1 of 29

PRESENTATION NAME

Paula Martins

Policy Advocacy Lead APC

What is advocacy afterall?

2 of 29

Former NRA president invited to speaking at a graduation ceremony

3 of 29

4 of 29

Sleeping giants - defund disinformation

5 of 29

Reflect on your experience in advocacy or what you have learned / heard about it

=> share 1 word that summarizes the concept you have in your mind

6 of 29

WORK IN GROUPS!

Use the post-its to make your group’s definition of advocacy

report back

7 of 29

Advocacy

  • “... the active support of an idea or cause expressed through strategies and methods that influence the opinions and decisions of people and organisations.” (Buckley, 2018). Advocacy tries to 'convince', influence (through evidence, arguments, strategies and methods);

  • “... an organized attempt to change policy, practice, and/or attitudes by presenting evidence and arguments for how and why change should happen.” (OSF). It seeks to generate an expected change;

8 of 29

WHAT DO YOU WANT TO CHANGE?

  • people’s perceptions
  • people’s behavior
  • people’s engagement
  • people’s decisions

INSTITUTIONAL CHANGE

9 of 29

POLICY ADVOCACY

  • a strategy to affect policy change or action
  • a primary audience of decision makers
  • a deliberate process of persuasive communication
  • a process that normally requires the building of momentum and support behind the proposed policy idea or recommendation
  • conducted by groups of organized citizens

EXAMPLES??

some core ideas

10 of 29

whispering to or shouting at government?

ADVISING

MEDIA OUTREACH

LOBBYING

ACTIVISM

cooperation / inside track

confrontation / outside track

evidence based

value based

11 of 29

ADVOCACY IS A PROCESS:

ISSUE

AUDIENCE

MESSAGE

MEANS OF DELIVERY

IMPLEMENTATION

EVALUATION

12 of 29

  • CLEARLY IDENTIFY THE PROBLEM

  • THEN, VERIFY THE PROBLEM

(in other words, LISTEN)

ISSUE IDENTIFICATION AND VERIFICATION

  • ascertain the needs and aspirations of a

community

  • avoid assumptions about what a problem might be and who’s affected
  • ensure that policy proposals are based in evidence and not based on hearsay or headlines

13 of 29

ONCE YOU IDENTIFY THE PROBLEM, PROPOSE SOLUTIONS

  • present policy options

14 of 29

Strategic Focus

A feasible policy objective - considering the obstacles that exist and the leverage you have, how far do you think you can move the process?

The leverage you can bring and use - what can you bring to and use in the process to move it in the direction you wish?

Current obstacles to change - what is currently blocking the policymaking process from moving in the direction you want?

critical self-assessment

15 of 29

Strategic analysis

  • Who are the key decision makers and opinion leaders that you need to influence?
  • How does the decision-making process really work?
  • What is the best timing/opportunity to start or continue your advocacy effort?
  • How do the stakeholders understand the target policy issue and the potential solutions?
  • What are the current positions of key actors in relation to any proposed change in policy?

16 of 29

Shaping messages

What message would appeal to and convince your target audiences?

How can you make your messages striking, memorable, and portable?

Will you upset powerful or influential people with the positions you will

advocate for? Is there any risk to your sustainability or even safety in the positions you will put forward?

Strategic Risk

What responses or challenges do you expect from the audiences that you will present to? How will you defend or respond to these challenges?

Challenges and responses

How will you get your message to your target audiences

(e.g., papers, video, social media)? What kind of events and meetings do you need to allow you to engage enough your target audiences to convince them?

Activities and communication tools

Message and Activities

Why do your target audiences hold the current positions that they do? Will it be easy to move them from these positions?

Audience Profile

17 of 29

What will you need?

  • Credibility
  • Evidence
  • Know the places and processes / policy cycles
  • Know the jargon
  • Community outreach
  • Build relationships with decision makers
  • External communication
  • Network and coalition building

18 of 29

v

POLICY RESEARCH:

• Impact evidence (reviewing eff ec veness).

• Implementation evidence (determining effectiveness of implementation and delivery).

• Descriptive analytical evidence (measuring nature, size, and dynamics of problems, populations, and so on).

• Public attitudes and understanding (via methods such as opinion polls or focus groups).

• Statistical modeling (linear and logarithmic regression methods to make sound predictions).

• Economic evidence (cost-benefit/cost effectiveness of policies).

• Ethical evidence (social justice, redistribution, winners and losers).

FEASIBLE??? => partnerships with academia

19 of 29

RESULTS

  • Developing policy capacities
  • Broadening policy horizons
  • Having a direct policy impact

20 of 29

International digital advocacy

21 of 29

Digital trust and security

Artificial intelligence

Human Rights

Digital public goods

Access and digital inclusion

Internet governance / global digital cooperation architecture

Digital capacity building

Main themes

22 of 29

Why and when to use international advocacy?

  • Boomerang effect to create momentum to your national causes / issues
  • Make noise
  • Last recourse for accountability
  • Decolonize international law - influence standard setting

23 of 29

WHO WILL YOU TARGET?

  • Other States
  • Inter-State initiatives
  • Associations of regulators
  • Regional bodies
  • International bodies
    • United Nations

24 of 29

What can you get from advocacy at the UN?

  • develop or change norms and policies
  • address specific cases
  • recommendations to your State

25 of 29

Bureaucracy

Decentralization

Geo-Politics

CHALLENGES

AND

RISKS

Risk of reprisals

Cost

Civil society always sitting at the back

(COVID)

Impact on people’s lives on the ground?

26 of 29

remember that...

  • It takes time
  • Reaching a milestone can be success, so identify them
  • Monitoring is key to allow change and evaluation
  • Adopt a learning approach, so that you can renovate your strategy after assessing your successes and mistakes

27 of 29

Necessary and proportionate - ‘the 13 principles’

https://necessaryandproportionate.org/

Case study

28 of 29

why was it successful?

  • Clear message, catchy slogan
  • Actionable format
  • AND in-depth research
  • Multistakeholder consultation to identify the problem
  • Coalition building from start - 40 organizations
  • Later endorsed by 600 organizations and 270,000 individuals
  • Other supporting resources
  • Monitoring of impact - citations tracking (reinforcement)

29 of 29

Thank you

feel free to get in touch!

paula@apc.org

Thank you