1 of 33

Climate Change: The Move to Action�(AOSS 480 // NRE 480)

Richard B. Rood

Cell: 301-526-8572

2525 Space Research Building (North Campus)

rbrood@umich.edu

http://clasp.engin.umich.edu/people/rbrood

​

Winter 2020

2 of 33

3 of 33

4 of 33

Communication: Rhetoric and Form of Argument

  • Forms of Rhetoric and Argument
  • Argumentation
  • Communication

5 of 33

Climate Myths�https://www.skepticalscience.com

6 of 33

Communication of Science-based knowledge

  • “ … in the case of some people, not even if we had the most accurate scientific knowledge, would it be easy to persuade them …”

Aristotle, A Treatise on Rhetoric, 350 BCE

Important to know when rhetoric is being used as a tactic to achieve a goal.

7 of 33

Some possible conversations

  • To support an evidence-based decision
  • To convince someone that you excel at the art of argument or rhetoric
  • To convince someone to vote for or support your position
  • To create doubt
  • To do damage or create conflict

8 of 33

To analyze

  • Look at the form of argument
  • Use the principles of the scientific method
  • Remember the scientific method does not produce facts
    • Knowledge
    • Uncertainty

9 of 33

Rhetoric and Form of Argument

  • Are attacks to discredit the person or field prominent: dishonesty, fraud, conflict of interest, conspiracy
    • Accusation that ignoring information
    • (Ad Hominem Fallacy)
  • Labels: alarmists, warmists, denialists, uneducated, conservative, liberal
  • Moral levers of trust and distrust
  • Extract single pieces of information in absence of others and hold as contradiction
  • Reaching metaphors: The world was warmer and had more carbon dioxide when there were dinosaurs and no humans

​

​

10 of 33

More formal notions of argumentation

  • From
    • Persuasion, Argumentation, and Common Fallacies
      • Kenneth Alfano
      • Erik Hildinger

11 of 33

A Critical Consideration: Audience

It is essential to analyze your audience(s) prior to any persuasive endeavor.

​

  • How much do they know about the issue?
  • What are their predispositions or interests?
  • How will your request impact them?
  • What kind of personality types are involved?

​

​

This will influence your document’s (or presentation’s) organization, level, tone, appeal, etc.

​

​

12 of 33

APPEALS: Three main types

  • The Appeal to Reason
  • The Appeal to Emotion
  • The Appeal to Ethics

​

​

They’re used in different situations.

13 of 33

In technical areas, two of these appeals predominate:

​

  • Appeal to Reason – typically for the most “direct” issue at hand; reasons why the money, action, belief, etc. would logically lead to a desirable outcome…

​

  • Appeal to Ethics – usually as a limitation on what you can do in pursuit of other goals, but sometimes even a goal in itself!

​

  • The arguments about climate change are often political, not technical, not scientific

14 of 33

Other distinctions in argument

  • Argument of “Fact”
    • This is about what is or is not.
    • Example: “Global warming will cause consequence X by year Y, with a statistical likelihood of Z%.”

​

  • Argument of Policy
    • This is about what should or should not be.
    • Example: “A Z% chance of consequence X is sufficient grounds to take action A, but not necessarily action B.”

15 of 33

Relationship between arguments of fact and arguments of policy

  • Knowledge base needs to be established before you discuss policy.

​

  • Arguments of “fact,” what we know and don’t know, often precede arguments of policy.

​

  • You need to carefully parse the distinction between them, especially where they tend to get conflated.

​

  • Both need support, but in different ways.

16 of 33

A note on policy arguments:

While policy arguments may be motivated by ethics or morality, it is more likely for such arguments to succeed if they emphasize expediency, advantage, or other self-interested motives of the audience.

​

It’s not a perfect world, and we don’t get very far by pretending it is…

17 of 33

Common Logical Fallacies

  • Confirmation Bias
    • searching for and interpreting information in a way that supports pre-existing beliefs
  • False cause
  • Hasty generalization
  • Irrelevant appeal
  • Non sequitur
  • Circular reasoning
  • Undistributed middle
  • Equivocation

18 of 33

False cause

  • Presuming that correlation implies causation
  • Often arises in cases where there is a temporal proximity (“post hoc”), e.g. “X follows Y a lot, so Y must cause X”
  • Can overlap w/ fallacies involving hasty generalization of insufficient data
  • Generally only a prospective study can conclusively indicate causation

19 of 33

Hasty generalization

  • Essentially, insufficient data
    • Quantitatively (n value) and/or qualitatively (e.g. not accounting for all appropriate confounding variables)
  • Often overlaps with false/premature causation assertions
  • Unlike many other fallacies, this one can be a matter of degree and thus not always as logically objective

20 of 33

Irrelevant appeal

  • Invoking true facts or knowledge that superficially appear to bolster a point, but are actually inapt
  • Commonly occurs with credentials, e.g. appealing to an expert in one scientific discipline as a purported authority for a contention in a substantially different one
  • Can come in degrees, such as overstating the value of an authority

​

21 of 33

Non sequitur

  • Similar to irrelevant appeal, except making no effort to “simulate” relevance even superficially
  • Commonly involves seeking to distract from an unfounded assertion via emotion, such as humor or fear or affection
  • “Jane is a good and honest person, so she must be a very good employee”

22 of 33

Some possible conversations

  • To support an evidence-based decision
  • To convince someone that you excel at the art of argument or rhetoric
  • To convince someone to vote for or support your position
  • To create doubt
  • To do damage or create conflict

23 of 33

Misinformation and Disinformation:

  • Misinformation and disinformation are false information.
    • Disinformation is usually viewed as having intent to deceive.
    • Misinformation is false and usually propagated without intent to deceive – sometimes in ignorance, sometimes for fun
    • They are both part of “fake news” and the culture of social networks. 
  • Propaganda - information, especially of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote or publicize a particular political cause or point of view

24 of 33

Corrections of Facts and Knowledge

  • When Corrections Fail: Nyhan & Reifler, 2010
    • “Results indicate that corrections frequently fail to reduce misperceptions among the targeted ideological group. We also document several instances of a ‘‘backfire effect’’ in which corrections actually increase misperceptions among the group in question.”

​

25 of 33

Inoculation

  • How to Counter Alternative Facts
  • Neutralizing misinformation through inoculation: Exposing misleading argumentation techniques reduces their influence Cook et al., PloS One, 2017.
    • “We found that inoculating messages that (1) explain the flawed argumentation technique used in the misinformation or that (2) highlight the scientific consensus on climate change were effective in neutralizing those adverse effects of misinformation.”

​

26 of 33

Why Form of Argument Important in Climate and Communication

  • Realize the purpose of the person with whom you are engaged
    • Point it out
  • Realize what tactic of arguments are being used
    • Point it out
  • Avoid the emotional bait and response
    • Don’t make it personal
  • Focus your comments on the audience listening to you, not the person with whom you arguing
  • Challenge the form or argument.
    • Think scientific method first
    • Not “facts,” knowledge + uncertainty

27 of 33

Communication: Rhetoric and Form of Argument

  • Forms of Rhetoric and Argument
  • Argumentation
  • Communication

28 of 33

29 of 33

Supplemental Material

30 of 33

Circular reasoning

  • Also called “begging the question”
  • Presuming one’s conclusion, A => A
  • Gives the illusion of a deductive step
  • Ex. “John is lazy, because he doesn’t work hard.”
  • Often hides in the form of re-stating assertions with largely synonymous phrasing, disguised as support
  • Also hides behind rhetorical queries

31 of 33

Undistributed middle

  • A basic fallacy of set theory – presuming that because there is overlap, that there is no non-overlap
  • “All iPods are portable electronic devices, and all smartphones are portable electronic devices, therefore all iPods are smartphones.”
  • Related to fallacies of presumptions of mutual inclusivity/exclusivity

32 of 33

Equivocation

  • Using a word in 2 different senses/meanings in the same context, hoping the audience won’t notice the “mirror trick”
  • Of course, as with most fallacies, some are easier to spot than others
  • “Noisy children are a headache. Aspirin makes headaches go away. Therefore, aspirin makes noisy children go away.”

(http://dict.space.4goo.net/dict?q=equivocation)

​

33 of 33

Some References

​

​

  • Skeptical Science

​

​

  • Watts Up With That?

​