A no marking policy is utter nonsense.
Mark your books. Do your job!
Making marking meaningful
Kevin McLaughlin
@_kevinmcl
Senior Lecturer in ITT
Bishop Grosseteste University, Lincoln
All work is marked daily and 2-3 written pieces per week are marked intensively using coding and three colours.
Let’s be conservative
They still don’t know how to use capital letters and full stops!
True, but useless.
Marking is usually an approach to ‘showcase that feedback is given,’ however, often does very little for the student.
Sarah Donarski (@s_donarski)
“It is too easy to assume that lots of dialogical marking inevitably means that great teaching is happening.”�
@claresealy
“Marking policy and practice that is focused on following a system regardless of pupil outcomes does not support high quality assessment.”
Dawn Copping, Head Teacher,
Shaw Primary Academy.
Marking myths that need to be debunked
What does the research say?
Evidence ready �vs �Evidence committed
Evidence-informed teaching: an evaluation of progress in England Research report July 2017
In reality, what students need is to go back to the very basics of sentence construction, and slowly consolidate their knowledge of every piece of the jigsaw that makes up the summative understanding of punctuating their writing. (Paul Moss, 2019)
Marking should be
Meaningful
Manageable
Motivating
Report of the Independent Teacher Workload Review Group (2016)
Dawn Copping, Shaw Primary Academy
@primarypercival
@primarypercival
@MrColesDrama
Live marking
Beware of lethal mutations
One risk is that you simply replace unhelpful individual written comments with unhelpful whole-class written comments
Done well, whole-class feedback is much better at providing this recipe than traditional written comments. (Christadoulou)
To be effective, feedback must provide a recipe for future action.’ (Wiliam)
“Rather than thinking about feedback as
an isolated event, it is likely to be more
effective if it is approached systemically”
Dylan Wiliam?
A model of task sequencing to promote learning. (Edwards, 2015)
As proposed by Sarah Donarski, 2019
8. Strengthened and consolidated demonstration of grasp of key concepts and ways of enquiring. | 4. Demonstration of grasp of key concepts and ways of enquiring. | 1. Introduction of key concepts and modelling of ways of engaging with key concepts | 5. Introduce key about the learning positives and mistakes through exemplars and initial work. |
7. More open tasks that encourage students to evaluate their work against the entirety of the key concepts addressed. | 3. More open tasks which enable learners to apply key concepts and ways of enquiring. | 2. Tightly structured tasks which demand engagement with key concepts and ways of enquiring | 6. Tightly structured tasks where students write/rewrite introductions or conclusions – or include key concepts that have been missed. |
How to and more
Further reading
Blogs and further reading
https://educontrarianblog.com/2017/11/26/what-can-we-infer-from-an-exercise-book/
What can we infer from a neat book? Lots of written feedback? Success criteria and smiley faces?
https://library.ncte.org/journals/VM/issues/v21-2/24461 Wiliam ‘our students do not learn what we teach’
And ‘well-intentioned attempts to communicate learning intentions to students have made writing a mechanistic process of checklist management’
https://educationendowmentfoundation.org.uk/education-evidence/evidence-reviews/written-marking
https://thirdspacelearning.com/blog/new-no-marking-policy-confessions-primary-headteacher/
https://blog.nomoremarking.com/whole-class-feedback-saviour-or-fad-5c54c463a4d0
https://thelearningaddict.co.uk/2018/11/28/comparative-judgement-trial-and-the-feedback-question/
https://jcmcnamara15.wordpress.com/2017/10/11/using-comparative-judgement-to-assess-primary-writing/
https://www.st-james-elstead.surrey.sch.uk/Feedback-and-marking/
https://adam-robbins.com/2021/11/14/whole-class-feedback-making-the-juice-worth-the-squeeze/
https://researchschool.org.uk/huntington/news/whole-class-feedback-a-primary-case-study
https://my.chartered.college/research-hub/effective-feedback-whole-class-marking/