1 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

WATER POLLUTION

AT INDONESIA INDUSTRIAL PARKS

IN THE NICKEL SUPPLY CHAIN

Bahodopi River

2 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Sulawesi

Halmahera

Obi

3 of 29

    • National Strategic Project
    • Shareholders:
      • Shanghai Decent Inv: 49.69%
      • Sulawesi Mining Inv: 25%
      • Bintang Delapan Inv: 25.31%
    • Shanghai Decent Investment --> a subsidiary of Tshingshan Group

Indonesia Morowali Industrial Park (IMIP)

Keurea

4 of 29

    • 2015: 2,000 ha --> 4,000 ha
    • ± 81,500 workers (inc. 13% Chinese)
    • 18 tenants (2025: 40 tenants)
    • 44-line RKEF + 2 HPAL
    • coal-fired power plants 4,000 MW
    • 3 clusters (3rd: cathode material for EV batteries)
    • LG Energy Solution, Samsung SDI, CATL --> Stellantis NV, BMW, Volkswagen, Marcedes-Benz, Tesla

Indonesia Morowali Industrial Park (IMIP)

reclaimed land

reclaimed land

reclaimed land

5 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Keurea Village

6 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Fatufia Village

7 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Reclaimed area in Fatufia marine area

8 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

The barge ruins & Langala Island

9 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

La Kumpi River in Fatufia Village

10 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Labota River in Labota Village

11 of 29

    • Two measurements:
      • June 2022
      • August 2023
    • The changes in the concentration level of Cr6+ vary, but all of them exceed the IRMA standard of 0.0044 mg/L

Seawater

On-site measurement

12 of 29

Seawater

Coal plant wastewater

31.4 degree Celcius

Permit for Discharge of Wastewater into the Sea SK.259/Menlhk/Setjen/PKL.1/5/2018:

    • Coal plant wastewater
    • Wastewater from production processes
    • Coal stockpile runoff
    • Domestic wastewater

Coal plant wastewater

13 of 29

    • Laboratory examination results:
      • 4 samples → turbidity, Cd, Pb ↑
      • 5 samples → Zn ↑
      • 6 samples → TSS ↑
      • 7 samples → Cu ↑
    • Using the strictest threshold (national regulation vs IRMA std)

Seawater

Off-site measurement

14 of 29

Cr6+ concentration exceeds the IRMA standard of 0.011 mg/L:

    • Dampala R. → Dampala Sejahtera Bersama
    • Lalampu R. → Graha Mining Utama
    • La Kumpi R. → cluster 1 of IMIP
    • Labota R.→ cluster 3 of IMIP
    • Coal plant wastewater → cluster 3 of IMIP

Freshwater

On-site measurement

La Kumpi River

Cr6+ = 0.013 mg/L

Labota River

Cr6+ = 0.012 mg/L

15 of 29

    • Laboratory examination results:
      • La Kumpi R. → TSS, Hg, Cd, Ni, Cu, Cr6+ ↑
      • Labota R. → Hg, Ni, Cu, Pb, Cr6+ ↑
    • Using the strictest threshold (national regulation vs IRMA std)
    • The concentration of suspended solids in La Kumpi River is classified as high, in line with Dethier et al (Nature, 2023)

Freshwater

Off-site measurement

La Kumpi River

Cr6+ = 0.018 mg/L

Labota River

Cr6+ = 0.015 mg/L

16 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Halmahera

Sulawesi

Obi

17 of 29

Indonesia Weda Bay Industrial Park (IWIP)

    • National Strategic Project
    • Shareholders:
      • Perlux Technology: 40%
      • Zhenshi Group: 30%
      • Huachang Int. Inv.: 30%
    • Perlux Technology --> a subsidiary of Tshingshan Group

18 of 29

Indonesia Weda Bay Industrial Park (IWIP)

    • 2018: 5,000 ha
    • ± 42,000 workers (inc. 7% Chinese)
    • 21 tenants (planned)
    • 49-line RKEF + 1 HPAL
    • coal-fired power plants 1,000 MW
    • Huafei Nickel Cobalt --> a subsidiary of Zhejiang Huayou Cobalt --> LG Energy Solution --> Stellantis NV

reclaimed land

reclaimed land

19 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

The county road cutting through the industrial park

20 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Coal-fired power plant on the reclaimed land

21 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Wosea River crossing the industrial park

22 of 29

An old woman witnessing the changes in Kobe River

23 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Sagea Lake (June 2023) threatened

24 of 29

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

Sagea River & Bokimaruru Cave (June 2023) threatened

25 of 29

Seawater

On-site measurement

Coal plant wastewater discharge

Cr6+ = 0.024 mg/L

suhu ↑

    • Measurement at 9 sites in June 2023
    • Cr6+ concentration exceeds the IRMA standard of 0.0044 mg/L or the national regulation of 0.002 mg/L:
      • Botepo
      • Outlet of coal plant wastewater discharge
      • Cape Ulie
      • Mouth of Ake Doma R.

Cape Ulie

Cr6+ = 0.003 mg/L

Botepo

Cr6+ = 0,005 mg/L

Mouth of Ake Doma R.

Cr6+ = 0.015 mg/L

26 of 29

Seawater

Coal plant wastewater

Coal plant wastewater

35 degree Celcius

Environmental Impact Assessment (IWIP, Dec 2018)

    • Coal plant wastewater
    • Domestic wastewater
    • Wastewater from port
    • Wastewater from manufacturing processes

27 of 29

Freshwater

On-site measurement

Wosea River

Cr6+ = 0.017 mg/L

pH ↑

Waterfall

pH ↑

    • Measurement at 9 sites in June 2023 --> Cr6+ concentration in Wosea River exceeds the IRMA standard of 0.011 mg/L
    • Karkar River, Woebem River, and Gwondi River are buried
    • Wosea River and Ake Doma River experiencing narrowing or constriction
    • The flow of Ake Sake River diverted

28 of 29

    • Fewer fish in coastal waters, fishermen have to venture further out to sea --> requiring more fuel
    • Access to several rivers is closed, including Wosea River
    • The mangrove forest area is decreasing, coral reef ecosystems are disrupted --> a decrease in fish stocks in coastal areas
    • Several residents are complaining about the disappearance of fish in the river, skin rashes due to contact with the water
    • IWIP: diarrhea, Acute Respiratory Infection (ARI) reaching 1,000 cases per year (Community Health Center of Lelilef, 2022)

Sumber: Dokumentasi AEER, 2023

IMPLICATIONS

    • IMIP: tuberculosis 66, pneumonia in toddlers 59, Acute Respiratory Infection (ARI) reaching 855 cases per year (Community Health Center of Bahodopi, 2022)

29 of 29

THANK YOU

Website: https://www.aeer.or.id/

Email: aeermail@gmail.com