1 of 47

Michael McFaul

Putinism

Transnational Ideology or Disruptive Virus?

2 of 47

1

2

3

Defining �“Putinism”

Exporting �Putinism

Putin’s

Successes

3 of 47

Evolution of Putinism

Democracy

Markets

Relations with the West

2

4 of 47

Putin’s Education

3

5 of 47

Putin’s Attitude towards Democracy

The Early Years

4

6 of 47

Weakening Checks on Kremlin Power

✔️

Elimination of national independent media

✔️

Reigning in regional leaders

7 Districts, distribution of tax receipts, elimination of elections

✔️

Reconfiguration of party system

  • Pro-Putin parties stronger (United Russia, Just Russia, LDPR)
  • Independent parties weaker (KPRF, Yabloko, SPS, Republicans, Kasyanov)

✔️

Emasculation of Federation Council

✔️

Duma is a rubberstamp

✔️

Elections not free, nor fair

✔️

Civil society more constrained

✔️

Crackdown on protesters

7 of 47

Putin’s Attitude towards Democracy

Later Years

Opposition

Media

Free and Fair Elections

NGOs

6

8 of 47

Putin’s Attitude towards Markets

  • New flat tax – 13 %
  • Cut corporate taxes
  • Encourages foreign investment
  • Sound fiscal & monetary policies
  • Budget surpluses
  • Inflation controlled
  • Stabilization Fund was growing

The Early Years

  • Sound fiscal & monetary policies
  • Greater suspicion of free markets
  • New nationalization
  • Redistribution of property rights to Putin loyalists
  • Increased military spending
  • Less enthusiasm for foreign investment
  • Economic Populism

Later Years

9 of 47

Putin Attitude towards the West�

KGB Analytic Framework

But Flirted with Cooperation

  • September 11
  • Joining NATO:��David Frost: Is it possible Russia could join NATO?��Putin: I don't see why not. I would not rule out such a possibility - but I repeat - if and when Russia's views are taken into account as those of an equal partner.

The Early Years

8

10 of 47

Reaction to “Aggressive” U.S. Policies

1

1999

2003

2003 – 2004

Serbia Bombing

NATO Expansion

Iraq Invasion

U.S. Support for Revolution

Color Revolutions (2000, 2003, 2004)

​

9

11 of 47

Moscow, July 2009

10

12 of 47

Egypt 2011

11

13 of 47

Libya 2011

12

14 of 47

Syria 2011

13

15 of 47

Russia 2011

14

16 of 47

Russia 1991

15

17 of 47

Ukraine 2014: Fall of Yanukovych

16

18 of 47

Venezuela 2019

17

19 of 47

Moscow 2019

18

20 of 47

Mature Putinism

Sovereignty

Conservative Values

Nationalism

Economic Populism

21 of 47

“Unilateral and frequently illegitimate actions have not resolved any problems…Today we are witnessing an almost uncontained hyper use of force – military force – in international relations, force that is plunging the world into an abyss of permanent conflicts… We are seeing a greater and greater disdain for the basic principles of international law… And independent legal norms are, as a matter of fact, coming increasingly closer to one state’s legal system. One state and, of course, first and foremost the United States, has overstepped its national borders in every way. This is visible in the economic, political, cultural and educational policies it imposes on other nations. Well, who likes this? Who is happy about this?”

Vladimir Putin, Munich Conference on Security, February 2007

Sovereignty

AMERICAN HEGEMONY

SOVEREIGN RUSSIA

VS.

22 of 47

Sovereignty

“We know, regrettably, that … some representatives of some foreign states are gathering those to whom they are paying money, so-called grant recipients, carrying out instruction sessions with them and preparing them to do the relevant work, in inverted commas, in order to influence, ultimately, the election campaign process in our country.”

Vladimir Putin, November 2011

23 of 47

Sovereignty

“[Hillary Clinton] set the tone for some actors in our country and gave them a signal... They heard the signal and with the support of the U.S. State Department began active work.”

Vladimir Putin, December 2011

24 of 47

“Therefore, the author of the Aleksey Navalny project is none other than Michael McFaul.”

​

“…he [McFaul] started working thoroughly on making anti-Putin rallies in Moscow more creatively. It seemed that the February 4 rally was bound for success.”

Russia Today, Feb 7, 2012

U.S. (McFaul) Responsible for Demonstrations

25 of 47

26 of 47

27 of 47

28 of 47

“US Ambassador McFaul is a Pedophile”

27

29 of 47

“Deep state” in Western countries is “a harsh, absolutely non-democratic organization of real power of defense and law enforcement agencies” that hides behind the façade of democratic institutions.

Vladislav Surkov, February 2019

Sovereignty

DEEP STATE

30 of 47

Conservative Values

“In order to reach new heights, it is important to preserve our identity, unity and solidarity, which rely on values that have been cherished at all times by Orthodoxy and other traditional religions of Russia”

Vladimir Putin, January 2019

31 of 47

“Without the values ​embedded in Christianity people will inevitably lose their human dignity.”

​

“We consider it natural and right to defend these values.”

Vladimir Putin, September 2013

Conservative Values

32 of 47

Russia as a Civilization

“The great mission of the ethnically Russians is to unite and bond the civilization. To bond Russian Armenians, Russian Azerbaijanians, Russian Germans, Russian Tatars through the language, the culture, ‘the universal kind-heartedness’ as Fyodor Dostoevsky defined it. To bond them in a type of a civilization-state that has no ‘ethnic minorities’ and where the principle of defining friends vs. foes is based on the common culture and common values.”

Vladimir Putin, January 2012

33 of 47

1

2

3

Defining �“Putinism”

Exporting �Putinism

Putin’s

Successes

34 of 47

  • Media
  • Other Instruments

33

Putinism is “an ideology of the future”… a “political system created in Russia [which] is suitable not only for the national future, but it has a significant export potential; there is already demand on it and on some of its components; its experience is already being examined and adopted; both people in power and opposition groups in many countries imitate it.”

Vladislav Surkov, February 2019

Exporting Putinism

35 of 47

Tools for Exporting Putinism

International

Media

Bots & Trolls

People-to-People Ties

Export�by Force

36 of 47

Organizations, Bots, Fake Identities

Media: Russian state channels, RT, Sputnik

  • 6 languages of broadcast.
  • 3 billion views on YouTube.
  • 85 million households have access in USA.
  • $300 million – annual budget.

Internet Research Agency

and others.

37 of 47

Building Relationships with Politicians

38 of 47

Society-to-Society Ties

  • Russian Houses
  • Party Ties
    • Financial assistance
  • Religious organizations
  • Non-governmental organizations
  • Ideological ”Epistemic” communities

Valdai

Fort Ross

Russkiy Mir Foundation

Dugin appears on Alex Jones’s Infowars

39 of 47

Soldiers & “Volunteers”

40 of 47

1

2

3

Defining �“Putinism”

Exporting �Putinism

Putin’s

Successes

41 of 47

Putin’s Successes…

✔️

Consolidated power at home

✔️

West is forgetting about past egregious behavior

  • Nordstream II
  • St Petersburg Economic Forum
  • Trump invites to join G7
  • More Europeans calling for lifting sanctions

✔️

Transatlantic relations more strained today that ever before

  • Brexit
  • Trump
  • Orban in Hungary
  • Government in Italy

✔️

Successful interventions

  • Ukraine 2014
  • Syria 2015
  • United States 2016
  • (United Kingdom 2018)
  • (Venezuela 2019)

40

42 of 47

… Putin’s Successes 2

✔️

United States in retreat

Trump Withdrawal Doctrine:

  • TPP
  • Paris Climate agreement
  • Iran Nuclear agreement
  • INF
  • New Start
  • NATO?
  • UN Arms Trade Treaty

✔️

Little discussion of democratic values at all

  • US no longer seen as “leader of the free world.”
  • Embrace of autocrats
  • Whataboutism on the rise

✔️

Russian alliances stronger? (Not yet)

  • SCO vs G7
  • EEU vs EU
  • Russia-China

✔️

Societal attitude’s shifting towards �Russia and against US

  • Citizens in 9 US allies trust Putin more than Trump
  • Globally, image has moved in more positive direction in only 2 countries: Russia and Israel
  • Do these attitudes matter? In a crisis, maybe yes (9-11).

41

43 of 47

Contain most aggressive foreign actions

Pushback in third arenas (i.e. Iran)

Advance ideas defining a free society

Engage with Kremlin on issues of mutual interest

Engage Russian society

Unite the Democratic World

Stay the course

What Is To Be Done?

Strategic Stalemate

44 of 47

Autocracy After Putin?

  • No strong “Party of Power”
  • No institutionalized way to hand over power
  • Alternatives to Putin:

Another strong man,

Nationalists,

Pro-democracy forces

  • Weak ideology

43

45 of 47

Modernization

FP

Lipset right �in the long run:

hard to see how Russia defies world trends forever

Just don’t know how long the long run is

44

46 of 47

Thank you!

45

47 of 47

For a Deeper Dive?

Buy �the Book!