Review of RPD Design
Dr Samiha Sartawi
The goal of partial denture design is
To control the denture movement while not exceeding the physiological tolerance of the oral structures.
Perpetual preservation of what is remaining is more important than meticulous replacement of what is lost” De Van
to achieve this objective it is important to: �
Support
Stability
Retention
Mechanical principles applicable in RPD
Lever
A simple machine consisting of a rigid bar pivoted on a fixed point and used to transmit force, as in raising or moving a weight at one end by pushing down on the other.
Class I
Class II
Class III
So:
As a rule, the longer the extension base, the greater the potential for damaging loads to be generated on the opposite side of the fulcrum line.
Inclined plane
Forces against an inclined plane may result in deflection of that which is applying the forces or may result in movement to the inclined plane, neither of these is desirable.
E.g Cingulum rest seat on cuspids
Snowshoe principle
This principle is based on distribution of forces to as large an area as possible.
Type of Support
Tooth support
Tooth and tissue
support
Indirect retention
a rest on an anterior tooth (indirect retainer) becomes the fulcrum of movement of the saddle in an occlusal direction causing the clasp to move up the tooth, engage the undercut and thus resist the tendency for the denture to pivot.
F = Fulcrum — indirect retainer, a component which obtains support.
R = Resistance — retention generated by the clasp.
E = Effort — displacing force, eg a bolus of sticky food.
to obtain indirect retention the clasp must always be placed between the saddle and the indirect retainer.
The clasp (R) is always nearer to the indirect retainer (fulcrum) than is the displacing force (E). The clasp is therefore working at a mechanical disadvantage relative to the displacing force.
The RPD design should strive to reduce the mechanical advantage of the displacing force by placing the clasp axis as close as possible to the saddle and by placing the indirect retainers as far as possible from the saddle.
E
R
F
Path of Insertion�
Guide surfaces (*) are two or more parallel axial surfaces on abutment teeth, which limit the path of insertion of a denture. Guide surfaces may occur naturally or, as is more often the case, may need to be prepared. Increased stability is achieved by the guide surfaces resisting displacement of the denture (red arrows) in directions other than along the planned path of displacement.
Tooth preparation
1) A rest placed on an inclined surface will tend to slide down the tooth under the influence of occlusal loads. The resulting horizontal force may cause a limited labial migration of the tooth with further loss of support for the denture and may tend to collect food particles and possibly create difficulties in tolerating the denture.
2) The provision of a rest seat will result in a vertical loading of the tooth, more efficient support and absence of tooth movement and less apparent to the patient and also harmonizes with the occlusal relationship.
Unfavourable survey lines
*may create an occlusal
interference
*a high clasp arm is more
noticeable to the patient and
may interfere with mastication
*Unfavourable forces applied to
the tooth
Major connector
Connects parts of prosthesis located on one side of the arch with those on the opposite side−
Should be rigid:−
Distribution of force
Effectiveness of other components
If flexible forces concentrated on individual teeth or ridge damaging.
Reciprocation
A guide surface* allows a reciprocating component to maintain continuous contact with a tooth as the denture is displaced occlusally. The retentive arm of the clasp is thus forced to flex as it moves up the tooth. It is this elastic deformation of the clasp that creates the retentive force
Guide surfaces ensure that the patient removes the denture along a planned path (1). The clasps are therefore flexed to the extent for which they were designed. Without guide surfaces the patient may tilt or rotate the denture on removal (2), causing clasps to flex beyond their proportional limit.
The reciprocal element which is in contact with the side of the tooth opposite the retentive clasp can also play an important role in the effectiveness of the latter, and thus in the overall retention of the denture. (1) A horizontally directed force is produced as a retentive arm is displaced in an occlusal direction over the bulbosity of a tooth. If the clasp arm is unopposed the tooth is displaced in the periodontal space and much of the retentive capability will be lost. (2) If the retentive clasp is opposed by a rigid component which maintains contact with the tooth as the retentive arm moves over the bulbosity of the tooth, displacement of the tooth is resisted, the retentive arm is forced to flex and thus the efficiency of the retentive element is increased. This principle is known as reciprocation. It is thus apparent that reciprocation is required as the denture is being displaced occlusally whilst the bracing function, comes into play when the denture is fully seated.
(1) A clasp is effective in retention from its position when the denture is fully seated to where it escapes over the bulbosity of the tooth. This vertical measurement may be termed the 'retention distance'. It will be appreciated that the reciprocal element on the other side of the tooth should be in continuous contact with the tooth surface as the retentive arm traverses the 'retention distance'. Effective reciprocation can be achieved either (2) by a clasp arm contacting a guide surface of similar height to the 'retention distance', or (3) by a plate making continuous contact with the tooth surface as the retentive arm moves through its 'retention distance'. (4) If the reciprocating clasp is placed on a tooth without an adequate guide surface, it will lose contact with the tooth before the retentive arm has passed over the maximum bulbosity of the tooth and fail to provide effective reciprocation.
Bracing
Horizontal forces are generated during function by occlusal contact (1 and 2) and by the oral musculature surrounding the denture (3). These forces tend to displace the denture in both antero-posterior and lateral directions.
The horizontal forces are resisted by placing rigid components of the denture (bracing components) against suitable vertical surfaces on the teeth and residual ridges. Parts of a denture resting against the stippled areas will resist the forces whose directions are shown by the arrows. It is important to appreciate that bracing occurs only when the denture is fully seated.
+-
The RPI system is a combination of occlusal rest (R) distal guide plate (P) and gingivally approaching I bar clasp (I) used primarily with mandibular distal extension saddles.
The minor connector carrying the mesial rest contacts the mesiolingual surface of the abutment tooth and, together with the distal plate, acts as a reciprocal for the tip of the retentive clasp which is positioned on or anterior to the midpoint of the buccal surface of the tooth.
A distal extension saddle should not be rigidly attached to the abutment tooth by a combination of stiff clasp and long guide plates. If these are incorporated the occlusal loads falling on the saddle, which is in effect a long cantilever arm, are likely to result in the RPD acting like extraction forceps, with consequent damage to the supporting structures of the tooth.
The RPI system is designed to allow vertical rotation of a distal extension saddle into the denture-bearing mucosa under occlusal loading without damaging the supporting structures of the abutment tooth. As the saddle is pressed into the denture-bearing mucosa, the denture rotates about a point close to the mesial rest. Both the distal guide plate and the I bar move in the directions indicated and disengage from the tooth surface. Potentially harmful torque is thus avoided. When trying in the metal framework, it is advisable to check that it is able to rotate about the abutment tooth in the intended fashion. If this is found not to be the case, the framework should be carefully adjusted to allow this rotation.
Factors influencing magnitude of stress
RPD CLASSIFICATION
Classification is based on the frequency of the partially edentulous state. It is descriptive of the anatomical form of the respective arch and merely provides an overall description of where the saddles are without outlining the size of the saddles.
DIFFERENTIATION BETWEEN TWO MAIN TYPES OF REMOVABLE PARTIAL DENTURES�
Components of RPD
These may be rests on the crowns of teeth, coronal
restorations, root faces of teeth, mucosa or implants.
These are termed direct retainers and may be clasps,
precision retainers, guiding plates acting on surfaces.
These may be major connectors, which join up the saddles, or minor connectors that join rests or direct retainers to the major connector.
Often referred to as indirect retainers, although they also function as supporting elements for the framework.
The denture base material and denture flange may serve as one or more of the above components.
Principles of design
1. Outline the saddles and determine which ones need to be restored.
2. Decide on the nature of the support.
3. Decide on how best to maximize retention.
4. Decide on how best to unite the saddles.
5. Decide whether anti-rotational devices are required and, if so, how this is achieved.
6. Re-assess for hygiene and, with an eye on the future, maintenance of the prosthesis (e.g. relining, repair and replacement of components of precision attachments) and the prognosis of the remaining dentition.
7. Decide on how the occlusion is to be planned and, at the same time, plan with appearance in mind.
Simply:
1. Saddles.
2. Support.
3. Retention.
4. Bracing and reciprocation.
5. Connector.
6. Indirect retention.
7. Review of completed design.
O : Outline the saddle areas :
Class I Kennedy
Primary abutments : LR 5 & LL 5
Potential guiding planes
Posterior saddle : Anterior tilt !
GP 1
GP 2
Anterior tilt
exposure of lingual sulcus (elimination of undercut) for placement of major connector.
exposure of the distal surface of the primary (terminal) abutment : minimum preparation for guiding plane achievement.
S: Support
It is dependent on the residual ridge for a portion of its support.
Factors influencing support:
1. Contour and quality of the residual ridge
2. Extent of residual ridge coverage by the
denture base
3. Type and accuracy of the impression registration
4. Accuracy of the fit of the denture base
5. Design of the partial denture framework
6. Total occlusal load applied
Type and accuracy of impression registration
Occlusal load
How??
a- buccolingually :
- using narrow teeth
- using canines and premolars instead of premolars and molars
b- antero-posteriorly :
- leaving a tooth off a saddle
2) Wide coverage of the residual ridge area by the base of the saddle as is compatible with function.
Maximum coverage within the physiologic tolerance of the limiting border structure.
Reduce the load per unit area.
Reducing the saddle movement under occlusal loads
Methods :
Mesio-occlusal rest !
Disto-occlusal rest !
Disto-occlusal rest: Simplicity
proximal plate Disto-occlusal rest
But???
1- Creation of class I lever
2. Distal displacement of the abutment tooth
Distal drifting of the terminal abutment opening of the mesial contact point = food impaction = caries = periodontal disease
3. Less alveolar bone for support
The alveolar bone utilized for support lies distal to the primary supporting element…
Mesio-occlusal rest:
Additional minor connector
But???
1. Creation of class 2 lever
Occlusal forces will deactivate the lever action
2. Mesial displacement of the terminal abutment causing enhancement of the mesial contact point
3. More alveolar bone utilization for support
4. Stress breaking effect :
Disengagement of primary abutment tooth upon occlusal load application (short guiding planes)
Full tooth length plane ?
* Interferes with the physiological movements of the abutment tooth.
* Requires excessive preparation.
Support access
2 rests = fulcrum
Clasp access
Indirect retainers
Indirect retention is required
Indirect retention
The posterior part of the distal extension saddle is capable of rotating in the horizontal plane. If a long saddle is clasped rigidly to a single
abutment tooth the rotatory movement can transmit considerable force to that tooth.
Indirect retainers do not prevent displacement towards the ridge. This movement is resisted by the occlusal rest on the abutment tooth and by full extension of the saddle to gain maximum support from the residual ridge.
Design of tooth borne RPD
The principle of tilting the cast to enhance retention is that by so altering the path of insertion (1) a rigid part of the denture can enter an area of the tooth surface or an area of the ridge which is undercut relative to the path of displacement (2).
In this example, providing retention by engaging the distal undercut (*) of the canine may well look more pleasing than a clasp arm on the same tooth.
3- Rests also act as indirect retainers for Kennedy Class I and Class IV partial dentures.
Maxilla: plate, strap, ring (anterior-posterior palatal strap), horseshoe.
2-The lingual plate +ve more acceptable to the tongue, can act as an indirect retainer, -ve it does of course cover over the lingual surfaces of the lower anterior teeth, thus predisposing to caries and gingival/periodontal irritation. The appearance may also be poor if there is spacing between the teeth.
3-The sublingual bar which fits in the lingual pouch beneath the tongue and is +ve less noticeable, more rigid. –ve more bulky than a lingual bar (it is half pear-shaped and requires a 10 mm space from lingual gingival margins to the lingual reflection), careful attention must be paid to the impression technique, using functional tongue movements to roll the impression material while it is setting.
4-The dental bar may be used where there is a limited lingual sulcus, but as this fits onto the cingulum region of the teeth and has to be -ve bulky for strength, it may not be readily acceptable to the patient.
5-The labial or buccal bar is recommended for lingually inclined lower anterior teeth such as Skeletal III cases.
6- The Kennedy bar is a combination of a continuous clasp on the lingual surfaces of the lower anterior teeth and a lingual bar. This type of major connector tends not to be well perceived by patients owing to the number of edges that are in contact with the tongue
Selection of the type of connector(s) is based on four factors:
undercut area nearer to the saddle: ring clasp
Tilted molar: ring clasp
When guide surfaces are used to provide resistance to displacement of the denture in an
occlusal direction, the retentive portion of the clasp needs only to resist movement along
the path of withdrawal and therefore can be positioned solely with reference to the red
survey line.
A gingivally approaching clasp positioned at the cross-over point of the survey lines resists
movement along both the path of withdrawal and the path of displacement without being
permanently deformed by movement along either path.
?
?
?
?
?
M
D
?
?
1-Maximum contact of proximal plate minor connector with guiding plane produces more horizontal distribution of stress. 2- Minimum contact or disengagement of minor connector with guiding plane allows rotation around fulcrum located on mesio-occ1usal rest, producing more vertical distribution of stress to ridge area. 3- Minor connector contact with guiding plane from marginal ridge to junction of middle and gingival thirds of abutment tooth distributes load vertically to ridge and horizontally to abutment tooth.