TITLE IX *PLUS*�FROM 2020 REGULATIONS TO PRESENT
©FisherFirm2024
With Jodie Kennemer
AGENDA
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Overview
Know your Team
Navigating Complaints
Case Studies
Pregnancy & Title IX
TITLE IX
WHY?
Requirements
©FisherFirm2024
WHY YOU?
©FisherFirm2024
To learn from our collective experiences!
TRAINING REQUIREMENTS
All Employees
Investigator, Decision Maker, & Others
Facilitator
Title IX Coordinator
©FisherFirm2024
2024
�TITLE IX�OVERVIEW
©FisherFirm2024
WHAT IS TITLE IX?
©FisherFirm2024
THE 2020 REGS
©FisherFirm2024
NEW YEAR . . . NEW RULES . . . MAYBE?
©FisherFirm2024
WHAT IS �“SEX-BASED”?
Gender Identity
SCOPE OF SEX DISCRIMINATION
©FisherFirm2024
©FisherFirm2024
SCOPE OF SEX DISCRIMINATION
©FisherFirm2024
SCOPE OF SEX DISCRIMINATION
©FisherFirm2024
§ 106.10
2024
NOTE: the Ruling was not specifically related to information published in 2024, BUT It may be expanded to apply.
©FisherFirm2024
July 8, 2024
©FisherFirm2024
July 8, 2024
WHAT ABOUT ISD POLICIES?
©FisherFirm2024
DEFINITIONS: SEXUAL HARASSMENT
©FisherFirm2024
34 CFR 106.30
Sexual harassment means conduct on the basis of sex that satisfies one or more of the following:
(2) Unwelcome conduct determined by a reasonable person to be so severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive that it effectively denies a person equal access to the recipient's education program or activity; or
(3) “Sexual assault” as defined in 20 U.S.C. 1092(f)(6)(A)(v), “dating violence” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(10), “domestic violence” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(8), or “stalking” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(30).
DEFINING SEX-BASED HARASSMENT
§ 106.2
©FisherFirm2024
2024
©FisherFirm2024
(3) “Sexual assault” as defined in 20 U.S.C. 1092(f)(6)(A)(v), “dating violence” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(10), “domestic violence” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(8), or “stalking” as defined in 34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(30).
20 USC 1092(f)(6)(A)(v)
(v) The term ‘‘sexual assault’’ means an offense classified as a forcible or nonforcible sex offense under the uniform crime reporting system of the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
©FisherFirm2024
©FisherFirm2024
General response to sexual harassment. A recipient with actual knowledge of sexual harassment in an education program or activity of the recipient against a person in the United States, must respond promptly in a manner that is not deliberately indifferent. A recipient is deliberately indifferent only if its response to sexual harassment is clearly unreasonable in light of the known circumstances.
IN A PROGRAM OR ACTIVITY
©FisherFirm2024
OUTSIDE OF THE UNITED STATES?
©FisherFirm2024
§ 106.11
Think social media, ISD senior trips, school summer travel groups, exchange students, or college study abroad
2024
ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE
©FisherFirm2024
STAFF CANNOT IGNORE!
ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE
©FisherFirm2024
§ 106.44(a)(1)
2024
EVERYONE HAS A DUTY
©FisherFirm2024
To report Title IX harassment!
KNOW YOUR �TITLE IX TEAM
©FisherFirm2024
REQUIRED �MEMBERS
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
REQUIRED �MEMBERS
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
2024 REGS ALLOW THESE ROLES TO BE THE SAME PERSON
2024 Regs
GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE § 106.45
©FisherFirm2024
THE TITLE IX COORDINATOR
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
©FisherFirm2024
THE TITLE IX COORDINATOR
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
2024 Regs
2024 REGS ALLOW THESE ROLES TO BE THE SAME PERSON
©FisherFirm2024
THE TITLE IX COORDINATOR
Assistant Superintendent
THE INVESTIGATOR
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
THE INVESTIGATOR
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
2024 Regs
2024 REGS ALLOW THESE ROLES TO BE THE SAME PERSON
©FisherFirm2024
THE INVESTIGATOR
Assistant Superintendent or Dist. Admin?
Campus Admin ?
THE DECISION-MAKER
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
THE DECISION-MAKER
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
2024 Regs
2024 REGS ALLOW THESE ROLES TO BE THE SAME PERSON
THE DECISION-MAKER
©FisherFirm2024
Assistant Superintendent
Campus Admin ?
THE�FACILITATOR
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
THE�FACILITATOR
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
?
2024 Regs
©FisherFirm2024
THE FACILITATOR
THE �APPEAL OFFICER
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
THE �APPEAL OFFICER
©FisherFirm2024
Title IX Coordinator
Investigator
Decision-Maker
Appeal Officer
Informal Resolution Facilitator
2024 Regs
©FisherFirm2024
THE APPEAL OFFICER
Superintendent
Appointed
BUILDING A GREAT TEAM
©FisherFirm2024
FAIRNESS REQUIREMENTS
Investigators, Decision-Makers, Appeal Officers, and Informal Resolution Facilitators must be:
©FisherFirm2024
Free from Bias
Impartial
No Conflicts of Interest
What are the differences???
Consider
Perception!
WHAT TO AVOID
Examples:
©FisherFirm2024
NAVIGATING COMPLAINTS
©FisherFirm2024
©FisherFirm2024
See KISD Administrative Board Policies DIA and FFH & Administrative Regs for DIA and FFH!
FORMAL GRIEVANCE POLICY STANDARDS
©FisherFirm2024
Equal treatment
Objective
review
Unbiased
investigations
Presumption
of innocence
Reasonably* Prompt
timelines
Discipline
options
Standard of
Evidence*
Appeal
procedures
Supportive
measures
Protect
privileges
BASIC TITLE IX GRIEVANCE PROCESS
©FisherFirm2024
Knowledge of inappropriate conduct that is sexual in nature
Title IX Coordinator communicates with alleged victim
Determination of supportive measures
Determination of emergency removal
Formal complaint
Initial determination of sexual harassment threshold
Notice of formal complaint (to both parties)
Investigation
Gather & Submit Evidence to
Both Parties
Parties may “meaningfully respond”
Investigative Report
Parties may submit questions, written responses
Decision-Maker responds to questions
Written Determination of Responsibility
Appeal
10 DAYS
10 DAYS
CHANGES TO TIMELINES
©FisherFirm2024
§ 106.45
2024
ADDITIONAL CHANGES TO �PROCESS
©FisherFirm2024
§ 106.44(k) and 106.45
2024
KNOWLEDGE OF THE ALLEGED CONDUCT
©FisherFirm2024
How will you get this knowledge?
If not received by Title IX Coordinator, must be forwarded to them ASAP!
INITIAL RESPONSE
©FisherFirm2024
Note: Regs don’t say “when a complaint is filed…”
SUPPORTIVE MEASURES
©FisherFirm2024
EXAMPLES OF SUPPORTIVE MEASURES
©FisherFirm2024
**Completely removing a respondent from an activity would likely be considered punitive, except for “emergency removals” for students and “administrative leaves” for employees.
EMERGENCY REMOVALS
©FisherFirm2024
NOTICE�AND �HEARING
If Respondent poses “an immediate threat to the physical health or safety of any student or other individual arising from the allegations of sexual harassment”
EMERGENCY REMOVAL
©FisherFirm2024
§ 106.44(h)
2024
FORMAL COMPLAINT FORM
NOTE: Once Formal Complaint is filed, no assignment of student discipline until after determination is made
©FisherFirm2024
ACCESS
District’s Title IX Complaint Form ONLINE!
THRESHOLD REVIEW
©FisherFirm2024
Consider review of:
DISMISSAL OF COMPLAINT
Should dismiss if if conduct alleged:
- Not sexual harassment if true (after reasonable clarification attempts)
- Did not occur in the school’s program or activity
*Can still address under a non-Title IX policy
May dismiss if:
- Complainant requests to withdraw
- Respondent’s enrollment or employment ends
- Specific circumstances prevent District from gathering evidence sufficient to reach a determination (e.g., passage of time, lack of cooperation by Complainant)
- Respondent cannot be identified after reasonable attempt
©FisherFirm2024
USE Dismissal WITH CAUTION – Call your Attorney FIRST!
DISMISSAL OF COMPLAINT
©FisherFirm2024
NOTICE
©FisherFirm2024
Written notice to all known parties with sufficient details and in enough time to prepare a response before any initial interview
NOTICE OF NEW TOPICS
©FisherFirm2024
INVESTIGATION
©FisherFirm2024
PLANNING THE INVESTIGATION
©FisherFirm2024
What do you need to know to prove or disprove the allegations?
PLANNING THE INVESTIGATION
©FisherFirm2024
INTERVIEWS
Consider Order:
©FisherFirm2024
RECORDING
INTERVIEW OVERVIEW
©FisherFirm2024
1. Listen without interruption
2. Listen & interrupt with Q’s
3. Tell story back &
ask to correct
©FisherFirm2024
Don't let your notes/script/outline
REPLACE YOUR
BRAIN!!!
PREPARE THE EVIDENCE
©FisherFirm2024
WHAT DOES THIS LOOK LIKE?
©FisherFirm2024
PROMISES OF CONFIDENTIALITY
General Confidentiality
©FisherFirm2024
CONFIDENTIALITY
©FisherFirm2024
CONFIDENTIALITY & PRIVACY
�
©FisherFirm2024
2024
FERPA ALERT
©FisherFirm2024
§ 106.44(j)
2024
TO REDACT OR NOT TO REDACT
"To the extent that FERPA would require the withholding or redaction of personally identifiable information in education records, for purposes of Title IX the Department takes the position that principles of due process and fundamental fairness require the disclosure of unredacted evidence and information to the parties that is relevant to the allegation and not otherwise impermissible."
©FisherFirm2024
2024
©FisherFirm2024
Investigative Report
NOW WHAT?!
PURPOSE OF THE INVESTIGATIVE REPORT
But do not reach a conclusion!
****Remember, the Investigator is NOT the Decision-Maker!
GOAL = INFORM, NOT PERSUADE
©FisherFirm2024
The purpose of the investigative report is to put the Decision Maker in the best position to make a reasoned, well-informed decision that is supported by fact.
©FisherFirm2024
“Formula” for Investigative Report
Identify the allegations.
[“Summary of Allegations”]
Outline procedural steps taken, include supportive measures.
[“Procedural Background”]
Summarize each Party’s responses to the allegations.
[“Party Responses to Allegations”]
Identify the applicable laws and policy.
[“Overview of Law and Policy”]
Summarize the evidence obtained during investigation
[“Summary of Evidence”]
Make factual findings.
[“Factual Findings”]
CONSIDERING EVIDENCE
Is it RELEVANT?
Is it ALLOWABLE?
©FisherFirm2024
©FisherFirm2024
PROVIDING THE REPORT TO THE PARTIES
If Title IX Coordinator was NOT the Investigator:
If the Title IX Coordinator was the Investigator:
©FisherFirm2024
THE PARTIES RESPOND
©FisherFirm2024
DETERMINATION OF RESPONSIBILITY = �THE “DECISION”
©FisherFirm2024
Does the relevant evidence lead to a conclusion that it is more likely than not that Respondent committed the behavior complained of?
CHANGES TO BURDEN OF PROOF
©FisherFirm2024
2024
DETERMINATION OF RESPONSIBILITY
©FisherFirm2024
APPEALS
©FisherFirm2024
THE APPEAL PROCESS
©FisherFirm2024
TITLE IX� PITFALLS
Common Mistakes & Lessons Learned
©FisherFirm2024
©FisherFirm2024
Failing to recognize sex-based allegations
Shying away from awkward
Having a negative attitude toward parties / process
©FisherFirm2024
Forgetting the “Big Picture”
Not understanding your Role
Not getting ALL the evidence
Let’s put your understanding to the test!
©FisherFirm2024
SCENARIO #1
You are the high school principal. Mom, Karen, sends you an email saying that her daughter, Molly, has been "sexually assaulted" at school by John. Mom says that the harassment has been happening all year but hit a breaking point today when John “pinched Molly’s boob and slapped her butt.” Mom demands that you do something immediately because ”THIS NEEDS TO STOP NOW."
©FisherFirm2024
What are your first steps?
**Contact Title IX Coordinator**
Title IX Coordinator contacts mom. What should be discussed?
In the meantime, what should the principal be doing?
ONCE IT GETS TO YOUR DESK…
Review
Review your list before your interviews
List
Make a list of things you need to discover or questions to ask
Define
Define the ELEMENTS of proof – where to find??
Identify
Identify the misconduct alleged
KNOW
KNOW THE CHARGE
WHEN A DISCIPLINE ISSUE TURNS INTO… SOMETHING ELSE
Title IX?
Bullying?
DFPS?
Law Enforcement?
©FisherFirm2024
Twists
& Turns
Principal got statements from both students and issued discipline to John (3 days ISS). Mom still wants to file Formal Title IX Complaint – she says the harassment has been ongoing and 3 days ISS just isn't enough.
Where do we start...?
Prepare to interview Molly. Work with your table.
- List at least 3+ items you want to review before the interview.
- List as many questions as you can for an outline.
Twist:
Molly reveals that she and John used to date.
You just finished John's interview. He says it's all flirting and consensual.
- What evidence will you ask John for?
- What else could you review or do in order to find factual evidence to support John's position (if any)
Twists & Turns
©FisherFirm2024
Twists
& Turns
When you interview Molly, instead of admitting she and John used to date, Molly explains that she and John were just ”joking around” and it was witness by her brother who told her Mom. Molly also says that her Mom is completely overreacting and that her Mom and brother don’t like John and don’t think they should be dating so that’s how this all got started, but that she doesn’t even want this to continue.
Now what happens if Mom still wants to pursue a Title IX Complaint, even though Molly does not want the complaint to continue?
Twists & Turns
©FisherFirm2024
2024
If you leave today remembering only ONE THING, make it this:
Get a written statement.
Not YOUR statement… THEIR statement.
(Use discretion when it comes to young ages & disabilities)
SCENARIO #2
Dad of third grader, Brayden, calls demanding to speak with you. He tells you that another boy in the class poked Brayden’s head with a pencil last week, pinched him on the thigh two days ago, and chased him on the playground while yelling “tickle tickle” yesterday. Dad says Brayden is being “harassed” and the teacher keeps letting this happen so he wants to file a complaint.
©FisherFirm2024
What’s first???
If Parent files a formal complaint, is dismissal appropriate?
©FisherFirm2024
Twists
& Turns
You dismissed the formal Title IX complaint, but still directed the Principal to take statements and issue discipline under SCOC if warranted. Brayden (victim) says that the other boy regularly calls him “gay” or says that the things he wears are “gay”. He indicated he had used other slurs, and even mocked him once in an effeminate tone and demeanor.
OK… now what?
Twists & Turns
SCENARIO #3
The Counselor reports to you that 10th grader, Olivia, sought advice from the Softball Coach about how she should respond to a Senior guy who makes her “uncomfortable.” The Coach called the Counselor to come join the conversation and Olivia told them that Carl has been “hitting on” her. Olivia shared that Carl often “moves into her personal space” when talking to her, tells her he likes her clothes/body, and “jokes” about having sex with her. Olivia said that she doesn’t want to go to the AP about it because she is afraid it will get Carl in trouble and she just wants his behavior to stop.
The Counselor believes Olivia is genuinely upset and freaked out by Carl’s behavior. The Counselor knows that Olivia and Carl have the same lunch period, are in Ag together, run in the same social crowd, and regularly see each other outside of school hours at activities/events because they are both play sports and show animals, which also means they sometimes ride school transportation together.
©FisherFirm2024
Where do we start?
With your table, come up with as many supportive measures as you can in 5 minutes.
©FisherFirm2024
Twists
& Turns
Olivia’s mom, Tammy, thinks Olivia is overreacting and being dramatic. She knows Carl’s parents and thinks he’s a good kid.
The Formal Complaint proceeds: Carl admits almost all of the allegations, claiming they were all jokes.
You are the Decision-Maker. To determine Carl is “responsible” under Title IX, what would you need/want the Investigative Report to include…?
Twists & Turns
SCENARIO #4
Two JH students, 7th grader Claire and 8th grader Matt, are caught engaging in sexual activity in the visitor’s locker room during Friday’s pep rally. Claire’s parents are livid and initially want to file a formal complaint against Matt who they assumed pressured/forced Claire. They file the paperwork and you send a Notice of Allegations, including the Informal Resolution form. Claire’s parents call you to ask about informal resolution and ultimately indicate they are willing to try it out. Matt’s parents also agree to engage in informal resolution.
©FisherFirm2024
With only what you know now, what ideas do you have for informal resolution?
©FisherFirm2024
Twists
& Turns
In discussing Informal Resolution, Claire’s mother lets it slip that Claire has admitted the conduct was consensual and that she and Matt are dating.
How would you respond?
Twists & Turns
QUICK QUIZ
©FisherFirm2024
PREGNANCY & TITLE IX
©FisherFirm2024
2024
DISCRIMINATION BASED ON PREGNANCY
©FisherFirm2024
§ 106.40(b)(2)
2024
PREGNANCY-RELATED PROTECTIONS
§ 106.40
©FisherFirm2024
2024
PREGNANCY-RELATED PROTECTIONS CONT.
©FisherFirm2024
§ 106.40
2024
§ 106.40(b)(3)(vi)
Pregnancy-Related Protections Cont.
©FisherFirm2024
2024
§ 106.40(b)(3)(v) and 106.57(e)(1)–(2)
Lactation Space
©FisherFirm2024
2024
DON’T FORGET!
STAFF CANNOT IGNORE!
THINK...
"PASS THE BUCK"
BY TELLING THEIR SUPERVISOR
©FisherFirm2024
©FisherFirm2024
©FisherFirm2024
Please call if we can help!
Jodie T. Kennemer
jodie@fisherfirm.com
Office: 409.444.3333
Cell: 936.552.6099