1 of 19

Recognizing & Responding to High Conflict Patterns

Resolved LLC | www.resolvedwithlexi.com | lexi@resolvedwithlexi.com

CONFLICT RESOLUTION WORKSHOP

Lexi Wolfe

All Souls & Grace Church

2 of 19

What Would You Do…?

Imagine you lead a weekly Bible study.

For weeks, members of the group have been coming to you with the same concern. One person keeps arguing aggressively, talking over others, and turning every discussion into a debate. The tension is building, and some people have stopped speaking up. Behind the scenes, this person has been telling others that the real problem is you: that you don’t run the group well and that you take sides.

You’ve already talked it through with the Assistant Pastor, who supports you and encouraged you to address it directly.

You decide to meet with this person privately and offer calm, respectful feedback. It gets a bit heated, but you get through it.

Within hours, they email the entire group and copy the Assistant Pastor:

“I didn’t realize I was dealing with such a naive and closed-minded group of children! A friendly debate isn’t a crime. Stop tattling to the pastor!”

3 of 19

What’s Next?

  • How would you feel as the Bible study leader?
  • What would be your instinct for responding?

4 of 19

Recognizing�High Conflict

PART 1

5 of 19

Typical Conflict Dynamics and Interventions

5

WHAT YOU SEE

Escalation

Strong emotions arise when something important to you feels at risk

WHAT IT NEEDS

De-escalation

Cool things down before trying to fix anything

WHAT YOU SEE

Stalemate

Only win-lose options seem possible

WHAT IT NEEDS

Negotiation

Look for common ground to open up win-win options

WHAT YOU SEE

Blind Spot

Not yet aware of how a behavior lands with others

WHAT IT NEEDS

Feedback

Name the behavior and its impact, privately and promptly

6 of 19

6

High Conflict Dynamics

A conflict shows up

MOST OF US

Cool down

Talk, listen, and adjust – even when it's hard or uncomfortable

SOME PEOPLE

Turn it up

Escalate, blame, and push harder, because that's what feels normal

Keep in mind: Not just a bad day. A deeply ingrained pattern that plays over years and different relationships.

7 of 19

Four Signs of a High-Conflict Pattern

7

Framework from Bill Eddy, The High Conflict Institute

Preoccupation with Blaming Others

It's always someone else's fault; consistently sidesteps personal responsibility

Unmanaged Emotions

Emotional reactivity that takes over most interactions

​

All-or-Nothing Thinking

Binary framing: “always/never,” “everyone/no one,” “with me/against me”

​

Extreme Behaviors or Threats

Things most people wouldn't do under stress

​

Keep in mind: Eddy estimates this pattern shows up in about 10% of U.S. adults; believes the rate is increasing

8 of 19

A Hard Moment or a Recurring Pattern

Everyone has hard moments in conflict. Here’s how to tell when it might be something more.

Typical Conflict Patterns

A High-Conflict Pattern

Come back seeking repair

After things cool down, they…

Come back with accusations

Own at least some of their part

When it comes to blame, they…

Everything is someone else's fault

Focused on a specific context or person

Issues that arise tend to be…

Tied to any person or issue they work closely with

Adjust, even if reluctantly

When a boundary is set, they…

Escalate and widen the circle of impact

9 of 19

9

Is It Stress or a Pattern?

These can overlap. The difference is whether the cycle can be interrupted.

A Stress Response

Perceived threat

Fight, flight, or freeze

Shutting down or lashing out

Shame or self-protection

The cycle can be interrupted

Can repair relationships when seen/heard

Calms down with time and safety

Reflects once they feel safe

A High-Conflict Pattern

Perceived threat

Escalation

Defensiveness or deflection

Outward blame

The cycle is their normal

“Justified” retaliation

Doubles down, even when it backfires

Pulls others onto their side

Red arrows: what keeps it going

Green arrows: ways out of the cycle

10 of 19

“Can’t You See?”

It’s not won’t. It’s can’t.

  • They aren’t refusing to see it. It may feel obvious to others, but they genuinely can’t reflect on their part.
  • The threat-and-blame cycle is fixed. Their attention stays locked on the threat and who’s to blame.
  • Feedback feels like another threat. Asking them to reflect tends to raise their guard, not lower it.

11 of 19

Responding to�High Conflict

PART 2

12 of 19

Changing the Approach for High Conflict

Approaches that Escalate

  • More explanation or evidence
  • Feedback aimed at self-reflection
  • Offering more options or "one more chance"
  • Extra empathy meant to soothe
  • Avoiding or delaying responses or follow-through

Better Approaches for High Conflict

  • Clear limits and structure
  • Focus on moving forward and future behaviors
  • Clear, consistent consequences and follow-through
  • Plan for escalation: align early on roles, process, and communication (see BIFF® tool)
  • Get expert support

13 of 19

13

So, What Does “Success” Look Like?

What is the Goal: Aim for a workable relationship, not a changed person.

HIGH CONFLICT IS A SPECTRUM

← Lower

Higher →

Lower on the Spectrum

With clear limits and boundaries on future behavior, they may be able to co-exist in ways that are less disruptive and more manageable.

Higher on the Spectrum

A much larger impact on the community and the people involved. Sometimes, the only proportional solution is for the person to leave.

14 of 19

Questions?

What's stirring for you? What would you like to talk through?

15 of 19

Additional Resources

15

16 of 19

Thank You

17 of 19

EAR: Calm the Defenses

17

Bill Eddy built EAR for high-conflict moments. People caught in this pattern often feel unheard, disrespected, or under attack. A short statement of Empathy, Attention, and Respect lowers their guard so the conversation can move forward.

E - Empathy

Seen: Acknowledge emotion without agreeing

"I recognize this is hard."

​

A - Attention

Heard: Show you are truly listening

​

"It's safe to keep talking; your perspective counts."

​

R - Respect

Valued: Affirm their intent and effort

​

"You matter & have agency."

​

18 of 19

18

Catch It Early: Bill Eddy's WEB

Each part of WEB is a way to notice the four signs.

W

Words

Listen to what they say

  • All-or-nothing absolutes: “always,” “never,” “everyone knows”
  • Either/or framing: “You're with me or against me”
  • Blame that never lets up

CONNECTS TO

All-or-Nothing Thinking

Blaming Others

E

Emotions

Notice how you feel

  • Dread when you see an email from them appear in your inbox
  • Drained, on edge, or second-guessing yourself after engaging with them
  • A pull to rescue, defend, or give in just to make it stop

CONNECTS TO

Unmanaged Emotions

B

Behavior

Watch for patterns over time

  • The same behavior, again and again
  • Recruits others to their side (negative advocates)
  • Several people describe the same kind of run-in

CONNECTS TO

Extreme Behaviors or Threats

Blaming Others

19 of 19

19

BIFF: When You Have to Reply in Writing

Bill Eddy's tool for answering hostile emails, texts, and messages without adding fuel.

B

Brief

A short paragraph. Long replies give them more to argue with.

I

Informative

Neutral facts and next steps. Skip the defending and correcting.

F

Friendly

A warm opening and close. Try to stay calm in your messages, even when they escalate.

F

Firm

Be firm in your stance and end the exchange or offer one clear next step.