1 of 46

Law and Regulation

Laws can have many meaning depending on the context they are used.

    • Law of nature - physical, physical-mathematical, or natural truth
    • Law of God - moral, spiritual, or religious truth
    • Scientific law - Newton’s Law of motion
    • Man-made laws - legal, administrative, or institutional rules
    • etc.

2 of 46

Law and Regulation

Two concept of laws when they are written are:

    • Orderly - In the form of procedures and system
    • Obey - Must obey the law

There are some rules that possess the same characteristics but must be differentiated from law such as :- Ethics, moral values, traditions etc.

All rules and laws must be self sufficient and complete in their own-self.

    • If a law encroaching into realm of public understanding or natural conduct, it will cause debate.
    • If the standard set by the law is too high, it will have problem in enforcing it.

3 of 46

The law is given definition according to:

    • Law of nature - Law of nature set by God and it is fair.
    • Social contract - The governing power which comes from the people and the people release it to the government as obligation to carry it out in fairness.
    • A decree - official order or a legal judgment made by a leader, government, or court. It carries the power and force of a law that people must obey
        • Broadly, decree has to be followed and obeyed
        • It must come from an individual or selected group of people
        • In a civilize community, the law is written by politician/ member or parliment and enforce in the court of law.

Law and Regulation

4 of 46

Law and Regulation

Laws and Nation

    • Laws have existed long before the people have any political alliance.
    • These laws were established through good elements and properly ordered.
    • The type of governing practice in a tribe can have many differences
      • The head of a tribe has an absolute power and above the law.
      • However, with the court of law system, all cases were brought to justice, including the head of tribe.

5 of 46

The law that describe all rules is called The Law of The Nation (Hukum Negara)

In Malaysia, the law of the nation, Perlembagaan Negara is a written law, and it is the highest law in the nation.

The head of the nation is Y.M.M. Agong

      • The head for 3 branches of government
        1. Legislature (Dewan penggubal undang-undang / Parliament/Dewan Undangan Negeri)
        2. Executive (Pentadbir Kerajaan)
        3. Justice

The law of the nation can be found in the Federal Constitution and State Constitution in the form of code.

Law and Regulation

6 of 46

Law and Regulation

    • Federal constitution is the highest law together with state constitution.
    • The law was made in parliament and Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) under respective constitution.
    • Subsidiary Legislation (Undang-undang tambahan) was made by individual or agency empowered by an act of parliament or DUN.
    • The basis of law is English Common Laws adapted for local situation

7 of 46

Law and Regulation

Implication of laws

    • Law sometimes put legal constraints and liabilities on engineers
      • Suspension of works
        • Ir. Harban Singh, Suspension of work: An Overview, Buletin Ingenieur, pg 24-35
      • Imposing responsibility
        • Avoid pollution from the waste material
        • Health matter
        • Reducing danger to the environment
      • Provide protection of right of workmen and employers
      • Procedure for investigation and inquiry
      • Managing trade dispute, strike and lock out

8 of 46

Guidance in Performance of Practice

  • The professional practice is the conduct of how an engineer performs and executes his duties and responsibilities.
  • This conduct is governed by a set of rules such as ‘code of professional conduct or code of ethics’
  • The codes serves as a guide as they are in essence not too detail and explicit, the professional has to use his better judgment in certain cases as to what is morally correct and what is not
  • Engineers are required to be proficient in engineering practice, standards, code of practice and regulations

​

​

​

8

9 of 46

Guidance in Performance of Practice

  • Skills considered ‘expert level’ in yesteryears will become “normal practice” in present times
  • This requires engineers to have Continuous Professional Development (CPD) in order to stay current in his practice
  • Even non-registered engineers who practice engineering will be subject to Torts (tort laws)
  • Once professional service is rendered, an engineer is liable even in the absence of a written contract or appointment (contract law)
  • Therefore, it is important to have a sound understanding of the laws and regulations that governs our profession.

9

10 of 46

Corporate Governance & �the Professional Engineer

  • What is corporate governance?
    • Corporate governance is generally defined as the system or process by which a company or organization is directed and controlled in order to protect shareholder’s interest and stakeholder’s concern , whilst bearing in mind conformance to law and regulations
    • The concern most of the time is the focus, whether it should be on issue of performance or conformance. It is important to get the balance between the two as strictly leaning to either side will not be good for the organization

​

​

10

11 of 46

Corporate Governance & �the Professional Engineer

What are the elements of corporate governance ?

​

Corporate governance comprises of elements of best practice

        • Strategic guideline
        • Policy formulation
        • The selection of chief executive officer (CEO)
        • Risk management and control
        • Monitoring performance
        • Reporting on stewardship/ management
        • Legislative compliance

​

​

​

11

12 of 46

Corporate Governance & �the Professional Engineer

Legislative Compliance

    • Company’s Act 1965 would be a good place to start. It is a regulation that had been tested through time to provide guidance into the management of an organization
    • It draws out the responsibilities and accountabilities of the various officers holding responsible job portfolios in the board and company/organization
    • Besides the Company’s Act there are other legislative regulations that need to be made known to the board and management such that proper governance is maintained at all times

​

​

​

12

13 of 46

Major laws governing �the engineering profession

Registration of Engineers Act 1967

​

​

​

​

13

14 of 46

Major laws governing �the engineering profession

Registration of Engineers Act 1967

    • An act of Parliament passed in 1967 to regulate Engineers
    • The act was originally a reaction to building failures in the early 1960s
    • The most important document in Law governing all Engineers

14

15 of 46

Major laws governing �the engineering profession

Registration of Engineers Act 1967

​

The Registration Of Engineers Regulations 1990 (Revised 2003) contains the following important regulations on:

      • Registration of Registered Engineers – PART III
      • Code of Professional Conduct – PART IV
      • Registration of Engineering Consultancy Practice – PART V
      • Professional Assessment Examination – PART VI

​

​

​

15

16 of 46

Major laws governing �the engineering profession

Employment Act 1955

​

​

​

​

16

17 of 46

Major laws governing �the engineering profession

Employment Act 1955

    • Employment Law is covered by various legislation including Employment Act 1955, Industrial Relations Act 1967 and Trade Unions Act 1959
    • These laws governs the relationship between an employer and an employee
    • They aim to safeguard the interests of the employer and society in general and an employee/workman in particular

​

​

​

17

18 of 46

Major laws governing �the engineering profession

Employment Act 1955

    • The employment act 1955 deals with the contract of employment but it is not applicable to every employee or to every employer
    • Under this act, an employer is any person who enters into a contract of service to employ any other person as an employee
    • A contract of service is an agreement whereby one person agrees to employ another as an employee and the other agrees to serve his employer as an employee

​

​

​

​

​

18

19 of 46

Major laws governing �the engineering profession

Employment Act 1955

    • An employee is any person who enters into contract of service with an employer and whose wages “do not exceed one thousand five hundred ringgit a month”
    • However, there are some exceptions, where a person falls within the definition of an employee, even though his wages exceed the above limit
    • For example, persons supervising or overseeing other employees engaged in manual labour employed by the same employer in and throughout the performance of their work and the persons specified in the first schedule of the Act

​

​

​

​

​

19

20 of 46

Major laws governing �the engineering profession

Employment Act 1955

    • The Employment Act 1955 also covers:
      • Payment of Wages – PART III
      • Employment of Women – PART VIII
      • Maternity Protection – PART IX
      • Employment of Children and Young Persons – PART X
        • “Child” means any person who has not completed his fifteenth year of age
        • “Young Person” means any person who, not being a child, has not completed his eighteenth year of age

​

​

​

​

​

20

21 of 46

Major laws governing �the engineering profession

Industrial Relations Act 1967 (Revised 1976)

​

​

​

​

​

21

22 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

  • Industrial Relations Act 1967 (IRA 1967) is a landmark piece of Malaysian legislation that governs the relationship between employers, employees, and trade unions. It provides the legal framework for collective bargaining, handling trade union recognition, managing industrial disputes, and protecting employees against unfair dismissal.
  • Core Objectives & Scope
    • Promote Industrial Peace & Harmony: Creates a structured system to resolve workplace complaints and disputes.
    • Regulation of Trade Unions: Governs how trade unions operate in relation to employers and collective bargaining.
    • Protection Against Unfair Dismissal: Sets out the legal remedies available to workers who have been terminated without just cause.

​

23 of 46

  • Early Trade Union Laws: Industrial laws began under British colonial rule. Following World War II, growing labor unrest—often tied to the Malayan Communist Party and plantation strikes—led to strict union controls under the Trade Unions Ordinance 1946.
  • Industrial Courts Ordinance 1948: Enacted to manage trade disputes, it established a voluntary arbitration (timbang tara) framework and created a permanent Industrial Court.
  • Voluntary Arbitration Limitation: Between 1948 and 1964, arbitration was voluntary—meaning disputes were only referred to the Industrial Court if both the employer and trade union agreed. As a result, very few industrial disputes were formally resolved through the court during this period.

The Pre-Independence Era

(Colonial Foundations)

24 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

    • The Industrial Courts Ordinance 1948 provided for the promotion of peaceful and voluntary settlement of trade disputes through conciliation by a third party or through the voluntary reference of a dispute to the Industrial Court for arbitration.
    • The Trade Unions Ordinance 1946 provided the Government with supervisory powers to maintain vigilance over trade disputes and certain matters arising from such disputes so as to ensure and safeguard the interests of the public generally.

​

25 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

In September 1965, the Essential (Trade Disputes in Essential Services) Regulations, 1965 was promulgated.

    • It was designed to ensure that trade disputes in certain scheduled services would not lead to disruption of such services.
    • Background: Promulgated during the emergency period of the Indonesian Confrontation (Konfrontasi 1963-1966) to safeguard national security and economic stability.
  • Compulsory Arbitration: Introduced compulsory arbitration mechanisms for trade disputes occurring within critical infrastructure and essential public services (e.g., healthcare, utilities, police, army, transport).
  • Precursor to IRA 1967: Serves as one of the fundamental emergency decrees that was later integrated and consolidated into the Industrial Relations Act 1967.

26 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

    • These Regulations vested in the Minister of Labour certain powers to intervene of his own volition in such disputes and, if necessary, to refer them to the Industrial Arbitration Tribunal for settlement.
    • No strike or lock-out could be declared, or, where already declared, could continue once the Minister had so intervened.
    • This IRA 1967 came into force on 7th August 1967 and is applicable throughout Malaysia (Revised in 1976) .
    • The Act retains most of the principles and practices as set out in the repealed legislation and continues to promote the voluntary system up to the point where Government intervention is necessary so that the ever-present public and national interests are not prejudiced while the parties promote their own respective interests.

​

27 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

The summary of the Act: Part I, which sets the legal foundational definitions, scope, and administrative jurisdiction for the entire Act

      • Part I of the Industrial Relations Act provides an interpretation of some of the terms used. �Among the important ones is the interpretation of strike, which is defined as the act of discontinuation of work carried out by a group of workers acting in unison, or jointly refusing or refusing to continue working or to accept employment under a common understanding by a number of employees, and includes any action or omission by a group of workers acting together or under mutual understanding, which is intended to or causes any limitation, restriction, reduction or termination or suspension of the performance or any part of the duties relating to the employment.

28 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART II

PROTECTION OF RIGHTS OF WORKMEN AND EMPLOYERS AND THEIR TRADE UNIONS

​

Section 3. Expression “trade union”

Section 4. Rights of workmen and employers

Section 5. Prohibition on employers and their trade unions in respect of certain acts

Section 6. Leave on trade union business

Section 7. Prohibition on workmen and their trade unions in respect of certain acts

Section 8. Reference of complaint to Industrial Court

Section 8A. Employer may provide information on collective bargaining and trade dispute to his workmen

29 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

    • On the rights of workers and employers and their trade unions�Prohibition on employees, employers and their trade unions in relation to certain actions such as; anti-union activities, persecution and other unfair labor practices. �A complaint about a violation of any provision under this Part may be made in writing to the Director General who may take such steps as it deems necessary to resolve the complaint.
    • If it is not resolved, he shall notify the Minister of Human Resources who will refer the complaint to the Industrial Court for trial, if deemed appropriate.�Under Section 6 of the Act, an employer shall authorise an employee to take leave for a reasonable period to carry out his duties as a trade union officer; It is also a must for the employer to provide paid leave if the employee's absence is to represent the members of his trade union in matters relating to his employer.

30 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART III

RECOGNITION AND SCOPE OF REPRESENTATION OF TRADE UNIONS

​

Section 9. Claim for recognition

Section 10. Prohibition of strike, lock-out, picketing and termination of service pending recognition of a trade union

Section 10A. No other claims after trade union has made a claim

Section 11. Trade unions accorded recognition

Section 12. Trade unions not accorded recognition

31 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

​

  1. This section deals with the issue of trade union recognition. �It sets out the basic procedures that must be followed in handling a recognition claim. �A trade union may not claim recognition in respect of employees employed in managerial, executive, confidential or security capacities, if the majority of its membership consists of employees who are not employed in any such capacity. �If the claim is not resolved, the matter can be reported in writing to the Director General, who will take such steps as he deems necessary to resolve it.

32 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

    • If the matter is not resolved, the Director-General must inform the Minister of Human Resources so that a decision can be made. �This decision includes a decision on which employees are hired in a managerial, executive, confidential or security capacity.� The decision of the Minister made under this Division shall be final and shall not be challenged in any court.

33 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

    • Workers are prohibited from striking or picketing for any reason whatsoever while awaiting the outcome of proceedings under this Division or after a decision has been made by the Minister, and there is any dissatisfaction with the decision; and �An employer is prohibited from declaring a lock-out or termination of an employee's service (except for disciplinary reasons, retirement, termination of fixed-term contracts, employees on unconfirmed probationary periods in the position and for medical reasons), as soon as a trade union for employees submits a claim for recognition in writing to the employer.
    • Workers' unions are prohibited from making claims for recognition or recognition of the same employee or class of workers if there is an unresolved claim for recognition.

�

34 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART IV

COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AND COLLECTIVE AGREEMENTS

​

Section 13. Collective bargaining

Section 14. Collective agreements

Section 15. (Deleted)

Section 16. Deposit of collective agreements

Section 17. Effect of collective agreement

35 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

  • This section explains the procedure to be followed in submitting wage claims and collective bargaining and the form and content of the collective agreement.�For example, under section 13 (3), certain common law rights such as promotion, exchange, employment, termination of service for excessive employment or reorganisation, removal and reinstatement, assignment or assignment of duties, cannot be included in the collective agreement proposals by a trade union.
  • This division also has provisions to promote training, annual revision of the wage system, and a performance-based pay system.

​

36 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART V

CONCILIATION

​

Section 18. Reference of disputes for conciliation

Section 19. Information, documents and compulsory conference for conciliation

Section 19A. The Minister may conciliate in any trade dispute

Section 19B. Representation in conciliation proceedings

37 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

  • This section also encourages direct negotiations between employers and employees and their trade unions in resolving disputes. �Provisions are also provided to resolve corporate disputes through peaceful negotiations and arbitration quickly and thoroughly.
  • The intervening power of the Minister of Human Resources refers a dispute, at any time, to the Industrial Court; and the prohibition of strikes and lock-outs applies after an enterprise dispute is referred to the Industrial Court and for any matter covered by a collective agreement or by an Industrial Court award.

38 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

    • Either party may make a report to the Director-General on any unresolved enterprise dispute between them, for peaceful negotiation and resolution.�This section also empowers the Director-General to direct any person involved in or connected with the dispute, whether directly or indirectly, to attend a peace negotiation meeting and to submit necessary information in relation to the matter in dispute.
    • The Minister can at any time intervene in an enterprise dispute as he sees fit, if he deems it necessary.
    • This section also stipulates who can represent the warring parties in peace negotiation proceedings.

​

39 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART VI

REPRESENTATIONS ON DISMISSALS

​

Section 20. Representations on dismissals (pemecatan)

​

  • This section provides that if an employee, regardless of whether he is a member of a trade union or otherwise, considers himself to have been dismissed by the employer without just cause or cause, then he may, within sixty (60) days from the date of his dismissal, make a representation (appeal) in writing to the Director General for reinstatement to his original employment. �If the representation is still not completed after the steps deemed necessary or desirable to complete it have been taken by the Director General, the Minister will be informed of it.

40 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART VII

INDUSTRIAL COURT

21. Industrial Court

22. Constitution of the Court

23. Divisions of the Court

23A. Qualification of President and Chairman of Industrial Court

24. Protection and immunity to members of the Court

25. Registrar and officers

26. Reference of trade disputes to the Court

27. Appearance and representation at proceedings before the Court

28. Power of President to regulate procedure and proceedings 29. Power of the Court

30. Awards

31. Agreement during proceeding

32. Effect of an award

33. Interpretation and variation of awards and agreements

33A. Reference to the High Court on a question of law

33B. Award, decision or order of the Court to be final and conclusive

41 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART VIII INVESTIGATION AND INQUIRY

​

Section 34. Investigation and inquiry into trade disputes

Section 35. Committee

Section 36. Board

Section 37. Reports

42 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

  • This section is about the establishment and functioning of a Committee of Inquiry or a Board of Inquiry.� This section is to deal with issues or disputes that are not suitable to be handled according to the usual means or methods of resolution, and it is considered useful in promoting good relations between employers and employees. �The Minister is empowered to appoint a Committee consisting of one or more members, or a Board consisting of a Chairman and such person as the Minister deems appropriate, to investigate the facts, causes and circumstances of a dispute referred to the body and to submit a report. �A report from the Inquiry Board should be tabled in Parliament as soon as possible.

43 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART IX

TRADE DISPUTES, STRIKES AND LOCK-OUTS AND MATTERS ARISING THEREFROM

​

38. Pupils not to take part in trade disputes

39. Intimidation

40. Picketing

41. Breach of contract liable to injure person or property

42. Conspiracy in trade disputes

43. Restrictions on strikes and lock-outs in essential services

44. Prohibition of strikes and lock-outs

45. Illegal strikes and lock-outs

46. Penalty for illegal strikes and lock-outs

47. Penalty for instigation

48. Penalty for giving financial aid to illegal strikes and lock-outs

49. Protection of persons refusing to take part in illegal strikes or lock-outs

50. Offences seizable, and no bail to be granted

51. (Deleted)

44 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART IXA

INVESTIGATION AND PROSECUTION

​

Section 51A. Investigation officers

Section 51B. Authority card

Section 51C. Power to conduct investigation

Section 51D. Power to examine persons

Section 51E. Prosecution

Section 51F. Offence by bodies corporate, etc

​

​

    • This section provides for specific matters relating to investigation and prosecution. �Among the provisions in this section are the power of appointment of the Investigating Officer and his powers.

45 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

PART X

MISCELLANEOUS

52. Application

53. Appointment of public officer

54. Exclusion of evidence as to certain matters

55. Secrecy

56. Non-compliance with award or collective agreement

57. (Deleted)

58. Contempt

59. Injuring a workman on account of certain acts

60. General penalties

60A. Protection of Director for General and other officers

61. Schedule

62. Regulations

63. Repeal and savings

FIRST SCHEDULE

SECOND SCHEDULE

46 of 46

Industrial Relations Act, 1967

      • This section contains various provisions which, among other things, relate to the procedures to be followed in the case of non-compliance with an award or collective agreement that has been recognized by the Industrial Court, the enforcement of the orders that follow therefrom and the general penalties for violation of certain sections of the Act. �A violation of section 59 makes it an offence to dismiss an employee or to injure or threaten to injure him in his employment or to alter or threaten to change his position.
      • An employer who contravenes any provision of this subsection is guilty of an offence and, upon conviction, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year or a fine not exceeding two thousand ringgit or both.