1 of 22

Fuel Poverty Policy Roundtable

​

Discussion Results

​

​

​

​

11th October 2025

​

UHI House, Inverness

​

2 of 22

Setting the Scene

​

​

#2050StartsNow

As the energy transition accelerates, fuel poverty is becoming an increasingly urgent issue. It is critical that communities living closest to renewable energy projects are not left behind, but among the first to benefit from it.

​

In the Highlands, one in three households is forced to choose between heating and eating, while the region generates 27% of Scotland’s renewable energy. Fuel poverty is multi-faceted driven by several interconnected challenges: remote and isolated homes, reliance on off-grid and expensive fuels, an ageing and poorly insulated housing stock, and a rapidly ageing population as young people leave in search of better opportunities.

​

Over a quarter of young people are leaving the Highlands reluctantly, even as large renewable developments rise around them. An industry that promised jobs, investment, and opportunity has instead become associated with exclusion. This disconnect is fuelling growing anti-renewables sentiment, a trend that will only intensify as more large-scale projects are built without meaningful local benefit. Yet there is a better path forward.

​

Apprenticeships offer tangible pathways for young people to access secure employment in a low-carbon economy, while renewable heat upgrades can replace outdated, expensive fuels such as coal and oil. Alongside retrofitting and energy-efficiency measures that reduce heat loss and lower bills, the energy transition has the potential to significantly reduce fuel poverty and regenerate rural communities. However, this will only be realised if communities are placed at the centre of decision-making, allowing the Highlands to move from passive hosts to active participants through co-ownership models, equitable benefit-sharing, and targeted investment in developing the next generation of skilled workers.

​

​

3 of 22

Event Structure

  • On the 11th October 2025, 2050 Climate Group organised a fuel poverty policy roundtable at UHI House, with 20 participants compromising of key stakeholders, such as young professionals, policy makers, and community representatives discussing the barriers and solutions to topics including green energy transition, infrastructure both grid and transport, retrofitting, and upskilling.

​

  • The results of the roundtable discussions including both key barriers and solutions are presented in the following slides, alongside a summary of key points.

​

  • These insights will be transformed into a social justice campaign led by 2050 Climate Group, turning lived experience and practical solutions into a powerful call to action. Through the documentary being produced, 2050 Climate Group aims to bridge the gap between industry, government, and communities by amplifying underrepresented voices, highlighting the reality of living in fuel poverty, and showcasing actionable pathways to a just transition. This documentary aims to raise awareness and encourage open dialogue, which fosters collaboration, accountability, and change ensuring those living at the heart of Scotland’s energy transition are not left behind but among the first to benefit from it.

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

4 of 22

​

�

In the shift to renewable and low-carbon energy be made fair and affordable for everyone, especially rural and low-income households in the Highlands?

​

​

​

​

​

Facilitated by Dianah Alinaitwe

#2050StartsNow

5 of 22

Barriers

#2050StartsNow

  • ​
  • The Highlands generate 27% of Scotland’s renewable energy yet experience some of the highest levels of fuel poverty in the country. This stark contradiction highlights the systemic barriers preventing local communities from sharing in the benefits of the energy transition.

​

  • A sparse, dispersed population means local energy demand will never match supply, yet the financial value generated continues to flow out of the region. At the same time, 27% of young people are leaving the Highlands reluctantly in search of opportunities elsewhere, despite repeated promises that renewables would deliver local jobs and investment. Where developers are largely external to the region, trust is eroded, and local knowledge, culture, and lived experience are often overlooked.

​

  • While community benefit schemes appear positive on the surface, they are widely perceived as inconsistent, short-term, and lacking transparency. Not all projects offer them, and where they do exist, communities are often unclear how funding decisions are made. This has created tensions between neighbouring communities, with some seen to be favoured over others. Meanwhile, community ownership is currently too risky and inaccessible for those who need it most, reinforcing existing inequalities.

​

  • Most significantly, young people are not being meaningfully included in shaping their own futures. Despite being the generation most affected by the energy transition, there is no clear pathway into jobs, limited guidance on qualifications, uncertainty around when opportunities will emerge, and increasing competition for available roles reinforcing a sense of exclusion from an industry being built on their doorstep. Although several databases for jobs and qualifications exist, the lack of a single, trusted one-stop shop creates fragmentation and confusion, making it even harder for young people to navigate a route into the sector.

​

​

​

6 of 22

Solutions

#2050StartsNow

  • ​
  • To address fuel poverty and ensure a just energy transition in the Highlands, power, investment, and opportunity must be embedded within communities from the outset. This requires a shift from extractive development models towards shared and community-led approaches that prioritise long-term local benefit. Introducing clearer pathways for community and shared ownership, supported by structured guidance and risk protection, would enable communities, not external investors, to retain value and shape their own energy futures.

​

  • Greater transparency and consistency in community benefit schemes is also essential. Standardising expectations across projects, increasing accountability over how funds are distributed, and exploring the creation of regional funding pots could reduce inter-community tension while ensuring a more equitable and strategic allocation of resources. These funds could be directed towards retrofitting, energy efficiency upgrades, local infrastructure, and affordable heating solutions, offering both immediate and long-term impact.

​

  • Empowering young people must be a central pillar of the transition. Establishing a clear, accessible, and trusted one-stop hub for renewable energy jobs, training, and qualifications would remove current barriers and confusion. Alongside this, targeted apprenticeships, local training programmes, and paid pathways into green careers would ensure that opportunities are tangible and achievable. Meaningful youth representation in decision-making, project design, and governance would further ensure that those most affected by the transition are helping to lead it.

​

  • Finally, rebuilding trust between industry, government, and communities will be critical. This can be achieved through long-term strategic engagement, locally-based community liaison officers, and consistent two-way communication. By valuing local knowledge, embedding youth voice, and prioritising transparency, the energy transition can evolve from a source of division into a shared, community-powered opportunity for the Highlands.

​

​

​

​

7 of 22

​

�

​

In communities that are off the main gas grid, what kinds of self-sufficient or community-led energy systems could best meet local needs while keeping energy affordable?

​

​

​

​

​

Facilitated by Mari-Nikol Staneva

#2050StartsNow

8 of 22

Barriers

  • ​
  • Many rural homes are isolated, off-grid, and connected to outdated fuels such as coal, oil and LPG, leaving households exposed to high costs, supply insecurity, and limited low-carbon alternatives. In off-mains and weak-grid communities, the transition to clean, affordable energy is far more complex, costly, and inaccessible than in urban areas.

​

  • Severely constrained grid capacity and outdated infrastructure present major barriers. Distribution Network Operators (DNOs) tend to prioritise large-scale developments over local, community-scale solutions, while microgrids and small connections face strict limitations. Inaccurate demand mapping and poor long-term planning mean infrastructure investment does not reflect real community needs, and increasing pressure from large developments such as data centres risks further limiting local access.

​

  • Policy and regulatory systems are equally restrictive. Off-grid legislation is overly complex and poorly suited to rural contexts. There is no clear, accessible framework to support community-led or self-sufficient energy systems, and responsibility is fragmented across developers, network operators and government, resulting in a lack of accountability and stalled progress.

​

  • Finally, communities are excluded from meaningful participation in energy planning. Local voices are not adequately represented in future energy scenario planning, energy literacy remains low, and residents lack access to clear, trustworthy information. Without inclusion, transparency and local empowerment, rural communities remain disconnected from and disadvantaged by a transition that should be designed around their needs.

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

9 of 22

Solutions

  • ​
  • Communities identified strong potential in decentralised, community-led energy systems to reduce costs and increase resilience. Off-grid and weak-grid areas may be better positioned to pilot microgrid and shared energy models, where small clusters of homes can generate, store and distribute power locally. Battery energy storage systems (BESS) and smarter use of storage heaters were highlighted as immediate opportunities to reduce peak demand and lower household costs.

​

  • Participants emphasised the need for innovative approaches to transport and charging infrastructure. Community-owned EV charging hubs, shared transport models, and partnerships between public and private sectors could improve accessibility for households without driveways. While hydrogen and larger-scale electrification may be viable for buses and ferries, community-scale solutions were viewed as more practical and impactful in the short to medium term.

​

  • There is also significant opportunity to reuse and redistribute waste energy, particularly from data centres and large developments. Models such as Deep Green, where waste heat is returned to local homes and businesses, were seen as promising examples of how infrastructure investment could directly benefit nearby communities, reduce fuel bills, and improve energy justice — if planned transparently and in collaboration with residents.

​

  • Finally, participants stressed that long-term success depends on community inclusion, improved energy literacy, and local leadership in planning processes. Involving communities in Distribution Future Energy Scenarios (DFES), strengthening local representation, and investing in education and awareness would enable informed decision-making and local ownership. With clear governance, accountability, and genuine partnership, rural communities can move from being passive recipients of infrastructure to active leaders in a fair, local energy transition.

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

10 of 22

​

�What practical changes in transport whether local, regional, or national could reduce fuel poverty in the Highlands?

​

​

​

Facilitated by Kashvi Gupta

#2050StartsNow

11 of 22

Barriers

  • ​
  • High car dependency is a major driver of fuel poverty in the Highlands. Many households rely on two or even three vehicles due to long distances, limited services, and lack of alternatives. The cost of fuel, insurance, maintenance, and replacement places significant financial pressure on already vulnerable households, reinforcing the cycle of transport-related fuel poverty.

​

  • Inadequate infrastructure is a critical barrier to change. Public EV charging is extremely limited, and many homes do not have private driveways or dedicated parking to install chargers. Planning and installation processes are slow and inconsistent, while funding for rural charging networks is minimal. Councils are attempting to act but lack the necessary financial and technical support, leaving many communities without viable low-carbon transport options.

​

  • Public transport is currently not a realistic alternative for most rural residents. Services are often slow, infrequent, poorly connected, and expensive, making them impractical for work, education, healthcare, or daily needs. National transport policy is largely designed around urban and Central Belt conditions and does not reflect the realities of dispersed Highland communities, where greater distances and lower population density require a fundamentally different approach.

​

  • Finally, behavioural, geographical, and governance issues compound these barriers. Steep terrain, long travel distances, and extreme weather make active travel difficult, while a lack of coordination and accountability between government, developers and transport bodies stalls progress. Marginalised communities are frequently overlooked in planning, and excessive communication without concrete action has contributed to mistrust, fragmentation, and a lack of meaningful change on the ground.

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

12 of 22

Solutions

  • ​
  • Addressing transport-related fuel poverty in the Highlands requires a fundamental shift away from private car dependency and toward affordable, shared, and community-led mobility options. Expanding community transport, car clubs, and demand-responsive services can reduce the need for multiple vehicles per household, lowering overall transport and fuel costs for residents.

​

  • A significant and targeted investment in rural EV and charging infrastructure is also essential. Installing charging points in every public car park, developing community-owned charging hubs, and supporting council-led delivery would improve access for households without private driveways. These systems could be strengthened through hybrid and microgrid solutions, linking local renewables with battery storage to increase resilience and reduce operating costs.

​

  • Public transport must be reimagined for a rural context, rather than adapted from urban models. Greater investment in Highland rail and community bus networks, along with initiatives such as split-ticketing, fare caps, and travel passes, would make low-carbon transport more affordable and realistic. Supporting innovative models already operating in the region, such as community and low-emissions bus services, can provide scalable, locally appropriate solutions.

​

  • Finally, transport reform must be integrated into wider economic and energy planning. Improving access to jobs, apprenticeships and services locally will reduce the need for long-distance travel, while strengthening links between transport and local energy systems including microgrids and battery storage can improve resilience during outages. By placing communities at the centre of planning, transport can become a powerful tool for tackling fuel poverty, rather than a barrier to opportunity.

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

13 of 22

How can retrofitting support all three pillars of sustainability? Why is it still not reaching or helping many Highland households and what’s standing in the way?

​

​

Facilitated by Manas Disoriya

#2050StartsNow

14 of 22

Barriers

  • Retrofitting in the Highlands is constrained by limited local capacity and outdated infrastructure. Many communities lack accredited installers in the region, with most qualified contractors based in the Central Belt. This creates delays, higher costs, and a reliance on external labour that does not always understand local building types, heritage considerations or climate conditions. Transport, logistics and poor road access further increase the complexity and expense of retrofit projects, making them less attractive and harder to scale.

​

  • Economic and funding barriers continue to block widespread uptake. Funds like ECO4 is intended to support low-income and fuel-poor households, it is often poorly aligned with rural and off-grid realities. Complex eligibility rules, fragmented delivery through large energy suppliers, reliance on intermediaries and a lack of whole-house funding options mean that many Highland households either do not qualify or cannot access it in practice. Funding pathways remain confusing and short-term, discouraging both homeowners and contractors from engaging with long-term retrofit solutions.

​

  • Social and cultural factors also inhibit progress. Low energy literacy, misinformation and distrust of external contractors create hesitation, particularly among older and vulnerable residents. There is a widespread perception that change is risky, complicated or not worth the disruption. Many households wait for a “perfect solution,” delaying action even where smaller, phased improvements could make a significant difference. Local voices are still not consistently embedded in decision-making, and the absence of trusted community liaison roles deepens this disconnect.

​

  • Finally, policy and skills misalignment continues to restrict impact. National retrofit frameworks are not designed for scattered rural settlements, heritage properties or non-traditional housing stock common in the Highlands. Unstable policy signals and stop-start funding undermine confidence in the sector, preventing sustained investment in training and apprenticeships. Without a stable long-term strategy, clear rural retrofit standards and a locally embedded workforce, the region remains locked out of the full social, environmental and economic benefits of retrofitting.

​

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

15 of 22

Solutions

  • Retrofitting can become a powerful tool to tackle fuel poverty in the Highlands if it is designed around place, people, and local delivery. A shift towards community-led, locally coordinated retrofit programmes would ensure that solutions reflect the realities of Highland housing, climate and geography. Establishing locally based retrofit hubs, supported by trusted community liaison officers, would help bridge the gap between households, installers and policymakers while building trust and improving engagement.

​

  • Funds like ECO4 model must be rural-proofed to reach those who need it most. Simplifying the application process, widening eligibility for off-grid and hard-to-treat homes, and supporting whole-house, phased retrofits would make the scheme far more effective in the Highlands. Community and local authority-led aggregation of homes could create economies of scale, attracting funding that individual households would otherwise miss. Reforming ECO4 so that it supports long-term, area-based programmes rather than fragmented, supplier-led delivery could unlock meaningful, scalable change.

​

  • Building local skills and workforce capacity is essential to make retrofitting viable. Investing in place-based training, apprenticeships and upskilling for young people and career-changers would increase the number of accredited installers in the region and keep economic value within communities. Recognising transferable skills from construction and oil and gas, alongside reducing the cost and complexity of accreditation, would make it easier for local tradespeople to enter the retrofit sector. Over time, this would strengthen supply chains, reduce costs and create sustainable, local employment.

​

  • Finally, progress depends on strong, stable policy and long-term investment. A clear, consistent retrofit roadmap for the Highlands, aligned with national targets but tailored to rural realities, would give communities and contractors the confidence to plan and invest. Integrating retrofitting with wider goals – such as health improvement, carbon reduction and economic resilience – will ensure it delivers across all three pillars of sustainability. By placing trust in communities and enabling them with the right tools, funding and skills, retrofitting can move from a barrier to a cornerstone of a just transition in the Highlands.

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

16 of 22

​

What would it take to get the right people skilled to tackle fuel poverty in the Highlands and who should be leading the effort?

​

​

​

Facilitated by Ainya Taylor

#2050StartsNow

17 of 22

Barriers

  • Training opportunities for the green and retrofit sectors are largely central-belt focused, making them physically, financially and logistically inaccessible for many in the Highlands. Programmes are often not tailored to the realities of rural, island and Highland environments, where building types, climate conditions and community needs are distinct. As a result, there is a persistent skills gap in areas such as retrofit, insulation, heat pump installation and energy efficiency, despite urgent local need.

​

  • Leadership and coordination remain fragmented. There is no clear, consistent direction on who is responsible for driving workforce development in response to fuel poverty, and short-term funding cycles prevent long-term planning. Previous boom-and-bust patterns in energy investment have undermined confidence, while responsibility is dispersed across government bodies, developers, organisations and communities, resulting in a lack of accountability and strategic focus.

​

  • A skills mismatch further limits progress. Although many workers from industries such as oil and gas possess transferable skills, there is insufficient support to help them transition into local green roles. At the same time, green jobs are not always well-paid enough to offset the high cost of living in the Highlands, and the expense of retraining and certification places further barriers on entry. The transient nature of the workforce and the need for rural contractors to be multi-skilled only deepens these challenges.

​

  • Finally, young people and local knowledge are underutilised. Barriers around housing, education, social opportunities and career pathways continue to push young people away from the region. Local knowledge of buildings, climate and community dynamics is often overlooked in favour of external expertise, reinforcing the disconnect between national strategies and lived reality. Without a clearer pathway for participation, training and leadership, communities are left excluded from shaping the very transition that most affects them.

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

18 of 22

Solutions

  • Tackling fuel poverty through workforce development in the Highlands requires a shift to place-based, community-centred training models. Training must be brought to where people live, delivered through local hubs and partnerships that reflect the realities of rural housing, climate and infrastructure. By embedding practical skills in retrofit, renewable installation and energy efficiency within local communities, barriers to access can be reduced while building long-term regional capacity.

​

  • Clear and coordinated leadership is essential. Communities should be the strongest voice in shaping priorities, supported by trusted local organisations, local authorities and a national coordinating body to provide strategic direction and stability. Moving away from short-term funding cycles towards long-term, predictable investment will allow for confident planning, continuity of programmes and a clear pathway for individuals and organisations to engage in the transition.

​

  • Targeted support for workforce transition will unlock significant potential. Workers from sectors such as oil and gas already possess valuable, transferable skills that can be redirected into green jobs with the right training, mentoring and financial support. Removing unnecessary barriers to qualification, reducing certification costs and recognising prior learning can accelerate this transition, while making rural green careers more viable and attractive.

​

  • Finally, young people must be placed at the centre of the solution. Integrating climate, energy and community learning into schools, creating apprenticeships and paid pathways into the sector, and strengthening youth engagement initiatives will ensure the next generation is empowered to lead. By valuing local knowledge, investing in long-term opportunity and aligning skills development with community need, the Highlands can build a resilient, locally-led workforce at the heart of a just transition.

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

19 of 22

Overview of Barriers

  • Despite producing a large share of Scotland’s renewable energy, the Highlands experience some of the highest levels of fuel poverty, driven by isolation, off-grid living and reliance on expensive, outdated fuels such as oil, LPG and coal. Poor housing insulation, an ageing population, and weak infrastructure compound the issue, while the value of locally generated energy flows out of the region, leaving communities with little ownership, little trust, and minimal long-term benefit.

​

  • Even where communities could become energy self-sufficient, grid constraints, restrictive regulations, and the prioritisation of large-scale developments block progress. In sparsely populated areas, demand rarely matches supply, and confusing connection processes, poor data mapping, and fragmented accountability make it extremely difficult for community-led or microgrid solutions to move beyond the planning stage. As a result, communities are excluded from the very energy transition happening around them.

​

  • Transport further deepens this inequality. Long distances and limited services force many households to rely on multiple private vehicles, driving up fuel and living costs. Public transport is unreliable, slow and urban-focused, while EV infrastructure is sparse, inaccessible for those without driveways, and underfunded in rural areas. For many, low-carbon transport remains unreachable, locking communities into car dependency.

​

  • Retrofitting is constrained by high upfront costs, limited local capacity and complex funding systems, with schemes such as ECO4 often failing to reach rural and off-grid households. A shortage of trusted local installers, low energy literacy, and fear of disruption slow uptake, while inconsistent policy, fragmented delivery and poor alignment with rural housing types prevent the scale of action needed to meaningfully reduce fuel poverty.

​

  • Finally, a lack of clear leadership and accessible pathways is stalling workforce development. Training remains centralised, costly and poorly aligned with rural needs, while fragmented responsibility and short-term funding prevent long-term planning. Although transferable skills exist, support for transition is limited and young people continue to leave, unable to see a clear future in the green economy unfolding around them. Without targeted investment in local skills, apprenticeships and long-term career pathways, the region will struggle to deliver or benefit from its own transition.

​

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

20 of 22

Overview of Solutions

  • ​
  • Addressing fuel poverty in the Highlands requires that communities closest to renewable energy are placed first, not last, in line to benefit. This means embedding local ownership, shared value and long-term community investment into every renewable development, alongside targeted support for energy efficiency, affordable heat and local power use. A just transition must move away from extractive models and towards place-based, people-centred energy systems that keep wealth, power and decision-making within the region.

​

  • In off-grid and rural areas, community-led and decentralised energy models offer a clear path forward. Supporting the development of microgrids, local battery storage, and shared generation systems would reduce reliance on the national grid while increasing resilience and affordability. This must be matched with planning and regulatory reform that prioritises small-scale, community ownership models, improves local demand mapping and removes barriers to connection, allowing innovative, self-sufficient systems to finally move from vision to reality.

​

  • Transport reform must focus on reducing car dependency while expanding accessible, low-carbon alternatives. Community and shared transport schemes, demand-responsive services, and car clubs can lower household costs and reduce isolation. Investment in rural EV charging particularly in public car parks and community hubs alongside improved, affordable public transport and integrated ticketing, would provide realistic, cost-effective travel options designed specifically for remote and dispersed communities.

​

  • Retrofitting must become a coordinated, large-scale, community-led effort rather than fragmented individual projects. By rural-proofing ECO4 and other funding schemes, simplifying access and allowing community or local authority-led aggregation of homes, retrofit can be delivered at scale where it is most needed. Establishing local retrofit hubs, improving energy literacy, and prioritising whole-house approaches will reduce heat loss, lower bills and significantly improve health and living conditions.

​

  • Finally, a just transition in the Highlands will only succeed if it is built by a locally skilled, empowered and supported workforce. Bringing training into communities, expanding apprenticeships, recognising transferable skills and removing financial barriers to qualifications will create clear, accessible pathways into green careers. By placing young people at the centre, valuing local knowledge and offering long-term, meaningful employment, the Highlands can move from being a site of extraction to a leader in a people-powered energy transition.

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

21 of 22

Next Steps

  • These findings will shape the next stage of engagement led by 2050 Climate Group. The results will be shared with key stakeholders across government, industry, local authorities, and communities to strengthen understanding of the lived realities of fuel poverty in the Highlands and to ensure future decision-making is rooted in lived experience, local knowledge, and regional need.

​

  • Building on these insights, 2050 Climate Group will launch a social justice campaign for a just transition, placing Highland communities at the centre of energy, transport, retrofit and workforce planning. This campaign will call for greater transparency, shared ownership, targeted investment, and rural-specific policies that ensure those living closest to renewable developments are not left behind, but among the first to benefit.

​

  • These findings will also form the backbone of a documentary, using lived experience, expert insight and youth voice to turn evidence into a powerful call to action. The film will highlight key barriers, elevate community-led solutions and challenge the disconnect between policy, industry and those most impacted by fuel poverty.

​

  • Through a combined programme of campaigning, storytelling and partnership-building, this work will bridge the gap between government, industry and communities, accelerating progress towards Scotland’s 2040 fuel poverty targets and ensuring the transition is fair, inclusive and rooted in lived experience.

​

​

​

​

​

#2050StartsNow

22 of 22

2050.scot

#2050StartsNow

Thank you for your contributions!