1 of 44

SESSION 3: The PO-CLO Alignment Process Based on AUN-QA

Donato O. Abaya, EdD

2 of 44

SESSION ROADMAP

AUN-QA Lens: POs, COs, and why alignment matters

PART 1

Writing Measurable COs using Bloom’s Taxonomy

PART 2

Constructive Alignment: POs – COs – TLA – Assessment

PART 3

PO – CO Mapping and checking alignment

PART

3 of 44

PART 1�AUN-QA Lens: POs, COs, and Why Alignment Matters

4 of 44

1.1. Terms to remember

Course Outcomes (COs) – What a student SHOULD be able TO DO at the END of a specific course (Research in Psycholoy)

Program Outcomes (POs) – What a graduate of the whole degree is expected to know, do, and be after finishing the program (BS Psychology)

University VMGO

National Qualifications Framework (PQF Level 6 for BS)

Professional / Discipline Standards (CHED CMO, PAP Guidelines, RA 10029)

5 of 44

1.2. AUN-QA Expectations

Clear, measurable POs and COs

A mapping showing how each course contributes to each PO

Evidence that TLA and assessment tasks really assess the COs

Appropriate cognitive level (e.g., a fourth year BS Psychology COs should not be stuck at “define” and ”recall”)

6 of 44

1.3. Example: PO vs CO in BS Psychology

PO

CO

PO 1: Apply psychological theories and scientific methods to understand and explain human behavior in diverse cultural and social contexts.

By the end of the course, students should be able to:

​

  1. Differentiate major quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods research designs in psychology in terms of their purpose, data collection procedures, and strengths and limitations;
  2. Evaluate the methodological quality of published psychological research articles using a structured appraisal checklist that covers sampling, design, measurement, ethics, and data analysis;
  3. Design a basic psychological research proposal that is ethical, feasible, and responsive to a locally relevant psychological issue, following APA format;
  4. Communicate research ideas clearly through an APA-style written proposal and oral presentation appropriate for an academic audience

Research in Psychology

7 of 44

PART II �Writing Measurable COs using Bloom’s Taxonomy

8 of 44

2.1. Characteristics of a Good CO

Student-centered: focuses on what the student will be able to do

Observable and measurable: uses ACTION VERBS

Specific but not too small: not just one tiny task

Aligned: with the course level and program outcomes

9 of 44

10 of 44

Examples: (action verb; what; context or condition)

CLO 1 - Analyze

  • Differentiate quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods research designs in psychology in terms of their purpose, data collection procedures, and strength and limitations

CLO - Evaluate

  • Evaluate the methodological quality of published psychological research articles using a structured appraisal checklist that covers sampling, design, measurement, ethics, and data analysis.

11 of 44

Examples: (action verb; what; context or condition)

CLO 3 - Create

  • Design a basic psychological research proposal that is ethical, feasible, and responsive to a locally relevant psychological issue, following APA format;

CLO 4 - Apply

  • Communicate proposed research study through an APA-style written proposal and oral presentation appropriate for an academic audience

​

12 of 44

2.2.

13 of 44

14 of 44

15 of 44

2.3. Non-measurable vs measurable COs

❌ understand psychological disorders

✅ explain the major diagnostic criteria for common psychological disorders using DSM/ICD frameworks

​

❌ expose to psychological tests

✅ administer and score selected psychological tests according to standardized procedures

​

16 of 44

PART III�Constructive Alignment: POs – COs – ILOs – TLA – Assessment

17 of 44

18 of 44

19 of 44

20 of 44

21 of 44

22 of 44

23 of 44

24 of 44

25 of 44

26 of 44

27 of 44

28 of 44

29 of 44

Aspect (Teaching & Learning Approach)

Active Learning

Lifelong Learning

Main focus in TLA

How the course is delivered now so that students are actively engaged in learning.

How the course develops habits and skills that enable students to keep learning beyond the course/program.

Role in AUN-QA TLA criterion

Strong, explicit: panels expect student-centered, active learning strategies (not lecture-only) aligned with CLOs.

Indirect but important: TLA should cultivate self-directed learning, reflection, and responsibility for one’s own learning.

30 of 44

Aspect (Teaching & Learning Approach)

Active Learning

Lifelong Learning

Student role

Students are co-constructors of learning: they discuss, solve problems, analyze cases, do projects, reflect in class.

Students become self-regulated learners: they plan, monitor, and evaluate their own learning; they seek resources beyond what is given.

Teacher role

From 'sage on the stage' to facilitator/coach/guide who designs engaging activities and provides feedback.

Mentor for independent learning: models learning habits, encourages curiosity, guides students in setting learning goals and strategies.

31 of 44

Aspect (Teaching & Learning Approach)

Active Learning

Lifelong Learning

Typical methods (TLA)

Group discussions, debates, problem-based learning (PBL), case studies, role plays, labs, simulations, community engagement, flipped classroom.

Inquiry-based projects, independent research, capstone/thesis, portfolios, learning contracts, self-paced online modules, reflective journals.

Type of tasks

Tasks that require students to use, apply, analyze, evaluate, or create (not just listen and copy notes).

Tasks that require students to plan their work, search for information, manage time, and reflect on what/how they learned.

32 of 44

33 of 44

Constructive Alignment: PO–CO–ILO-TLA–Assessment (Research Methods in Psychology)�

Program Outcome (PO)

Course Outcome (CO) & Bloom Level

Topic Learning Outcomes

Sample Topic

Aligned Teaching–Learning Activities (TLA)

PO1�Apply psychological theories and scientific methods to understand and explain human behavior in diverse cultural and social contexts.

CLO2 �Evaluate the methodological quality of published psychological research articles using a structured appraisal checklist that covers sampling, design, measurement, ethics, and data analysis.

ILO

Explain at least three methodological strengths and three limitations in a selected published psychological research article, focusing on sampling, design, measurement, ethics, and data analysis using a structured appraisal checklist

Critiquing Methodological Quality of Psychology Articles

  • Pre-class reading of a selected psychological research article
  • Mini-lecture on methodological quality criteria: sampling, design, measurement, ethics, and analysis.
  • Guided article critique workshop: students work in small groups to apply a structured appraisal checklist to the article, section by section (Method, Results, Ethics).
  • Class “journal club” discussion where groups present their identified strengths and limitations and respond to questions from peers and teacher.

34 of 44

Constructive Alignment: PO–CO–ILO-TLA–Assessment (Research Methods in Psychology)�

Program Outcome (PO)

Course Outcome (CO) & Bloom Level

Topic Learning Outcomes

Sample Topic

Aligned Teaching–Learning Activities (TLA)

PO1�Apply psychological theories and scientific methods to understand and explain human behavior in diverse cultural and social contexts.

CLO 3 – Design a basic psychological research proposal that is ethical, feasible within one semester, and responsive to a locally relevant psychological issue, following APA format.

ILO

draft a complete Method section for a proposed study on a locally relevant psychological issue that is feasible and observes basic ethical principles.

Designing a Feasible and Ethical Method Section for a Research Proposal

  • Brainstorming activity on locally relevant psychological issues;
  • Instructor input/mini-lecture on components of a good Method section and checks for feasibility and ethics.
  • Analysis of exemplar Method sections from previous theses/articles: students highlight features that make them clear, feasible, and ethical.
  • Writing workshop: students draft their own Method section for a chosen topic; teacher roams and gives formative feedback.
  • Short peer review activity using a checklist.

35 of 44

36 of 44

37 of 44

38 of 44

39 of 44

40 of 44

Constructive Alignment: PO–CO–ILO-TLA–Assessment (Research Methods in Psychology)�

Course Outcome (CO) & Bloom Level

Topic Learning Outcomes

Sample Topic

Aligned Teaching–Learning Activities (TLA)

Assessment Tasks

CLO2 �Evaluate the methodological quality of published psychological research articles using a structured appraisal checklist that covers sampling, design, measurement, ethics, and data analysis.

ILO

Explain at least three methodological strengths and three limitations in a selected published psychological research article, focusing on sampling, design, measurement, ethics, and data analysis using a structured appraisal checklist

Critiquing Methodological Quality of Psychology Articles

  • Pre-class reading of a selected psychological research article
  • Mini-lecture on methodological quality criteria: sampling, design, measurement, ethics, and analysis.
  • Guided article critique workshop: students work in small groups to apply a structured appraisal checklist to the article, section by section (Method, Results, Ethics).
  • Class “journal club” discussion where groups present their identified strengths and limitations and respond to questions from peers and teacher.
  • Individual Research Critique Paper (2–3 pages) applying the checklist to the article, ending with an overall methodological judgment.
  • Rubric assesses correct identification of issues, depth of reasoning, and appropriate use of methodological concepts.

41 of 44

Constructive Alignment: PO–CO–ILO-TLA–Assessment (Research Methods in Psychology)�

Course Outcome (CO) & Bloom Level

Topic Learning Outcomes

Sample Topic

Aligned Teaching–Learning Activities (TLA)

Assessment Task

CLO 3 – Design a basic psychological research proposal that is ethical, feasible within one semester, and responsive to a locally relevant psychological issue, following APA format.

ILO

draft a complete Method section for a proposed study on a locally relevant psychological issue that is feasible and observes basic ethical principles.

Designing a Feasible and Ethical Method Section for a Research Proposal

  • Brainstorming activity on locally relevant psychological issues;
  • Instructor input/mini-lecture on components of a good Method section and checks for feasibility and ethics.
  • Analysis of exemplar Method sections from previous theses/articles: students highlight features that make them clear, feasible, and ethical.
  • Writing workshop: students draft their own Method section for a chosen topic; teacher roams and gives formative feedback.
  • Short peer review activity using a checklist.
  • Draft Method section (1–2 pages) submitted as a checkpoint exercise, graded for alignment with research question, feasibility, and ethical soundness.
  • Integrated into a Final Research Proposal, graded with a rubric (relevance, clarity, appropriateness of design, feasibility, ethical considerations, APA format).

42 of 44

43 of 44

WORKSHOP PROPER

44 of 44

Goal: Produce one stronger and model syllabus that is AUN-AQ compliant and student-centered

Program Outcomes

Course Outcome (CO)

Topic Learning Outcomes

Topic

Teaching–Learning Activities

Assessment Task

​

  • Action Verb + What + Condition/Context
  • Action Verb + What + Condition/Context

​

  • Per Chapter with sub-topics
  • How you ensure learning takes place
  • How you check learning

Consider this question from AUN-QA Assessor: ”Can you show me where in your course students really demonstrate this CO?

​

Note: You must confidently point to specific activities and assessment tasks?