recipe
  • buy now

does it have benefits?

here’s what experts have to say

I tried it and here’s my experience

51 of 65

Future of SEO Content

Thoughts on AI content, video, topical shifts and more

52 of 65

GPT & AI content for SEO

53 of 65

GPT & AI content for SEO

99%

95%

70%

Current AI models are sophisticated autocompletes

54 of 65

GPT & AI content for SEO

Current AI models are sophisticated autocompletes

The quick fox jumps over…

🤖 (AI content) 🤖

the lazy dog.

99.99%

55 of 65

GPT & AI content for SEO

Small inconsistencies in short writing produces small discrepancies

  • Sentence 1 (99%)
  • Sentence 2 (99%)
  • Sentence 3 (99%)
  • Sentence 4 (99%)
  • Sentence 5 (99%)

Sentences 1-5 (0.99)^5 = 95%

56 of 65

GPT & AI content for SEO

Small sample data in newer topics (or long form content) produces large discrepancies

  • Sentence A (90%)
  • Sentence B (90%)
  • Sentence C (90%)
  • Sentence D (90%)
  • Sentence E (90%)

Sentences 1-5 (0.90)^5 = 59%

57 of 65

Google’s updated view on AI content for SEO

58 of 65

Future of SEO content

Produce better content with relevant information gain on SERPs that are high similarity

#1 answer

Entity-rich content matching fringes of knowledge graph�

#2 answer

what is X

what is X

59 of 65

Clearscope for entity optimization

60 of 65

Information gain and SERP similarity

Shortcut rankings by presenting new search perspectives

Shortcut rankings by presenting new search perspectives

#1 answer

Perspective that prevents further searches

#2 answer

should you X?

what is X

61 of 65

Clearscope content inventory for monitoring

62 of 65

Search perspective frameworks

  • stages of consideration
    • “things to consider before doing X”
    • “common mistakes/myths while doing X”
    • “reasons not to do X”
  • contrarian viewpoints
    • “are we sure X is good?”
  • expert viewpoints
    • “surveyed # experts, here’s what they say on X”

63 of 65

Search perspective frameworks

  • experience viewpoints
    • “I tried X and here’s what happened”
  • discussion viewpoints
    • “is it acceptable to do X?”
  • leverage current events
    • “make money from home during X”
  • predict the future
    • “if marijuana is legalized federally, then X”

64 of 65

Future of SEO content - video

Google owns YouTube

  • many searches start on YouTube
  • featured videos / video carousels appear

best for:

  • building trust
  • instructional / how to
  • reviews / experiences
  • what is

Rise of video content for SEO: high barrier to entry, normalized consumption

65 of 65

Questions?

Youtube: youtube.com/c/clearscope

Twitter: @clearscope

We’re hiring at Clearscope!