1 of 19

Religious Studies A2�Philosophy

2 of 19

Aim and Objective�

  • To reinforce your understanding of how religion has responded to new atheism�Looking at evaluation arguments (AO2) on this topic

Religious Response to New Atheism

3 of 19

WJEC Specification?

4 of 19

Religious Response to New Atheism

What response has new atheism had among religious believers?

Religion and science are incompatible

Increase in religious moral and social fundamentalism

The rise of religious apologists in the media

5 of 19

a) Religion and Science are Incompatible

  1. New Atheism is obsessed with science! Is science the only answer? Can science prove/disprove everything!
  2. New Atheism deals with the obvious and stereotypical side of religion - New Atheism does not deal with the deep impact/complexity that religions have on believers.
  3. Using science to deal with religion is not suitable. Science is too empirical (verifying things through senses) and the ideas of religions are too abstract! Scientists like to measure, weigh, see, smell, feel things to prove their existence. This is not possible with certain religious concepts e.g. God, miracles, soul etc. Think - is it possible for you to see, weigh, smell etc. the soul. Using science to measure religion is like using a "chocolate teapot“ …totally unsuitable! Many would say that philosophy or sociology is the best way to deal with the validation of religion.

BUT

It is possible for religion and science to work well together. Religion and science have different focuses. Religion is about purpose, meaning and moral values, where science deals with fact and explaining how things work e.g. it is possible to apply religion and science to explain the creation of the universe.

Can you explain how?

6 of 19

  1. The narrative of creation in the bible - the world has been created by God in 6 days. The World was created in 144 hours (24x6)

​

  • BUT

​

  • Religion and science can be combined to gain a better understanding of creation -
  • The Big Bang - God created the big bang. Evolution – God created animals (before people) and on the sixth day created people. This fits with the theory of evolution.
  • Each "day" is a period of millions of years rather than 24 hours. So the order is generally correct but not the timing.
  • Science tells HOW the world was created, where religion emphasizes WHY it was created - the narrative has a special message that God created the earth and man should respect and protect it

Religion and Science are compatible? Can you explain how!

7 of 19

Religion and Science not compatible??????

8 of 19

b) Increase in Religious Moral and Social Fundamentalism

According to New Atheism, with the emergence of new scientific and rational ideas, religions have lost influence on society. Society is becoming more secularized in the last fifty years.

Because of this change, believers try to preserve the authority of the moral rules of religion within society.

The effect of new atheism is to create more religious fundamentalism as a response to the threat of atheism. Believers respond to social or moral changes by standing up and protesting and trying to influence politics For example, influencing the affairs of a country on issues such as homosexuality, same-sex marriages, abortion etc.

​

​

​

​

REMEMBER ….Some believers claim that new atheists are fundamentalist atheists!

Fundamentalism – a strong belief or firm grasp of a belief

9 of 19

c) Rise of Religious Apologists in the Media

​

New Atheism claims have given more emphasis on religious beliefs causing more discussion and attention to religions!

Charismatic religious apologists can be seen in the media e.g. discussion programmes on television/radio/You tube, books e.g. “The Dawkins Delusion?”, “ Atheist Fundamentalism and the denial of the divine” – Alister McGrath.

Religious apologists are religious people who present rational and evidence-based arguments to justify their beliefs.

Alister McGrath.

10 of 19

For example,

  1. Dawkins is very 'selective' in his choice of teachings within the Bible in order to disprove God. He does not choose logical passages and does not consider the time or cultural context of these passages.
  2. Dawkins believes that religions are evil that cause extremism and wars. McGrath recognizes that religions can contribute to extremism, war and intolerance. But, he doesn't agree that religions themselves promote violence - e.g. Jesus never showed any violence towards a person, love is the focus of Christianity and "Peace" is the meaning of "Islam". It is also clear that famous atheists have caused wars/infidelity and hatred. e.g. Pol Pot in Cambodia, atheist guerrillas in Sri Lanka created the suicide vest
  3. Dawkins claims that discrimination would disappear if religion “disappeared", but Mc Grath says that race, culture, language, class and politics would still exist and these cause discrimination.
  4. If religious ideas are childish and a babyish wish list, then why do adults get converted to religion?

Alister Mc Grath has tried to answer the charges of New Atheism

11 of 19

Evaluation (AA2)

(b) questions

  • How successful are new atheism arguments against religions?
  • To what extent have religious responses to New Atheism been successful?

12 of 19

How successful are atheistic arguments against religious beliefs?�

Successful

Not Successful

  • Logical - the arguments deal with logic, whereas religions sometimes deal with blind faith.
  • Maturity of mind and not believing in illogical beliefs.
  • Empiricism - Science deals with reality and evidence - religion moves over to mythology and superstition.
  • Society is becoming more scientific. Scientific evidence supports atheism and has provided answers to what was traditionally attributed to religions

​

​

​

​

​

​

13 of 19

How successful are atheistic arguments against religious beliefs?�

Successful

Not Successful

​

​

​

​

​

  • There are limits to what science can prove. Science cannot deal with abstract concepts e.g. values ​​(why is the death penalty wrong?) or meaning (e.g. WHY are we here?). Empirical methods don't work. Science cannot say if something is morally good. (BUT, others like Sam Harris would say that science is about promoting welfare and science promotes welfare. That is a good thing, so science can show what is good and bad e.g. effect of smoking on the body.
  • Empiricism - people question empiricism (which is the idea of ​​dealing with things according to the senses) This is not possible with God. Science says that "experience" of something is the greatest authority for proving something. But the fact that empirical methods cannot prove the existence of God does not mean that it is not a reality. Some people do feel God’s existence.
  • Religious response to new atheism e.g. “Dawkins Delusion” shows that Dawkins is not reasonable, he focuses on some aspects of religion and not ALL aspects of religion. His arguments are criticized for being too superficial.
  • New Atheism has caused more attention on religions – as religious people defend their religious beliefs
  • More emphasis on fundamentalist believers as a response to new atheism – increase in religious moral and social activity
  • Religions are immoral? Religions create conflict, extremism and hatred? But what about atheist leaders who have killed etc. What about those religious beliefs that are moral? (e.g. love a neighbour)
  • Scientists with a religious belief disagree with Dawkins' "scientific" arguments. The big bang and evolution are theories - not fact, why not combine religion and science?

14 of 19

How successful are atheistic arguments against religious beliefs?�

Successful

Not Successful

  • Logical - the arguments deal with logic, whereas religions sometimes deal with blind faith.
  • Maturity of mind and not believing in illogical beliefs.
  • Empiricism - Science deals with reality and evidence - religion moves over to mythology and superstition.
  • Society is becoming more scientific. Scientific evidence supports atheism and has provided answers to what was traditionally attributed to religions

​

​

​

​

​

  • There are limits to what science can prove. Science cannot deal with abstract concepts e.g. values ​​(why is the death penalty wrong?) or meaning (e.g. WHY are we here?). Empirical methods don't work. Science cannot say if something is morally good. (BUT, others like Sam Harris would say that science is about promoting welfare and science promotes welfare. That is a good thing, so science can show what is good and bad e.g. effect of smoking on the body.
  • Empiricism - people question empiricism (which is the idea of ​​dealing with things according to the senses) This is not possible with God. Science says that "experience" of something is the greatest authority for proving something. But the fact that empirical methods cannot prove the existence of God does not mean that it is not a reality. Some people do feel God’s existence.
  • Religious response to new atheism e.g. “Dawkins Delusion” shows that Dawkins is not reasonable, he focuses on some aspects of religion and not ALL aspects of religion. His arguments are criticized for being too superficial.
  • New Atheism has caused more attention on religions – as religious people defend their religious beliefs
  • More emphasis on fundamentalist believers as a response to new atheism – increase in religious moral and social activity
  • Religions are immoral? Religions create conflict, extremism and hatred? But what about atheist leaders who have killed etc. What about those religious beliefs that are moral? (e.g. love a neighbour)
  • Scientists with a religious belief disagree with Dawkins' "scientific" arguments. The big bang and evolution are theories - not fact, why not combine religion and science?

15 of 19

To what extent have religious responses to New Atheism been successful?�

Limited Extent

Large Extent

​

  • An increase in those people who become atheists - science has a strong grasp on society. Secularization is obvious
  • Leaders/pastors/priests who used to be religious are turning into atheists according to Dawkins
  • New Atheism has a prominent place in society and in the media - e.g. video clips on YouTube and social media

​

​

​

​

​

16 of 19

To what extent have religious responses to New Atheism been successful?�

Limited Extent

Large Extent

​

​

​

​

​

  • Religious apologists are evident in society e.g. discussions on YouTube trying to LOGICALLY defend religious beliefs.
  • Religious responses has given MORE attention to religious beliefs because of the discussion on religion
  • Religious apologists are vocal and try to answer New Atheism's accusations or claims (refer to Mc Grath)
  • Most of the the world's population have a religious belief, so religious belief continues to be prominent and important in the modern world.
  • Science has replaced religion according to New atheism. Although modern society is scientific, many religious believers are also scientists. It is possible to combine religion and science
  • Religious beliefs have an influence on politics e.g. Shariah law
  • According to New atheism, religious belief causes hatred and intolerance, there are plenty of examples of atheist individuals who show hatred and intolerance. Other factors cause hatred, discrimination and intolerance
  • According to New atheism, religion causes extremism and terrorism - other factors can cause extremism and terrorism e.g. political, patriotic, economic beliefs

17 of 19

To what extent have religious responses to New Atheism been successful?�

Limited Extent

Large Extent

​

  • An increase in those people who become atheists - science has a strong grasp on society. Secularization is obvious
  • Leaders/pastors/priests who used to be religious are turning into atheists according to Dawkins
  • New Atheism has a prominent place in society and in the media - e.g. video clips on YouTube and social media

​

​

​

​

  • Religious apologists are evident in society e.g. discussions on YouTube trying to LOGICALLY defend religious beliefs.
  • Religious responses has given MORE attention to religious beliefs because of the discussion on religion
  • Religious apologists are vocal and try to answer New Atheism's accusations or claims (refer to Mc Grath)
  • Most of the the world's population have a religious belief, so religious belief continues to be prominent and important in the modern world.
  • Science has replaced religion according to New atheism. Although modern society is scientific, many religious believers are also scientists. It is possible to combine religion and science
  • Religious beliefs have an influence on politics e.g. Shariah law
  • According to New atheism, religious belief causes hatred and intolerance, there are plenty of examples of atheist individuals who show hatred and intolerance. Other factors cause hatred, discrimination and intolerance
  • According to New atheism, religion causes extremism and terrorism - other factors can cause extremism and terrorism e.g. political, patriotic, economic beliefs

18 of 19

Do I understand?

19 of 19