1 of 55

Welcome To CCL Training!

  • We’ll get started at the top of the hour.
  • In the meantime...
    • Share in the chat: where you’re calling in from and what you’ve been up to with agriculture outreach in your community.
    • Turn your video on, if you’re able and willing!
    • Follow us online (FB, Twitter, or Insta).
    • Polls & Q&A: pollev.com/ccl123 - Slides: http://cclusa.org/agriculture-outreach

www.citizensclimatelobby.org

2 of 55

CCL & Outreach to Agriculture Communities

Presentation Slides:

http://cclusa.org/agriculture-outreach

April 1, 2021

3 of 55

Housekeeping

  • Everyone is muted
  • Unmute during Q&A using the mic icon (or *6 on phone)
  • Your Zoom screen set up:

Mute/Unmute

Participants

Raise Hand

Gallery View

  • This meeting is being recorded

Chat

4 of 55

About Our Speakers

Nancy Jacobson

Agriculture Action Team Co-lead

CCL Southern Finger Lakes Chapter Co-lead

Julie Heath

CCL CA Chico Chapter

Business Climate Leaders Agriculture Interview Lead

5 of 55

Educate CCLers about agriculture and ag policies in the context of climate change

Ag Forum, Ag Monthly Call

Engage farmers, ranchers, & foresters, as individuals and organizations, in climate solutions

LTEs and Op-eds

Collaborate with BCL-Ag in outreach to farmers and ranchers and ag organizations

Provide resources for lobbying MoCs who care about agriculture

Handouts and resources for background and to help answer questions on both the

• Energy Innovation and Carbon Dividend Act (primary ask)

• Growing Climate Solutions Act (secondary ask)

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

What do we do?

   

 

Agriculture Action Team

6 of 55

Business Climate Leaders - Agriculture

sites.google.com/view/GCSAccl

Outreach Campaigns

7 of 55

Our Agenda

Reaching Out to Farmers

Agriculture and Climate Change

Growing Climate Solutions Act & Energy Innovation and Carbon Dividend Act

1

2t

3

8 of 55

  • High temperatures lead to health challenges to farm workers and livestock

  • Drought leads to reduced agricultural productivity

  • Extreme precipitation events lead to degradation of soil and water resources

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

4th National Assessment on Climate Change - 2018

   

 

Agriculture and Climate Change a

https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/downloads/NCA4_Ch10_Agriculture_Full.pdf

9 of 55

  • Cause heat stress (heat exhaustion and heart attacks) in workers.

  • Cause heat stress for livestock which decreases the production of meat and milk and results in large economic losses for producers.

  • In warm regions, may not get the winter chill needed for stone fruits.
  • In cold regions warm spell in winter, early budding then cold kills buds.

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

High Temperatures - increased frequency and intensity

Agriculture and Climate Change

10 of 55

From decreases in snowpack and/or rainfall and is exacerbated by high temperatures (increases evaporation from the soil)

  • Decreases food and forage

    • Increase soil organic matter &

keeping soil covered

retains water (short-term droughts)

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

Drought - increased frequency and duration

Agriculture and Climate Change

11 of 55

Has increased in the central and eastern United States.

  • Causes flooding, soil erosion, and nutrient leaching which threaten sustainable crop production.

    • Soil health practices

restore soil structure

which can absorb and

drain water better.

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

Extreme precipitation events - increased frequency

   

 

Agriculture and Climate Change

12 of 55

  • Will address 80% of the U.S. emissions that are causing climate change.
  • Will help farmers transition to farming practices that make them more resilient to the impacts of climate change.

  • Will help farmers reduce the 10% of U.S. emissions that are attributed to agriculture.

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

Energy Innovation & Carbon Dividend Act

   

 

How would the two bills help?

Growing Climate Solutions Act +

13 of 55

  • “The issue of climate change is highly polarized among rural voters and there is less support for government action than among urban/suburban voters…. We found that even perceptions of extreme weather are polarized along a partisan divide and across the urban/rural divide.”

  • “Rural reluctance to accept the science around climate change may be based on concerns about regulations.”

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

Attitudes towards climate change

   

 

What may stand in your way?

https://nicholasinstitute.duke.edu/publications/understanding-rural-attitudes-toward-environment-and-conservation-america

  • “Messengers matter. The most trusted sources are scientists and local farmers/ranchers, while environmental advocacy groups were the least likely to be chosen.”

14 of 55

  • “Among forest and farmland conservation, renewable energy development, and incentives for conservation-oriented farming practices, there are ample opportunities to connect environmental policy priorities and rural economies in a way that rural residents will appreciate and support.”

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

The 2020 study recommends:

   

 

What environmental advocates can do

https://nicholasinstitute.duke.edu/publications/understanding-rural-attitudes-toward-environment-and-conservation-america

15 of 55

  • Decreases input costs / yield

  • Can be maintained in the long-term, with steadier yields and profits

  • Can withstand extreme weather events better

Great place to start: Healthy soil

Can make farmers more financially resilient

16 of 55

Time For Questions

Click Unmute (Mic Icon)� Or *6 If On The Phone

17 of 55

Going Net Zero isn’t Enough

CO2

CO2

X

NET

NEGATIVE

EMISSIONS

Energy Innovation Act

Ag Producers

Net Negative Emissions

18 of 55

Listen First Strategy

19 of 55

Agriculture

20 of 55

Agriculture

21 of 55

.

22 of 55

Soil Health as a Solution

23 of 55

Co-Benefits of Soil Health

24 of 55

Agriculture

25 of 55

Soil Health Survey

Citizens Climate Lobby

Email CCL.GCSA@gmail.com

26 of 55

GCSA/Soil Health Survey

27 of 55

Growing Climate Solutions Act

28 of 55

GCSA: Making Markets Easier

Making it easier

Website

Tech Help with

-practices

-verification

Tech Provider

Certification Programs

29 of 55

Turning Carbon into a Cash Crop

Verify carbon

Get Credits

Cash the

credits

Implement

Practice

1.6% SOC

17 years tilled

4.3% SOC

After no tilling for long time

30 of 55

How to Incentivize these Practices?

Keep soil covered

Minimize soil disturbance

(low/no-till)

Plant diversity

Continual live plants and roots

Livestock integration

31 of 55

GCSA/Soil Health Survey

32 of 55

GCSA Website/Toolkit

sites.google.com/view/GCSAccl

Contact: Julie Heath CCL.GCSA@gmail.com

Resource creation:

33 of 55

Time For Questions

Click Unmute (Mic Icon)� Or *6 If On The Phone

34 of 55

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

IPCC Special Report 1.5°C

   

 

Role of GCSA and EICDA

[EICDA +]

[GCSA +]

35 of 55

  • EICDA exempts on-farm fuel use
    • Dyed diesel, as part of existing program - carbon fee isn’t included in its price
    • Gasoline, natural gas, propane - can get rebates
  • Why?
    • Many farmers are “price takers not price makers”
  • No fee on on-farm emissions
    • EICDA only places a fee on fossil fuels

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

Agriculture exemption

   

 

Energy Innovation & Carbon Dividend Act

36 of 55

  • In year 1, a decrease in net returns by 1.0% (corn), 1.6% (soybeans)
  • In year 10, a decrease in net returns by 6.3% (soybeans), 8.2% (corn)
  • Primarily due to increased price of fertilizer

    • Natural gas is used to make it
      • Takes a lot of energy - high heat and pressure
      • Methane used to provide hydrogen: N gas + hydrogen → ammonia)

    • Organic farmers wouldn’t be impacted by this

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

How will the bill impact farmers?

   

 

Energy Innovation & Carbon Dividend Act

Dumortier, J. and A. Elobeid. 2021. Effects of a carbon tax in the United States on agricultural markets and carbon emissions from land-use change. Land Use Policy. 103 (2021) 105320. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2021.105320

37 of 55

  • Farmers can change their practices to decrease fertilizer use
    • move to precision nitrogen management
    • practices that increase soil health
      • these will generally decrease the amount of fertilizer used / yield
  • Fertilizer manufacturing
    • Captures and uses or stores carbon dioxide (CCUS)
      • already used by some
      • EICDA has rebate

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

But two types of changes could occur over time to reduce the impact

   

 

Energy Innovation & Carbon Dividend Act

38 of 55

Such market-based solutions as a carbon price should:

- not tax any greenhouse gas emissions from the farm

- cause only slow increases in the price of gasoline, electricity, natural gas, and home heating oil, such as about ten cents per gallon of gasoline each year

- ensure that costs and benefits fall equally on urban and rural people

- protect the poor and middle-class, the elderly, and those on a fixed income

- create jobs and keep jobs in our communities

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

Wording about the EICDA that may be acceptable to farmers

   

 

Once you have a good relationship

We support market-based solutions, rather than federal or state emission limits, being used to achieve a reduction in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from any sources.

39 of 55

The link is on Community in both the BCL-Ag EICDA for Farmers and the Ag Action Team

https://www.businessclimateleaders.org/ag-declaration

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

have them go to the Agriculture’s Climate Declaration

   

 

If they’re ready to endorse

40 of 55

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

We at CCL still bet the farm on relationships

   

 

And get to know your local Farm Bureau

A Cooperative Extension agent gave me this advice:

“Wait until after the bill has been passed by both the House and the Senate because farmers won’t be interested until then. Then visit them to talk about it, and bring a Farm Bureau person with you.”

Look for resources on the BCL-Ag site:

EICDA for Farmers

41 of 55

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

Agriculture Action Team and BCL-Ag Outreach Campaigns

   

 

Join Us!

42 of 55

Time For Questions

Click Unmute (Mic Icon)� Or *6 If On The Phone

43 of 55

community.citizensclimate.org/topics#recent-trainings

  1. Saving Your Chat Log
  2. Finding Recordings After Tonight
  3. Share online, with social media, and with your chapter, family and friends!

44 of 55

Thank You!

Julie Heath email: ccl.gcsa@gmail.com

Nancy Jacobson email: agriculture@citizensclimatelobby.org

Join the Agriculture Action Team: https://community.citizensclimate.org/groups/home/968

GCSA Interview Team: sites.google.com/view/GCSAccl

www.citizensclimatelobby.org

45 of 55

This concludes our presentation.

What follows below is an appendix we keep in reserve in case audience members ask questions that are best answered with a related slide.

For those reading this presentation on your own later ...

46 of 55

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

Watch CCLer Hallie Shoffner’s great video!

   

 

Maybe not a local farmer but ...

  • Rural voters respond to messages about environmental policies that emphasize moral responsibility, acting on behalf of future generations and clean water.

47 of 55

Frequent Concerns of Farmers

  • Mandates
  • One-size-fits-all solutions
  • Non-farmers telling them how to farm

Agriculture Action TeamWhWhat

Great tips from Johnna Miller, Director of Media and Advocacy Training at the American Farm Bureau Federation (to see her ag call with us go to June Ag Call)

   

 

How do you talk with farmers?

Beware

  • Condescension
  • You can’t back it up
  • Too much jargon
  • Absolutes

48 of 55

No-till / redduced till / conservation tillage

Soybeans planted into rye residue

What types of practices help make soils healthy?

By not plowing, the soil structure stays intact

49 of 55

Cover crops

  • Keep soil covered so doesn’t wash away
  • Roots in the ground, when cash crops aren’t there, feed the bacteria and fungi and so increase soil organic matter

What types of practices help make soils healthy?

50 of 55

Rotational grazing

What types of practices help make soils healthy?

51 of 55

can be part of the solution

Soil Carbon Sequestration

and

Afforestation & Reforestation

are the most cost-effective means of removing CO2

from the atmosphere

GCSA: Agriculture and forestry

52 of 55

  • USDA - NRCS Conservation Stewardship Program (CSP)
    • Allows greater than 100% of practice costs and income forgone for transition to cover crops, resource-conserving crop rotations, and advanced grazing management.

  • USDA - NRCS Environmental Incentives Program (EQIP)
    • Can receive up to 90% of practice costs for state-selected high priority practices.

  • USDA - NRCS Conservation Reserve Program (CRP)
    • Includes pilot program for paying farmers for increased soil carbon through planting cover crops. Being rolled out now in Iowa, Minnesota, Montana, North Dakota, and South Dakota

  • USDA - NRCS Conservation Innovation Grants (CIG) $13.6 million 2019

2018 Farm Bill (next will be 2023)

has programs that support soil health

53 of 55

(A) land or soil carbon sequestration; 

(B) emissions reductions derived from fuel choice or reduced fuel use;

(C) livestock emissions reductions, including emissions reductions achieved through feeds and feed additives; 

(D) on-farm energy generation, including fuel switching; 

(E) energy feedstock production; 

(F) fertilizer use emissions reductions;

(G) reforestation; 

(H) forest management, including improving harvesting practices and thinning diseased trees;

(I) avoidance of the conversion of forests;

(J) grassland management, including prescribed grazing; and 

(K) such other activities, or combinations of activities, that the Secretary, in consultation with the Advisory Council, determine to be appropriate. 

GCSA: Activities expected to be credit-earning

54 of 55

is bipartisan, bicameral, and widely supported

Last session:

Cosponsors in the Senate:

Braun (IN), Stabenow (MI), Graham (SC),

Whitehouse (RI), [Fischer (NE)]

Cosponsors in the House:

Spanberger (VA7), Bacon (NE2), Pingree (ME1),

Stefanik (NY21), Lujan (NM3), Fortenberry (NE1),

Tonko (NY20), Baird (IN4), Harder (CA10), Katko (NY24),

plus 4 more Rs and 7 more Ds

Organizations supporting the GCSA

The Growing Climate Solution Act complements the EICDA,

55 of 55

The Growing Climate Solutions Act can help farmers help us

Watch CCL’s Video on the GCSA