1 of 15

An Exploratory Study of School Climate and the Elementary Teachers’ Sense of Well-being

Lenelle E. Taylor, Ed.D. & Karen Stansberry Beard, Ph.D.

The University Council of Educational Administration

1

2 of 15

Many educators are experiencing increased degrees of stress and unprecedented challenges in the aftermath of the global pandemic

(Beard et al., 2021; Farley & Chamberlain, 2021).

Gimbert et al. (2021) describes actions principals and counselors should take to create a culture of well-being in school where the social-emotional competence is a priority. It is recommended that there be training in these areas for school leaders and staffs: hope, mindfulness, and self-efficacy to address educators developing self-regulatory practices and learning to increase their knowledge and skills regarding their own social-emotional learning.

Nevarez and Wood (2007) suggest urban school leaders and teachers can change many of the negative conditions in schools such as underachievement by cultivating a positive school climate.

Introduction

2

2

3 of 15

Many educators are experiencing increased degrees of stress and unprecedented challenges in the aftermath of the global pandemic

(Beard et al., 2021; Farley & Chamberlain, 2021).

Gimbert et al. (2021) describes actions principals and counselors should take to create a culture of well-being in school where the social-emotional competence is a priority. It is recommended that there be training in these areas for school leaders and staffs: hope, mindfulness, and self-efficacy to address educators developing self-regulatory practices and learning to increase their knowledge and skills regarding their own social-emotional learning.

Nevarez and Wood (2007) suggest urban school leaders and teachers can change many of the negative conditions in schools such as underachievement by cultivating a positive school climate.

Introduction

2

3

4 of 15

Background

Turnover creates instability in schools

Prolonged stress leads to burnout

School leaders must support teacher social- emotional competence

School Climate /Teacher Well-being

Teacher Turnover

Is costly financially, academically, socially emotionally for school

Up to $20,000 in annual cost

Teacher Stress

Is a serious concern, frustration, anxiety, poor performance, and negativity

Turnover is 50% greater in urban schools than suburban

Gimbert et al. 2021

Darling-Hammond, 2012

4

5 of 15

Problem Statement

How can principals influence school climates to support teacher well-being?

5

6 of 15

  • Conducted with 134 urban elementary school teachers in
  • Grades K-5

  • To examine the relationship between school climate and the elementary teachers’ sense of well-being

  • Oct ’22 to Nov ‘22
  • Large urban school district in central Ohio

05

01

02

03

04

PURPOSE

QUANTITATIVE

TIMELINE & LOCATION

PARTICIPANT INPUT

  • Two self-reporting survey instruments
    • ‘PERMA profiler- well-being measure
    • OCDQ-RE- school climate measure

TOOLS

  • 134 Respondents 42-question online climate survey(OCDQ-RE)
  • PERMA Profiler 23 questionnaire for the well-being

The Study Details

6

7 of 15

Research Questions & Hypotheses

7

Research Questions

Hypotheses

1. Is there a correlation between an elementary teacher’s sense of PERMAH and school climate?

H 1: The greater the degree of support from principals to teachers in the school climate the greater the degree of the teacher’s sense of well-being.

H0 : There is no difference in the support of teachers in the school climate in relation to the teacher’s sense of well-being.

2. What relationships exist between the dimensions of school climate and the dimensions of well-being?

H2: School climate is significantly correlated to teacher's sense of well-being.

H0: There is no relationship between school climate and the teachers’ sense of well-being.

7

8 of 15

8

Well-being/ PERMA-H Descriptors

Complete absorption in an activity, living in the moment, fully immersed in the present and current experience with a loss of self-awareness or self-consciousness

Feeling loved, supported and valued by others. Relationships are important because humans are social beings

Feeling good, hopeful and inspired by the things we do and the life we live

Engagement:

Relationships:

Positive Emotions:

Accomplishment/ Achievement:

Working toward and reaching goals

Health- being physically healthy

Meaning:

Gives purpose to life. The need to have a sense of value or worth

8

9 of 15

Organizational Climate-The “feel” of the school

9

Principal Behavior Dimensions

Teacher Behavior Dimensions

Supportive

Demonstrating care and concern for teachers, listening to teachers, and being open to their suggestions. Praises teachers genuinely and frequently, Provides constructive criticism, and respects teachers’ professional expertise and ability. Has both a professional and personal interest in teachers.

Collegial

Collegial behaviors support open and professional interactions among teachers. Teachers are proud of their school, enjoy working with colleagues, and are enthusiastic, accepting, and mutually respectful of the professional competence of colleagues.

Directive

The principal is rigid and closely supervises with constant control over the teacher and school activities. Every detail is handled by the principal.

Intimate

Teacher behaviors reflect a cohesive and strong network of social support among the faculty. Teachers know each other well, have close personal friendships, socialize regularly, and provide strong support for each other.

Restrictive

Behavior that restricts, hinders rather than facilitates teacher work. The principal burdens teachers with responsibilities that interfere with teaching duties.

Disengaged

Lack of meaning and focus on professional activities. The teacher is putting in minimal effort. The teacher is negative about the school and colleagues. The teacher’s goals are not congruent with the school community.

9

10 of 15

Key Points from Literature Review

What leadership and teacher behaviors contribute to an open and supportive organizational climate?

4

SCHOOL CLIMATE WELL-BEING

  • Difficult to define

School climate is difficult to define. Hoy operationalized school climate and founds that a positive and supportive school climate is conducive to collegiality, supported teachers, and positive professional and personal relationships between principals and teachers (Hoy & Tarter, 1992).

1

The principal is positioned to be the single most important person affecting school climate (Hoy et al., 1991).

2

Some tenets of school climate remain consistent throughout climate studies such as; relationships and teaching and learning (NSCC, 2021; Hoy et al., 1991; Appleby & Hoy, 1986; Anderson, 1982)

3

PERMA( H)

Positive Emotions: Feeling good, hopeful, and inspired by the things we do and the life we live

Engagement: Complete absorption in an activity, living in the moment, fully immersed in the present and current experience with a loss of self-awareness or self-consciousness

Relationships: Feeling loved, supported, and valued by others. Relationships

4

Meaning: Give purpose to life. The need to have a sense of value or worth

Accomplishment: Working toward and reaching goals

Health: Good Physical

5

10

11 of 15

Findings- Correlation Analysis

Pearson Correlations of School Climate Survey and Well-Being Survey

  • Highest correlations were between teacher to teacher intimacy with multiple dimensions of well-being
  • Additionally, moderate correlations were also found between collegial teacher-to-teacher behavior and well-being- 3.15 and PERMA and intimate teacher to teacher relationships. There is a small correlation between supportive principal behviors and teacher well being(.213)

11

12 of 15

Findings cont. Correlation-r examples

12

Positive Correlations with Well-being Dimensions/ Other Correlations

Comments

Intimate Teacher to Teacher Behavior and Accomplishment

r=.365, p=<.01

Moderate positive correlation(2 tailed**)

Teacher to Teacher Disengaged Behavior to Negative Emotions

r=.343, p=<.01

Teacher to Teacher Intimate Relations Positive Emotions

r=.338, p=<.01

Supportive Principal behaviors with Positive Emotions

r=.315, p=<.01

Teacher to Teacher Intimate Behavior and Relations

r=.311, p=<.01

Collegial Relation with Positive Emotions

r=.309, p=<.01

Correlations with negative or less than moderation relations

Supportive Principal Behaviors and Negative Emotions

r=-.333, p=<.0.01

Moderate negative correlation

Directive Principal Behaviors and Relationships

r=.002, p=<0.05

Less than moderate correlation

Supportive Principal Behaviors and Relationships

r=.103, p=<0.05

Restrictive Principal Behaviors and Loneliness

r=.117, p=<0.05

Collegial Teacher to Teacher Relationships and Happiness

r=.170, p=<0.05

Intimate Teacher to Teacher Relationships and Health

r=.229, p=<0.01

Disengaged Teacher to Teacher Behavior and Loneliness

r=.231,p=<0.01

Correlation is significant at 0.01 , (2 tailed)

12

13 of 15

Discussion and Implications

13

Discussion

Implications

  • Improving school climates by strengthening working relationship teacher to teacher is an investment in teacher social-emotional competence

  • Darling-Hammond and DePaoli (2020) explain that if we want teachers to improve outcomes for students, there must be an investment in professional development around school climate

  • Increasing interdisciplinary teaming and co-teaching partnership is a means to greater collegial relationships and teacher intimacy
  • There are supportive practices principals can employ to moderately impact well-being(listening, bonding, respect professional practice and give quality feedback, open to suggestion)
  • Collegial relationships support positive emotions Teachers should be encouraged to withdraw from isolated practices and to form teams
  • Negative emotions decrease as engagement increases.School leaders can intentional about finding teacher interests to strengthen engagement
  • Further investigation on school climate and teacher social-emotional competence is needed

13

14 of 15

14

14

15 of 15

15

15