1 of 43

Transforming Education through CBE and CTE

tinyurl.com/2zwt88hr

2 of 43

Meet the Presenters:

  • Michelle Barry
    • Director of IGNITE Pathways, Woodbine, IA
    • mbarry@ignite-pathways.com
  • Andrea Stewart
    • Student Engagement Consultant at MBAEA and Director of The Center
    • astewart@mbaea.org

3 of 43

Session Objectives:

As a result of this session, participants will:

  1. Describe the value of aligning learning to business, industry, and community needs
  2. Describe how competency-based education (CBE) blends with CTE, core academic credits, and Iowa’s Universal Constructs

4 of 43

Woodbine, Iowa

~45 minutes NE of Council Bluffs

Woodbine, Iowa population = 1,500

PreK-12 school system 475 students

5 of 43

6 of 43

Infrastructure: IGNITE Pathways ~ Woodbine, Iowa

  • Vision Statement: Empower future ready leaders.
  • Mission Statement: Transform educational experiences through business collaboration and involved learning.
  • Education Model: Students can earn core credits (English, Math, Science, and Social Studies) through CTE experiences.
    • 2021-22 - Served 60 students in 11-12th grades
    • 2022-23 - Will serve 120+ students in 9-12th grades
    • 2023-24 - Will serve students in 7-12th grades

7 of 43

Scope of Design

Infrastructure

  • Design team
  • Vision, goals, collective commitments, strategies
  • Professional learning structures and supports

Communication & Coordination

  • Rational
  • Policies, procedures, processes
  • Feedback loops

Learning Design

  • Learner competencies and standards
  • Learner pathways and supports

Data-Based Decision-Making

  • Assessment of, as, and for learning
  • Grading, credit, and progress
  • Evaluation and data collection

8 of 43

Scope of Design

Elbow partners:

  • Review categories, potential artifacts that are created during implementation, and guiding questions for Year 1
  • Identify areas that are already underway in your context and note what you might like to learn more about

9 of 43

Infrastructure & Learning and Design

  • CTE programs of study - business/industry needs
  • Core competencies (11th/12th grade)
  • Integrated Universal Constructs
  • Established overarching competencies
    • Communicator, Critical Thinker, Collaborator, Creator

10 of 43

11 of 43

12 of 43

What is CBE?

13 of 43

CBE Design and Implementation Timeline

Benchmark 1

Not Started

Benchmark 2

Making Progress

Benchmark 3

Getting Feedback

Benchmark 4

Plan Drafted

14 of 43

Data-Based Decision-Making: Iowa Code

Within competency-based pathways, a unit of credit in grades 9-12 “requires the demonstration of proficiency of formal competencies associated with the course according to the State Guidelines for Competency-Based Education or its successor organization or it is an equated requirement as a part of an innovative program filed as prescribed in rule 281— 12.9(256)” (p. 59).

K-8 is locally determined” (p. 59), so K-8 schools may also advance students based on proficiency rather than based on seat time.

(Iowa Department of Education (2015) Code, 281—IAC 12.5(14))

15 of 43

Data-Based Decision-Making: CBE Principles

Collaborative schools used local design processes to determine which of the following CBE Principles were part of their plan for improving teaching and learning over the course of the Collaborative:

  1. Students advance upon demonstrated proficiency. MASTERY LEARNING
  2. Students’ demonstration of competencies requires transfer of knowledge across content areas and/or beyond the classroom. DEEPER LEARNING
  3. Students engage in assessment as a meaningful and positive learning experience. (Schools embrace a strong emphasis on formative assessment as learning becomes focused on standards and competencies.) AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT
  4. Students receive rapid, personalized support based on individual learning needs. PERSONALIZED SUPPORTS
  5. Students’ learning is validated regardless of when, where or how they acquire and/or demonstrate the learning. ANYTIME/ANYWHERE LEARNING

16 of 43

Traditional System

Seat time

Hours of instruction

in the school day

CBE System

Proficiency with

course competencies and standards

Anytime/anywhere learning

Carnegie Unit

Competency Demonstration

17 of 43

Communication and Coordination

18 of 43

19 of 43

20 of 43

Pause and Reflect: What do you wonder and what might you add to the implementation planning document?

21 of 43

IGNITE Pathway’s CBE/CTE Implementation

22 of 43

Infrastructure

  • Establish your team
  • Determine vision and goals
  • Be strategic
  • Invest in Professional Learning

23 of 43

Infrastructure: Professional Learning

24 of 43

CTE Pathways

Aviation

Agriculture

Information Technology

Early Childhood Education

Construction and HVAC

Health Sciences

Social Media/Marketing

Welding and Automotive

Core Credits through CBE

English 9, 10, 11, and 12

Applied Mathematics

Unified Science

World History

Sociology

Economics

Government

American History

Programs of Study/Academic Courses

25 of 43

Learning and Design

  • Personalized, authentic learning
  • Instructional strategies
    • Universal Design for Learning (UDL)
    • Specially Designed Instruction (SDI)
  • Self-directed learning modules + micro-teaching (Headrush)
  • Competencies with embedded essential standards
  • Universal Constructs:
    • Communication
    • Critical Thinking
    • Collaboration
    • Creativity

26 of 43

Competencies as Drivers of Learning

CBE Journey ~ January 2020

27 of 43

Canopy (Competency)

Ribs (Standards)

Handle (Transfer)

RI.11-12.1

W.11-12.3

Explore complex information and ideas while influencing thoughts and actions affecting outcomes to improve a system that will positively impact society.

What learners will do

How they will do it

Why it matters

High School English Competency

Learning can be used where and when it is necessary

W.11-12.8

W.11-12.2

Competency

28 of 43

Example of English Competency and Universal Constructs

English 11: Explore complex information and ideas while influencing thoughts and actions affecting outcomes to improve a system that will positively impact society.

What the students will do…

How will students do this…

Why are these important…

W1: Craft a message based on an awareness of relevant knowledge of a topic. W.11-12.3 Creativity

H1: Create a visual element using relevant information from multiple sources. RI.11-12.1 W.11-12.8 Creativity - Productivity/Accountability

Y1: Develop or improve a new or existing system or process.

Creativity - Critical Thinking

W2: Utilize iterative process of design and revision.

Critical Thinking

H2: Select and integrate various communication processes/technologies.

Critical Thinking

Y2: Compose an argument to a claim that examines and conveys complex ideas. W.11-12.2 Creativity - Critical Thinking

W3: Incorporate technology to manage and maximize impact of the exchanging of ideas. Communication - Creativity

H3: Utilize different communication modes using written and spoken or visual. W.11-12.3 SL.11-12.1

Communication

Y3: Present information to stakeholders that are interested in the topic. Communication - Collaboration

W4: Interact with people of different cultures and/or backgrounds. Collaboration

H4: Understand others’ perspectives and views affecting various outcomes.

Communication - Critical Thinking

Y4: Negotiate ideas that generate mutually satisfactory solutions. SL.11-12.1

Communication - Collaboration

Critical Thinking Flexibility/Adaptability

29 of 43

CBE: Core Curriculum and Universal Constructs

Communicator Competency

English: Exchange complex information by using visual, verbal, and written modes to contribute to a larger purpose.

Performance Descriptors

W1: Craft a message based on an awareness of relevant knowledge of a topic. W.11-12.3 Creativity

W2: Utilize iterative process of design and revision. Critical Thinking

W3: Incorporate technology to manage and maximize impact of the exchanging of ideas. Communication and Creativity

W4: Interact with people of different cultures and/or backgrounds. Collaboration

30 of 43

What is CBE in Iowa?

1. Students advance upon demonstrated proficiency.

2. Students’ demonstration of competencies requires transfer of knowledge across content areas and/or beyond the classroom.

3. Students engage in assessment as a meaningful and positive learning experience.

4. Students receive rapid, personalized support based on their individual learning needs.

5. Students’ learning is validated regardless of when, where or how they acquire and/or demonstrate the learning.

31 of 43

Learning and Design

  • Cross-Curricular Credits
    • Collaboration between core teachers and CTE instructors
    • Identify connections between CTE standards and core competencies
    • Goal - capture learning as CTE/cores connect in authentic experiences

32 of 43

CTE: Human Services - Education and Training

Early Childhood

CTE: 13.5 Demonstrate professional practices and standards related to working with children, youth and adults, including diverse populations.

Performance Tasks

  • Explore diversity of children and partnerships with families.
  • Discuss plan/strategies to implement practice to accomplish diversity/family relations.
  • Incorporate technology tools that support meeting diversity/family relations.
  • Collaborate with teachers to understand students’ cultural needs and/or backgrounds/interests.

33 of 43

Personalized Learning Plans - Blue

Communicator Competency

English: Exchange complex information by using visual, verbal, and written modes to contribute to a larger purpose.

Early Childhood

CTE: 13.5 Demonstrate professional practices and standards related to working with children, youth and adults, including diverse populations

Welding

CTE: WLD7. Students understand various automated welding systems, welding design for manufacturing, flexible manufacturing systems and materials resource planning

Animal Science

CTE: AS.02.01.01.a. Explain the implications of animal welfare and animal rights for animal systems.

Performance Descriptors

Performance Tasks

Performance Tasks

Performance Tasks

W1: Craft a message based on an awareness of relevant knowledge of a topic. W.11-12.3 Creativity

  • Explore diversity of children and partnerships with families.
  • Discuss plan/strategies to implement practice to accomplish diversity/family relations.
  • Incorporate technology tools that support meeting diversity/family relations.
  • Collaborate with teachers to understand students’ cultural needs and/or backgrounds/interests.
  • Explore how welding is an essential component to many industries.
  • Discuss plan/strategies to inform a chosen industry on the impact welding makes in the profession.
  • Incorporate technology as you prepare to share findings with industry partners.
  • Collaborate with industry professionals to discuss the impact of welding in the field.
  • Explore current issues surrounding the treatment of farm animals.
  • Discuss plan/strategies to craft the message about farm animals.
  • Incorporate technology to enhance the message of animal treatment.
  • Collaborate with industry partners to share findings and brainstorm ways to improve the treatment of farm animals.

W2: Utilize iterative process of design and revision. Critical Thinking

W3: Incorporate technology to manage and maximize impact of the exchanging of ideas. Communication and Creativity

W4: Interact with people of different cultures and/or backgrounds. Collaboration

34 of 43

Personalized Learning Plans

Communicator Competency

English: Exchange complex information by using visual, verbal, and written modes to contribute to a larger purpose.

Early Childhood

CTE: 13.5 Demonstrate professional practices and standards related to working with children, youth and adults, including diverse populations

Welding

CTE: WLD7. Students understand various automated welding systems, welding design for manufacturing, flexible manufacturing systems and materials resource planning

Animal Science

CTE: AS.02.01.01.a. Explain the implications of animal welfare and animal rights for animal systems.

Performance Descriptors

Performance Tasks

Performance Tasks

Performance Tasks

W1: Craft a message based on an awareness of relevant knowledge of a topic. W.11-12.3 Creativity

  • Explore diversity of children and partnerships with families.
  • Discuss plan/strategies to implement practice to accomplish diversity/family relations.
  • Incorporate technology tools that support meeting diversity/family relations.
  • Collaborate with teachers to understand students’ cultural needs and/or backgrounds/interests.
  • Explore how welding is an essential component to many industries.
  • Discuss plan/strategies to inform a chosen industry on the impact welding makes in the profession.
  • Incorporate technology as you prepare to share findings with industry partners.
  • Collaborate with industry professionals to discuss the impact of welding in the field.
  • Explore current issues surrounding the treatment of farm animals.
  • Discuss plan/strategies to craft the message about farm animals.
  • Incorporate technology to enhance the message of animal treatment.
  • Collaborate with industry partners to share findings and brainstorm ways to improve the treatment of farm animals.

W2: Utilize iterative process of design and revision. Critical Thinking

W3: Incorporate technology to manage and maximize impact of the exchanging of ideas. Communication and Creativity

W4: Interact with people of different cultures and/or backgrounds. Collaboration

35 of 43

Personalized Learning Plans - Green

Creator Competency

Science: Show relationships between systems and their components by developing, revising, and/or using a model to predict and influence future outcomes of similar networks.

HVAC/R

CTE: CON6.2 Understand the processes and materials (e.g., structural, electrical, mechanical, finish) appropriate to the architectural design and residential construction.

PC Support (IT)

CTE: IT 2.7.1 Understand the integration of a computer system within other devices and discuss how they work together

Aviation

CTE: IND1. Students will examine how engineering and technology helps improve, manage and control natural and engineered environments.

Performance Descriptors

Performance Tasks

Performance Tasks

Performance Tasks

W1: Identify known systems and the purpose of each system. HS-ETS1-3

Critical Thinking

  • Possible systems: Geothermal, air conditioning, radiant heat, heat pump, refrigeration
  • Choose one of the above systems and identify components in the system.
  • Describe how the components work together to make the system function.
  • Explain how the system improves a heating/cooling process in a residential home and how the system operates.
  • PC system
  • Components: Input, output, power source, motherboard
  • Describe how the components work together to make the system function.
  • Explain how the system works together to create the standard PC user experience.
  • Possible systems: Engine, propeller, ignition systems, landing gear, and others
  • Choose one of the above systems and identify components in the system.
  • Describe how the components work together to make the system function.
  • Explain how the system works to safely fly the aircraft.

W2: Describe one system and identify the components in the system. Communication - Critical Thinking

W3: Show relationships between system components. Creativity - Critical Thinking

W4: Explain the significance of the system and how it works. Communication - Critical Thinking

36 of 43

Personalized Learning Plans

Creator Competency

Science: Show relationships between systems and their components by developing, revising, and/or using a model to predict and influence future outcomes of similar networks.

HVAC/R

CTE: CON6.2 Understand the processes and materials (e.g., structural, electrical, mechanical, finish) appropriate to the architectural design and residential construction.

PC Support (IT)

CTE: IT 2.7.1 Understand the integration of a computer system within other devices and discuss how they work together

Aviation

CTE: IND1. Students will examine how engineering and technology helps improve, manage and control natural and engineered environments.

Performance Descriptors

Performance Tasks

Performance Tasks

Performance Tasks

W1: Identify known systems and the purpose of each system. HS-ETS1-3

Critical Thinking

  • Possible systems: Geothermal, air conditioning, radiant heat, heat pump, refrigeration
  • Choose one of the above systems and identify components in the system.
  • Describe how the components work together to make the system function.
  • Explain how the system improves a heating/cooling process in a residential home and how the system operates.
  • PC system
  • Components: Input, output, power source, motherboard
  • Describe how the components work together to make the system function.
  • Explain how the system works together to create the standard PC user experience.
  • Possible systems: Engine, propeller, ignition systems, landing gear, and others
  • Choose one of the above systems and identify components in the system.
  • Describe how the components work together to make the system function.
  • Explain how the system works to safely fly the aircraft.

W2: Describe one system and identify the components in the system. Communication - Critical Thinking

W3: Show relationships between system components. Creativity - Critical Thinking

W4: Explain the significance of the system and how it works. Communication - Critical Thinking

37 of 43

Learning and Design

  • Overarching competencies
    • Communicator - Exchange complex information and ideas through justifiable modes to effectively meet the needs of diverse individuals/groups.
    • Critical Thinker - Create solutions to complex problems through inquiry and investigations to influence internal and/or external conditions.
    • Collaborator - Negotiate in a respectful team process by contributing personal capacity to share ownership of outcomes that are larger than the individual.
    • Creator - Generate ideas by reconfiguring current thinking or by connecting seemingly unrelated ideas for an aesthetic or practical purpose.

38 of 43

Example Competencies

Course

Communicator

Critical Thinker

Collaborator

Creator

English 9

Exchange complex information by using visual, verbal, and written modes to contribute to a larger purpose.

Examine solutions to a problem by comparing and contrasting possible outcomes to determine the impact on society.

Produce a response to a current issue by analyzing perspectives of others to interpret how outcomes are larger than an individual.

Analyze the interconnectedness of multiple viewpoints across media by participating as a critical consumer to show that systems thinking improves decision-making.

English 10

Maximize the exchange of ideas by utilizing interdependency and networking to refine knowledge and delivery with feedback loops.

Anticipate the intended and unintended consequences of actions (or inactions) by mapping cause/effect relationships to trace potentially unforeseen short- and long-term impacts.

Make a case that challenging assumptions/perceptions lead to change by using evidence from selected time periods, cultures, or worldviews to show how people are influenced to cultivate wisdom or take action.

Formulate a course of action with a sequence of steps by generating a vision and facilitating thoughtful planning to produce a cohesive effort toward a goal.

    • Communicator - Exchange complex information and ideas through justifiable modes to effectively meet the needs of diverse individuals/groups.

39 of 43

How do we measure progress?

40 of 43

Data-Based Decision Making (2021-22)

  • Focus on which data impact vision and mission
  • Use data to tell a story
  • IGNITE Pathways data collection
    • Academics
    • Attendance
    • Behavior

41 of 43

Data-Based Decision Making (2022-23)

  • Academics, attendance, behavior - PowerSchool
  • Track and monitor student progress towards competencies - Headrush Learning
  • Competency progressions and progress monitoring
  • Defense of learning

42 of 43

Scope of Design

43 of 43

Questions and Next Steps

Survey for fall workshop(s)

What’s still circling in your mind?

What has helped square your thinking?

What three things will you take away?