1 of 69

Leadership Support for Equity: Collaboratively Supporting Multilingual Learners

�IMPACT Day 1

#ELLevationImpact22

December 5, 2022

Dr. Andrea Honigsfeld

ahonigsfeld@gmail.com

2 of 69

3 of 69

4 of 69

Greeting at the door:

  • “Teacher greetings produced increases in students’ on-task behavior from a mean of 45% in baseline to a mean of 72% during the intervention phase.” (Allday & Pakurar, 2007, p. 317). 

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17624071/

5 of 69

6 of 69

Hungary�

7 of 69

PS 68, Queens, NYC DOE, 1996

7

8 of 69

9 of 69

Select Publications to Support �Programs for ELs/MLs and Collaboration

2010

2012

2014

2018

2015

2019

2019

2021

2022

2022

2023

2019

10 of 69

Special thanks to:

  • Maria G. Dove
  • Audrey Cohan
  • Carrie McDermott Goldman
  • Claribel Gonzalez
  • Valentina Gonzalez

    • Corwin
    • ASCD
    • Seidlitz

Raffle: Tweet @andreahonigsfel

#EllevationImpact22

ahonigsfeld@gmail.com

11 of 69

INTRODUCTION, PLEASE! 2 P’S: POSITION AND PASSION

11

12 of 69

Goals:

This session will address leadership support for equitable learning environment and learning opportunities for multilingual learners through three interconnected places and perspectives:��1. District level leadership is needed to ensure equitable allocation of resources and staffing and to build community relationships��2. School level leadership is necessary for administrators and coaches to collaboratively leverage the time and expertise of ML specialists��3. Classroom level (teacher) leadership is needed for deliberate daily actions in support of MLs

13 of 69

Let’s ponder:

How will you remember the pandemic

    • in 1 year?
    • in 5 years?
    • in 10 years?

How will it be remembered in 100 years?

14 of 69

How about our students?

15 of 69

One special moment

16 of 69

Arundhati Roy,

Indian Novelist

17 of 69

“Historically, pandemics have forced humans to break with the past and imagine their world anew. This one is no different. It is a portal, a gateway between one world and the next. We can choose to walk through it, dragging the carcasses of our prejudice and hatred, our avarice, our data banks and dead ideas, our dead rivers and smoky skies behind us. Or we can walk through lightly, with little luggage, ready to imagine another world. And ready to fight for it.” (para. 58)

18 of 69

Educational portal

What do we leave behind?

19 of 69

Essential Questions

What drives you to pursue equity for MLs in your context?

What is the role of leadership in creating equitable learning opportunities for MLs?

20 of 69

21 of 69

22 of 69

Let’s Position Equity Work for MLs

  • At the macro-level – involving the entire district and the neighborhood community (and beyond)
  • At the meso-level – involving all stakeholders within a school community
  • At the micro-level – involving teacher teams  

23 of 69

What’s your why?

24 of 69

It is all about the kids…

  • “Educational equity means that every child receives whatever she/he/they need to develop to her/his/their full academic and social potential and to thrive, every day” (Aguilar, 2021, p. 6).

25 of 69

26 of 69

26

SOME�ESSENTIAL

ROAD MAPS

27 of 69

27

28 of 69

28

29 of 69

Shane Safir and Jamila Dugan’s (2021) call for advocacy:�

  • “Equity isn’t a destination but an unwavering commitment to a journey. It can be easy to focus on where we hope to land and lose sight of the deliberate daily actions that constitute the process” (p. 29).

30 of 69

District Leadership for Equity for MLs

31 of 69

James Clear

  • “You do not rise to the level of your goals. You fall to the level of your systems. “

The goal is the desired outcome … the system is what gets you there…

32 of 69

R & R

33 of 69

International Center for Leadership in Education

34 of 69

35 of 69

4 R’s

Honigsfeld and Dove, 2022

36 of 69

4 R’s Will Guide Some Essential Leadership Practices:

  • Equity audit – to name and dismantle systemic inequities
  • A shared vision – to guide a strategic plan, policy, protocols, and practice (4 P’s)
  • “Humble inquiry” – for continued learning, ongoing support for knowledge transfer
  • Allocation of resources – to create equitable access to high quality education for MLs
  • Building community within the district and beyond

37 of 69

MTSS

District Leadership team:

Jamie Scripps

Svetlana Stowell

Rosalie Sullivan

38 of 69

District-level Leadership

Define -- Narrate -- Act (DNA):

  • Define the terms you’ll be using such as how you define equity, antiracism, or belonging. What do those terms mean in your district? Make sure everyone has an understanding of what you really mean.
  • Narrate why you are doing this work, what the data says, and why you want buy in from the community.
  • Act (affirm, counter, and transform) is about taking the steps needed to affirm equity in your community, counter any resistance that you might be working against, and determine how to transform the mindsets of people in opposition to the work. 

Dr. Tauheedah Baker-Jones

Chief Equity and Social Justice Officer Atlanta Public School

39 of 69

School Leadership for Equity for MLs

40 of 69

41 of 69

U and I – A System to Set Priorities

42 of 69

What you focus on, you accomplish.”����

Craig Gfeller led one of the lower-performing schools to earning Prince William County School of Excellence status in just two years.

He fostered a team approach that enabled teachers to help students master required subjects at the same time most were working to learn English as their second language.

Test scores rose dramatically, earning Mr. Gfeller and his school widespread recognition and a visit from Virginia’s Governor.

43 of 69

Integrated, Collaborative Service Delivery

Collaborative Teacher Teams: ESOL & Grade-Level/Content Teachers, TAs

Integrated Instructional Services

Integrated Student Population

Integrated Curriculum: Content & Language

44 of 69

Leadership Support for Equitable Services for MLs

44

45 of 69

All teachers are teachers of ELs/MLs

46 of 69

Engage all MLs in instruction that is grade- appropriate, academically rigorous, and aligned with the state standards.

47 of 69

Leverage the expertise of ELD and Bilingual teachers while increasing their professional capacities

48 of 69

What are the priorities in your context?�What is urgent? �What is important?��ABCDE’s of Equity Work Based on Nicole Law and Ricky Roberston

  • Assess examples of inequities and their sources in your school
  • Build your capacity to get to know members of the school community
  • Collaborate and communicate with students, families, and fellow educators 
  • Determine your daily equity moves and actions
  • Evaluate your impact on students’ academic, linguistic, and social-emotional development

49 of 69

Teacher Leadership for Equity for MLs

50 of 69

Four Equity Strategies:��1. Amplify the Talents, Spirits, �and Personal Powers of MLs��2. Recalibrate the Curriculum to Accelerate Learning for MLs��3. Teach and Assess to Build Student Autonomy, Agency, and Resilience��4. Harness the Power of Connections and Relationships

Claribel

González 

51 of 69

1. Amplify the Talents, Spirits, and Personal Powers of MLs��2. Recalibrate the Curriculum to Accelerate Learning for MLs��3. Teach and Assess to Build Student Autonomy, Agency, and Resilience��4. Harness the Power of Connections and Relationships

Affirmations

52 of 69

53 of 69

54 of 69

Deliberate Daily Actions

  • Talk with and listen to your students
  • Get to know each and every student and understand their full humanity
  • Invite multiple modalities of communication and expression

55 of 69

56 of 69

--Critically examine or recalibrate your curricula to be:

    • relevant
    • rigorous
    • relational

--Integrate content, language, literacy, and SEL 

Deliberate Daily Actions

57 of 69

58 of 69

Deliberate Daily Actions

  • Implement multidimensional instructional strategies
  • Create an equitable approach to assessment as and for learning

59 of 69

60 of 69

  • Build a strong sense of classroom community, belonging, and purpose
  • Support students’ social-emotional well-being and freedom of expression
  • Collaborate – with all stakeholders
  • Harness the system of social workers, guidance counselors, teaching aids, and others to offer mentoring and coaching as needed

Deliberate Daily Actions

61 of 69

Six Elements Of Successful Content-Language Integration (Caudill et al, 2022)

SHARE

COMMUNICATE

INTEGRATE

COOPERATE

REFLECT

ADJUST

Ready-Set-Co-Teach Team

62 of 69

Authentic Co-Assessments

  1. Designing
  2. Monitoring
  3. Analyzing student progress

63 of 69

64 of 69

Virtual field trips

6 continents – 33 countries

65 of 69

66 of 69

NEXT STEPS: ACTION PLANNING�

67 of 69

Start with “Triple � AAA”

View MLs as capable students who want to meet and exceed the high expectations we hold for them. (AGENCY)

Recognize that they are already competent in one language/culture and can use their funds of knowledge and identity to acquire English. (ASSETS)

Intentionally focus on their language acquisition levels of English, scaffold up, and address academic/disciplinary literacy. (ACCELERATE)

68 of 69

Raffle:

Tweet @andreahonigsfel

#EllevationImpact22

ahonigsfeld@gmail.com

69 of 69