1 of 32

Oregon Charter School Law Update 2024

Presented by Jordan Ramis Attorneys Matthew D. Lowe & Matthew L. Kahl

November 14, 2024

BEYOND THE LEGAL OPINION

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

2 of 32

Impactful New / Recently New Laws

  • Public Contracting
    • Thresholds (2023)
    • Indemnification (2023)
  • Charter School Facilities (2023)
  • Public Meetings
    • Video Recording (2024)
    • Enforcement (2024)

Page 2

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

3 of 32

Senate Bill 1047 – Procurement Thresholds (2023)

  • Effective: January 1, 2024
  • Changed monetary thresholds for awarding (i) public contracts for goods and services, and (ii) public improvement contracts for construction services

Page 3

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

4 of 32

Senate Bill 1047 – Procurement Thresholds (2023)

  • ORS 279B.065 (Small Procurements)
    • Old: Contracting agency may award a public contract for goods or services that does not exceed $10,000.
    • New: Contracting agency may award a public contract for goods or services that does not exceed $25,000.

Page 4

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

5 of 32

Senate Bill 1047 – Procurement Thresholds (2023)

  • ORS 279B.070 (Intermediate Procurements)
    • Old: Contracting agency may award a public contract for goods or services that exceeds $10,000 but does not exceed $150,000.
    • New: Contracting agency may award a public contract for goods or services that exceeds $25,000 but does not exceed $250,000.

Page 5

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

6 of 32

Senate Bill 1047 – Procurement Thresholds (2023)

  • ORS 279C.335 (Construction Contracts)
  • Contracting agency may award a public improvement contract only in response to competitive bids, except:
    • Old: A public improvement contract with a value less than $10,000.
    • New: A public improvement contract with a value less than $25,000.

Page 6

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

7 of 32

Senate Bill 1047 – Procurement Thresholds (2023)

  • Possible action needed by Boards –
    • If the public charter school board has adopted the Attorney General’s Model Public Contracting Rules, then no additional action is needed to utilize the new monetary thresholds
    • If the public charter school board has adopted its own public contracting rules, then it must comply with the monetary thresholds within those rules until such time that the board’s public contracting rules are amended.

Page 7

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

8 of 32

Senate Bill 1575 – Indemnification (2024)

  • Effective: January 1, 2025
  • Limits a school’s ability to require a duty to defend in indemnification provisions for certain construction-related services
    • architectural, engineering, photogrammetric mapping, transportation planning, land surveying services or related services
  • Duty to defend provisions are unenforceable
  • Exemption: real property lease or rental agreements; personal property lease or rental agreements; or any design-build contracts

Page 8

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

9 of 32

Senate Bill 767 – Charter School Facilities (2023)

  • Effective: June 6, 2023
  • Establishes procedures for virtual and nonvirtual public charter schools to open facilities outside sponsoring district
    • Nonvirtual public charter school may operate a facility outside sponsoring district only if:
      • Governing body has received written permission from non-sponsoring school district board.
        • Must be received prior to the first day on which students will attend classes at the school.

Page 9

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

10 of 32

Senate Bill 767 – Charter School Facilities (2023)

    • Nonvirtual public charter school may operate a facility outside sponsoring district without written permission only if:
      • School that began operating prior to June 6, 2023;
      • Location of the school has not changed since June 6, 2023; and
      • Written notification is provided to the non-sponsoring school district board each time the charter is renewed.

Page 10

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

11 of 32

Senate Bill 767 – Charter School Facilities (2023)

    • Virtual public charter school may not operate a facility outside sponsoring district
    • Virtual public charter school may operate administrative offices outside sponsoring district only after:
      • Providing written notice to non-sponsoring school district board:
        • Prior to first day the administrative offices are open; and
        • Each time the charter is renewed

Page 11

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

12 of 32

Senate Bill 767 – Charter School Facilities (2023)

    • Virtual public charter school may operate tutoring or testing facility outside sponsoring district only if:
      • Board provides written notice to non-sponsoring school district board:
        • Prior to first day the students will receive tutoring or testing at the facility for a facility that began operating after June 6, 2023; and
        • Each time the charter is renewed

Page 12

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

13 of 32

Senate Bill 767 – Charter School Facilities (2023)

    • Public charter school sponsored by State Board of Education may not operate a school or tutoring or testing facility outside of the district specified in the school’s charter

Page 13

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

14 of 32

Senate Bill 767 – Charter School Facilities (2023)

    • Noncompliance
      • Non-sponsoring school district board may file a complaint with the Superintendent of Public Instruction.
      • Upon receipt of a complaint, the superintendent shall schedule a contested case hearing.
      • Upon a determination that the governing body did not comply with the requirements of this section, the superintendent may withhold State School Fund moneys otherwise due to the public charter school.
      • The superintendent shall withhold moneys until the governing body is in compliance or until some other date determined by the superintendent.

Page 14

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

15 of 32

Senate Bill 1502 - Board Transparency (2024)

  • https://olis.oregonlegislature.gov/liz/2024R1/Downloads/MeasureDocument/SB1502/Enrolled
  • Effective: January 1, 2025
  • Requires boards of “common or union high school district” to post a video recordings of meetings on their websites and social media sites.
    • Applicability to public charter school boards
  • Must occur within 7 days of the meeting
  • If a school does not have sufficient internet access to video record or stream, then they may post audio recording.
  • Exemption:
    • Executive Sessions
    • School Districts with Resident ADM of less than 50 students.

Page 15

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

16 of 32

Senate Bill 1502 - Board Transparency (2024)

  • Still need to comply with ORS 192.670 (2021)
  • When public charter school board uses telephone or other electronic means of communication for meeting, excluding executive sessions, it must make available to the public at least one place where, or at least one electronic means by which, the public can attend the meeting.
  • All meetings held by public charter school board, excluding executive sessions, must provide to members of the public, to the extent reasonably possible, an opportunity to:
    • Access and attend the meeting by telephone, video or other electronic or virtual means;
    • If in-person oral testimony is allowed, submit during the meeting oral testimony by telephone, video or other electronic or virtual means; and
    • If in-person written testimony is allowed, submit written testimony, including by electronic mail or other electronic means, so that the board is able to consider the submitted testimony in a timely manner.

Page 16

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

17 of 32

House Bill 2805 – Public Meetings (2023)

Page 17

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

18 of 32

House Bill 2085 – Public Meetings (2023)

  • Additional definitions and clarifications
    • Meeting: “the convening of a governing body of a public body for which a quorum is required in order to make a decision or to deliberate toward a decision on any matter.”

Page 18

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

19 of 32

House Bill 2085 – Public Meetings (2023)

  • Defines “convening” as:
    • (i) “gathering in a physical location”;
    • (ii) “using electronic, video or telephonic technology to be able to communicate contemporaneously among participants”;
    • (iii) “using serial electronic written communication among participants”, or
    • (iv) “using an intermediary to communicate among participants”

Page 19

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

20 of 32

House Bill 2085 – Public Meetings (2023)

  • Does not apply to communications among members of a governing body:
    • (i) “purely factual or educational in nature and that convey no deliberation or decision on any matter that might reasonably come before the governing body”
    • (ii) “not related to any matter that, at any time, could reasonably be foreseen to come before the governing body for deliberation and decision”; or
    • (iii) “nonsubstantative in nature” (scheduling, leaves of absences, etc.)

Page 20

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

21 of 32

House Bill 2085 – Public Meetings (2023)

  • Mandatory training for members of governing bodies*
    • Effective: January 1, 2024
    • OGEC Special Meeting: September 20, 2024
    • Adopted and available as of: October 1, 2024

Page 21

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

22 of 32

House Bill 2085 – Public Meetings (2023)

  • Mandatory training for members of governing bodies*
    • Applies to all members of governing body of a public body with total expenditures for a fiscal year of $1 million or more
    • At least once during member’s term of office
    • Maintain records of trainings including date and name of provider
    • Certify completion upon request by OGEC

Page 22

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

23 of 32

House Bill 2085 – Public Meetings (2023)

  • Mandatory training for members of governing bodies*
    • May attend trainings either in person or virtual
    • If a member serves on multiple governing bodies, then only need to attend a singe training as long as training occurs during applicable term of office

Page 23

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

24 of 32

House Bill 2085 – Public Meetings (2023)

  • Expanded oversight by OGEC
    • Submit written grievance to public body within 30 days of the date of alleged violation
    • Public body must respond in writing within 21 days
    • Public body must send the written grievance and its response to OGEC when the public body sends its response to the person who filed the grievance

Page 24

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

25 of 32

House Bill 2085 – Public Meetings (2023)

  • Public body’s written response:
    • A. Acknowledge receipt of grievance
    • B(1). Deny facts/circumstances in the grievance and state the facts/circumstances determined by the public body and state reasons why those facts/circumstances do not amount to a violation.
    • B(2). Admit facts/circumstances in the grievance but deny those facts/circumstances amount to a violation.

Page 25

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

26 of 32

House Bill 2085 – Public Meetings (2023)

  • Public body’s written response:
    • B(3). Admit facts/circumstances in the grievance amount to a violation and state steps the governing body will take to cure violation.
      • B(3)(i): Rescind decision
      • B(3)(ii): Acknowledge original decision was made in violation, good cause exists not to rescind decision, and governing body will modify its procedures to ensure future violations do not occur

Page 26

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

27 of 32

Public Meetings Reminders

  • All meetings of the governing body of a public body shall be open to the public unless exempt.
  • Quorum of a public body may not meet in private to decide or deliberate on any matter.
  • Discriminatory to meet in a place inaccessible to persons with disabilities, or to fail to make good faith effort to have an interpreter.
  • All votes in public sessions – no secret ballots

Page 27

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

28 of 32

Public Meetings Reminders

  • Public Notice Required
    • “reasonably calculated to give actual notice” to interested persons of time and place of regular meetings.
      • Displayed conspicuously on the public body’s or governing body’s website; or
      • Displayed conspicuously on a publicly accessible website hosted by a third-party and linked to the public body’s or governing body’s website; or
      • Other means (bulletin boards, newspapers, community boards, etc.)

Page 28

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

29 of 32

Public Meetings Reminders

    • Interested persons include news media
    • Can satisfy notice to interested persons through:
      • Mailing lists; or
      • Social media platforms normally utilized for communications; or
      • In the method requested (media representative); or
      • Any other means reasonably calculated to provide actual notice.

Page 29

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

30 of 32

Public Meetings Reminders

    • If an Executive Session will be held, the notice:
      • Must be given to:
        • the members of the governing body;
        • to the general public; and
        • to news media which have requested notice.
      • Must state the specific provision of law authorizing the executive session (ORS 192.660(2)(a) – (p).
    • Representatives of news media are permitted to attend executive sessions unless session relates to labor negotiations or member of news media is a party to the litigation or employee, agent or contractor of a news media organization that is a party to the litigation.

Page 30

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

31 of 32

Public Meetings Reminders

  • Public Notice (Timing)
    • Regular Meeting: as much advance notice as possible, but not less than 48 hours advance notice
    • Special Meeting: at least 24 hours advance notice
    • Emergency Meeting: as much advance notice as possible given emergency circumstances
      • Must be an actual emergency
      • Minutes must describe actual emergency and reason why meeting could not be delayed for at least 24 hours notice.

Page 31

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

32 of 32

Thank you!

Matthew D. Lowe, Shareholder Matthew L. Kahl, Attorney

Matthew.Lowe@jordanramis.com Matthew.Kahl@jordanramis.com�

BEYOND THE LEGAL OPINION

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC

© 2024 Jordan Ramis PC