1 of 17

Cumulative advantage, training and application of OS/RRI in policies, principles and practices within academia

​

David Pride, Thomas Klebel, Nancy Pontika, Matteo Cancellieri, Bikash Gyawali, Antonia Correia, Stefan Reichmann, Hannah Metzler, Helene Brinken, Pedro Príncipe, Ilaria Fava, Anja Rainer, Tony Ross-Hellauer, Petr Knoth

​

​

22. March 2022

#onmerritfinale

​

@onmerrit

www.on-merrit.eu

2 of 17

Research objectives

​

​

Task 1: Examining cumulative advantage in Open Science and RRI within academia

​

Task 2: Investigating the uptake of Open Science and RRI in policy and training

​

Task 3: Investigating institutional structures of reward and recognition in Open Science & RRI

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

3 of 17

Task 1: Cumulative Advantage in Open Science and RRI

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

OA production and consumption

OA Publishing and the academic hierarchy

​

Institutional performance and RRI / OA

​

Zero Hunger | Good Health | Climate Action

​

4 of 17

Task 1: Results 1/2

  • Medium-strong correlations between OA production and OA consumption
  • Higher ranked institutes both produce and consume more OA
  • Little overall correlation with GDP per capita.
  • Strong correlation between public engagement and RRI policy at national level

​

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

5 of 17

Task 1: Results 1/2

  • Medium-strong correlations between OA production and OA consumption
  • Higher ranked institutes both produce and consume more OA
  • Little overall correlation with GDP per capita.
  • Strong correlation between public engagement and RRI policy at national level

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

6 of 17

Task 1: Results 1/2

  • Medium-strong correlations between OA production and OA consumption
  • Higher ranked institutes both produce and consume more OA
  • Little overall correlation with GDP per capita.
  • Strong correlation between public engagement and RRI policy at national level

​

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

7 of 17

Task 1: Results 1/2

  • Medium-strong correlations between OA production and OA consumption
  • Higher ranked institutes both produce and consume more OA
  • Little overall correlation with GDP per capita.
  • Strong correlation between public engagement and RRI policy at national level

​

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

8 of 17

Task 1: Results 2/2

  • Upwards trend in female authorship
  • Higher % of female authors in OA (compared to non-OA)
  • Higher ranked institutes publish more OA

​

​

​

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

9 of 17

Task 1: Results 2/2

  • Upwards trend in female authorship
  • Higher % of female authors in OA (compared to non-OA)
  • Higher ranked institutes publish more OA

​

​

​

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

10 of 17

Task 1: Results 2/2

  • Upwards trend in female authorship
  • Higher % of female authors in OA (compared to non-OA)
  • Higher ranked institutes publish more OA

​

​

​

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

11 of 17

Task 2: Uptake of OS/RRI in training

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

  • Survey of 167 active researchers in 9 countries
  • Interviews with 11 institutions

12 of 17

Task 2: Results

​

  • Surprisingly low uptake of training opportunities
  • Lack of training staff / resources (not seen as a priority)
  • Need to incentivise OS/RRI practices

​

​

​

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

How many training events have you participated in?

13 of 17

Task 3: Investigating Institutional Structures of Reward & Recognition in Open Science & RRI

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

  • Systematic analysis of institutional Promotion, Review and Tenure policies (PRT)
    • 143 institutional policies analysed
    • 107 institutions
    • 7 countries (Austria, Brazil, Germany, India, Portugal, UK and US)
  • Survey of 200 active researchers

​

14 of 17

Task 3: Results from policy analysis

​

  • Use of OS / RRI Indicators remains rare in PRT policies
  • Traditional / Quantitative measures still dominate

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

Overall prevalence of indicators across all institutions/countries.

​

15 of 17

Task 3: Survey results

​

  • Differences in institutional / personal values

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

#onmerritfinale

22.03.2022

16 of 17

Contributions

  • Well-resourced / high-ranked institutes more likely to benefit from OA
  • Training gaps - Institutes still not training in OS / RRI
  • While researchers value practicing OS/RRI, these practices are not yet sufficiently embedded in institutional reward structures.

17 of 17

Thank you for your attention!

www.on-merrit.eu

The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme, under Grant Agreement no 824612.

@onmerrit