Teresa Sicignano
1
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Session 1
State of the Hubble Tension (L)
Distance Ladder: Gaia, eclipsing binaries, maser, SNIa, Hubble flow (L)
Short intro on Cepheids (HR diagram, kappa mechanism) (L)
Recent updates: clusters, JWST results (L)
Type II distance ladder: https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2025ApJ...987...87J/abstract
Session 2
More details on Cepheids: PL relation and why there is one (theory) (T)
Discovery of the PL relation by Henrietta Leavitt (Louise has slides)
Wesenheit definition (correct for dust)
Different classes of Cepheids (Type II, anomalous) (T)
Show light curves (T)
Population II distance ladder (see Mauricio’s paper) (T)
Session 3
Cepheid metallicity dependence: different methods (L)
Metallicity measurements (T)
Session 4
Notebooks and exercises (T&L)
How to use Cepheids: applications -> notebook (T&L)
Notebook 1 : Gaia calibration in MW + include metallicity -> scatter decreases
Notebook 2 : application to measure distance to a galaxy
Notebook 3: measure distance to the LMC
Teresa Sicignano
PhD student at ESO (Garching) - Scuola Superiore Meridionale - INAF – OACN (Naples)
CosmoVerse School@Sofia 2026
Measuring astronomical distances with Cepheid variables
Teresa Sicignano
3
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Riess+2022
The extragalactic distance scale. The three steps to H0
Geometry
Standard Candles
SN Ia
1
2
3
Teresa Sicignano
4
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Riess+2022
The first step to H0
Period Luminosity relation
Teresa Sicignano
5
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Period Luminosity relation
Teresa Sicignano
6
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Period Luminosity relation
Leavitt worked as a “Harvard computer” in charge of cataloguing the stars from the photographic plates.
Courtesy of Louise Breuval
Credit: Andrew Lockwood
Teresa Sicignano
7
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Period Luminosity relation
Leavitt 1912
Courtesy of Louise Breuval
Teresa Sicignano
8
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Period Luminosity relation
Breuval + 2025
Leavitt
OGLE
Leavitt 1912
Teresa Sicignano
9
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Period Luminosity relation
Leavitt 1912
Teresa Sicignano
10
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Leavitt Law Over the XXth century
Teresa Sicignano
11
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Period Luminosity in the Great Debate
Hubble 1925
Teresa Sicignano
12
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Period Luminosity in the Great Debate
Hubble, Washington, 1927
Teresa Sicignano
13
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Only Period Luminosity?
Hubble 1925
Sandage 1958
Log P
Log Lum
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
14
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
15
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
16
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Pulsating stars are intrinsic variables showing periodic variations.
In the simplest case they are radial pulsators.
Pulsating variable stars
The basic driver of pulsation are changes to opacity:
Teresa Sicignano
17
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Pulsating variable stars
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
18
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
19
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
20
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
21
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
22
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
23
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
24
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
25
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Consider the star as a self-gravitating sphere undergoing pulsations
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
26
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
27
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
28
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
29
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
30
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
P is a function of M, L, and Teff (and chemical composition)
M is not independent
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
31
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
P is a function of M, L, and Teff (and chemical composition)
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
32
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
P (M, L, and Teff -and chemical composition)
Madore & Freedman1991
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
33
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Madore & Freedman1991
With observable quantities:
The Period-Luminosity-Color relation
Teresa Sicignano
34
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Madore & Freedman1991
With observable quantities:
The PLC relation and its projections
Teresa Sicignano
35
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Madore & Freedman1991
With observable quantities:
The PLC relation and its projections
Teresa Sicignano
36
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Madore & Freedman1991
With observable quantities:
Standard(izable) Candle
The Instability Strip
Teresa Sicignano
37
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Bhardwaj+2022
Teresa Sicignano
38
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The physics behind the scenes…
The Pulsation mechanism
Teresa Sicignano
39
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Only when the ionization regions are deep enough, the mass involved allows pulsation driving mechanisms to prevail over dumping.
�
When the quenching effect due to convection prevails, pulsation is no longer efficient.
�
The Pulsation mechanism
Teresa Sicignano
40
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Only when the ionization regions are deep enough, the mass involved allows pulsation driving mechanisms to prevail over dumping.
�
When the quenching effect due to convection prevails, pulsation is no longer efficient.
�
BLUE EDGE OF THE INSTABILITY STRIP
RED EDGE OF THE INSTABILITY STRIP
Path to the Instability Strip
Teresa Sicignano
41
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Bhardwaj+2022
Path to the Instability Strip
Teresa Sicignano
42
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Bhardwaj+2022
Path to the Instability Strip
Teresa Sicignano
43
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Bhardwaj+2022
Path to the Instability Strip
Teresa Sicignano
44
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Bhardwaj+2022
Type II Cepheids:
BLHer & WVir Pop II; low mass;
1-4 & 4-20 days.
RVTau t > 2 Gyr; intermediate mass; 20-100 days.
Path to the Instability Strip
Teresa Sicignano
45
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Bhardwaj+2022
Type II Cepheids:
BLHer & WVir Pop II; low mass;
1-4 & 4-20 days.
RVTau t > 2 Gyr; intermediate mass; 20-100 days.
Path to the Instability Strip
Teresa Sicignano
46
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Bhardwaj+2022
Type II Cepheids:
BLHer & WVir Pop II; low mass;
1-4 & 4-20 days.
RVTau t > 2 Gyr; intermediate mass; 20-100 days.
Period Luminosity relations of pulsating stars in the LMC
Teresa Sicignano
47
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Data from Cusano+2021, Ripepi+2022, Sicignano+2024,+2025
Teresa Sicignano
48
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Limitations of the PL relation
Teresa Sicignano
49
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Limitations of the PL relation
Teresa Sicignano
50
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
51
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
52
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
53
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
54
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
55
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Skowron 2022
From the PLC to the Period Wesenheit
Teresa Sicignano
56
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Riess+2018
Teresa Sicignano
57
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Adapted from De Somma+2024
Adapted from Trentin+2024
P is a function of M, L, and Teff (and chemical composition)
Theory
Observations
Teresa Sicignano
58
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
P is a function of M, L, and Teff (and chemical composition)
Breuval + 2024
STAY TUNED FOR THE EVENING LESSON!!
Not only Classical Cepheids…
Teresa Sicignano
59
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Other pulsating stars that populate the instability strip can be used to establish an alternative first step of the extragalactic distance scale.
Data from Cusano+2021, Ripepi+2022, Sicignano+2024,+2025
WHERE WE ARE:
Teresa Sicignano
60
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
TYPE II AND ANOMALOUS CEPHEIDS
Teresa Sicignano
61
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Type II Cepheids:
BLHer & WVir Pop II; low mass;
1-4 & 4-20 days.
RVTau t > 2 Gyr; intermediate mass; 20-100 days.
Bhardwaj+2022
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
62
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
63
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
64
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
OGLE
The Optical Gavitational Lensing Experiment
GAIA
High accuracy astrometric survey mission
Teresa Sicignano
65
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
OGLE
The Optical Gavitational Lensing Experiment
GAIA
High accuracy astrometric survey mission
RUBIN OBSERVATORY
Transient and Variable Sky Survey
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
66
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
67
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
68
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The period is the time difference between two minima ( or maxima) of the magnitude of a star.
The more the light curve of the star is well sampled, the better we know the period.
The PL relation is a powerful tool because we the period is measured with an uncertainty much smaller than all other quantities involved.
Teresa Sicignano
69
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
70
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
71
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
72
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
73
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
74
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Flux arrived at the instrument
Zero-point flux according to the chosen photometric system
Teresa Sicignano
75
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
I
V
B
U
Flux arrived at the instrument
Zero-point flux according to the chosen photometric system
Bessell 2005
Teresa Sicignano
76
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Sicignano + 2024
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
77
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
78
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
79
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Sicignano + 2024
HOW TO BUILD A PL/PW RELATION
Teresa Sicignano
80
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Sicignano + 2024
CALIBRATION WITH GAIA PARALLAXES
Teresa Sicignano
81
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
82
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
CALIBRATION WITH GAIA PARALLAXES
Teresa Sicignano
83
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
CALIBRATION WITH GAIA PARALLAXES
CALIBRATION WITH GAIA PARALLAXES
Teresa Sicignano
84
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
SANITY CHECK: THE LMC DISTANCE
Teresa Sicignano
85
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Sicignano + 2025
APPLICATION: THE TIP OF THE RED GIANT BRANCH
Teresa Sicignano
86
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Lengen + 2026
Cruz-Reyes + 2026
Teresa Sicignano
87
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
TAKE HOME MESSAGES
Teresa Sicignano
88
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
TAKE HOME MESSAGES
Teresa Sicignano
89
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
TAKE HOME MESSAGES
Teresa Sicignano
90
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
TAKE HOME MESSAGES
Teresa Sicignano
91
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
TAKE HOME MESSAGES
Teresa Sicignano
92
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
TAKE HOME MESSAGES
Teresa Sicignano
93
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
94
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
THE FUTURE IS PULSATING
Teresa Sicignano
95
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
teresa.sicignano@inaf.it
Thank you for your attention!
BACKUP SLIDES
Teresa Sicignano
97
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
An alternative self-consistent stellar route to the Hubble constant
Teresa Sicignano
98
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Exploitation of the VMC-Deep and TNG-REM photometry for Type II and Anomalous Cepheids.
Quantify the effect of metallicity on the zero point and slope of PL relation through high-resolution spectroscopic abundances from the 4MOST 1001MC survey and UVES spectra.
Compare the distance scales produced for different kinds of pulsating stars and look into the reasons for any discrepancies.
Calibration through Gaia DR4 parallaxes.
Teresa Sicignano
99
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
TYPE II AND ANOMALOUS CEPHEIDS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS
339 T2Cs and 198 ACs with VMC photometry in the Magellanic Clouds
TEMPLATE FITTING TO THE DATA
Teresa Sicignano
100
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
To construct the PL/PW it is necessary to calculate the intensity-averaged magnitudes, using the tecnique of templetes.
TYPE II CEPHEIDS
Teresa Sicignano
101
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
OBSERVED PERIOD – LUMINOSITY RELATIONS
Sicignano+2024,
A&A, 685, A41.
LIGHT CURVES
TYPE II CEPHEIDS
Teresa Sicignano
102
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
FITTED PERIOD – LUMINOSITY AND PERIOD - WESENHEIT RELATIONS
Sicignano+2024,
A&A, 685, A41.
IMPACT ON THE DISTANCE SCALE
Teresa Sicignano
103
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The distance moduli of GGCs appear overestimated up to 3%.
Comparison between our distance moduli and those by Baumbgardt & Vasiliev 21
Sicignano+2024,
A&A, 685, A41.
ANOMALOUS CEPHEIDS
Teresa Sicignano
104
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
OBSERVED PERIOD – LUMINOSITY RELATIONS
Sicignano
+2025, A&A,
under revision.
LIGHT CURVES
Teresa Sicignano
105
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Riess+2022
Freedman+ 2021
IMPACT ON THE DISTANCE SCALE
ANOMALOUS CEPHEIDS
Teresa Sicignano
106
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
FITTED PERIOD – LUMINOSITY AND PERIOD WESENHEIT RELATIONS
Sicignano
+2025, A&A,
under revision.
FIRST TIME: FUNDAMENTALIZATION OF FIRST OVERTONE ACs
ANOMALOUS CEPHEIDS
Teresa Sicignano
107
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
FITTED PERIOD – LUMINOSITY AND PERIOD-WESENHEIT RELATIONS
Sicignano
+2025, A&A,
under revision.
LMC/SMC RELATIVE DISTANCE
Teresa Sicignano
108
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Sicignano+2025, under review.
DRACO
Teresa Sicignano
109
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Sicignano
+2025,A&A,
under review.
Future prospectives
Teresa Sicignano
110
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
{
LSST VERA RUBIN AND NANCY GRACE ROMAN SPACE TELESCOPES.
Sicignano+,
in prep.
A self-consistent stellar route to the Hubble constant
Teresa Sicignano
111
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
{
Exploitation of the VMC-Deep and TNG-REM photometry for Type II and Anomalous Cepheids.
Quantify the effect of metallicity on the zero point and slope of PL relation through high-resolution spectroscopic abundances from the 4MOST 1001MC survey and UVES spectra.
Compare the distance scales produced for different kinds of pulsating stars and look into the reasons for any discrepancies.
Calibration through Gaia DR4 parallaxes.
Teresa Sicignano
112
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
{
Exploitation of the VMC-Deep and TNG-REM photometry for Type II and Anomalous Cepheids.
Quantify the effect of metallicity on the zero point and slope of PL relation through high-resolution spectroscopic abundances from the 4MOST 1001MC survey and UVES spectra.
Compare observational data with newly developed stellar pulsation models.
SESAME: Synergies between ESO�Spectroscopic And photoMEtric surveys
Path to the Instability Strip
Stars cross the IS at different evolutionary phases:
Teresa Sicignano
113
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Bhardwaj+2022
Teresa Sicignano
114
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
{
TYPE II CEPHEIDS:
THEORY? OBSERVATIONS?
Di Criscienzo+2007
& No dependence in GGCs.
A self-consistent stellar route to the Hubble constant
Teresa Sicignano
115
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
{
RRLYRAE THEORY AND OBSERVATIONS
Adapted from
Marconi+2015
Adapted from
Bhardwaj+2023
Teresa Sicignano
116
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
117
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
The extragalactic distance scale. The three steps to H0
Teresa Sicignano
118
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
A self-consistent stellar route to the Hubble constant
Teresa Sicignano
119
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
MASTER
THESIS
{
PHD
PROJECT
TYPE II CEPHEIDS:
THEORY? OBSERVATIONS?
Gratton+2004
A self-consistent stellar route to the Hubble constant
Teresa Sicignano
120
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
MASTER
THESIS
{
PHD
PROJECT
TYPE II CEPHEIDS:
THEORY? OBSERVATIONS?
Wielgorski+2022
& No dependence in GGCs.
WHY TYPE II CEPHEIDS?
Teresa Sicignano
121
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Adapted from Beaton+2016
Teresa Sicignano
122
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Riess+2022
The first step to H0
Riess+2024
TYPE II CEPHEIDS
Teresa Sicignano
123
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
TYPE II CEPHEIDS
Teresa Sicignano
124
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
MASTER
THESIS
Evolution of Population II stars
Teresa Sicignano
125
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
BASIC ASTROPHYSICAL CONCEPTS
Pulsating variable stars
Teresa Sicignano
126
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Classical Cepheids |
Pop I |
Spiral Galaxies |
|
Super giants |
0.2-100 days |
F, 1O, 2O. |
Mv -2 to -7 mag |
30-40 Mpc from the Sun |
Type II Cepheids
Teresa Sicignano
127
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
BL Herculis | W Virginis | RV Tauri |
Low mass | Low mass | Intermediate-mass |
t>10 Gyrs | t>10 Gyrs | t>1-2 Gyrs |
Post-HB | AGB stars | Post AGB stars |
1-4 days | 4-20 days | 20-150 days |
L > RRLyrae | L> BLHer | L> WVir |
| * pWVir | |
Anomalous Cepheids
Teresa Sicignano
128
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Intermediate age |
|
Giants with partially He-degenerate core |
0.5-2.5 days/ 0.4 – 1 day |
F, 1O |
L(T2Cs)<L(Acep)<L(CCs) |
|
Pulsation mechanism
Trapped energy becomes pulsational work.
Teresa Sicignano
129
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
PULSATING STARS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS
Teresa Sicignano
130
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
131
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Teresa Sicignano
132
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
Type II and Anomalous Cepheids
Teresa Sicignano
133
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
PULSATING STARS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS
Period-luminosity-colour and �period-luminosity
Teresa Sicignano
134
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
PULSATING STARS IN THE MAGELLANIC CLOUDS
Template derivation
But can all observed light curves be fitted?
Teresa Sicignano
135
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
FROM THE VISTA TELESCOPE TO THE MULTIBAND PHOTOMETRY
TYPE II CEPHEIDS
Teresa Sicignano
136
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
MASTER
THESIS
IMPACT ON THE DISTANCE SCALE
Teresa Sicignano
137
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
MASTER
THESIS
Comparison between our distances and those by Bhardwaj 2023
The distance moduli of GGCs appear overestimated up to 2%.
Sicignano+2024,
A&A, 685, A41.
IMPACT ON THE DISTANCE SCALE
Teresa Sicignano
138
25/05/2026 CosmoVerse@Sofia
{
MASTER
THESIS
― Slope LMC
• Galactic T2C
Sicignano+2024,
A&A, 685, A41.