COVID-19 Trends: �Looking Past First-Order Effects
by Steph Smith
Minimal Solution
1
Disclaimer
Minimal Solution
2
One month ago, these
concepts meant nothing...
And these change quickly. We were focused on flattening the curve. Now that it’s ~flattened, the conversation evolves. This will continue for months.
Minimal Solution
3
A quick recap of how we found ourselves here
“Exponential curves can be gradual until they aren’t. They come at you fast. They drown you. And they keep going and going. Until they don’t. But when is that?” - Azeem Azhar
“Every Western institution was unprepared for the coronavirus pandemic, despite many prior warnings” - Marc Andreessen
Minimal Solution
4
These are unprecedented times
Minimal Solution
5
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) indicates world will “very likely” experience the worst recession since the 1930s, already receiving "an unprecedented number of calls for emergency funding."
Out of its 189 members, more than 90 of them have asked for financial support. The latest forecasts from the IMF suggest the following 2020 economic contractions:
US: -5.9%
Europe: -7.5%
Our “new” world
Minimal Solution
6
But still so many questions/unknowns ...
Minimal Solution
7
These uncertainties will determine the shape of recovery
Minimal Solution
8
And the recovery will not depend only on “us”
Minimal Solution
9
Economic Indicators
Minimal Solution
10
Banks, landlords, and other creditors are giving longer grace periods to individuals and businesses. Almost ⅓ of US apartment renters didn’t pay April rent (Source: National Multifamily Housing Council)
There’s a lot going on. First, the “good”:
Unprecedented stimulus
Federal relief was swift and massive: The U.S.’ $4.3 trillion of monetary and fiscal stimulus = 124% of government revenue in 2019. And more is coming.
Loans classified as “grace”
Minimal Solution
11
Now, the “not so good”:
Federal debt at historic highs
Oil prices plummeting
Minimal Solution
12
More “not so good”: Industrial Production
Industrial production (-5.4%) and manufacturing output (-6.3%) saw their largest declines in March, since 1946. All market groups declined, led be motor vehicle output (-28%).
Minimal Solution
13
Consumer confidence is nearing Great Recession levels.
More: Housing Starts and Consumer Confidence
US housing starts dipped by 22.3% in March, the largest decline since 1984.
Minimal Solution
14
And, more...retail sales are down 8.7%. The previous record was -3.8% in November 2008.
Minimal Solution
15
A few more data points ...
Minimal Solution
16
Important: this likely won’t be short-term
Minimal Solution
17
Minimal Solution
18
In answering these questions, you’ll likely be guided to the perhaps obvious conclusion that the world will likely not rebound in immediate fashion, regardless of what businesses are “open.” Until a vaccine or herd immunity is achieved, we find ourselves in a complicated world.
Questions to ask yourself
Minimal Solution
19
The economic “circle of life”
Suppliers
Manufacturers
Businesses
Consumers
Landlords
Mortgages
Banks
Helps to finance the rest of the circle
The COVID pandemic has already hit all “rounds” to some degree.
Minimal Solution
20
Even then, not all industries are hit equally. For some, it’s an “ice age”.
Minimal Solution
21
Very few industries are being hit positively...
Minimal Solution
22
Second-, third-, fourth-order effects
Minimal Solution
23
As demand for their products slows, hardware and software companies cannot invest the same $ into R&D. Layoffs begin.
Movie theaters
Pre-production, post-production, marketing, etc.
Equipment companies
Hardware and software companies
Actors, producers, directors, lighting experts, set scouts, etc.
The “story” behind movie theaters and live TV...
Theaters are completely closed. -100% in revenue. Companies will try to sell their entertainment online. Inexperienced companies will largely fail at this.
Some market share will go to online entertainment. Some of that revenue will disappear entirely.
People directly associated with producing movies will be impacted, as the box office loses money and has less to spend downstream.
People indirectly associated with movie success will be impacted, including computer graphics experts, PR teams, etc.
Individuals farther up the chain won’t have the same cash flow to upgrade equipment. Think processors, animation software, etc. These companies are now losing $.
Minimal Solution
24
“The virus shock does not discriminate across sectors as we initially thought,” Oxford's Gregory Daco told the WSJ.
Minimal Solution
25
Different industries will recover along different timelines...
Minimal Solution
26
The same trickle-down behavior is true within organizations.
“Must haves” end up replacing “nice to haves.”
Directly related to closures
Internal Growth, R&D
Consumer facing roles
Everything else
External Growth/
Marketing
Any positions which become obsolete with closures are the first to go.
Any positions related to previous growth projections that are unsustainable in the current environment will go next.
Any positions related to scaling the team (like recruiting, people ops, etc.) will need to be scaled back. R&D will be lumped into that equation.
With less consumer demand, consumer-facing roles like support and enterprise sales will join the pack.
As R&D is reduced, product and tech teams eventually will be hit, too. Nothing will be “untouched” in an industry or organization.
Bonus: See this layoffs tracker
Minimal Solution
27
SMB hours and wages lost add up quickly
Minimal Solution
28
Layoffs by industry
Minimal Solution
29
Layoffs already hitting at historic highs,
nearing Great Depression levels
Minimal Solution
30
“To get more specific, nearly 50% of jobs in this country are with small businesses. Many are not operating, and have less than 30 days of a cash buffer.” - Bill Trenchard
Under these economic conditions, SMBs are more vulnerable
Minimal Solution
31
For every day that the pandemic continues, companies will go out of business and individuals will default on their loans.
The individual American is also at risk
Minimal Solution
32
The dynamics are also very complex.
No one is 100% a winner. Examples:
Minimal Solution
33
Venture Capital is slowing with the rest
Minimal Solution
34
What is getting funding?
Minimal Solution
35
What if you’re not these industries?
Minimal Solution
36
Additional Tips
Minimal Solution
37
Some of the best companies in history have been started during a recession.
Or, start a new business.
Minimal Solution
38
Changing Behaviors
“Most of us can remember who we were 10 years ago, but we find it hard to imagine who we’re going to be, and then we mistakenly think that because it’s hard to imagine, it’s not likely to happen.”
Minimal Solution
39
Changing perceptions….
Unprecedented times lead to people questioning the norm. In this case, it’s forced people to look past tradition.
Examples of where this is true:
Minimal Solution
40
People have even taken their health into their own hands
Minimal Solution
41
Summary: What are people searching for?
Minimal Solution
42
Niche companies where sales are booming �(from our Trends community)
Minimal Solution
43
Will all of these last? No.
Minimal Solution
44
This experiment has forced us to try things
Minimal Solution
45
Things already trending
Minimal Solution
46
Skyrockets
Assessing longevity
Trending up pre-COVID
Trending down or flat pre-COVID
Solves problem during COVID
Doesn’t solve problem during COVID
Ice age
Skyrockets
Dies
Skyrockets
Trending up pre-COVID
Trending down or flat pre-COVID
Solves problem during COVID
Doesn’t solve problem during COVID
Recovery, if survives
Dies
Dies
During COVID
Post-COVID
Assessing business viability during COVID is just as important as assessing its viability post-COVID. We have clues to post-COVID behavior based on pre-COVID behavior. Notice that a company that was dying pre-COVID may have a spike during the pandemic, but unless something fundamentally shifts, it will likely die later. Another important company phenotype: That which struggles during COVID due to restrictions could thrive if it survives this uncertain time. There is an important caveat with the framework above in both scenarios….
Minimal Solution
47
A new world
And of course, with a new world, there must be completely new companies solving completely new problems! (Or problems that existed before, but the friction:cost relationship was less desirable)
We know a lot of wealth will be destroyed, but a lot will also be created. In some cases, there is reason to believe that the world has fundamentally shifted (i.e., things that weren’t as important before now are). Examples:
Meanwhile, there is little reason to believe that the amount of online users will slow (it’s accelerating due to COVID).
Minimal Solution
48
Here are some search terms that have surged during the pandemic. In my view, only one will remain as relevant post-COVID. Can you guess which one it is?
Some of the queries above have to do with broken supply chains (leading to DIY) which will be fixed, spending an inordinate amount of time at home, or trying to fill time. One of them stands out as something that people are focusing on now that will become embedded in their future behavior: getting a better night’s rest. (PS: Trends wrote a great sleep report here).
Example Exercise
Minimal Solution
49
Stackline compiled the list of the fastest growing and declining categories in eCommerce. Take a minute to consider whether these trends will likely be long-term or short-term, based on the framework on the previous slide.
Minimal Solution
50
Other trends to get the “wheels spinning”
Minimal Solution
51
Final prediction: Tech wins. Monopolies rule.
Minimal Solution
52
“Part of the problem is clearly foresight, a failure of imagination. But the other part of the problem is what we didn’t *do* in advance, and what we’re failing to do now. And that is a failure of action, and specifically our widespread inability to *build*.” - Marc Andreessen
“Will we learn and adapt? We have an opportunity to take something that kills .1% of us and have it make 99.9% of us stronger. Don’t waste it. A virus that kills millions, but serves as a wake-up call for billions? Is COVID-19 a vaccine?”
As Andreessen says, we get out of this by building
Minimal Solution
53
Some thought-provoking questions to ask
“Every step of the way, to everyone around us, we should be asking the question, what are you building? What are you building directly, or helping other people to build, or teaching other people to build, or taking care of people who are building? If the work you’re doing isn’t either leading to something being built or taking care of people directly, we’ve failed you, and we need to get you into a position, an occupation, a career where you can contribute to building.” - Marc Andreessen
Minimal Solution
54
Now some additional questions to ask society...
Policy
Economics
Specific Industries
Minimal Solution
55
Resources: Virus-related. Full list available here
Minimal Solution
56
Resources: Tracking/Data - Full list available here
Minimal Solution
57
Resources for SMBs and individuals - Full list available here
Minimal Solution
58
Recommended Reading/Listening
Read
Listen
Minimal Solution
59
Appendix
Minimal Solution
60
Potential Scenarios
Minimal Solution
61
Potential Scenarios
Minimal Solution
62
Additional Data Points: Relationship with the “Markets”
Minimal Solution
63
Additional Data Points
Minimal Solution
64
Jobs → Gig Economy
Minimal Solution
65
Worldwide Scope
Minimal Solution
66
Digital Transformation Accelerating
Minimal Solution
67