1 of 1

Effects of Age and Sex on Microbial Diversity at Gut, Oral, and Skin Sites

Elias Wojahn and Nicole Thue

Background

References: -Haro, Carmen, et al. “Intestinal Microbiota Is Influenced by Gender and Body Mass Index.” PLoS ONE, 2016, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0154090. -Huttenhower, Curtis, et al. “Structure, Function and Diversity of the Healthy Human Microbiome.” Nature, 2012, doi:10.1038/nature11234. -Taneja, Veena. “Microbiome: Impact of Gender on Function & Characteristics of Gut Microbiome.” Principles of Gender-Specific Medicine: Gender in the Genomic Era, by Marianne J. Legato, Academic Press, 2017, pp. 569–583. Yatsunenko, Tanya, et al. “Human Gut Microbiome Viewed across Age and Geography.” Nature, 2012, doi:10.1038/nature11053. Viera, A. T., Castelo, P. M., Ribeiro, D. A. and Ferreira, C. M. (2017). Influence of Oral and Gut Microbiota in the Health of Menopausal Women . Frontiers in Microbiology

​

​

​

Fig. 3 Comparison of age, sample site, and Shannon index. An ANOVA test was run on shannon index vs age at each site with n=4637, and a p-value of 2 x 10-6 was found.

Then a comparison of sex, sample sites, and Shannon index. An ANOVA test was run on shannon vs sex at each site with n=4637 and a p-value of 0.1893.

Methods

Results

Conclusion

  • The human microbiome has become a new way of understanding chronic illness and treating them.
  • The Human Microbiome Project (HMP) was one of the first groups to analyze the microbes of 242 individuals at different body sites (Huttenhower 2012).
  • Other research of age on microbial diversity conveyed that every population (from Amazonas to US) showed an increase in microbial diversity with age (Yatsunenko et al., 2012).
  • Further analysis between females and males showed that females typically maintain a higher microbial diversity than men (Haro, 2016).
  • Most research indicates that women and older individuals have the highest microbial diversity, but there is not much analysis conducted on the effects of both age and sex on microbial diversity at the gut, oral, and skin sites.
  • Our hypothesis is that age has a bigger effect on microbial diversity than sex at the gut, oral, and skin sites.

​

Major Findings: The null hypothesis was rejected as a significant difference was found between younger and older individual’s alpha diversity samples, whereas there was no significant difference was found between sexes. This is supported with a P-value of 2 x 10-6 for age, but only 0.1893 for sex. Qualitative examination of the PCoA plots indicates that neither Age nor Sex has a large impact on beta diversity differences. Statistical testing of the taxa summary plots indicated that neither variable had a significant impact on human microbiome beta diversity.

​

Relationship to Previous Knowledge: It is interesting to note that while differences were found between sexes’ microbiomes, they were not significant unlike results found in previous studies.

​

Future Studies: Our study was rather limited due to the oldest age samples being 40. Future projects could obtain samples from individuals well into their 70’s or 80’s for a better comparison of microbial diversity. Also, older females and males could be compared between each other. Since there could be a greater difference between sexes after certain events like menopause. Since, estrogen deficiency can alter the oral and gut microbiota along with the vaginal microbiota (Viera A et al 2017).

​

  • This experiment was carried out with the HMP dataset. The Operational Taxonomic Unit identities were assigned by closed reference picking against the Greengenes database, at a 97% similarity level.
  • Shannon index was chosen to measure alpha diversity because it accounts for both evenness and abundance.
  • Alpha diversity was displayed through boxplots by sites with age or sex. Beta diversity was used to create the PCoA plot and taxa summary to compare the differences in diversity between the different environments.
  • The population was divided into young (18 to 26) and old (26 to 40).

HMP Core Metrics in QIIME

Rarefied OTU Table

2 Shannon Plots

(age and sex at each bodysite) ANOVA

Subset and Filtered Data

​

Beta Diversity (unweighted unifrac)

Alpha Diversity Shannon

PCoA Plot

(T-tests of Beta Diversities)

Taxa Summary Plot

(T-tests between microbes with sex and age)

Fig. 1 PCoA plots created using PC1 vs PC2 which are continuous variables with the most variation of the beta diversity metrics. Sorted by sample site and then age or sex respectively. Clumping of points represents similarity, which age and sex do not have an effect on.

Fig. 2 Taxa Summary plots created at the level. These plots compared the various taxa found at each sample site and then split by either sex or age. An ANOVA test was run on relative abundance vs sex and relative abundance vs age at each site. Splitting by age had a stronger difference, ultimately neither was significant with p-values of .659 and .284 for sex and age respectively.