1 of 33

Spotlight Series:

Mathematical Generalising

Secondary

Julia Crawford

jcrawford@cognitioneducation.com

​

Senior Education Consultant

Cognition Education

​

Click on the cameo to play the recorded message

2 of 33

Spotlight abstract

The intention of this resource is to provide opportunities for groups of teachers to explore different ideas that are highlighted in the refreshed New Zealand Mathematics and Statistics curriculum. This Spotlight focus is on Generalising.

What to expect? A mix of Video, Discussion Questions and Classroom Activities, and planning time. I aim, asynchronously, to help you to:

  • unpack what ‘Generalising’ is in mathematics and statistics
  • consider how we support teachers and students to make maths and stats generalisations
  • explore some activities that support making generalising
  • consider some pedagogical factors when teaching and learning to generalise.

​

3 of 33

Outline with possible timings

Slide

Topic and Activities

Timing

4

Activity 1 Brainstorm

10 mins

5 - 7

Link to curriculum & Thinking Mathematically

​

8

Activity 2 Warm up: Warehouse

5 mins

9 - 10

Activity 3 Let’s go deeper

15- 20 mins

11 - 14

Specialising and generalising

​

15 - 16

Activity 4 Your turn

15 mins

17 - 19

Phases of work

​

20

Activity 5 Feelings

5 mins

21 - 26

Teaching generalising with top tips

​

27 - 28

Where to find activities

​

29

Activity 6 Explore nrich

10 mins

30 - 31

Plenary and where to find further info

​

4 of 33

Activity 1 What is Generalising?

Brainstorm�

Record your groups’ ideas on a whiteboard.

We will refer to this at the end of the workshop.

(take a photo or leave on the board for later)

5 of 33

Mathematics & Statistics Learning Area Curriculum

6 of 33

Thinking Mathematically

Generalisations are the life-blood of mathematics.

  • A specific result is useful but the general result gives more insight and application to more situations.
  • Generalising starts when you sense an underlying pattern
  • Looking at a range of systematic examples, we gather evidence on which the generalisation is made.

7 of 33

Generalisation

Generalisation is part of doing maths (mathematical and statistical processes) and involves ‘working like a mathematician’.

· The essence of generalising is finding a strategy or method that always works to solve a specific type of problem. The key skill in moving towards a generalisation is for students to transfer their thinking from one example to another example. The similarities and differences in the examples offer insight into what always works (the generalisation).

· Generalising involves identifying or seeing the underlying mathematical structure (e.g., patterns).

8 of 33

Activity 2 Warm up: Warehouse

How do you get to grips with the question?

Try it… get specific (e.g. $100) (specialising)

Try it again … another amount… write down your working …

Try again with a general price e.g., $P

*Thinking mathematically, Page 1

9 of 33

Activity 3 Let’s go deeper: Palindromes

STUCK?

Find some palindromes with four digits. Test it.

Is it always true? How can we be sure?

*Thinking mathematically, Page 4

10 of 33

Palindromes cont…

When I tested some examples (4 digit palindromes) it seemed to work.

But I can’t test them all!

Better to look for an underlying pattern. TRY IT NOW

STUCK?

  • What is the smallest four-digit palindrome?
  • What is the next smallest?
  • How can one palindrome be changed to another one?

11 of 33

Reflecting on specialising and generalising

Can you identify when you were specialising and/or generalising?

Generalising

Specialising

12 of 33

Linking these ideas to general curriculum topics

Yes … I know … these all look great but…

  • we don’t have time!
  • there is so much to ‘cover’!

​

What if we can use these ideas while teaching curriculum topics?

13 of 33

For example:

Learning to factorise quadratics.

Goal: students to have a general method (process) to factorise a quadratic expression with understanding.

  • Use a representation that is familiar and offers opportunities to notice the underlying structure (the area model).
  • Start with quadratics examples with all positive terms, and all prime

e.g., x2 + 7x + 6

  • The next examples could involve a constant with more factors, e.g., x2 +7x + 12
  • Explore examples where there are negative terms,

e.g., x2 - 6x - 7

14 of 33

Example continued …

Can you see how this example relates to the process of generalising?

15 of 33

Activity 4 Your turn

Identify a mathematics idea to explore (or see the ideas on the next slide)

  • Develop a set of examples that would help guide students towards making a generalisation.
  • What representations (equipment, models, diagrams) could you use?
  • Work in small groups to explore then present to each other.
  • What adaptations could you make?

​

16 of 33

Ideas to explore

Multiplying a fraction by a fraction

Find the area of a triangle

The sum of the interior angles of any polygon

Or another idea?

Increase or decrease a quantity by a percentage using a single multiplier

Anything to the power of zero is equal to 1

The location of the turning point for any quadratic in the form:

y= a (x ± h)2± k

Changing between improper fractions and mixed numbers

The chance of getting 1 head and 1 tail when I throw 2 coins is 0.5.

17 of 33

Phases of work

For any problem or investigation we can identify three distinct phases of work.

They correspond with a change in your feelings about the question and reflects the progress which is (or not) being made.

Image from: Thinking mathematically p 24

18 of 33

Entry - Attack - Review

  1. Entry
    • What do I KNOW?
    • What do I WANT?
    • What can I INTRODUCE (examples, diagrams, symbols)?
  2. Attack
    • Trying ideas
    • Making conjectures
    • Getting stuck
    • Having AHA moments
  3. Review (the phase schools usually skip)
    • CHECK the reasoning
    • REFLECT on key ideas and moments
    • EXTEND the question

The authors argue that most learning happens in Review, not in Attack.

Image from: Thinking mathematically p 96

19 of 33

Consider how our feelings change throughout investigations

Image from: Thinking mathematically p 119

20 of 33

Activity 5 Feelings

Consider how our feelings change when we are working through mathematical problem or investigation.

​

During the Palindromes Problem we did earlier

  • Did you experience different feelings at the entry, attack and review phases?

​

  • Discuss with your colleagues how teachers support their students during these phases.
  • Are there benefits for students to ‘struggle’ through a problem?
  • How do we support students to struggle?
  • Is there a balance between unproductive struggle and bailing them out too early?

​

21 of 33

Teaching

generalising

Image from: Thinking mathematically p 24

22 of 33

Why is learning to generalise important?

We need to challenge three common school practices:

❌ Over‑scaffolding

Leads to compliance, not thinking.

❌ Speed culture

Rewards quick answers, suppresses reflection.

❌ Teacher as explainer

Blocks students from noticing structure for themselves.

✅ Tasks that demand noticing

✅ Questions that create productive discomfort

✅ Teachers who delay explanation

✅ Classrooms with language for thinking states

​

23 of 33

Use the Mathematics Investigation Cycle

Explicitly teach how to engage in a investigation by using the structure in the Mathematics Investigation Cycle.

This poster and prompt cards are available on Tāhūrangi.

24 of 33

7 top tips for teachers

2. Delay explaining – provoke noticing instead�Before telling, ask students to try examples, draw diagrams, or describe what they notice. Understanding grows from their activity.

3. Use specialising before generalising�Encourage students to try simple, concrete cases first, then look for what stays the same across examples.

4. Make thinking visible with shared language�Use consistent phrases like “What do you know?”, “What do you want?”, “What have you noticed?” to scaffold thinking.

  1. Treat being stuck as productive�Normalise uncertainty and struggle; tell students that being stuck is where thinking happens, not a sign of failure.

25 of 33

Top tips for teachers continued…

5. Build in time for Review�After answers, ask students to check, reflect, and extend. This is where learning consolidates.

6. Value conjectures more than answers�Reward students for sensible guesses, partial ideas, and revised thinking – not just correctness.

7. Model curiosity and uncertainty yourself�Show students how you grapple, question, change your mind, and justify ideas; this legitimises real mathematical thinking.

​

26 of 33

Values and ethos

  • Mathematics is about relationships and interconnected ideas.
  • Everyone can conjecture, everyone can work like a mathematician, everyone can contribute valuable ideas.
  • A conjecturing atmosphere encourages students to feel comfortable about expressing their ideas.
  • Being uncertain is not something to be embarrassed about ("I'd like to hear from those who are not quite sure..."); instead it provides a springboard for discussion. This is how we make progress.

​

27 of 33

Facilitating discussion

The teacher models the questions and comments a mathematician might make and, over time, encourages students to ask these questions themselves ('scaffolding and fading'):

  • Looking at these examples, what's the same? What's different?
  • What do you think would happen if you changed ...?
  • Do you think this will always happen?
  • Does this example confirm your conjecture?
  • Can you find a counterexample?
  • What example might you try if you wanted to refute the conjecture?
  • Can you think of an 'extreme' or 'nasty' example that would be worth testing?
  • Do you agree with that conjecture? Why, or why not?
  • How could you modify your conjecture?
  • What do you think I'm going to ask you next?

28 of 33

Where to find more activities to support generalising

Thinking mathematically p 27, 33, 34

29 of 33

NRICH

30 of 33

Activity 6 Explore the resources on Nrich

Explore an activity from Nrich: https://nrich.maths.org/generalising

31 of 33

Teaching Packs on Tāhūrangi

The Mathematical and Statistical Processes page on Tāhūrangi has Teacher Guidance Packs for Phases 1 - 4 of the NZ curriculum

32 of 33

Plenary: What is Generalising?

Reflect on your brainstorm from the beginning of this workshop

  • Have you extended your definition?
  • How can you apply these ideas to your current planning?
  • What new activities can you add to your planning documents to develop generalising skills?
  • How can we support each other to develop facilitation skills to support students’ generalising?

33 of 33

Further help & resources