1 of 121

TITLE IX *PLUS*�FROM 2020 REGULATIONS TO PRESENT

©FisherFirm2024

With Jodie Kennemer

2 of 121

AGENDA

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Overview

Know your Team

Navigating Complaints

Case Studies

Pregnancy & Title IX

TITLE IX

3 of 121

WHY?

  • The risks:
    • Litigation
    • TEA/OCR
    • PR / news attention

​

  • The Rights and

Requirements

    • Freedom from sexual harassment
    • Federal funding

©FisherFirm2024

4 of 121

WHY YOU?

  • The federal regulations REQUIRE basic training for all employees and more for administrators who may be designated as:
    • Title IX Coordinator
    • Investigator
    • Decision-Maker (both initial and appeals)
    • A person involved in an information resolution process
  • CONSISTENT responses across campuses
  • You are a “First Responder”

©FisherFirm2024

To learn from our collective experiences!

5 of 121

TRAINING REQUIREMENTS

All Employees

    • Training must address: 
      • Obligations to address Title IX discrimination 
      • Scope of conduct that equals Title IX discrimination
      • Definition of "sex-based" harassment 
      • Notification requirements

Investigator, Decision Maker, & Others 

    • Involved in Title IX process or with authority to modify/terminate supportive measures
    • Training must address: 
      • All prior topics
      • Individual obligations
      • Grievance process and how to serve impartially
      • "Relevant" evidence and impermissibility of certain evidence

Facilitator 

    • Training must address: 
      • All  prior topics
      • Practices regarding informal resolution process

Title IX Coordinator

    •  Training must address: 
      • All prior topics
      • Coordinator Responsibilities
      • Record keeping requirements

​

​

  • Frequency: 
    • Promptly upon hire OR transfer to a position that alters the employee's Title IX duties
    • ANNUALLY for all employees
  • Record Keeping – NO MORE website posting requirements 
    • Available for public inspection upon request

​

©FisherFirm2024

2024

6 of 121

�TITLE IX�OVERVIEW

©FisherFirm2024

7 of 121

WHAT IS TITLE IX?

  • Federal law + regulations

​

  • Title IX prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in education programs and activities that receive federal funds

©FisherFirm2024

8 of 121

THE 2020 REGS

  • Initially became effective August 14, 2020
    1. Created federal definition of “sexual harassment” of students
    2. Clarified actual knowledge
    3. Developed investigation and grievance procedures

​

©FisherFirm2024

9 of 121

NEW YEAR . . . NEW RULES . . . MAYBE?

  • Biden Administration’s changes to 2020 Regs were published in April 2024
  • Become effective per Feds on August 1, 2024
  • April 29, 2024 Letter from TX Governor to White House
    • “instructing the Texas Education Agency to ignore your illegal dictate”

​

©FisherFirm2024

10 of 121

WHAT IS �“SEX-BASED”?

Gender Identity

11 of 121

SCOPE OF SEX DISCRIMINATION

©FisherFirm2024

12 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

13 of 121

SCOPE OF SEX DISCRIMINATION

©FisherFirm2024

14 of 121

SCOPE OF SEX DISCRIMINATION

  • 2024 regulations clarify that sex discrimination on the basis of sex includes discrimination based on sex stereotypes, sex characteristics, pregnancy or related conditions, sexual orientation, and gender identity

©FisherFirm2024

§ 106.10

2024

15 of 121

16 of 121

NOTE: the Ruling was not specifically related to information published in 2024, BUT It may be expanded to apply.

17 of 121

18 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

July 8, 2024

19 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

July 8, 2024

20 of 121

WHAT ABOUT ISD POLICIES?

©FisherFirm2024

21 of 121

DEFINITIONS: SEXUAL HARASSMENT

©FisherFirm2024

34 CFR 106.30

​

Sexual harassment means conduct on the basis of sex that satisfies one or more of the following:

  1. An employee of the recipient conditioning the provision of an aid, benefit, or service of the recipient on an individual's participation in unwelcome sexual conduct;

​

(2) Unwelcome conduct determined by a reasonable person to be so severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive that it effectively denies a person equal access to the recipient's education program or activity; or

​

(3) “Sexual assault” as defined in 20 U.S.C. 1092(f)(6)(A)(v), “dating violence” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(10), “domestic violence” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(8), or “stalking” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(30).

​

22 of 121

DEFINING SEX-BASED HARASSMENT

  • 2024 regulations now require the conduct in question be “(1) unwelcome, (2) sex-based, (3) subjectively and objectively offensive, as well as (4) so severe or pervasive (5) that it results in a limitation or denial of a person’s ability to participate in or benefit from the recipient’s education program or activity”
      • 2020 Regs: severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive

§ 106.2

©FisherFirm2024

2024

23 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

(3) “Sexual assault” as defined in 20 U.S.C. 1092(f)(6)(A)(v), “dating violence” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(10), “domestic violence” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(8), or “stalking” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(30).

20 USC 1092(f)(6)(A)(v)

(v) The term ‘‘sexual assault’’ means an offense classified as a forcible or nonforcible sex offense under the uniform crime reporting system of the Federal Bureau of Investigation.

24 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

  • Sex Offenses—Any sexual act including Rape, Sodomy, Sexual Assault With An Object, or Fondling directed against another person, without the consent of the victim, including instances where the victim is incapable of giving consent; also unlawful sexual intercourse
    • Rape—(Except Statutory Rape) The carnal knowledge of a person, without the consent of the victim, including instances where the victim is incapable of giving consent because of his/her age or because of his/her temporary or permanent mental or physical incapacity
    • Sodomy—Oral or anal sexual intercourse with another person, without the consent of the victim, including instances where the victim is incapable of giving consent because of his/her age or because of his/her temporary or permanent mental or physical incapacity
    • Sexual Assault With An Object—To use an object or instrument to unlawfully penetrate, however slightly, the genital or anal opening of the body of another person, without the consent of the victim, including instances where the victim is incapable of giving consent because of his/her age or because of his/her temporary or permanent mental or physical incapacity
    • Fondling—The touching of the private body parts of another person for the purpose of sexual gratification without the consent of the victim, including instances where the victim is incapable of giving consent because of his/her age or because of his/her temporary or permanent mental or physical incapacity
    • Incest—Nonforcible sexual intercourse between persons who are related to each other within the degrees wherein marriage is prohibited by law
    • Statutory Rape—Nonforcible sexual intercourse with a person who is under the statutory age of consent

25 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

General response to sexual harassment. A recipient with actual knowledge of sexual harassment in an education program or activity of the recipient against a person in the United States, must respond promptly in a manner that is not deliberately indifferent. A recipient is deliberately indifferent only if its response to sexual harassment is clearly unreasonable in light of the known circumstances.

26 of 121

IN A PROGRAM OR ACTIVITY

  • “Program or activity and program means all of the operations of . . .A local educational agency (as defined in 20 U.S.C. 8801), system of vocational education, or other school system”
    • On campus
    • Off campus
    • Instructional
    • Extracurricular
    • Etc.

©FisherFirm2024

27 of 121

OUTSIDE OF THE UNITED STATES?

  • 2024 regulations broaden geographical scope to include some conduct alleged to be contributing to the hostile environment that occurred outside the recipient’s education program or activity or outside the United States

©FisherFirm2024

§ 106.11

Think social media, ISD senior trips, school summer travel groups,  exchange students, or college study abroad

2024

28 of 121

ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE

  • Notice of sexual harassment or allegations of sexual harassment by…
    • ANY EMPLOYEE of an elementary or secondary school
      • This could be a custodian, teacher, bus driver, etc.
  • Actual knowledge received by:
    • Direct report from complainant to ANY employee
    • Another student expressing concern
    • Any employee personally observing harassment

​

©FisherFirm2024

STAFF CANNOT IGNORE!

29 of 121

ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE

  • 2024 Regs: A recipient with knowledge of conduct that reasonably may constitute sex discrimination in its education program or activity must respond promptly and effectively

©FisherFirm2024

§ 106.44(a)(1)

2024

30 of 121

EVERYONE HAS A DUTY

  • Think of Title IX reporting duty like CPS!
  • High School:
    • Harassment (comments, jokes, touching)
    • Assault
    • Dating Violence
  • Elementary:
    • Even though the kiddos are young, if based on sex, it’s discrimination and not mere bullying

​

​

©FisherFirm2024

To report Title IX harassment!

31 of 121

KNOW YOUR �TITLE IX TEAM

©FisherFirm2024

32 of 121

REQUIRED �MEMBERS

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

33 of 121

REQUIRED �MEMBERS

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

2024 REGS ALLOW THESE ROLES TO BE THE SAME PERSON

2024 Regs

GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE § 106.45

©FisherFirm2024

34 of 121

THE TITLE IX COORDINATOR

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

35 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

THE TITLE IX COORDINATOR

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

2024 Regs

2024 REGS ALLOW THESE ROLES TO BE THE SAME PERSON

36 of 121

  • Main point of contact regarding Title IX
  • Designated on website and in handbooks
  • Can have more than one or even deputy Title IX Coordinators
  • 2020 Regs prohibit Title IX Coordinator from being Decision Maker or Appeal Officer
  • Under 2024 Regs, can be the Investigator and initial decision-maker
  • LOOK: Listed in Board Policies FFH & DIA Exhibit

©FisherFirm2024

THE TITLE IX COORDINATOR

Assistant Superintendent

37 of 121

THE INVESTIGATOR

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

38 of 121

THE INVESTIGATOR

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

2024 Regs

2024 REGS ALLOW THESE ROLES TO BE THE SAME PERSON

39 of 121

  • Can never be the Appeal Officer
  • Per 2020 Regs cannot be the Decision Maker and per 2024 Regs cannot be the Facilitator
  • Investigator’s job:
    • The Investigator has the burden to gather evidence sufficient to prove or disprove the allegation(s) within the Complaint [District’s burden]
    • Investigate the allegations
      • Interview
      • Review Documents
      • Summarize Information
  • Likely either . . .

​

©FisherFirm2024

THE INVESTIGATOR

Assistant Superintendent or Dist. Admin?

Campus Admin ?

40 of 121

THE DECISION-MAKER

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

41 of 121

THE DECISION-MAKER

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

2024 Regs

2024 REGS ALLOW THESE ROLES TO BE THE SAME PERSON

42 of 121

THE DECISION-MAKER

  • Can never be the Appeal Officer
  • Per 2020 regs, cannot be the Title IX Coordinator or Investigator, but both are allowed under 2024 Regs
  • 2024 Regs also prohibit from being the Facilitator
  • Their job:
    • Receive and answer questions re: investigative report
    • Review investigation and APPLY FACTS TO LAW
    • Prepare written determination of responsibility

​

  • Likely either . . .

​

​

©FisherFirm2024

Assistant Superintendent

Campus Admin ?

43 of 121

THE�FACILITATOR

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

44 of 121

THE�FACILITATOR

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

?

2024 Regs

45 of 121

  • Can share any dual role under 2020 Regs
  • 2024 Regs prohibit being the Investigator or Decision Maker
    • Title IX Coordinator also prohibited if other roles are shared
  • Their Job:
    • Work with both parties to reach a written resolution to the Complaint
  • Likely: Campus/District Administrator other than Asst. Supt.

​

​

©FisherFirm2024

THE FACILITATOR

46 of 121

THE �APPEAL OFFICER

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

47 of 121

THE �APPEAL OFFICER

©FisherFirm2024

Title IX Coordinator

Investigator

Decision-Maker

Appeal Officer

Informal Resolution Facilitator

2024 Regs

48 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

THE APPEAL OFFICER

  • Can never be the Title IX Coordinator, Investigator, or Decision Maker
  • Their job:
    • Evaluate appeal for proper basis (Procedural irregularities, New evidence, COIs)
    • Notify parties of appeal and rights to submit statements
    • Review and evaluate statements, investigation, and decision
      • APPLY FACTS TO LAW
    • Prepare written determination of appeal
    • Likely either . . .

​

​

Superintendent

Appointed

49 of 121

BUILDING A GREAT TEAM

  • Smart to cross train team members in all roles!
    • Can use District employees in roles or can outsource (e.g. attorney, retired administrator, etc.)
  • Do not have to pre-assign each role (other than Title IX Coordinator)
    • Can make assignments as allegation is raised (based on facts, availability, etc.)
  • Can use District employees in roles or can outsource (e.g. attorney, retired administrator, etc.)
  • Investigators, Decision-Makers, Appeal Officers, and Informal Resolution Facilitators must be:
    • Impartial
    • Free from Bias
    • Free from Conflict of Interest

​

©FisherFirm2024

50 of 121

FAIRNESS REQUIREMENTS

Investigators, Decision-Makers, Appeal Officers, and Informal Resolution Facilitators must be:

​

©FisherFirm2024

Free from Bias

Impartial

No Conflicts of Interest

What are the differences???

Consider

Perception!

51 of 121

WHAT TO AVOID

  • Family members
  • Friendships
  • Enemies
  • Business relationships
  • ________________
  • ________________

​

Examples:

  • Complainant was in a fight last year with daughter of Investigator
  • Complaint involves allegation of sexual assault; Decision-Maker’s daughter was victimized previously
  • Investigator is in same Sunday school class as Respondent’s parents
  • Respondent is nephew of Appeal Officer
  • Decision-Maker put Respondent in DAEP earlier this year

​

©FisherFirm2024

52 of 121

NAVIGATING COMPLAINTS

©FisherFirm2024

53 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

See KISD Administrative Board Policies DIA and FFH & Administrative Regs for DIA and FFH!

54 of 121

FORMAL GRIEVANCE POLICY STANDARDS

©FisherFirm2024

Equal treatment

Objective

review

Unbiased

investigations

Presumption

of innocence

Reasonably* Prompt

timelines

Discipline

options

Standard of

Evidence*

Appeal

procedures

Supportive

measures

Protect

privileges

55 of 121

BASIC TITLE IX GRIEVANCE PROCESS

©FisherFirm2024

Knowledge of inappropriate conduct that is sexual in nature

Title IX Coordinator communicates with alleged victim

Determination of supportive measures

Determination of emergency removal

Formal complaint

Initial determination of sexual harassment threshold

Notice of formal complaint (to both parties)

Investigation

Gather & Submit Evidence to

Both Parties

Parties may “meaningfully respond”

Investigative Report

Parties may submit questions, written responses

Decision-Maker responds to questions

Written Determination of Responsibility

Appeal

10 DAYS

10 DAYS

56 of 121

CHANGES TO TIMELINES

  • Establishes a reasonably prompt time frame for major stages of the grievance procedures
      • Evaluation, Investigation, Determination, Appeal
  • Requires ISD to provide parties with a description of relevant evidence and a reasonable opportunity to respond
    • Removed specified 10-day periods to review evidence
    • Removed second 10-day review period for investigative report before final determination can be issued

©FisherFirm2024

§ 106.45

2024

57 of 121

ADDITIONAL CHANGES TO �PROCESS

  • A school may offer an informal resolution process upon receipt of a sex discrimination complaint or when it has information about conduct that reasonably may constitute sex discrimination (regardless of whether a formal complaint is initiated)
  • Must offer an appeal process that is at least the same as that offered in comparable proceedings
        • i.e., Board policy FNG or DGBA

©FisherFirm2024

§ 106.44(k) and 106.45

2024

58 of 121

KNOWLEDGE OF THE ALLEGED CONDUCT

  • The process is triggered when someone receives “actual knowledge” of sexual harassment (2020)/conduct that reasonably may constitute sex discrimination(2024) in its education program or activity

©FisherFirm2024

How will you get this knowledge?

    • Direct report from a student or employee
    • Parent report/concern
    • Teacher or staff member observes concern
    • Other students?

If not received by Title IX Coordinator, must be forwarded to them ASAP!

59 of 121

INITIAL RESPONSE

  • When a report is made, the Title IX Coordinator must take action to promptly and effectively end end any sex discrimination, prevent its recurrence, and remedy its effects

©FisherFirm2024

    • Promptly contact the Complainant to:
      • Discuss supportive measures;
      • Consider the Complainant’s wishes with respect to supportive measures;
      • Inform the Complainant that supportive measures are available with or without filing a formal complaint; and
      • Explain the process for filing a formal complaint

Note: Regs don’t say “when a complaint is filed…”

60 of 121

SUPPORTIVE MEASURES

  • What used to be called “interim measures”
  • Non-punitive, individualized services, offered as appropriate and without charge to a Complainant OR Respondent before or after the filing of a formal complaint
  • Should be designed to restore or preserve equal access to educational opportunities and benefits

​

©FisherFirm2024

61 of 121

EXAMPLES OF SUPPORTIVE MEASURES

  • “Safe” space or person
  • Counseling
  • Course modifications
  • Schedule changes
  • Stay Away Agreements
  • Increased monitoring or supervision
  • Referral to outside sources or resources

©FisherFirm2024

**Completely removing a respondent from an activity would likely be considered punitive, except for “emergency removals” for students and “administrative leaves” for employees.

62 of 121

EMERGENCY REMOVALS

  • Only in severe circumstances
  • Be CAUTIOUS removing Respondent prior to a decision being made
  • If Respondent-student is SpEd, discuss with Special Education department
  • Call ISD’s attorney!

©FisherFirm2024

NOTICE�AND �HEARING

If Respondent poses “an immediate threat to the physical health or safety of any student or other individual arising from the allegations of sexual harassment”

63 of 121

EMERGENCY REMOVAL

  • 2024 Regs: require recipient to determine there is “imminent and serious threat to the health or safety of a complainant or any students, employees, or other persons arising from the allegations of sex discrimination”
    • Removes the “physical” threat requirement

©FisherFirm2024

§ 106.44(h)

2024

64 of 121

FORMAL COMPLAINT FORM

  • Form includes the following elements for a written complaint
    • Detailed description of allegations
    • Statement that victim believes he/she has experienced sexual harassment
    • Statement that victim wishes to institute formal Title IX grievance process
    • Signature/date of:
      • Victim/parent
      • Title IX Coordinator (evidencing date of receipt of grievance)

NOTE: Once Formal Complaint is filed, no assignment of student discipline until after determination is made

©FisherFirm2024

ACCESS

District’s Title IX Complaint Form ONLINE!

​

65 of 121

THRESHOLD REVIEW

  • Before moving forward with investigation, Title IX Coordinator performs “threshold review”
  • Threshold question:
  • Would the allegations, IF TRUE, meet the definition of sexual harassment under Title IX?
    • If so, did they occur at school or in a school program or activity?
      • YES – complaint investigation proceeds
  • NO – dismiss and address through SCOC or other policy

©FisherFirm2024

Consider review of:

  • Formal Title IX complaint alleges race discrimination
  • Formal Title IX complaint alleges only that 5th grade boy called another boy "wuss"
  • Formal Title IX complaint alleges that their daughter was "harassed" by a student from a neighboring school while at the mall this weekend

​

66 of 121

DISMISSAL OF COMPLAINT

Should dismiss if if conduct alleged:

- Not sexual harassment if true (after reasonable clarification attempts)

- Did not occur in the school’s program or activity

*Can still address under a non-Title IX policy

May dismiss if:

- Complainant requests to withdraw

- Respondent’s enrollment or employment ends

- Specific circumstances prevent District from gathering evidence sufficient to reach a determination (e.g., passage of time, lack of cooperation by Complainant)

- Respondent cannot be identified after reasonable attempt

©FisherFirm2024

USE Dismissal WITH CAUTION – Call your Attorney FIRST!

​

67 of 121

DISMISSAL OF COMPLAINT

  • Must notify Complainant of dismissal and basis for decision
    • AND respondent if they have been notified of complaint
  • Opportunity to appeal the dismissal if any of the following would change the outcome
    • Procedural irregularity
    • New or evidence that was not reasonably available
    • Conflict of interest of Title IX Coordinator, Investigator, or Decision Maker

​

  • Upon dismissal, must still offer supportive measures
  • Take prompt and effective remedial action to prevent continuation/recurrence of sexual harassment, as needed

​

​

©FisherFirm2024

68 of 121

NOTICE

  • Will include:
    • Names of known parties / conduct alleged with dates if available
    • Notice of grievance process, including informal resolution process
    • Statement that respondent presumed not responsible and that responsibility will be determined at conclusion of grievance process
    • Notice of parties’ rights to have an attorney or non-attorney advisor and to inspect and review evidence
    • Notice of any provision in the code of conduct that prohibits knowingly making false statements or providing false evidence during the grievance process

©FisherFirm2024

Written notice to all known parties with sufficient details and in enough time to prepare a response before any initial interview

69 of 121

NOTICE OF NEW TOPICS

©FisherFirm2024

70 of 121

INVESTIGATION

  • Burden of proof on school
  • No restriction of rights of parties to discuss allegations or gather evidence
  • Same opportunities for others present during interviews or related proceedings (e.g., attorney or non-attorney advisor)
  • Written notice to parties of date, time, participants, purpose, and location of each investigative interview with sufficient time to prepare

©FisherFirm2024

71 of 121

PLANNING THE INVESTIGATION

  • Attack like a research project; identify all factual allegations and evidence provided
  • Review allegations within the context of the definition of sexual harassment
    • Quid pro quo
    • Hostile environment
    • Specific sex offenses

​

©FisherFirm2024

What do you need to know to prove or disprove the allegations?

72 of 121

PLANNING THE INVESTIGATION

  • Create a list of background information needed for review: grades, attendance, discipline records, statements, SpEd docs
  • Create a list of needed evidence (update along the way)
  • Create a list of anticipated witnesses (update along the way)
  • Create an outline of questions for each witness (but listen and adjust as necessary)
  • *Notes may be discoverable

©FisherFirm2024

73 of 121

INTERVIEWS

Consider Order:

    • Complainant
    • Respondent
    • Witnesses (student, staff)
    • Complainant/Respondent again

©FisherFirm2024

RECORDING

  • Ensures complete capture
  • Helps you relax, focus, listen
  • Both sides can receive
  • Get consent, address consent on tape
  • Make sure it works, is audible...

74 of 121

INTERVIEW OVERVIEW

  • Consider location, space, amenities
  • Introduce yourself
  • Address advisor, parent, support person
  • Lay groundwork of the complaint
  • Explain RECORDING (after consent gained, turn on recorder; briefly summarize, including all present, date, time and purpose)
  • Start with softball questions
  • Discuss background
  • Nitty Gritty
  • Don't forget to ask IMPACT questions
  • Ask if any other evidence or witnesses they can think of or provide
  • Ask about remedy or resolution

©FisherFirm2024

1. Listen without interruption

2. Listen & interrupt with Q’s

3. Tell story back &

ask to correct

75 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

Don't let your notes/script/outline

REPLACE YOUR

BRAIN!!!

76 of 121

PREPARE THE EVIDENCE

  • Provide both parties an equal opportunity to inspect and review any evidence obtained as part of the investigation that is directly related to the allegations raised in a formal complaint,
    • Includes the evidence upon which the recipient does not intend to rely in reaching a determination regarding responsibility and inculpatory or exculpatory evidence whether obtained from a party or other source
  • Allow each party can meaningfully respond to the evidence prior to the conclusion of the investigation.
    • Requires at least 10 days to submit a written response

​

  • Prior to completion of the investigative report, send to each party and the party’s advisor, if any, the evidence subject to inspection and review
    • In an electronic format or hard copy

©FisherFirm2024

77 of 121

WHAT DOES THIS LOOK LIKE?

  • Evidence Submitted
    • Gather everything
  • Summary of Evidence Received
    • Must include everything you will consider, review or reference in the investigative report
      • Reference Exhibits / Attachments
  • Creation of Evidence Packet
    • Neatly organized, labeled, numbered
    • Electronic or hard copy, but if electronic, consider encryption or other protections
  • Parties must have 10 days to review
    • Might be a good idea to get a draft investigative report completed BEFORE you compile all your evidence

​

©FisherFirm2024

78 of 121

PROMISES OF CONFIDENTIALITY

General Confidentiality

  • Make no promises!
  • Counsel witnesses to maintain confidentiality
  • Cannot restrict parties from discussing

​

©FisherFirm2024

79 of 121

CONFIDENTIALITY

  • The regs are silent as to how the evidence should be submitted to the parties from a CONFIDENTIALITY perspective
  • Seems to conflict with prior FERPA training, BUT DOE says no:
    • “Schools that receive federal financial assistance generally must comply both with FERPA and these Title IX requirements. Although FERPA does not have an express “exception” for disclosures in Title IX sexual harassment proceedings, these requirements may nonetheless be reconcilable. According to ED, the requirements of FERPA and the Title IX regulations do not contradict each other.143 But in cases in which a direct conflict arises, ED asserts, Title IX’s requirements override FERPA.” See https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R46799
  • District may seek agreement from Parties via Letter + NDA before the evidence packet is disclosed

©FisherFirm2024

80 of 121

CONFIDENTIALITY & PRIVACY

  • District is required “to take reasonable steps to protect the privacy of the parties and witnesses.”
    • Protections cannot impair the parties’ ability to:
      • “obtain and present evidence” 
      • “speak[] to witnesses”
      • “consult with their family members, confidential resources, or advisors”
      • “or otherwise prepare for or participate in the grievance procedures.”

​

  • District “must take reasonable steps to prevent and address the parties’ unauthorized disclosure of information and evidence obtained solely through the grievance procedures."

�

​

©FisherFirm2024

2024

81 of 121

FERPA ALERT

  • 2024 regulations prohibit a recipient from disclosing personally identifiable information obtained in the course of complying with Title IX, with limited exceptions, such as:
        • When the recipient has prior written consent from a person with the legal right to consent to the disclosure; or 
        • When the information is disclosed to the parent of a minor
        • When disclosure is required or permitted by Title IX Regs in order to carry out the purposes of the Regs by fully implementing Title IX’s nondiscrimination mandate and ensuring fair and equitable resolution of complaints of sex discrimination

​

©FisherFirm2024

§ 106.44(j)

2024

82 of 121

TO REDACT OR NOT TO REDACT

  • MUST Redact: 
    • Impermissible evidence

​

  • May Redact:
    • Information that is not relevant to the allegations but that is contained within documents or evidence that are relevant to the allegations 

​

  • CANNOT Redact:  
    • Information or evidence that is relevant to the allegations of sex discrimination and not otherwise impermissible because such redaction infringes on:
      • The right of the parties to receive access to the relevant and not otherwise impermissible evidence, 
      • The parties due process rights

​

"To the extent that FERPA would require the withholding or redaction of personally identifiable information in education records, for purposes of Title IX the Department takes the position that principles of due process and fundamental fairness require the disclosure of unredacted evidence and information to the parties that is relevant to the allegation and not otherwise impermissible."

​

©FisherFirm2024

2024

83 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

Investigative Report

  • Investigation is finished…
  • Evidence has been submitted to the Parties…
  • They have 10 days to review and respond…

​

NOW WHAT?!

84 of 121

PURPOSE OF THE INVESTIGATIVE REPORT

But do not reach a conclusion!

****Remember, the Investigator is NOT the Decision-Maker!

​

GOAL = INFORM, NOT PERSUADE

©FisherFirm2024

The purpose of the investigative report is to put the Decision Maker in the best position to make a reasoned, well-informed decision that is supported by fact.

85 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

“Formula” for Investigative Report

Identify the allegations.

[“Summary of Allegations”]

Outline procedural steps taken, include supportive measures.

[“Procedural Background”]

Summarize each Party’s responses to the allegations.

[“Party Responses to Allegations”]

Identify the applicable laws and policy.

[“Overview of Law and Policy”]

Summarize the evidence obtained during investigation

[“Summary of Evidence”]

Make factual findings.

[“Factual Findings”]

86 of 121

CONSIDERING EVIDENCE

Is it RELEVANT?

  • OCR Title IX Guidance: “The final regulations do not define relevance, and the ordinary meaning of the word should be understood and applied.”
  • FRCP 401 – Evidence is relevant if:
    • It has a tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without the evidence; and
    • The fact is of consequence in determining the action
  • Does it help you determine the FACTS? What question are you answering?

Is it ALLOWABLE?

​

  • NOT allowable:
    • Past sexual behavior/predisposition
      • Except to prove someone else committed the conduct
      • Except to show consensual behavior between Complainant and Respondent
    • Legal privilege
    • Treatment records

©FisherFirm2024

87 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

  • ORGANIZE
    • Chronologically
    • Give the FULL story, including background
    • Break it up: use headings and subheadings, paragraphs, tables or bulleted lists
  • BE CLEAR
    • Don’t assume knowledge
    • Avoid jargon, acronyms & terms of art
  • PROOFREAD!
    • Read it carefully for grammar, punctuation and spelling
  • Why? Errors undermine credibility of investigator/investigation
    • You may have to answer for it later

88 of 121

PROVIDING THE REPORT TO THE PARTIES

If Title IX Coordinator was NOT the Investigator:

  • Simultaneously provide the Investigation Report to both parties
  • Send a copy of the Investigation Report to the Title IX Coordinator

If the Title IX Coordinator was the Investigator:

  • Simultaneously provide the Investigation Report to both parties
  • Send a copy of the Investigative Report to the Decision Maker

©FisherFirm2024

89 of 121

THE PARTIES RESPOND

  • After the recipient has sent the investigative report to the parties and before reaching a determination regarding responsibility, the decision-maker(s) must afford each party the opportunity to submit written, relevant questions that a party wants asked of any party or witness, provide each party with the answers, and allow for additional, limited follow-up questions from each party.
    • 2020 Regs require 10-days
  • The decision-maker must explain to the party proposing the questions any decision to exclude a question deemed not relevant by the decision maker.

©FisherFirm2024

90 of 121

DETERMINATION OF RESPONSIBILITY = �THE “DECISION”

  • Remember, Decision Maker can be the Investigator AND/OR the Title IX Coordinator
  • Must evaluate the evidence based on the applicable “burden of proof” or evidentiary standard
    • Listed in Board Policy
    • “Preponderance of the evidence” = More likely than not, 51%, more than half

​

​

​

​

​

  • The Decision Maker must issue a written Determination of Responsibility.

​

©FisherFirm2024

Does the relevant evidence lead to a conclusion that it is more likely than not that Respondent committed the behavior complained of?

91 of 121

CHANGES TO BURDEN OF PROOF

  • 2024 Regs require use of “preponderance of the evidence standard” UNLESS your local policies utilize a different standard
  • If a different standard is used, the Title IX process must match

​

  • MOST District policies already utilize this standard.

©FisherFirm2024

2024

92 of 121

DETERMINATION OF RESPONSIBILITY

  • Must include:
    • Determination as to whether Respondent is responsible for the alleged conduct
    • The Decision Maker’s Findings of Fact
    • Conclusions about whether the alleged conduct occurred
    • Rationale for the determination made regarding each allegation
    • Disciplinary sanctions that will be imposed on Respondent, if any
    • Any remedies that will be provided to Complainant

​

  • Sent simultaneously to both Parties with info on how to file appeal

©FisherFirm2024

93 of 121

APPEALS

  • Filed with Title IX Coordinator
  • Available:
    • If complaint dismissed
    • After Determination of Responsibility
  • Grounds for appeal:
    • Procedural irregularity
    • New evidence that was not reasonably available
    • Conflict of interest against Title IX Coordinator, investigator, decisionmaker
  • Can offer for other reasons on equal terms (such as sanctions disproportionate to the offense) – CHECK FFH/DIA Regulations

​

​

©FisherFirm2024

94 of 121

THE APPEAL PROCESS

  • Parties are notified of appeal in writing and appeal procedures are implemented equally
  • Both parties have equal opportunity to submit written statement supporting or challenging the outcome
  • After considering parties’ written statements, Appeal Officer issues written decision and sends it to the parties simultaneously
  • Determination of whether the Respondent is responsible for the sexual harassment/discrimination becomes final after appeal decision

©FisherFirm2024

95 of 121

TITLE IX� PITFALLS

Common Mistakes & Lessons Learned

©FisherFirm2024

96 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

    • Failure to report to Title IX Coordinator
    • “Coding” actions as sexual harassment on referrals, etc.
    • Failure to do a basic SCOC investigation (statements)
    • Failing to discuss supportive measures

Failing to recognize sex-based allegations

    • Not using (and requiring use of) specific, full language
    • Use "quotes" and you're off the hook
    • Get specific, nitty gritty
    • Follow-up on "lingo"

Shying away from awkward

    • Against Complainant (and parents) especially
    • Bashing or undercutting the process to parties
    • Appearing doubtful, critical, judgmental
    • The little things MATTER

Having a negative attitude toward parties / process

97 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

    • What are you trying to prove or disprove?
    • Applicable definitions
    • Relevancy of evidence

Forgetting the “Big Picture”

    • Title IX Coordinator: oversight, compliance
    • Investigator: find all relevant facts (inform, not persuade)
    • Decision-maker: Apply facts to law/policy
    • Informal Resolution: not making any findings; focus on remedy

Not understanding your Role

    • Investigator’s job to present all FACTS to decision-maker
    • Facts must be supported by evidence
    • Can’t be afraid to look for or ask for evidence; can’t be afraid to upset or disrupt; can’t be afraid to prolong timeline

Not getting ALL the evidence

98 of 121

Let’s put your understanding to the test!

©FisherFirm2024

99 of 121

SCENARIO #1

You are the high school principal. Mom, Karen, sends you an email saying that her daughter, Molly, has been "sexually assaulted" at school by John. Mom says that the harassment has been happening all year but hit a breaking point today when John “pinched Molly’s boob and slapped her butt.” Mom demands that you do something immediately because ”THIS NEEDS TO STOP NOW." 

©FisherFirm2024

What are your first steps?

**Contact Title IX Coordinator**

Title IX Coordinator contacts mom. What should be discussed?

In the meantime, what should the principal be doing?

100 of 121

ONCE IT GETS TO YOUR DESK…

Review

Review your list before your interviews

List

Make a list of things you need to discover or questions to ask

Define

Define the ELEMENTS of proof – where to find??

    • SCOC

Identify

Identify the misconduct alleged

KNOW

KNOW THE CHARGE

101 of 121

WHEN A DISCIPLINE ISSUE TURNS INTO… SOMETHING ELSE

Title IX?

    • Report all claims of sexual harassment or sexual assault to the District’s Title IX Coordinator

Bullying?

    • FFI – Must provide written notices, investigate, write report, etc.

DFPS?

    • Report suspected child abuse or neglect to local law enforcement or CPS
    • Pay close attention to repeat behavior patterns w/ sexual themes
    • Remember mandatory reporters

Law Enforcement?

    • What do you have to report?

102 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

Twists

& Turns

Principal got statements from both students and issued discipline to John (3 days ISS). Mom still wants to file Formal Title IX Complaint – she says the harassment has been ongoing and 3 days ISS just isn't enough.

​

Where do we start...?

Prepare to interview Molly. Work with your table.

- List at least 3+ items you want to review before the interview.

- List as many questions as you can for an outline.

Twist:

Molly reveals that she and John used to date.

You just finished John's interview. He says it's all flirting and consensual.

- What evidence will you ask John for?

- What else could you review or do in order to find factual evidence to support John's position (if any)

Twists & Turns

103 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

Twists

& Turns

When you interview Molly, instead of admitting she and John used to date, Molly explains that she and John were just ”joking around” and it was witness by her brother who told her Mom. Molly also says that her Mom is completely overreacting and that her Mom and brother don’t like John and don’t think they should be dating so that’s how this all got started, but that she doesn’t even want this to continue.

Now what happens if Mom still wants to pursue a Title IX Complaint, even though Molly does not want the complaint to continue?

Twists & Turns

104 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

2024

105 of 121

If you leave today remembering only ONE THING, make it this:

​

Get a written statement.

Not YOUR statement… THEIR statement.

​

(Use discretion when it comes to young ages & disabilities)

106 of 121

SCENARIO #2

Dad of third grader, Brayden, calls demanding to speak with you. He tells you that another boy in the class poked Brayden’s head with a pencil last week, pinched him on the thigh two days ago, and chased him on the playground while yelling “tickle tickle” yesterday. Dad says Brayden is being “harassed” and the teacher keeps letting this happen so he wants to file a complaint.

©FisherFirm2024

What’s first???

If Parent files a formal complaint, is dismissal appropriate?

107 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

Twists

& Turns

You dismissed the formal Title IX complaint, but still directed the Principal to take statements and issue discipline under SCOC if warranted. Brayden (victim) says that the other boy regularly calls him “gay” or says that the things he wears are “gay”. He indicated he had used other slurs, and even mocked him once in an effeminate tone and demeanor.

OK… now what?

Twists & Turns

108 of 121

SCENARIO #3

The Counselor reports to you that 10th grader, Olivia, sought advice from the Softball Coach about how she should respond to a Senior guy who makes her “uncomfortable.” The Coach called the Counselor to come join the conversation and Olivia told them that Carl has been “hitting on” her. Olivia shared that Carl often “moves into her personal space” when talking to her, tells her he likes her clothes/body, and “jokes” about having sex with her. Olivia said that she doesn’t want to go to the AP about it because she is afraid it will get Carl in trouble and she just wants his behavior to stop.

The Counselor believes Olivia is genuinely upset and freaked out by Carl’s behavior. The Counselor knows that Olivia and Carl have the same lunch period, are in Ag together, run in the same social crowd, and regularly see each other outside of school hours at activities/events because they are both play sports and show animals, which also means they sometimes ride school transportation together.

©FisherFirm2024

Where do we start?

With your table, come up with as many supportive measures as you can in 5 minutes.

109 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

Twists

& Turns

Olivia’s mom, Tammy, thinks Olivia is overreacting and being dramatic. She knows Carl’s parents and thinks he’s a good kid.

The Formal Complaint proceeds: Carl admits almost all of the allegations, claiming they were all jokes.

​

You are the Decision-Maker. To determine Carl is “responsible” under Title IX, what would you need/want the Investigative Report to include…?

Twists & Turns

110 of 121

SCENARIO #4

Two JH students, 7th grader Claire and 8th grader Matt, are caught engaging in sexual activity in the visitor’s locker room during Friday’s pep rally. Claire’s parents are livid and initially want to file a formal complaint against Matt who they assumed pressured/forced Claire. They file the paperwork and you send a Notice of Allegations, including the Informal Resolution form. Claire’s parents call you to ask about informal resolution and ultimately indicate they are willing to try it out. Matt’s parents also agree to engage in informal resolution.

©FisherFirm2024

With only what you know now, what ideas do you have for informal resolution?

111 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

Twists

& Turns

In discussing Informal Resolution, Claire’s mother lets it slip that Claire has admitted the conduct was consensual and that she and Matt are dating.

​

How would you respond?

Twists & Turns

112 of 121

QUICK QUIZ

  • Which of the following issues could result in Title IX investigations?
      • In the cafeteria during lunch, a 7th grade girl air drops a nude that her 8th grade ex-boyfriend consensually sent her 3 months ago as revenge for their breakup
      • The boys’ athletic programs buy shoes for athletes, but the girls’ coaches decided to pay for an off-site end of year banquet instead
      • Elementary parent claims that her daughter with Tourette’s is being made fun of by “all the boys”
      • Gendered dress codes
      • Kindergarten students comparing body parts in the restroom
      • A teacher’s refusal to call a student by their preferred name/pronoun
      • Male employee being discouraged from taking FMLA for 12 weeks after birth of child
      • Not hiring a male coach for the girls basketball team since “he can’t be in the locker room” and opting instead for a less qualified female coach

​

​

©FisherFirm2024

113 of 121

PREGNANCY & TITLE IX

©FisherFirm2024

2024

114 of 121

DISCRIMINATION BASED ON PREGNANCY

  • When a student (or a student’s parent or other legal representative) informs an employee of the recipient of the student’s pregnancy or related conditions, the employee must provide the individual with the Title IX Coordinator’s contact information and inform the individual that the Coordinator can assist in preventing sex discrimination and ensuring the student’s equal access to the education program or activity

©FisherFirm2024

§ 106.40(b)(2)

2024

115 of 121

PREGNANCY-RELATED PROTECTIONS

  • Once a student or the student’s representative notifies the Title IX Coordinator, the recipient must:
    1. Inform the student of the recipient’s obligations to students who are pregnant or experiencing pregnancy-related conditions and restrictions on recipient disclosure of personal information, as well as provide the recipient’s notice of nondiscrimination. (§ 106.40(b)(3)(i))
    2. Provide the student with the option of individualized, reasonable modifications as needed to prevent discrimination and ensure equal access to the recipient’s education program or activity. (§ 106.40(b)(3)(ii))

§ 106.40

©FisherFirm2024

2024

116 of 121

PREGNANCY-RELATED PROTECTIONS CONT.

    • Allow the student a voluntary leave of absence for, at minimum, the medically necessary period and reinstatement upon return. (§ 106.40(b)(3)(iv))
    • Ensure the student’s access to a clean, private space for lactation. (§ 106.40(b)(3)(v))

©FisherFirm2024

§ 106.40

2024

117 of 121

  • A recipient must not require supporting documentation from a student unless doing so is necessary and reasonable

§ 106.40(b)(3)(vi)

Pregnancy-Related Protections Cont.

©FisherFirm2024

2024

118 of 121

  • 2024 regulations require recipient to ensure students and employees have access to a lactation space, which must be a space other than a bathroom that is clean, shielded from view, free from intrusion from others, and may be used for expressing breast milk or breastfeeding as needed
  • A recipient is required to provide its employees with reasonable break time for lactation and ensure they can access a clean and private lactation space
  • NOTE: This should sound familiar . . . It mirrors other pregnancy-related legal protections already in place

§ 106.40(b)(3)(v) and 106.57(e)(1)–(2)

Lactation Space

©FisherFirm2024

2024

119 of 121

DON’T FORGET!

  • Knowledge of conduct “that reasonably may constitute sex discrimination” by…
      • ANY EMPLOYEE of an elementary or secondary school
        • This could be a custodian, teacher, bus driver, etc.
  •  RECIPIENT MUST RESPOND "PROMPTLY AND EFFECTIVELY"

STAFF CANNOT IGNORE!

THINK...

 "PASS THE BUCK"

BY TELLING THEIR SUPERVISOR

©FisherFirm2024

120 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

121 of 121

©FisherFirm2024

Please call if we can help!

​

Jodie T. Kennemer

jodie@fisherfirm.com

Office: 409.444.3333

Cell: 936.552.6099