1 of 38

WPT System for Cooperative Robotics

Senior Design Project Proposal

Andrew Terrazas, Blake Janowicz, Jason Knight-Han

Sonoma State University Department of Engineering

Faculty Advisor: Dr. Nansong Wu

Industrial Advisor: Dr. Shun Yao (Skydio)

Client: NASA

05/05/2023

https://knightha4.wixsite.com/my-site-1

terrazasa@sonoma.edu

janowiczb@sonoma.edu

knightha@sonoma.edu

2 of 38

Overview

  • Problem Statement, Value Proposition, Existing and Proposed Solution
  • Marketing and Engineering Requirements
  • System Overview, Hardware Diagram, Software Flowchart
  • Alternate Design Matrices, Challenges and Risks
  • Tests and Results
  • Budget and Materials
  • Schedule
  • Supporting Courses

2

3 of 38

3

The problem we are exploring concerns companies and scientific missions which use Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) in collaborative systems, who desire more efficiency in remote operations. The inability to efficiently charge a cooperative UAV with tolerance for misalignment while providing robust charging capabilities reduces the efficiency of scientific missions which leaves mission planners and operators feeling frustrated.

Problem Statement

4 of 38

Our wireless charging system gives companies and scientific missions a way to wirelessly charge their UAVs in an efficient manner. The system reduces operator frustration by providing a robust charging method that is tolerant to misalignment and resistant to physical degradation, increasing available flight time.

4

Value Proposition

5 of 38

5

There are currently multiple methods for charging electric UAVs:

  • Manual battery replacement
  • Charging Contacts
    • Skydio Drone Dock™
  • Solar:
    • NASA Ingenuity
  • Inductive Charging
    • Powermat PMT 300

While these existing solutions provide high charging efficiency, they fall short in providing a robust charging system that can tolerate misalignment and different size UAVs in an autonomous system.

Existing Solutions

Pros

Cons

Method

Manual Replacement

Contact Charging

Solar Charging

Non-Resonant Wireless

Best efficiency

High efficiency, no manual interaction

Moderate efficiency, no manual interaction

No manual interaction, robust

Requires manual interaction

Requires precision, physically vulnerable

Utility only in certain locations, time of day

Low misalignment tolerance, variable efficiency

6 of 38

Proposed Solution

6

7 of 38

7

System Overview

Source

Gain/Loss

50 VDC RF Source + ENI 420L amplifier

+42 dBm [15,800 mW] max(up

Coil Loss (high power)

-0.79 dB @ 83.4%

Rx System Loss

-3.98 dB @ 40%* -0.97 dB @ 80%)

Total:

37.23 dBm [5285 mW] @ rx 40%, 40.24 dBm @ 80%

Requirement:

23 dBm (200 mW)

Margin:

14.23 dB @ rx 40%, 17.24 dBm @ rx80%

End-to-End Efficiency:

33.34%* up to 66.68% efficiency @ Rx80%

8 of 38

8

Marketing Requirements

[1] The system shall provide power transfer wirelessly.

[2] The system shall have an efficient charging cycle.

[3] The system shall allow for lateral misalignment while charging.

[4] The receiving module shall supply DC power sufficient for a small UAV battery.

[5] The transmitting module shall require no manual interaction to activate.

[6] The base module shall be able to determine the charge state of the UAV.

[7] The system shall operate in an FCC compliant manner.

[8] The transmitting module shall be contained in a UAV landing pad.

9 of 38

9

Engineering Requirements

[1 - MR 1] The system shall transfer no less than 1000 mW power wirelessly between its source and load coil under normal operating conditions.

[2 - MR 2] The power transfer efficiency between coils shall be no less than 70% at optimal alignment and displacement.

[3 - MR 3] The system shall offer lateral forgiveness up to 50mm while maintaining 60% power transfer efficiency between coils.

[4 - MR 4] The receiving system shall provide no less than 200 mW DC power to its load under optimal conditions.

[5 - MR 5] The receiving module shall activate within 50mm of the base station.

[6 - MR 6] The receiving system shall monitor load current with an accuracy of ±5 mA.

[7 - MR 7] System shall emit a specific absorption rate (SAR) and an equivalent radiated power (ERP) no higher than permitted by FCC regulation Part 18 for power transfer.

[8 - MR 8] The receiving system shall reside in an assembly no more than 16 x 20 cm² in area.

10 of 38

10

System Overview

11 of 38

11

Hardware Block Diagram

12 of 38

12

Software Design

13 of 38

Rx Microcontroller

13

Transceiver

weight

HiLetgo HC-05 Bluetooth Transceiver

HiLetgo RC522 RFID Module

HiLetgo PN532 NFC Module

Mass

0.34

0.43

0.32

0.25

Power

0.25

0.20

0.12

0.68

Size

0.23

0.43

0.26

0.31

Cost

0.17

0.34

0.46

0.20

Score

1

0.35

0.28

0.37

Alternate Design Matrices

MCU

weight

Adafruit Trinket MCU

PIC16F877A

Node MCU ESP8266

Mass

0.48

0.49

0.31

0.20

Power

0.24

0.52

0.38

0.10

Size

0.16

0.38

0.52

0.10

Cost

0.12

0.47

0.29

0.24

Score

1

0.48

0.36

0.16

Transceiver

14 of 38

14

Challenges

Previous Challenges:

RF signals from coils may interfere with external components

Limited availability of a cost-effective AC power source

Lack of experience prototyping high frequency

Current Challenges:

Different Capacitors Yield Different Results

Achieving High Efficiency with RF-DC Converter

Capacitors are in a Physically Compromised Position

Ripped capacitor

Burnt capacitor

15 of 38

15

Summary of Tests Conducted

Test #

Objective

ER addressed

Notes

FT.1 - Power Transfer Efficiency Test

Validate efficiency of power transfer under optimal alignment.

ER.2

Pass 12/06

FT.2 - Lateral Misalignment Test

Validate efficiency of power transfer under lateral misalignment.

ER.3

Pass 12/06

FT.3 - Current Detection Test

Validate ability to monitor current at output of receiving system.

ER.6

Pass 11/30

FT.4 - Data Communication Test

Validate that NFC sensing is compatible with our system.

ER.5

Pass 12/06

ST.1 - NFC Coil Power Switching Test

Validate the system requires no manual interaction to activate.

MR.5

Fail 12/06

ST.2 - Rx System Rectification Test

Validate that our receiving system supplies DC power sufficient for small UAV battery

MR.4

In Progress

Test #

Objective

ER addressed

Notes

FT.1 - Power Transfer Efficiency Test

Validate efficiency of power transfer under optimal alignment.

ER.2

Pass 12/06

FT.2 - Misalignment Test

Validate efficiency of power transfer under lateral misalignment.

ER.3

Pass 12/06

FT.3 - Current Detection Test

Validate ability to monitor current at receiving system output

within ±5 mA.

ER.6

Pass 11/30

FT.4 - Data Communication Test

Determine base system can activate within 5 cm of receiving system (w/NFC)

ER.5

Pass 12/7

ST.1 - NFC Coil Power Switching Test

Validate the system requires no manual interaction to activate.

MR.5

Fail 12/8

ST.2 - Rx System Rectification Test

Validate that our receiving system supplies DC power sufficient for small UAV battery

MR.4

Pass 03/02, 03/25

ST.3 Power Characterization Test

Characterize and determine received power across coils vs. power being supplied to the RF power amplifier

ER.1, ER. 4

Pass 03/14

Final System Verification

Validate system integration

ER.1, MR.8

Conditional

16 of 38

16

Test Results –

FT.1 - Power Transfer Efficiency Test (Low Power)

FT.1 - Power Transfer Efficiency Test

The power transfer efficiency shall be no less than 70% at optimal alignment and displacement.

ER.2

Pass 12/06

17 of 38

17

Test Results –

FT.1 - Power Transfer Efficiency Test (High Power)

  • Peak power transfer of 41.2dBm [13.2W] was observed with a efficiency of 83.4%

18 of 38

18

Test Results –

FT.2 - Misalignment Test (Low Power)

FT.2 - Misalignment Test

The system shall offer lateral forgiveness up to 50mm while maintaining 60% power transfer efficiency between coils.

ER.3

Pass 12/06

19 of 38

19

Test Results –

FT.2 - Misalignment Test (High Power)

  • 50mm - 80% power transfer efficiency
  • 80mm - 60 % power transfer efficiency
  • Test Setup

20 of 38

20

Test Results –

FT.3 - Current Detection Testing

FT.3 - Current Detection Test

Validate ability to monitor current at output of receiving system within ±5 mA.

ER.6

Pass 11/30

RANGE

ACCURACY

RESOLUTION

AC voltage

4V / 1000V

±(1.2%+5) @ 40V

1mV-1V

DC voltage

400mV / 1000V

±(1.0%+3) @ 4-400V

0.1mV-1V

AC current

400µA / 10A

±(1.5%+3)

0.1µA-0.01A

DC current

400µA / 10A

±(1.0%+3)

0.1µA-0.01A

Resistance

400Ω / 40MΩ

±(1.5%+5) @ 400Ω-400kΩ

0.1Ω-10kΩ

Frequency

10Hz / 500kHz

±(1.0%+5)

0.001-100Hz

Capacitance

40nF / 4000µF

±(3.0%+5) @ 400nF-400µF

10pF-1µF

Duty cycle

1% to 99%

±(1.2%+2)

0.1%

Temperature °F

0 / 1500

±(2.0%+9°F)

0.1-1°F

Temperature °C

-18 / 538

±(2.0%+5°C)

0.1-1°C

MM700 SPECS

N = 30

21 of 38

21

Test Results –

FT.4 - Data Communication Test

FT.4 - Data Communication Test

Validate that NFC sensing is compatible with our system.

ER.5

Pass 12/06

MM700 SPECS

22 of 38

22

Test Results –

ST.1 - NFC Coil Power Switching Test

ST.1 - NFC Coil Power Switching Test

Validate the system requires no manual interaction to activate.

MR.5

Fail 12/06

MM700 SPECS

Future:

Experiment with code for two Modules, only one Module, implement Backscatter through coils

23 of 38

23

Test Results –

ST.2 - Initial Rectification Test

ST.2 - Rx System Rectification Test

Validate that our receiving system supplies DC power at our desired operating frequency

MR.4

Pass 03/02

Conclusion:

Max available power pre-amplification (up to 25 mW) of AC signal rectified into rippled DC at desired frequency.

24 of 38

24

Test Results –

ST.2 - Final Rectification Test

ST.2 - Rx System Rectification Test

Validate that our receiving system supplies no less than 200 mW DC power to its load under optimal operating conditions

MR.4

Pass 03/25/23

25 of 38

25

Test Results –

ST.5 - Communication Test

Backscatter Communication Test

Receiving Module Shall be able to provide modulated backscatter to the Base Station Module

ER.3

Pass 01/23

26 of 38

26

Estimated Budget

REVENUE

Income (NASA Minds)

$1,500.00

Donation (RF Diagnostics LLC)

$40.00

Total Exp Income

$1,540.00

EXPENSES

Part/ Quantity

Qty#

ER/MR#

Test

Description

Link

Price

Capacitors - various types/values

1

All (ER.1)

All (ST.3)

Capacitors used in resonant circuit, modulation circuit, rectifying circuit, etc.

N/a

$77.00

80/20 Rods

1

All (ER.1)

All (ST.3)

Rods used for device housing.

$157.35

Copper Rods [4mm diameter]

1

All (ER.1)

All (ST.3)

Copper wire used for charging and communication coils.

$52.49

Copper Tape

1

All (ER.1)

All (ST.3)

Tape Used for Prototyping RF components

$14.50

HiLetgo PN532 NFC NXP RFID Module

3

ER.3

FT.4, ST.1

Used for the Rx system to communicate with the Tx system

$8.99

Adafruit Trinket M0

2

ER.6

ST.1, FT.4

Lightweight MCU for Rx system

$11.82

INA219 Current Sensor

2

ER.7

FT.3

Current sensor for Rx System

$4.25

4410 Adafruit MicroLipo Charge Controller

4

MR.4

FT.4

Module to feed DC to the battery for the Rx system (post-rectification)

$5.95

TP4056 LiPo Charger Modules

3

MR.4

FT.4

Module to feed DC to the battery for the Rx system (post-rectification)

$6.99

Various Schottky Diodes (1N5817, SB550A)

26

ER.4

ST.2

Used in rectification circuit for Rx system

$0.48

Various Zener Diodes

6

ER.4

ST.2

Used in rectification circuit for Rx system

$0.66

RFD199A-PCB RF-DC Converter

1

ER.4

ST.2

Backup module to support RF-DC rectification - low power but can be modified

$40.00

ZX60-100VH+ Low Noise Amplifier

1

All (ER.1)

All (ST.3)

36 dB 150kHz-300MHz 10W

$254.41

SMA Cable

1

Used for RF conections

$60.00

PLA 3D Printer Filament

3

Used for coil mounts and device enclosure

$18.99

Resistors - various types/values

20

All (ER.1)

All (ST.3)

Resistors used in resonant circuit, modulation circuit, rectifying circuit, etc.

N/a

$3.00

Inductors

1

All (ER.1)

All (ST.3)

Inductors used in resonant circuit, modulation circuit, rectifying circuit, etc.

N/a

$50.00

SMA Jack

1

Used for RF connections

$20.00

Protoboard

5

All (ER.1)

All (ST.3)

Used for circuit prototyping

$30.00

MISC Tools

1

All (ER.1)

All (ST.3)

Tools used for making product

N/a

$100.00

Terminal Blocks

1

Used for circuit prototyping and supplying power to circuits

$5.00

Total Cost

$1,214.19

Difference

$325.81

27 of 38

27

Schedule

Gantt Chart

On Track

Delay

28 of 38

28

Future Considerations

This project is still early in development and ripe for improvement.

Improvements in design mainly concern the efficiency of various subsystems:

Coil System:

  • Increase number of resonant coils to increase efficient bandwidth
  • Explore PCB Coil Designs
  • EIRP Measurements

Communication System:

  • Implement a more robust backscatter communication system
  • Explore different modulation schemes

Power Harvesting System:

  • Incorporate additional power-handling features including load-sharing

Build:

  • House system in a proper unit and attach receiving system onto a UAV

29 of 38

  • Microprocessors and System Design (EE 310)
  • Microelectronic Circuits (EE 334)
  • Linear Systems Theory (EE 400)
  • Electromagnetic Theory and Applications (EE 430)
  • Analog and Digital Communications (EE 442)
  • RF and Microwave Design (EE-444)

29

Supporting Courses

30 of 38

Questions/Comments?

30

Questions

Thank you:

Dr. Wu, Dr. Salem, Shahram Marivani, All other faculty members and industry advisors at SSU, Dr. Shun Yao, Asher Robbins-Rothman, and Chris with Skydio, Chris Stewart, Danny at Aerowest, Pawan at Dronegenuity, Starr Ginn with NASA’s Advanced Air Mobility Strategy, Paul Secor with NASA’s MINDS program, Dr. Tom Budka with RF Diagnostics LLC.

31 of 38

31

Demonstration

32 of 38

References

  1. Liu, Daerhan, "Novel Strongly Coupled Magnetic Resonant Systems" (2018). FIU Electronic Theses and Dissertations. 3717. https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/etd/3717
  2. T. Tzanetos et al., "Ingenuity Mars Helicopter: From Technology Demonstration to Extraterrestrial Scout," 2022 IEEE Aerospace Conference (AERO), 2022, pp. 01-19, doi: 10.1109/AERO53065.2022.9843428.
  3. Y. Wei, H. Qiu, Y. Liu, J. Du and M. -O. Pun, "Unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV)-assisted unmanned ground vehicle (UGV) systems design, implementation and optimization," 2017 3rd IEEE International Conference on Computer and Communications (ICCC), 2017, pp. 2797-2801, doi: 10.1109/CompComm.2017.8323042.
  4. A. Junaid, A. Konoiko, Y. Zweiri, M. Sahinkaya, and L. Seneviratne, “Autonomous Wireless Self-Charging for Multi-Rotor Unmanned Aerial Vehicles,” Energies, vol. 10, no. 6, p. 803, Jun. 2017, doi: 10.3390/en10060803.
  5. Wireless power transfer: Fundamentals, Challenges, and Technology Trends . YouTube, 2020 [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=liLJnFFhnng. [Accessed: 16-Oct-2022]
  6. C. Lecluyse, B. Minnaert, and M. Kleemann, “A review of the current state of Technology of Capacitive Wireless Power Transfer,” MDPI, 16-Sep-2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/14/18/5862. [Accessed: 16-Oct-2022]
  7. placeholder
  8. M. M. El Rayes, G. Nagib, and W. G. Ali Abdelaal, “A review on Wireless Power Transfer,” International Journal of Engineering Trends and Technology, vol. 40, no. 5, pp. 272–280, 2016.
  9. M. W. B. Chathuranga, D. N. K. Jayakody, and A. Sharma, “Performance study of strongly coupled magnetic resonance,” 07-Aug-2019. [Online]. Available: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335028560_Performance_Study_of_Strongly_Coupled_Magnetic_Resonance. [Accessed: 17-Oct-2022]
  10. G. Kiruthiga, M. Y. Jayant, and A. Sharmila, “Wireless charging for low power applications using Qi standard,” IEEE Xplore, Apr. 01, 2016. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7754338 [Accessed Oct. 17, 2022]
  11. J. Wu, C. Zhao, Z. Lin, J. Du, Y. Hu, and X. He, “Wireless Power and Data Transfer via a Common Inductive Link Using Frequency Division Multiplexing,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 62, no. 12, pp. 7810–7820, Dec. 2015, doi: 10.1109/TIE.2015.2453934. [Accessed Oct. 17,2022]
  12. T. Greicius, “NASA's Ingenuity Mars helicopter recharges its batteries in flight,” NASA, 13-Aug-2020. [Online]. Available: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/jpl/nasas-ingenuity-mars-helicopter-recharges-its-batteries-in-flight. [Accessed: 17-Oct-2022]
  13. Federal Communications Commision, “FCC 19-126” FCC. Washington, DC: Office of Headquarters Operations, November 27,2019. [Accessed: 07-Oct-2022]
  14. J. Buckley, “Air power in the age of Total War,” Air Power in the Age of Total War, pp. 11–31, 2006. [Accessed: 24-Oct-2022]
  15. S. A. Mohsan, M. A. Khan, F. Noor, I. Ullah, and M. H. Alsharif, “Towards the Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (uavs): A comprehensive review,” Drones, vol. 6, no. 6, p. 147, 2022. [Accessed: 24-Oct-2022]
  16. J. Lu, G. Zhu, and C. C. Mi, “Foreign object detection in wireless power transfer systems,” IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 58, no. 1, pp. 1340–1354, 2022. [Accessed: 24-Oct-2022]
  17. T. S. Pham, T. D. Nguyen, B. S. Tung, B. X. Khuyen, T. T. Hoang, Q. M. Ngo, L. T. Hiep, and V. D. Lam, “Optimal frequency for magnetic resonant wireless power transfer in conducting medium,” Scientific Reports, vol. 11, no. 1, 2021. [Accessed: 24-Oct-2022]
  18. M.Mueggenberg, “Wireless Battery-less Sensor Device Using NFC.”, 2017. [Accessed: 30-Oct-2022]
  19. J. Barreto, G. Perez, A.-S. Kaddour, and S. V. Georgakopoulos, “A study of wearable wireless power transfer systems on the human body,” IEEE Open Journal of Antennas and Propagation, vol. 2, pp. 86–94, Jan. 2021.
  20. H. Hu, S. Yao, K. Bao, and S. V. Georgakopoulos, “Misalignment insensitive WPT with conformal SCMR systems,” 2015 IEEE International Symposium on Antennas and Propagation & USNC/URSI National Radio Science Meeting, 2015.
  21. Jet Propulsion Lab, “Fact sheet - NASA Mars Exploration,” NASA Mars, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://mars.nasa.gov/files/mars2020/MarsHelicopterIngenuity_FactSheet.pdf. [Accessed: 14-Nov-2022]
  22. Y. Aoyama, “NTT DoCoMo's drone solution based on Docomo sky,” Drone Journal, Drone Journal, 30-Jun-2021. [Online]. Available: https://drone-journal.impress.co.jp/docs/event/1183617.html. [Accessed: 13-Nov-2022]
  23. “PMT 300: 300W DC Wireless Power Supply: POWERMAT • 100% wireless,” Powermat, 24-May-2022. [Online]. Available: https://powermat.com/pmt-family/pmt-300/. [Accessed: 13-Nov-2022]
  24. A. Kurs, et al., “Wireless power transfer via strongly coupled magnetic resonances,” Science, vol. 317, no. 5834, pp. 83–86, 2007.
  25. Lee, Gentry, director. So You Want to Be a Systems Engineer? Personal Behaviors of a Systems Engineer. The Systems Engineering Advancement Project (SEA), National Aeronautics and Space Administration, 2005, spacese.spacegrant.org/videos/. [Accessed: 13-Jan -2022]

32

References

33 of 38

33

Input Power (dBm)

Input Power (mW)

Vpp_in (mV)

Vrms_in (mV)

Vpp_out (mV)

Vrms_out (mV)

n_pp

n_rms

0

1

12.6

4.3

4.5

1.7

35.71%

39.53%

5

3.16

35.8

12.4

6.3

2.7

17.60%

21.77%

8

6.31

55.4

19

9.6

5.1

17.33%

26.84%

13

19.95

101

35

11.1

5.6

10.99%

16.00%

34 of 38

34

35 of 38

35

35V ~1.5A the max Vin for our 5V regulator (which feeds into 4100 5V 1S MicroLipo charging module), which has a minimum input dropout of: 2-2.5V (rounded up to 3V) w/6mA quiescent current, so Vout = Vin - Vdrop -> 5V = Vin- 3V = 8V x 6mA = 48mW (16.81 dBm) to turn on and anything else is charge… at full battery charge current 8V @ 100mA = 800 mW (29.03 dBm) but Pmax for simulation coherency [figure below] @ 550 mW (27.4 dBm). Taking this value at 40% efficiency gives us 220 mW or 23.42 dBm i.e., 8V @ 27.5mA that we conservatively expect to supply the load, which will be enough to meet charge requirement, albeit slowly.

Backup slide on why 200mw load:

36 of 38

36

[1, pg.16]

Backup slide on safety, SAR

37 of 38

WPT for Cooperative Systems 2023

Communication Demonstration:

38 of 38

WPT for Cooperative Systems 2023

Power-Harvesting Demonstration: